Wahoowa84
Heisman

Posts: 5,436
Joined: Oct 2017
Reputation: 1176
I Root For: UVa
Location:
|
RE: BC - Letter from the AD
(12-03-2025 02:09 PM)nodak651 Wrote: (12-03-2025 12:50 PM)Wahoowa84 Wrote: (12-02-2025 09:23 PM)DFW HOYA Wrote: (12-02-2025 04:01 PM)Wahoowa84 Wrote: IIRC, Georgetown sponsors FCS football without scholarships. Completely understand that Georgetown is willing to allow its football to flounder (FWIW - I've watched my share Georgetown and Patriot League games). But Georgetown is a horrible example for BC. Georgetown is appropriately following the amateur model. The ACC needs teams that are committed to elite collegiate football.
It's also very questionable whether Virginia can continue sponsoring so many teams. UVa's advantage has been that its a much larger public institution and athletic department donors have been traditionally generous, but the ante is increasing every year at a growing rate. UVa students already subsidize about 10% of the AD budget...and that no longer makes sense when athletes and coaches are earning substantial income.
Finally, D1 (with football) has a minimum commitment to at least sponsor 16 teams. So long as the football blue bloods keep that minimum threshold, FBS programs will all comply.
1. I was not saying BC has no ability to fund major college athletics--they do. It's a $140 million budget. But it's not a zero-sum game that you can't be good if you
have more than 18 sports.
2. Georgetown football is the contemporary version of mid-2000s Army football: a step too slow, a size too small, and underfunded to win consistently. By November they're absolutely worn out. I wouldn't call it floundering (its last three seasons is a combined 16-18) but it's not making plans for the playoffs, either. Were Georgetown not so committed on throwing $16 million/year into basketball and the subsequent ROI of marginal attendance and no at-large NCAA bids since 2015, football could stand more of a fighting chance with grants in aid. But so could 25-odd other teams, too.
3. Virginia's 10% subsidy is laudable compared to what Virginia Tech and James Madison tack on tuition bills to fund football and other sports. At JMU, 77% of its athletic department was funded by student fees as late as 2023.
"The James Madison athletic department spent $68 million on athletics in fiscal 2023 and reported funding $53.3 million of it via mandatory student fees, charged annually to every JMU student as part of their tuition. It’s by far the largest sum of any public school in the country, $23 million more than Old Dominion’s student fee subsidy."
https://www.sportico.com/leagues/college...234771980/
Agree that BC has dramatically improved its investment in athletics since Blake James moved from Miami as the new AD. From EADA reports, the total athletic revenues at Boston College have a nice trend:
FY2020-21 $81M
FY2021-22 $96M (19% YoY growth)
FY2022-23 $118M (23%)
FY2023-24 $137M (16%)
Average ACC athletic department revenues in FY2023-24 were $151M, so BC is still closing the revenue gap with conference peers.
IMHO, money is one (albeit important) variable. My point is that the new professional collegiate athletics model also requires efficiency and prioritization of limited resources. Before Stanford joined, BC sponsored the most sports in the conference. Yet BC has one of the least competitive athletic departments in terms Director Cup points:
FY2020-21 227 points (15th out of 15 ACC members)
FY2021-22 165 points (15th out of 15)
FY2022-23 170 points (15th out of 15)
FY2023-24 360 points (13th out of 15)
FY2024-25 378 points (15th out of 18)
For comparison, the average ACC peers achieve 650 to 700 points. BC isn't just lower than average, it's the most extreme negative outlier...sponsoring the most teams while still achieving on-field futility. That amateur mindset still works at Columbia, Dartmouth and Brown, but it's the opposite of what the A4 conferences are promoting. That's why the Georgetown comparison struck a nerve...as an FCS member, Georgetown has the luxury of under-resourcing its football team. The A4 conferences signed the House settlement committing to professionalizing collegiate athletics.
The old saying "jack of all trades and master of none" is the antithesis of professionalism. The new A4 efficiency role models for athletic departments are the University of Texas (winner of 4 of the past 5 Directors Cups, who only sponsors 21 teams) or Southern Cal (leader in the B1G, although it sponsors far fewer teams than OSU, Michigan or Penn State).
Slight correction - they had 277 points in 2020-21 rather than 227.
That said, they increased their athletics budget by 70% over the past 5 years and how much good has that actually done them? According to you, not much.
They could cut M/W Fencing, Skiing, and Sailing to get down to a more traditional number of 25 programs. Those programs aren't really very expensive to operate, so they would be saving, what, a few million dollars, at most, and at the expense of how much tuition revenue from the walk-ons in those programs, and how many pissed off alumni/donors, all to pump a few million dollars more into Football and Basketball? It's a drop in the bucket in the grand scheme of things - see the law of diminishing returns. BC is the school doing it right - look at the sorry state of college athletics right now thanks to the "pro" mindset of those who sponsor as few sports as possible. It will be a sad day if BC ever cuts a bunch of programs only to spend the savings on coaches that would innevitibly get bought out.
IMO, programs in A4 conferences are in an arms-race to recruit elite athletes that at a minimum have the best potential of making a career/living based on their athletic talents and passions. The competitive schools are attracting the truly elite and BC is getting left behind. Managing BC's 31 teams and 750 D1 athletes is a massive undertaking...BC administrators are currently barely able to survive, rather than thrive, in the A4 ecosystem.
In the amateur model, it was fine to intermingle the truly elite with some-next-level athletes. It worked well for an occasional Doug Flutie or Matt Ryan to subsidize the entire D1 infrastructure. The cost of being competitive, and necessary attention to detail, wasn't high when the NCAA enforced its archaic (and now illegal) rules. The "front-porch" marketing helped the school build its reputation and finances via D1 athletics.
As the new professional model takes hold, the value creators (mainly athletes, some coaches and the rare support staff) are increasingly empowered to demand efficiency. Football and basketball coaches have always been paid market rates (because those sports are profit generators)...now athletes are finally entering this environment. The exceptional athletes will eventually get, and earn, their clout/income. BC has required sports (football, basketball), core competencies (ice hockey, field hockey, etc.), and some well-funded legacy traditions, but a few sports are optional. The question is whether BC's current structure is aligned to succeed in the forthcoming A4 professional model (which will be even more competitive). The fact that the most successful programs (such as the University of Texas and Southern California) can be so successful with one-third fewer teams should cause alarm...because not only are they much more efficient in achieving athletic success, but they're also generating double the revenues.
(This post was last modified: 12-03-2025 04:03 PM by Wahoowa84.)
|
|