UofMstateU
Legend

Posts: 46,187
Joined: Dec 2009
Reputation: 4536
I Root For: Memphis
Location:
|
RE: ACC Tiebreaker
(12-10-2025 03:39 PM)Gitanole Wrote: (12-10-2025 11:51 AM)stever20 Wrote:
Are we sure we want to move so fast on it?

The ACC was left within a micrometer of being completely left out of the playoffs. I would want to ensure that wasnt possible again if I were them.
|
|
| 12-10-2025 03:52 PM |
|
schmolik
CSNBB's Big 10 Cheerleader

Posts: 12,646
Joined: Sep 2019
Reputation: 1106
I Root For: UIUC, PSU, Nova
Location: Philadelphia Suburbs
|
RE: ACC Tiebreaker
(12-10-2025 12:23 PM)bullet Wrote: (12-10-2025 12:14 PM)stever20 Wrote: (12-10-2025 12:09 PM)bullet Wrote: (12-10-2025 11:54 AM)GoBuckeyes1047 Wrote: If the CFP Rankings isn't used, I found a tiebreaker that apparently only the NFL uses between common opponents and strength of schedule. Strength of Victory (not to be confused with margin of victory). It takes into account of the win % of the teams you have beaten. I think that is something that should be considered too. Miami would've got 2nd in the ACC and into the ACC CCG if SoV was used ahead of SoS. SEC standings would've remained the same for their top 4 teams with Bama first and Georgia 2nd followed by Ole Miss and Texas A&M.
I don't think you are right. Duke not only played a significantly tougher conference schedule, the teams they beat were better, 19 conference wins vs. 18 for Miami.
None of yall can accept that Duke had the toughest road to 6-2 and earned it. You are distracted by their 3 ooc losses.
Using CFP is not "smart." Its putting $$s before equity. Its also saying the ACC is so weak, they have to do the same thing as G conferences.
Reality is that this is the only time this would have happened all the way back to 1998. Is the ACC so weakened that it will recur, or was this a fluke with FSU and Clemson both down?
think it's very possible that it's a universal situation in all the conferences going forward.
Possibly with the megaconferences. I think I checked it the other day and Alabama's SEC opponents had 32 wins and Texas A&M's had 18.
Without a doubt Alabama "deserved" to be in the SEC Championship Game more than Texas A&M (whether Alabama wanted to be in the SEC Championship is a whole other can of worms). Using the CFP rankings, Texas A&M would've been ahead. Is that fair that A&M played a bunch of cupcakes and got to the SEC Championship Game while Alabama played a tougher schedule? And why is A&M higher? Because Alabama lost a non conference game. Yes in this case it was to a sub .500 Florida State but Oklahoma was behind Texas in the CFP rankings because they lost to at the time undefeated Ohio State. Should a team be denied from a conference championship because they wanted to challenge themselves with a tough non conference game? The SEC will drop their P4 rule really quick or Purdue will be the most popular Big Ten team in the future. Agreed that a five loss Duke shouldn't be in the conference championship but you don't need CFP rankings for that, just have a loss component as a tiebreaker but allow everyone one to play one tough non conference opponent.
(This post was last modified: 12-10-2025 04:27 PM by schmolik.)
|
|
| 12-10-2025 04:26 PM |
|
GoBuckeyes1047
All American

