Hello There, Guest! Registered users see far less ads! Register today and join our virtual tailgate. (Login — Register)

Post Reply 
Cold war part deux- ND vs. The ACC
Author Message
Dr Dawgma III Offline
Hark the Sound
*

Posts: 26,072
Joined: Feb 2007
Reputation: 2768
I Root For: The SoCon
Location: The 19th Hole
Post: #81
RE: Cold war part deux- ND vs. The ACC
(11-25-2025 04:11 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  
(11-25-2025 02:57 PM)XLance Wrote:  
(11-25-2025 02:06 PM)tf8693 Wrote:  
(11-22-2025 09:14 PM)XLance Wrote:  
(11-22-2025 10:05 AM)ken d Wrote:  Would the ACC consider allowing ND to remain in the conference for Olympic sports, and just do away with the five game football commitment? The latter doesn't seem to benefit either side very much. It often hurts the Irish SOS, and it almost always hurts the ACC W-L record OOC.

Maybe it would be better for both sides for ND to schedule the top ACC brands instead of rotating through all 17 schools. Adjust the financial package and move on.

Not a chance, unless there is significant monetary compensation.

LOL. I love how defensive certain posters get about the ACC's contractual rights viz. Notre Dame. It's especially amusing when you consider that many of them root for a team that already has one foot out the ACC door anyway.

A few points to consider here:

1. ND fans are in near universal agreement that ND's football obligation to the ACC is excessive. There is ample evidence, albeit of an anecdotal nature, both in this thread and elsewhere on this board. (By way of comparison, there probably is not near universal agreement among ND fans as to the time of day.)

2. As Domer 1978 observed, ND's Administration is extremely tight-lipped about such things, but nevertheless listens to its fanbase.

3. The ACC's GoR is set to expire in 2036, at which time ND's obligation to the ACC would cease unless it were to be extended.

4. Previously, the ACC prematurely extended its media rights deal in an effort to extend its GoR, and in so doing, it left a great deal of money on the table. That caused the ACC to draw criticism from certain of its members, including, but not limited to, the one Lance roots for.

5. While the ACC has, thus far, escaped being the victim of any major raiding in conference realignment, it is unlikely to be as fortunate in the next round.

6. The fact set forth in #5 above puts the ACC in a weaker position than it was in 2012. By contrast, Notre Dame is in a stronger position than it was in 2012.

Based on all of the foregoing (and I don't think there is much argument with the facts above as I have laid them out), I would surmise that, in all likelihood, by 2036 if not sooner, either ND's football game obligation to the ACC will be significantly reduced, or the relationship between ND and the ACC will end. On the bright side, Lance, the school you root for will be out of the ACC by that time or shortly thereafter.

I hate to break it to you, but Notre Dame has already scheduled 5 ACC teams for 2037.
https://fbschedules.com/ncaa/notre-dame/
I hate to break it to you but only three or four of those are ACC teams in 2037.

lol King Salty is back with broken record predictions
11-25-2025 05:07 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
The Beaver Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 7,343
Joined: Apr 2024
Reputation: 955
I Root For: Penn State
Location:
Post: #82
RE: Cold war part deux- ND vs. The ACC
They sued your conference for the right to leave and your conference, rather than fight it in court, negotiated less onorous exit penalties with them. All thats left is the SEC invitation announcement.
11-25-2025 05:19 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Wahoowa84 Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,437
Joined: Oct 2017
Reputation: 1176
I Root For: UVa
Location:
Post: #83
RE: Cold war part deux- ND vs. The ACC
(11-25-2025 02:06 PM)tf8693 Wrote:  
(11-22-2025 09:14 PM)XLance Wrote:  
(11-22-2025 10:05 AM)ken d Wrote:  Would the ACC consider allowing ND to remain in the conference for Olympic sports, and just do away with the five game football commitment? The latter doesn't seem to benefit either side very much. It often hurts the Irish SOS, and it almost always hurts the ACC W-L record OOC.

Maybe it would be better for both sides for ND to schedule the top ACC brands instead of rotating through all 17 schools. Adjust the financial package and move on.

Not a chance, unless there is significant monetary compensation.

LOL. I love how defensive certain posters get about the ACC's contractual rights viz. Notre Dame. It's especially amusing when you consider that many of them root for a team that already has one foot out the ACC door anyway.

A few points to consider here:

1. ND fans are in near universal agreement that ND's football obligation to the ACC is excessive. There is ample evidence, albeit of an anecdotal nature, both in this thread and elsewhere on this board. (By way of comparison, there probably is not near universal agreement among ND fans as to the time of day.)

2. As Domer 1978 observed, ND's Administration is extremely tight-lipped about such things, but nevertheless listens to its fanbase.

3. The ACC's GoR is set to expire in 2036, at which time ND's obligation to the ACC would cease unless it were to be extended.

