(12-06-2025 10:45 AM)ccd494 Wrote: (12-06-2025 10:42 AM)bryanw1995 Wrote: Every time somebody tries to push greater g5 participation in the CFP (especially in a year like this one in which we have a very real chance of a 2nd g5 participant already!), we get that much closer to no more g5 at all and a full P4 breakaway. Do you really want that? I know a few who would love to see it happen, and they're only emboldened when people with a platform like ESPN openly push this agenda.
"You need to give us practically everything or we will leave you with nothing! Table scraps are better than nothing!"
"Give us"? Who do you think build the CFP? Roy Kramer built it, or helped to build it when he was SEC Commissioner. He just died yesterday. But he wasn't always an SEC guy. He won a d2 Title at Central Michigan (their only team championship in any sport if their press release is to be believed) before he became Vanderbilt AD and, later, SEC Commissioner. When the BCS moved to 4 teams and renamed to the CFP, that offered greater access for everybody, which Cincinnati gladly took advantage of in 2021. When the CFP expanded again to 12 teams, we guaranteed a spot for a g5 conference champ (and it might be 2 this year!).
The SEC and the rest of the P4 aren't being "given" anything by the g5, but rather it's the other way around. We are giving the g5 access to our playoff that we created, with full knowledge that throwing in another Big 12 or B1G school instead of the MAC or American Champ would draw far more eyeballs and more TV money in any given year. And I'll tell you, right now, most of us are happy to give that to the g5 because the benefits of growing football all across the country are obvious. Also, everybody loves an underdog story. But you can't have 5 of them every single year, or it's just a boring tournament with a bunch of "Conference Champs" getting blown out 50-10 by the the 5th best SEC team.
The CFP isn't some sort of "everyone is equal" crap, it's a meritocracy that offers a bone to some smaller schools, and also 10% of the money to them btw, b/c we think that it's currently in our own best interest and in the best interest of the game. But make no mistake about it, the only thing being given here is what we choose to give to the smaller schools. If you don't believe me, then I'd encourage you to drum up support for a g5 "breakaway". Go leave as a group for FCS, or try to get the NCAA to make you a new classification. Stage your own championships and quit taking body games with Michigan or Florida a couple times a year. Oh, wait, nobody is lining up to do that? I wonder why!
As my old boss used to say, the only unequal thing is treating unequals equally. ie, Alabama is not Alabama St. Texas is not Texas St. Cal is not Cal St Sacramento. ND is not UConn. If that bothers you then go back to school and take an Econ 101 class, or maybe read some Adam Smith.