Posts: 3,082
Joined: Jan 2021
Reputation: 302
I Root For: Ohio State
Location:
|
RE: ACC Tiebreaker
(12-10-2025 04:26 PM)schmolik Wrote: (12-10-2025 12:23 PM)bullet Wrote: (12-10-2025 12:14 PM)stever20 Wrote: (12-10-2025 12:09 PM)bullet Wrote: (12-10-2025 11:54 AM)GoBuckeyes1047 Wrote: If the CFP Rankings isn't used, I found a tiebreaker that apparently only the NFL uses between common opponents and strength of schedule. Strength of Victory (not to be confused with margin of victory). It takes into account of the win % of the teams you have beaten. I think that is something that should be considered too. Miami would've got 2nd in the ACC and into the ACC CCG if SoV was used ahead of SoS. SEC standings would've remained the same for their top 4 teams with Bama first and Georgia 2nd followed by Ole Miss and Texas A&M.
I don't think you are right. Duke not only played a significantly tougher conference schedule, the teams they beat were better, 19 conference wins vs. 18 for Miami.
None of yall can accept that Duke had the toughest road to 6-2 and earned it. You are distracted by their 3 ooc losses.
Using CFP is not "smart." Its putting $$s before equity. Its also saying the ACC is so weak, they have to do the same thing as G conferences.
Reality is that this is the only time this would have happened all the way back to 1998. Is the ACC so weakened that it will recur, or was this a fluke with FSU and Clemson both down?
think it's very possible that it's a universal situation in all the conferences going forward.
Possibly with the megaconferences. I think I checked it the other day and Alabama's SEC opponents had 32 wins and Texas A&M's had 18.
Without a doubt Alabama "deserved" to be in the SEC Championship Game more than Texas A&M (whether Alabama wanted to be in the SEC Championship is a whole other can of worms). Using the CFP rankings, Texas A&M would've been ahead. Is that fair that A&M played a bunch of cupcakes and got to the SEC Championship Game while Alabama played a tougher schedule? And why is A&M higher? Because Alabama lost a non conference game. Yes in this case it was to a sub .500 Florida State but Oklahoma was behind Texas in the CFP rankings because they lost to at the time undefeated Ohio State. Should a team be denied from a conference championship because they wanted to challenge themselves with a tough non conference game? The SEC will drop their P4 rule really quick or Purdue will be the most popular Big Ten team in the future. Agreed that a five loss Duke shouldn't be in the conference championship but you don't need CFP rankings for that, just have a loss component as a tiebreaker but allow everyone one to play one tough non conference opponent.
That's a fair point no one is talking about, Alabama (compared to most of the SEC) stepped up and played 10 P4 opponents along with SC and Florida. Everyone else played 9 P4 opponents and 3 cupcakes, except Ole Miss who technically only played 8 P4 opponents, but I'm willing to give Washington St. a pass because they were P5 when scheduled (also played Tulane). The majority of the other 3 P4 conferences (more than 70% of the other 3 conferences) played 10 P4 opponents with nearly all the ACC and B12 playing 10+ P4 opponents. Penn St., Indiana, and Nebraska need a talking for the B1G. Washington playing WSU has a pass.
|
|
| 12-10-2025 04:48 PM |
|
The Beaver
Heisman

Posts: 7,374
Joined: Apr 2024
Reputation: 960
I Root For: Penn State
Location:
|
RE: ACC Tiebreaker
(12-10-2025 04:48 PM)GoBuckeyes1047 Wrote: (12-10-2025 04:26 PM)schmolik Wrote: (12-10-2025 12:23 PM)bullet Wrote: (12-10-2025 12:14 PM)stever20 Wrote: (12-10-2025 12:09 PM)bullet Wrote: I don't think you are right. Duke not only played a significantly tougher conference schedule, the teams they beat were better, 19 conference wins vs. 18 for Miami.
None of yall can accept that Duke had the toughest road to 6-2 and earned it. You are distracted by their 3 ooc losses.
Using CFP is not "smart." Its putting $$s before equity. Its also saying the ACC is so weak, they have to do the same thing as G conferences.
Reality is that this is the only time this would have happened all the way back to 1998. Is the ACC so weakened that it will recur, or was this a fluke with FSU and Clemson both down?
think it's very possible that it's a universal situation in all the conferences going forward.
Possibly with the megaconferences. I think I checked it the other day and Alabama's SEC opponents had 32 wins and Texas A&M's had 18.
Without a doubt Alabama "deserved" to be in the SEC Championship Game more than Texas A&M (whether Alabama wanted to be in the SEC Championship is a whole other can of worms). Using the CFP rankings, Texas A&M would've been ahead. Is that fair that A&M played a bunch of cupcakes and got to the SEC Championship Game while Alabama played a tougher schedule? And why is A&M higher? Because Alabama lost a non conference game. Yes in this case it was to a sub .500 Florida State but Oklahoma was behind Texas in the CFP rankings because they lost to at the time undefeated Ohio State. Should a team be denied from a conference championship because they wanted to challenge themselves with a tough non conference game? The SEC will drop their P4 rule really quick or Purdue will be the most popular Big Ten team in the future. Agreed that a five loss Duke shouldn't be in the conference championship but you don't need CFP rankings for that, just have a loss component as a tiebreaker but allow everyone one to play one tough non conference opponent.
That's a fair point no one is talking about, Alabama (compared to most of the SEC) stepped up and played 10 P4 opponents along with SC and Florida. Everyone else played 9 P4 opponents and 3 cupcakes, except Ole Miss who technically only played 8 P4 opponents, but I'm willing to give Washington St. a pass because they were P5 when scheduled (also played Tulane). The majority of the other 3 P4 conferences (more than 70% of the other 3 conferences) played 10 P4 opponents with nearly all the ACC and B12 playing 10+ P4 opponents. Penn St., Indiana, and Nebraska need a talking for the B1G. Washington playing WSU has a pass.
We had VT on the schedule but they dropped us. In fairness, they dropped us because we dropped them in 2020 and had ages to work it out or find a replacement but oh well. Setting aside the fact that we treat Temple like a P5 for parochial reasons, we have a series with Syracuse for 27/28.
(This post was last modified: 12-10-2025 06:06 PM by The Beaver.)
|
|
| 12-10-2025 06:05 PM |
|
Gitanole
Barista

