Captain Bearcat
All-American in Everything

Posts: 10,227
Joined: Jun 2010
Reputation: 913
I Root For: UC
Location: Midwest, USA
|
RE: Source: MAC in discussions with Illinois State
(01-24-2026 07:34 PM)Garden_KC Wrote: (01-24-2026 02:38 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote: (01-24-2026 12:48 PM)Michael in Raleigh Wrote: I’ve heard many times that a school has to be in the media market itself, not just in the same state, in order to be of media value to a conference. This is especially true of G6 schools. Charlotte, for example, was chosen for a then stronger CUSA and later for the American. App State, which is also in the Charlotte media market but located 100 miles from city center, has long been deemed as small market.
So if Illinois State is in a fairly small city way outside Chicago, why is it supposedly going to cover the Chicago market?
That statement is not phrased correctly. Flagships and flagship-equivalents (e.g. Michigan State, Purdue, Texas A&M, Auburn) generally DO get media value credit for the entire state as its market. The high value of UT isn’t about the Austin market, but rather that they deliver the whole state. That’s why schools with that type of flagship/flagship-equivalent profile are so valuable in conference realignment: they get credit for entire states as opposed to just their local immediate media market.
Your second point about G6 schools not getting credit beyond their immediate media market is generally more correct because they are often non-flagship directional schools or only draw from a localized student and alumni base.
Illinois State is a tweener. I wouldn’t call it a “flagship equivalent” in the way that, say, Michigan State is (e.g. MSU’s institutional profile and academic rankings would make it the flagship in most states if it weren’t located in Michigan). However, ISU is also not a directional school that primarily draws students from its immediate local area. Northern Illinois is a classic directional school, but it’s just fortunate that it’s directly in the Chicago market in a way that Eastern Illinois isn’t. In contrast, the Illinois State student demographics are closer to the University of Illinois of being “2 parts Chicago area students/1 part St. Louis area and Downstate Illinois students” as opposed to purely Central Illinois students. The Illinois State alumni are even more tilted toward the Chicago area in terms of where they end up living.
The best geographic demographic comp for Illinois State among MAC schools is Miami of Ohio: they’re drawing from the entire state more like a flagship than they are drawing local students like a directional school. Think of a place like William & Mary in Virginia, as well (although W&M is super highly-rated academically). Those aren’t local commuter or “suitcase” (most students leave campus for home for the weekend) colleges and I’d characterize Illinois State in a similar manner.
Also, I’m not sure how many people are familiar with the Bloomington-Normal area, but it’s home to the world headquarters of State Farm and that’s a massive employer with a lot of higher-paying professional jobs. (It’s like a factory town, except the “factory workers” are actuarial, accounting, finance, and marketing professionals as opposed to being on a factory floor.) As a result, the economic demographics of that metro area are pretty high for a place that’s not a big major market. It looks more like a smaller version of a combo university/capital town like Madison or Austin in terms of local economic demographics than a lot of sole college towns (except that State Farm takes the place of the capital in this case).
In any event, that would be the bet with Illinois State: it’s more like a flagship-equivalent than a directional school in a large population state that, as bullet mentioned, is really underrepresented for FBS schools for its population and recruiting talent levels and has strong connections to the #3 Chicago market and, to a lesser extent, #24 St. Louis market.
Does this mean that Illinois State is going to deliver huge ratings in Chicago? Or course that’s not the idea. We’re just looking at it from a totality of what one can reasonably expect from a FCS call-up to a G6 league and, from that vantage point, you’re going to have a harder time finding a school that offers more from an institutional perspective (and isn’t in a state already oversaturated with other FBS schools) than Illinois State.
Illinois State has a profile that looks closest to Ball State, not Miami.
Enrollment
Illinois State 21,994
Ball State 20,440
Endowment
Ball State $411 million
Illinois State $240 million
Ball State does pull students from Chicago, Michigan and Ohio. More than double the enrollment of Indiana State.
Ball State has struggled to get FB capacity up to the MAC level. Their stadium seats 22,000 after a few expansions though rarely they have crowds that big. Very similar to what Illinois State needs to do with its stadium.
Illinois State to the MAC is OK. They are the only one in the MVC with an acceptable profile for the MAC. One of the better benefits on bringing in ISU it does put a footer in for adding Dakota schools in the future.
The difference is that most directional schools have historically had aspirations of grandeur.
UCLA, USF, UCF, Arizona State, SIU-Carbondale, Kent State, and many others were originally "directional" schools that focused on training teachers. But as they grew, the faculty wanted them to upgrade to R1 research institutions to increase their own status.
ISU never wanted that. It's always been happy to be a teaching-first school. Today, 1-in-6 teachers in Illinois have their degree from ISU.
As ISU gets more resources, it pours them into teaching (rather than high-prestige research that fails to impact its students). For example, ISU has over 60 English professors, 70 Music professors, and 140 professors in the School of Teaching and Learning.
It is arguably the single best school for teachers in the world.
Recognizing this, about 1/3 of ISU's faculty in the School of Teaching and Learning have their terminal degree from ISU. This is a similar ratio that you might see in U of Chicago Economics or in MIT Engineering.
Even when ISU added engineering this year, it did so specifically with the goal of teaching - in fact, it set an ambitious goal to have under a 15% dropout rate (other engineering schools typically have 1/2-2/3 of students drop the major over 3 years).
|
|