Crayton
Heisman

Posts: 5,309
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation: 379
I Root For: Florida
Location:
|
Power Football "Standings"
Complicated and proprietary ranking systems can sometimes seem just as opaque as the rankings emerging from smoke-filled rooms. If we want an objective yet simple way to rank Power teams, consider the following:
1. 11.1 Ohio St PW: 8 L: 0 OPW: 31 (Big Ten-1)
2. 10.6 Texas A&M PW: 8 L: 0 OPW: 26 (SEC-1)
3. 10.4 Indiana PW: 8 L: 0 OPW: 24 (Big Ten-2)
4. 10.0 BYU PW: 7 L: 1 OPW: 40 (Big 12-1)
5. 9.6 Georgia PW: 7 L: 1 OPW: 36 (SEC-2)
6. 9.5 Texas Tech PW: 7 L: 1 OPW: 35 (Big 12-2)
7. 9.3 Oregon PW: 7 L: 1 OPW: 33 (Big Ten-3)
8. 9.1 Georgia Tech PW: 7 L: 1 OPW: 31 (ACC-1)
9. 8.7 Alabama PW: 7 L: 2 OPW: 37 (SEC-3)
10. 8.2 Utah PW: 6 L: 2 OPW: 42 (Big 12-3)
11. 8.0 USC PW: 6 L: 2 OPW: 40 (Big Ten-4)
12. 7.6 Ole Miss PW: 6 L: 1 OPW: 26 (SEC-4)
13. 7.5 Michigan PW: 6 L: 2 OPW: 35 (Big Ten-5)
14. 7.4 Miami PW: 6 L: 2 OPW: 34 (ACC-2)
15. 7.1 Notre Dame PW: 6 L: 2 OPW: 31 (0-1)
16. 6.9 Oklahoma PW: 5 L: 2 OPW: 39 (SEC-5)
Wins against other Power teams are +1 point, Losses against any team are -1 point, and Opponents' Power Wins (OPW) are worth 0.1 points.
Because all Power Wins (PW) are equal, the M2 get a slight boost in comparison to more comprehensive models. BUT, the formula is SUPER EASY for fans to follow. It eliminates the need for polls and rankings. Subjectively, looking at the above, it is hard to be mad at any team's placement... given the simple and objective manner in which they've been ranked.
The Power Football Standings cannot really evaluate G6 teams, and so if a playoff format is derived from such a standing, G6 participation will have to be determined in a separate manner (perhaps an equivalent "standings" for non-Power teams).
ADDENDUM: The way Miami is shunted to #6 in the ACC standings because their losses happened to be "in" conference rather than "out" opens the door for these silly scenarios where 3-, 4-, and 5-loss teams could win the conference while 10-2 Miami sits at home. The Power Conferences themselves should use a standing such as this internally, if not also externally for a national playoff.
(This post was last modified: 11-18-2025 08:28 PM by Crayton.)
|
|
| 11-18-2025 08:25 PM |
|
Crayton
Heisman

Posts: 5,309
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation: 379
I Root For: Florida
Location:
|
RE: Power Football "Standings"
Top of The Power Standings with 1 more regular season week to go:
1. 12.6 Ohio St PW: 9 L: 0 OPW: 36 (Big Ten-1)
2. 11.6 BYU PW: 8 L: 1 OPW: 46 (Big 12-1)
3. 10.8 Texas A&M PW: 8 L: 0 OPW: 28 (SEC-1)
4. 10.8 Indiana PW: 8 L: 0 OPW: 28 (Big Ten-2)
5. 10.8 Oregon PW: 8 L: 1 OPW: 38 (Big Ten-3)
6. 9.9 Texas Tech PW: 7 L: 1 OPW: 39 (Big 12-2)
7. 9.8 Georgia PW: 7 L: 1 OPW: 38 (SEC-2)
8. 9.4 Utah PW: 7 L: 2 OPW: 44 (Big 12-3)
9. 9.1 Alabama PW: 7 L: 2 OPW: 41 (SEC-3)
10. 9.0 Michigan PW: 7 L: 2 OPW: 40 (Big Ten-4)
11. 8.9 Miami PW: 7 L: 2 OPW: 39 (ACC-1)
12. 8.5 Notre Dame PW: 7 L: 2 OPW: 35 (0-1)
13. 8.4 Georgia Tech PW: 7 L: 2 OPW: 34 (ACC-2)
14. 8.2 Oklahoma PW: 6 L: 2 OPW: 42 (SEC-4)
15. 7.7 Ole Miss PW: 6 L: 1 OPW: 27 (SEC-5)
16. 7.6 Arizona St PW: 6 L: 3 OPW: 46 (Big 12-4)
17. 7.5 USC PW: 6 L: 3 OPW: 45 (Big Ten-5)
18. 7.3 Vanderbilt PW: 6 L: 2 OPW: 33 (SEC-6)
|
|
| 11-23-2025 06:34 PM |
|
Crayton
Heisman