Posts: 13,948
Joined: May 2016
Reputation: 2821
I Root For: Florida State
Location: Speared Turf
|
RE: ACC Tiebreaker
ACC tie breaker 1:
Winemaking contest
ACC tie breaker 2:
Cheesemaking contest
|
|
| 12-10-2025 11:38 PM |
|
Crayton
Heisman

Posts: 5,316
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation: 379
I Root For: Florida
Location:
|
RE: ACC Tiebreaker
(12-10-2025 03:52 PM)UofMstateU Wrote: (12-10-2025 03:39 PM)Gitanole Wrote: (12-10-2025 11:51 AM)stever20 Wrote:
Are we sure we want to move so fast on it?

The ACC was left within a micrometer of being completely left out of the playoffs. I would want to ensure that wasnt possible again if I were them.
It isn’t possible again. ACC gets an AQ starting next year. Duke would have replaced JMU. Notre Dame (AQ if in Top 12) would have replaced Miami.
(This post was last modified: 12-11-2025 06:57 AM by Crayton.)
|
|
| 12-11-2025 06:56 AM |
|
Gitanole
Barista

Posts: 13,948
Joined: May 2016
Reputation: 2821
I Root For: Florida State
Location: Speared Turf
|
RE: ACC Tiebreaker
(12-10-2025 03:50 PM)stever20 Wrote: (12-10-2025 03:39 PM)Gitanole Wrote: (12-10-2025 11:51 AM)stever20 Wrote:
Are we sure we want to move so fast on it?

given how close the ACC was to disaster it's totally understandable.
Please engage irony radar.
I’ll try to be more careful next time.
Of course it’s understandable. What’s smh is that an outcome of this sort wasn’t better anticipated.
|
|
| 12-12-2025 08:49 AM |
|
Gitanole
Barista

Posts: 13,948
Joined: May 2016
Reputation: 2821
I Root For: Florida State
Location: Speared Turf
|
RE: ACC Tiebreaker
(12-10-2025 03:52 PM)UofMstateU Wrote: (12-10-2025 03:39 PM)Gitanole Wrote: (12-10-2025 11:51 AM)stever20 Wrote:
Are we sure we want to move so fast on it?

The ACC was left within a micrometer of being completely left out of the playoffs. I would want to ensure that wasnt possible again if I were them.
Please engage irony radar.
I’ll try to be more careful next time.
|
|
| 12-12-2025 08:50 AM |
|
ken d
Hall of Famer

Posts: 21,309
Joined: Dec 2013
Reputation: 2032
I Root For: college sports
Location: Raleigh
|
RE: ACC Tiebreaker
(12-10-2025 12:09 PM)bullet Wrote: (12-10-2025 11:54 AM)GoBuckeyes1047 Wrote: If the CFP Rankings isn't used, I found a tiebreaker that apparently only the NFL uses between common opponents and strength of schedule. Strength of Victory (not to be confused with margin of victory). It takes into account of the win % of the teams you have beaten. I think that is something that should be considered too. Miami would've got 2nd in the ACC and into the ACC CCG if SoV was used ahead of SoS. SEC standings would've remained the same for their top 4 teams with Bama first and Georgia 2nd followed by Ole Miss and Texas A&M.
I don't think you are right. Duke not only played a significantly tougher conference schedule, the teams they beat were better, 19 conference wins vs. 18 for Miami.
None of yall can accept that Duke had the toughest road to 6-2 and earned it. You are distracted by their 3 ooc losses.
Using CFP is not "smart." Its putting $$s before equity. Its also saying the ACC is so weak, they have to do the same thing as G conferences.
Reality is that this is the only time this would have happened all the way back to 1998. Is the ACC so weakened that it will recur, or was this a fluke with FSU and Clemson both down?
I'm not sure how you can say Duke played a significantly tougher conference schedule. Of the 5 other top 6 teams in the conference, they didn't play Miami, Pitt, or SMU, and they lost to Georgia Tech and Virginia.
(This post was last modified: 12-12-2025 09:17 AM by ken d.)
|
|
| 12-12-2025 09:06 AM |
|
bryanw1995
+12 Hackmaster

