quo vadis
Legend

Posts: 56,023
Joined: Aug 2008
Reputation: 3198
I Root For: Notre Dame/USF/G'Town
Location: New Orleans
|
RE: 2025 CFP Race (who is this year's #11 team? Texas?)
(12-01-2025 08:55 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote: (12-01-2025 08:13 PM)WhoseHouse? Wrote: (12-01-2025 07:57 PM)quo vadis Wrote: (12-01-2025 10:44 AM)WhoseHouse? Wrote: Texas resume isn’t any better than BYUs and BYU isn’t in line for an at large so any Texas discussion is really a non-starter. Now if the committee decided to drop Ole Miss out of the field for not having a HC then maybe you’d have an opening but right now the problem for both BYU and UT is the committee has shielded ND who’s clearly the least deserving team in the field right now, with the #9 spot. In a fair world we’d at least be debating ND vs BYU, Miami, and Texas but because they’re ranked in front of Bama for some reason we aren’t.
About the bolded, my gut tells me you're right. When I look at our season, I have a hard time justifying ND ahead of Texas or maybe BYU as well. The CFP seems to be taking a liking to us.
But then looking at other rankings, ND is also #9 in both the AP and Coaches polls. They are #3 in FPI, #6 in the Massey Composite, #5 in SP+, #8 in KPI. Heck, #2 in Sagarin. So a lot of formulas seem to like us. The only thing that has us outside the playoffs is SOR, where we are #13. So maybe my perception is a bit skewed.
ND is obviously really good and maybe you can make the case that they’re one of the 12 best teams in the country but imo they just don’t deserve to be in the playoffs. I think SOR tells the story. I think y’all being ahead of Miami devalues the regular season and yall being ahead of BYU discredits the committee and the things they say they value. Hell even Texas at 9-3 has a strong argument for being ranked ahead if we’re just going to say that losses don’t matter.
It's clear that the Committee cares very little for SOS these days, but the eye testadvanced metrics get a whole lot of love. Blowing out bad teams is just way more impressive to them than sneaking out a 3 point win over Georgia, and also looking very good against very talented teams with poor records is a big deal to them. As quo loves to bring up constantly, schools like LSU and Florida have top 15 talent but not very impressive records. A Committee that that actually watched their games would see that, but a committee that uses a spreadsheet to make its determination...well, all they see is that LSU is only 7-5 and you barely squeaked out a win against them, or that Florida is 4-8 and you lost to them. Never mind that Florida or LSU would have been 10-2 with ND's schedule, too.
Just about the bolded, you are close - what I constantly bring up is that teams like Florida and Auburn have top 15 talent. LSU has top 5 talent.
:)
|
|
| 12-02-2025 01:55 PM |
|
bryanw1995
+12 Hackmaster