Posts: 5,309
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation: 379
I Root For: Florida
Location:
|
RE: Power Football "Standings"
Maybe the ACC should use this. If the P4 all used it to pair their CCG, only Duke would be bounced, in favor of Miami.
1. 14.0 Ohio St PW: 10 L: 0 OPW: 40 (Big Ten-1)
2. 13.1 BYU PW: 9 L: 1 OPW: 51 (Big 12-1)
3. 12.3 Indiana PW: 9 L: 0 OPW: 33 (Big Ten-2)
4. 12.3 Oregon PW: 9 L: 1 OPW: 43 (Big Ten-3)
5. 11.3 Texas Tech PW: 8 L: 1 OPW: 43 (Big 12-2)
6. 11.2 Georgia PW: 8 L: 1 OPW: 42 (SEC-1)
7. 10.7 Utah PW: 8 L: 2 OPW: 47 (Big 12-3)
8. 10.5 Alabama PW: 8 L: 2 OPW: 45 (SEC-2)
9. 10.3 Miami PW: 8 L: 2 OPW: 43 (ACC-1)
10. 10.2 Texas A&M PW: 8 L: 1 OPW: 32 (SEC-3)
11. 9.9 Notre Dame PW: 8 L: 2 OPW: 39 (0-1)
12. 9.6 Oklahoma PW: 7 L: 2 OPW: 46 (SEC-4)
13. 9.0 Ole Miss PW: 7 L: 1 OPW: 30 (SEC-5)
14. 9.0 USC PW: 7 L: 3 OPW: 50 (Big Ten-4)
15. 8.6 Vanderbilt PW: 7 L: 2 OPW: 36 (SEC-6)
16. 8.6 Arizona PW: 7 L: 3 OPW: 46 (Big 12-4)
17. 8.5 Virginia PW: 7 L: 2 OPW: 35 (ACC-2)
18. 8.4 Michigan PW: 7 L: 3 OPW: 44 (Big Ten-5)
19. 8.3 TCU PW: 7 L: 4 OPW: 53 (Big 12-5)
20. 7.9 Georgia Tech PW: 7 L: 3 OPW: 39 (ACC-3)
21. 7.7 Texas PW: 6 L: 3 OPW: 47 (SEC-7)
22. 7.2 Arizona St PW: 6 L: 4 OPW: 52 (Big 12-6)
23. 7.0 Iowa PW: 6 L: 4 OPW: 50 (Big Ten-6)
24. 6.9 Iowa St PW: 6 L: 4 OPW: 49 (Big 12-7)
25. 6.9 Houston PW: 6 L: 3 OPW: 39 (Big 12-8)
|
|
| 12-02-2025 11:34 AM |
|
AztecEmpire
1st String

Posts: 1,079
Joined: May 2020
Reputation: 105
I Root For: SDSU
Location:
|
RE: Power Football "Standings"
Oregon and Utah are just better programs than USC and have been for awhile and the move to the BIG isnt going to fix it...may make it worse.
|
|
| 12-02-2025 11:56 AM |
|
Wahoowa84
Heisman

Posts: 5,436
Joined: Oct 2017
Reputation: 1176
I Root For: UVa
Location:
|
RE: Power Football "Standings"
(12-02-2025 11:34 AM)Crayton Wrote: Maybe the ACC should use this. If the P4 all used it to pair their CCG, only Duke would be bounced, in favor of Miami.
1. 14.0 Ohio St PW: 10 L: 0 OPW: 40 (Big Ten-1)
2. 13.1 BYU PW: 9 L: 1 OPW: 51 (Big 12-1)
3. 12.3 Indiana PW: 9 L: 0 OPW: 33 (Big Ten-2)
4. 12.3 Oregon PW: 9 L: 1 OPW: 43 (Big Ten-3)
5. 11.3 Texas Tech PW: 8 L: 1 OPW: 43 (Big 12-2)
6. 11.2 Georgia PW: 8 L: 1 OPW: 42 (SEC-1)
7. 10.7 Utah PW: 8 L: 2 OPW: 47 (Big 12-3)
8. 10.5 Alabama PW: 8 L: 2 OPW: 45 (SEC-2)
9. 10.3 Miami PW: 8 L: 2 OPW: 43 (ACC-1)
10. 10.2 Texas A&M PW: 8 L: 1 OPW: 32 (SEC-3)
11. 9.9 Notre Dame PW: 8 L: 2 OPW: 39 (0-1)
12. 9.6 Oklahoma PW: 7 L: 2 OPW: 46 (SEC-4)
13. 9.0 Ole Miss PW: 7 L: 1 OPW: 30 (SEC-5)
14. 9.0 USC PW: 7 L: 3 OPW: 50 (Big Ten-4)
15. 8.6 Vanderbilt PW: 7 L: 2 OPW: 36 (SEC-6)
16. 8.6 Arizona PW: 7 L: 3 OPW: 46 (Big 12-4)
17. 8.5 Virginia PW: 7 L: 2 OPW: 35 (ACC-2)
18. 8.4 Michigan PW: 7 L: 3 OPW: 44 (Big Ten-5)
19. 8.3 TCU PW: 7 L: 4 OPW: 53 (Big 12-5)
20. 7.9 Georgia Tech PW: 7 L: 3 OPW: 39 (ACC-3)
21. 7.7 Texas PW: 6 L: 3 OPW: 47 (SEC-7)
22. 7.2 Arizona St PW: 6 L: 4 OPW: 52 (Big 12-6)
23. 7.0 Iowa PW: 6 L: 4 OPW: 50 (Big Ten-6)
24. 6.9 Iowa St PW: 6 L: 4 OPW: 49 (Big 12-7)
25. 6.9 Houston PW: 6 L: 3 OPW: 39 (Big 12-8)
This would be a much better tie-breaker than the current ACC protocol. It keeps it simple, objective and rewards the desired behavior. Well done.
|
|
| 12-02-2025 12:35 PM |
|