Posts: 26,978
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3768
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
|
RE: ACC Tiebreaker
(12-10-2025 04:26 PM)schmolik Wrote: (12-10-2025 12:23 PM)bullet Wrote: (12-10-2025 12:14 PM)stever20 Wrote: (12-10-2025 12:09 PM)bullet Wrote: (12-10-2025 11:54 AM)GoBuckeyes1047 Wrote: If the CFP Rankings isn't used, I found a tiebreaker that apparently only the NFL uses between common opponents and strength of schedule. Strength of Victory (not to be confused with margin of victory). It takes into account of the win % of the teams you have beaten. I think that is something that should be considered too. Miami would've got 2nd in the ACC and into the ACC CCG if SoV was used ahead of SoS. SEC standings would've remained the same for their top 4 teams with Bama first and Georgia 2nd followed by Ole Miss and Texas A&M.
I don't think you are right. Duke not only played a significantly tougher conference schedule, the teams they beat were better, 19 conference wins vs. 18 for Miami.
None of yall can accept that Duke had the toughest road to 6-2 and earned it. You are distracted by their 3 ooc losses.
Using CFP is not "smart." Its putting $$s before equity. Its also saying the ACC is so weak, they have to do the same thing as G conferences.
Reality is that this is the only time this would have happened all the way back to 1998. Is the ACC so weakened that it will recur, or was this a fluke with FSU and Clemson both down?
think it's very possible that it's a universal situation in all the conferences going forward.
Possibly with the megaconferences. I think I checked it the other day and Alabama's SEC opponents had 32 wins and Texas A&M's had 18.
Without a doubt Alabama "deserved" to be in the SEC Championship Game more than Texas A&M (whether Alabama wanted to be in the SEC Championship is a whole other can of worms). Using the CFP rankings, Texas A&M would've been ahead. Is that fair that A&M played a bunch of cupcakes and got to the SEC Championship Game while Alabama played a tougher schedule? And why is A&M higher? Because Alabama lost a non conference game. Yes in this case it was to a sub .500 Florida State but Oklahoma was behind Texas in the CFP rankings because they lost to at the time undefeated Ohio State. Should a team be denied from a conference championship because they wanted to challenge themselves with a tough non conference game? The SEC will drop their P4 rule really quick or Purdue will be the most popular Big Ten team in the future. Agreed that a five loss Duke shouldn't be in the conference championship but you don't need CFP rankings for that, just have a loss component as a tiebreaker but allow everyone one to play one tough non conference opponent.
A&M's one "power" opponent won more games than Alabama's 2 opponents combined, and our opponent still came within a whisker of the CFP despite losing to A&M. Alabama had a top 10 SOS this season, but it had nothing to do with their nonconference schedule.
|
|
| 12-12-2025 10:32 AM |
|
bryanw1995
+12 Hackmaster

Posts: 26,978
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3768
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
|
RE: ACC Tiebreaker
(12-11-2025 06:56 AM)Crayton Wrote: (12-10-2025 03:52 PM)UofMstateU Wrote: (12-10-2025 03:39 PM)Gitanole Wrote: (12-10-2025 11:51 AM)stever20 Wrote:
Are we sure we want to move so fast on it?