Posts: 26,944
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3763
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
|
RE: 2025 CFP Race (who is this year's #11 team? Texas?)
(12-02-2025 01:55 PM)quo vadis Wrote: (12-01-2025 08:55 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote: (12-01-2025 08:13 PM)WhoseHouse? Wrote: (12-01-2025 07:57 PM)quo vadis Wrote: (12-01-2025 10:44 AM)WhoseHouse? Wrote: Texas resume isn’t any better than BYUs and BYU isn’t in line for an at large so any Texas discussion is really a non-starter. Now if the committee decided to drop Ole Miss out of the field for not having a HC then maybe you’d have an opening but right now the problem for both BYU and UT is the committee has shielded ND who’s clearly the least deserving team in the field right now, with the #9 spot. In a fair world we’d at least be debating ND vs BYU, Miami, and Texas but because they’re ranked in front of Bama for some reason we aren’t.
About the bolded, my gut tells me you're right. When I look at our season, I have a hard time justifying ND ahead of Texas or maybe BYU as well. The CFP seems to be taking a liking to us.
But then looking at other rankings, ND is also #9 in both the AP and Coaches polls. They are #3 in FPI, #6 in the Massey Composite, #5 in SP+, #8 in KPI. Heck, #2 in Sagarin. So a lot of formulas seem to like us. The only thing that has us outside the playoffs is SOR, where we are #13. So maybe my perception is a bit skewed.
ND is obviously really good and maybe you can make the case that they’re one of the 12 best teams in the country but imo they just don’t deserve to be in the playoffs. I think SOR tells the story. I think y’all being ahead of Miami devalues the regular season and yall being ahead of BYU discredits the committee and the things they say they value. Hell even Texas at 9-3 has a strong argument for being ranked ahead if we’re just going to say that losses don’t matter.
It's clear that the Committee cares very little for SOS these days, but the eye testadvanced metrics get a whole lot of love. Blowing out bad teams is just way more impressive to them than sneaking out a 3 point win over Georgia, and also looking very good against very talented teams with poor records is a big deal to them. As quo loves to bring up constantly, schools like LSU and Florida have top 15 talent but not very impressive records. A Committee that that actually watched their games would see that, but a committee that uses a spreadsheet to make its determination...well, all they see is that LSU is only 7-5 and you barely squeaked out a win against them, or that Florida is 4-8 and you lost to them. Never mind that Florida or LSU would have been 10-2 with ND's schedule, too.
Just about the bolded, you are close - what I constantly bring up is that teams like Florida and Auburn have top 15 talent. LSU has top 5 talent.
:)
Not this year. They were out-talented in all 5 losses.
Florida and Auburn have the same ceiling as LSU, but LSU was willing to pay Kiffin more money, and once they quit trying to pay Kelly his buyout then the last roadblock to his move was overcome.
Kiffin is a good coach, and as others have mentioned, he's also a good recruiter. But he's never been able to win anything, despite often having comparable to or better talent than others. Do you think that he'll have better talent in 2026/7/8/9 than Georgia, Alabama, A&M, Texas, or OU? There's a decent chance that LSU never has top 5 talent in just the SEC for his entire tenure.
The negative recruiting against him has to be enormous right now. "Don't go play for that guy, he'll ditch you and steal half your position coaches when you're on the cusp of a National Title" is a tough thing to overcome. LSU doesn't need as much money as other SEC rivals, they need MORE than the rest to overcome the drama that swirls around Kiffin like a dark cloud, and they don't have that today, nor will they in the future.
Imagine if he is only 34-14 in his first 3.75 years. Imagine if he goes 7-5 in year 1 or 2. How fast did A&M clear out the stands in Death Valley this year? How much faster would fans turn on a guy like Kiffin who has never left a place better off than it was when he got there?
(This post was last modified: 12-02-2025 02:08 PM by bryanw1995.)
|
|
| 12-02-2025 02:06 PM |
|
quo vadis
Legend

Posts: 56,023
Joined: Aug 2008
Reputation: 3198
I Root For: Notre Dame/USF/G'Town
Location: New Orleans
|
RE: 2025 CFP Race (who is this year's #11 team? Texas?)
(12-02-2025 02:06 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote: (12-02-2025 01:55 PM)quo vadis Wrote: (12-01-2025 08:55 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote: (12-01-2025 08:13 PM)WhoseHouse? Wrote: (12-01-2025 07:57 PM)quo vadis Wrote: About the bolded, my gut tells me you're right. When I look at our season, I have a hard time justifying ND ahead of Texas or maybe BYU as well. The CFP seems to be taking a liking to us.
But then looking at other rankings, ND is also #9 in both the AP and Coaches polls. They are #3 in FPI, #6 in the Massey Composite, #5 in SP+, #8 in KPI. Heck, #2 in Sagarin. So a lot of formulas seem to like us. The only thing that has us outside the playoffs is SOR, where we are #13. So maybe my perception is a bit skewed.
ND is obviously really good and maybe you can make the case that they’re one of the 12 best teams in the country but imo they just don’t deserve to be in the playoffs. I think SOR tells the story. I think y’all being ahead of Miami devalues the regular season and yall being ahead of BYU discredits the committee and the things they say they value. Hell even Texas at 9-3 has a strong argument for being ranked ahead if we’re just going to say that losses don’t matter.
It's clear that the Committee cares very little for SOS these days, but the eye testadvanced metrics get a whole lot of love. Blowing out bad teams is just way more impressive to them than sneaking out a 3 point win over Georgia, and also looking very good against very talented teams with poor records is a big deal to them. As quo loves to bring up constantly, schools like LSU and Florida have top 15 talent but not very impressive records. A Committee that that actually watched their games would see that, but a committee that uses a spreadsheet to make its determination...well, all they see is that LSU is only 7-5 and you barely squeaked out a win against them, or that Florida is 4-8 and you lost to them. Never mind that Florida or LSU would have been 10-2 with ND's schedule, too.
Just about the bolded, you are close - what I constantly bring up is that teams like Florida and Auburn have top 15 talent. LSU has top 5 talent.
:)
Not this year. They were out-talented in all 5 losses.
(snip)
I just go by the 24/7 talent composite.
|
|
| 12-02-2025 02:47 PM |
|