The ACC was left within a micrometer of being completely left out of the playoffs. I would want to ensure that wasnt possible again if I were them.
It isn’t possible again. ACC gets an AQ starting next year. Duke would have replaced JMU. Notre Dame (AQ if in Top 12) would have replaced Miami.
Like I said the other day, the "fix" for what happened this year was already agreed on months ago, it just doesn't come into effect until next year. Bad luck for Duke and ND, good luck for JMU and Miami.
|
|
| 12-12-2025 10:34 AM |
|
tf8693
All American

Posts: 2,902
Joined: Jul 2023
Reputation: 333
I Root For: Notre Dame
Location:
|
RE: ACC Tiebreaker
(12-10-2025 04:26 PM)schmolik Wrote: (12-10-2025 12:23 PM)bullet Wrote: (12-10-2025 12:14 PM)stever20 Wrote: (12-10-2025 12:09 PM)bullet Wrote: (12-10-2025 11:54 AM)GoBuckeyes1047 Wrote: If the CFP Rankings isn't used, I found a tiebreaker that apparently only the NFL uses between common opponents and strength of schedule. Strength of Victory (not to be confused with margin of victory). It takes into account of the win % of the teams you have beaten. I think that is something that should be considered too. Miami would've got 2nd in the ACC and into the ACC CCG if SoV was used ahead of SoS. SEC standings would've remained the same for their top 4 teams with Bama first and Georgia 2nd followed by Ole Miss and Texas A&M.
I don't think you are right. Duke not only played a significantly tougher conference schedule, the teams they beat were better, 19 conference wins vs. 18 for Miami.
None of yall can accept that Duke had the toughest road to 6-2 and earned it. You are distracted by their 3 ooc losses.
Using CFP is not "smart." Its putting $$s before equity. Its also saying the ACC is so weak, they have to do the same thing as G conferences.
Reality is that this is the only time this would have happened all the way back to 1998. Is the ACC so weakened that it will recur, or was this a fluke with FSU and Clemson both down?
think it's very possible that it's a universal situation in all the conferences going forward.
Possibly with the megaconferences. I think I checked it the other day and Alabama's SEC opponents had 32 wins and Texas A&M's had 18.
Without a doubt Alabama "deserved" to be in the SEC Championship Game more than Texas A&M (whether Alabama wanted to be in the SEC Championship is a whole other can of worms). Using the CFP rankings, Texas A&M would've been ahead. Is that fair that A&M played a bunch of cupcakes and got to the SEC Championship Game while Alabama played a tougher schedule? And why is A&M higher? Because Alabama lost a non conference game. Yes in this case it was to a sub .500 Florida State but Oklahoma was behind Texas in the CFP rankings because they lost to at the time undefeated Ohio State. Should a team be denied from a conference championship because they wanted to challenge themselves with a tough non conference game? The SEC will drop their P4 rule really quick or Purdue will be the most popular Big Ten team in the future. Agreed that a five loss Duke shouldn't be in the conference championship but you don't need CFP rankings for that, just have a loss component as a tiebreaker but allow everyone one to play one tough non conference opponent.
If it was CFP rankings, it would have been Ole Miss, not Alabama or Texas A&M. It Texas A&M had beaten Texas, they would have been in the CFP without application of tiebreakers.
|
|
| 12-12-2025 10:36 AM |
|
bullet
Legend

Posts: 83,946
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5074
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
|
RE: ACC Tiebreaker
(12-12-2025 09:06 AM)ken d Wrote: (12-10-2025 12:09 PM)bullet Wrote: (12-10-2025 11:54 AM)GoBuckeyes1047 Wrote: If the CFP Rankings isn't used, I found a tiebreaker that apparently only the NFL uses between common opponents and strength of schedule. Strength of Victory (not to be confused with margin of victory). It takes into account of the win % of the teams you have beaten. I think that is something that should be considered too. Miami would've got 2nd in the ACC and into the ACC CCG if SoV was used ahead of SoS. SEC standings would've remained the same for their top 4 teams with Bama first and Georgia 2nd followed by Ole Miss and Texas A&M.
I don't think you are right. Duke not only played a significantly tougher conference schedule, the teams they beat were better, 19 conference wins vs. 18 for Miami.
None of yall can accept that Duke had the toughest road to 6-2 and earned it. You are distracted by their 3 ooc losses.
Using CFP is not "smart." Its putting $$s before equity. Its also saying the ACC is so weak, they have to do the same thing as G conferences.
Reality is that this is the only time this would have happened all the way back to 1998. Is the ACC so weakened that it will recur, or was this a fluke with FSU and Clemson both down?
I'm not sure how you can say Duke played a significantly tougher conference schedule. Of the 5 other top 6 teams in the conference, they didn't play Miami, Pitt, or SMU, and they lost to Georgia Tech and Virginia.
The same reason they won the tiebreaker. Nobody else played more than 2 of the top 6. The teams Duke played won 31 games in conference. Everybody else was 28 wins or less.
|
|
| 12-13-2025 01:00 AM |
|
bullet
Legend

Posts: 83,946
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5074
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
|
RE: ACC Tiebreaker
(12-12-2025 10:32 AM)bryanw1995 Wrote: (12-10-2025 04:26 PM)schmolik Wrote: (12-10-2025 12:23 PM)bullet Wrote: (12-10-2025 12:14 PM)stever20 Wrote: (12-10-2025 12:09 PM)bullet Wrote: I don't think you are right. Duke not only played a significantly tougher conference schedule, the teams they beat were better, 19 conference wins vs. 18 for Miami.
None of yall can accept that Duke had the toughest road to 6-2 and earned it. You are distracted by their 3 ooc losses.
Using CFP is not "smart." Its putting $$s before equity. Its also saying the ACC is so weak, they have to do the same thing as G conferences.
Reality is that this is the only time this would have happened all the way back to 1998. Is the ACC so weakened that it will recur, or was this a fluke with FSU and Clemson both down?
think it's very possible that it's a universal situation in all the conferences going forward.
Possibly with the megaconferences. I think I checked it the other day and Alabama's SEC opponents had 32 wins and Texas A&M's had 18.
Without a doubt Alabama "deserved" to be in the SEC Championship Game more than Texas A&M (whether Alabama wanted to be in the SEC Championship is a whole other can of worms). Using the CFP rankings, Texas A&M would've been ahead. Is that fair that A&M played a bunch of cupcakes and got to the SEC Championship Game while Alabama played a tougher schedule? And why is A&M higher? Because Alabama lost a non conference game. Yes in this case it was to a sub .500 Florida State but Oklahoma was behind Texas in the CFP rankings because they lost to at the time undefeated Ohio State. Should a team be denied from a conference championship because they wanted to challenge themselves with a tough non conference game? The SEC will drop their P4 rule really quick or Purdue will be the most popular Big Ten team in the future. Agreed that a five loss Duke shouldn't be in the conference championship but you don't need CFP rankings for that, just have a loss component as a tiebreaker but allow everyone one to play one tough non conference opponent.
A&M's one "power" opponent won more games than Alabama's 2 opponents combined, and our opponent still came within a whisker of the CFP despite losing to A&M. Alabama had a top 10 SOS this season, but it had nothing to do with their nonconference schedule.
The way it worked, Alabama had a vastly tougher conference schedule than A&M. I think their's were 32-32 in conference play and A&M's 18-46.
|
|
| 12-13-2025 01:02 AM |
|
bullet
Legend

Posts: 83,946
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5074
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
|
RE: ACC Tiebreaker
According to the Massey composite, Alabama had the toughest average opponent of anyone in the top 25.
|
|
| 12-13-2025 01:03 AM |
|
The Cutter of Bish
Heisman

Posts: 8,837
Joined: Mar 2013
Reputation: 364
I Root For: the little guy
Location:
|
RE: ACC Tiebreaker
(12-13-2025 01:00 AM)bullet Wrote: (12-12-2025 09:06 AM)ken d Wrote: (12-10-2025 12:09 PM)bullet Wrote: (12-10-2025 11:54 AM)GoBuckeyes1047 Wrote: If the CFP Rankings isn't used, I found a tiebreaker that apparently only the NFL uses between common opponents and strength of schedule. Strength of Victory (not to be confused with margin of victory). It takes into account of the win % of the teams you have beaten. I think that is something that should be considered too. Miami would've got 2nd in the ACC and into the ACC CCG if SoV was used ahead of SoS. SEC standings would've remained the same for their top 4 teams with Bama first and Georgia 2nd followed by Ole Miss and Texas A&M.
I don't think you are right. Duke not only played a significantly tougher conference schedule, the teams they beat were better, 19 conference wins vs. 18 for Miami.
None of yall can accept that Duke had the toughest road to 6-2 and earned it. You are distracted by their 3 ooc losses.
Using CFP is not "smart." Its putting $$s before equity. Its also saying the ACC is so weak, they have to do the same thing as G conferences.
Reality is that this is the only time this would have happened all the way back to 1998. Is the ACC so weakened that it will recur, or was this a fluke with FSU and Clemson both down?
I'm not sure how you can say Duke played a significantly tougher conference schedule. Of the 5 other top 6 teams in the conference, they didn't play Miami, Pitt, or SMU, and they lost to Georgia Tech and Virginia.
The same reason they won the tiebreaker. Nobody else played more than 2 of the top 6. The teams Duke played won 31 games in conference. Everybody else was 28 wins or less.
It's kind of crazy thinking about how the conference went to a single-line format and scrapped divisions so that it could, theoretically, tap the two best overall teams, which too many assumed meant that the two most likely title contenders would get the +1/13th game data point.
And then Duke...
Boy, these mega conferences are quickly causing a lot of problems. I feel like there were some parallels between FCS and FBS playoff bids this season. MVFC might as well have been the SEC. ACC and Ivy results just add chaos, and some decent squads sit at home because of it. H2H sits down Notre Dame for Miami, and Monmouth for UNH. SOS favoring over sheer records, like Alabama and some of those MVFC bids. At least with the FCS bracket being larger, it could absorb a soft conference champion (URI) and have space for a Harvard. There was nothing for the likes of BYU, Notre Dame, or UVA.
|
|
| 12-13-2025 06:12 AM |
|
bullet
Legend

Posts: 83,946
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5074
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
|
RE: ACC Tiebreaker
(12-13-2025 06:12 AM)The Cutter of Bish Wrote: (12-13-2025 01:00 AM)bullet Wrote: (12-12-2025 09:06 AM)ken d Wrote: (12-10-2025 12:09 PM)bullet Wrote: (12-10-2025 11:54 AM)GoBuckeyes1047 Wrote: If the CFP Rankings isn't used, I found a tiebreaker that apparently only the NFL uses between common opponents and strength of schedule. Strength of Victory (not to be confused with margin of victory). It takes into account of the win % of the teams you have beaten. I think that is something that should be considered too. Miami would've got 2nd in the ACC and into the ACC CCG if SoV was used ahead of SoS. SEC standings would've remained the same for their top 4 teams with Bama first and Georgia 2nd followed by Ole Miss and Texas A&M.
I don't think you are right. Duke not only played a significantly tougher conference schedule, the teams they beat were better, 19 conference wins vs. 18 for Miami.
None of yall can accept that Duke had the toughest road to 6-2 and earned it. You are distracted by their 3 ooc losses.
Using CFP is not "smart." Its putting $$s before equity. Its also saying the ACC is so weak, they have to do the same thing as G conferences.
Reality is that this is the only time this would have happened all the way back to 1998. Is the ACC so weakened that it will recur, or was this a fluke with FSU and Clemson both down?
I'm not sure how you can say Duke played a significantly tougher conference schedule. Of the 5 other top 6 teams in the conference, they didn't play Miami, Pitt, or SMU, and they lost to Georgia Tech and Virginia.
The same reason they won the tiebreaker. Nobody else played more than 2 of the top 6. The teams Duke played won 31 games in conference. Everybody else was 28 wins or less.
It's kind of crazy thinking about how the conference went to a single-line format and scrapped divisions so that it could, theoretically, tap the two best overall teams, which too many assumed meant that the two most likely title contenders would get the +1/13th game data point.
And then Duke...
Boy, these mega conferences are quickly causing a lot of problems. I feel like there were some parallels between FCS and FBS playoff bids this season. MVFC might as well have been the SEC. ACC and Ivy results just add chaos, and some decent squads sit at home because of it. H2H sits down Notre Dame for Miami, and Monmouth for UNH. SOS favoring over sheer records, like Alabama and some of those MVFC bids. At least with the FCS bracket being larger, it could absorb a soft conference champion (URI) and have space for a Harvard. There was nothing for the likes of BYU, Notre Dame, or UVA.
It is funny.
You could say its because of the large conferences with variable scheduling, but it wasn't in this case. Duke earned their title by playing the toughest schedule. Now if they played most of the other contenders it might have been different, but it wasn't like they skipped tough teams and got the bottom. The other contenders mostly got the bottom teams, which is probably why there were so many contenders.
|
|
| 12-13-2025 08:12 AM |
|