4. Previously, the ACC prematurely extended its media rights deal in an effort to extend its GoR, and in so doing, it left a great deal of money on the table. That caused the ACC to draw criticism from certain of its members, including, but not limited to, the one Lance roots for.

5. While the ACC has, thus far, escaped being the victim of any major raiding in conference realignment, it is unlikely to be as fortunate in the next round.

6. The fact set forth in #5 above puts the ACC in a weaker position than it was in 2012. By contrast, Notre Dame is in a stronger position than it was in 2012.

Based on all of the foregoing (and I don't think there is much argument with the facts above as I have laid them out), I would surmise that, in all likelihood, by 2036 if not sooner, either ND's football game obligation to the ACC will be significantly reduced, or the relationship between ND and the ACC will end. On the bright side, Lance, the school you root for will be out of the ACC by that time or shortly thereafter.

Regarding point 6.

You’re looking at things through rose colored glasses. The P4 have already agreed to expand to 9-game conference schedules. The P2 are contemplating a conference regular season challenge to generate more media revenue. The B1G commissioner is pressing the idea of conference sponsored “wild card” games as another revenue source. The fact is that the opportunities for out-of-conference scheduling is being dramatically cut, while the financial benefits of conference participation is being enhanced.

Surviving as an independent has meant earning less money. Financially, ND earns $13M to $15M per year more from the ACC than it would in the Big East…and the gap will continue to grow as football-based media payouts outperform basketball growth. The ACC didn’t force ND to leave the Big East, ND made its decision and it has worked well for its football program.

It’s impossible to predict who (ND or the ACC) will have more leverage in 2036, or whether either party even wants leverage. The fact that ND recently publicly advocated for ACC expansion and signed a long-term football annual game contract (outside of the ACC commitment) with Clemson indicates that ND administrators have the opposite perspective on the ACC than what you are suggesting. As odd as it sounds, IMHO ND administrators are acting as a leader of the conference. That’s what is causing so much agitation amongst the football independent old-guard.
(This post was last modified: 11-25-2025 05:26 PM by Wahoowa84.)
11-25-2025 05:19 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
quo vadis Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 56,023
Joined: Aug 2008
Reputation: 3198
I Root For: Notre Dame/USF/G'Town
Location: New Orleans
Post: #84
RE: Cold war part deux- ND vs. The ACC
(11-25-2025 05:19 PM)Wahoowa84 Wrote:  
(11-25-2025 02:06 PM)tf8693 Wrote:  
(11-22-2025 09:14 PM)XLance Wrote:  
(11-22-2025 10:05 AM)ken d Wrote:  Would the ACC consider allowing ND to remain in the conference for Olympic sports, and just do away with the five game football commitment? The latter doesn't seem to benefit either side very much. It often hurts the Irish SOS, and it almost always hurts the ACC W-L record OOC.

Maybe it would be better for both sides for ND to schedule the top ACC brands instead of rotating through all 17 schools. Adjust the financial package and move on.

Not a chance, unless there is significant monetary compensation.

LOL. I love how defensive certain posters get about the ACC's contractual rights viz. Notre Dame. It's especially amusing when you consider that many of them root for a team that already has one foot out the ACC door anyway.

A few points to consider here:

1. ND fans are in near universal agreement that ND's football obligation to the ACC is excessive. There is ample evidence, albeit of an anecdotal nature, both in this thread and elsewhere on this board. (By way of comparison, there probably is not near universal agreement among ND fans as to the time of day.)

2. As Domer 1978 observed, ND's Administration is extremely tight-lipped about such things, but nevertheless listens to its fanbase.

3. The ACC's GoR is set to expire in 2036, at which time ND's obligation to the ACC would cease unless it were to be extended.

4. Previously, the ACC prematurely extended its media rights deal in an effort to extend its GoR, and in so doing, it left a great deal of money on the table. That caused the ACC to draw criticism from certain of its members, including, but not limited to, the one Lance roots for.

5. While the ACC has, thus far, escaped being the victim of any major raiding in conference realignment, it is unlikely to be as fortunate in the next round.

6. The fact set forth in #5 above puts the ACC in a weaker position than it was in 2012. By contrast, Notre Dame is in a stronger position than it was in 2012.

Based on all of the foregoing (and I don't think there is much argument with the facts above as I have laid them out), I would surmise that, in all likelihood, by 2036 if not sooner, either ND's football game obligation to the ACC will be significantly reduced, or the relationship between ND and the ACC will end. On the bright side, Lance, the school you root for will be out of the ACC by that time or shortly thereafter.

Regarding point 6.

You’re looking at things through rose colored glasses. The P4 have already agreed to expand to 9-game conference schedules. The P2 are contemplating a conference regular season challenge to generate more media revenue. The B1G commissioner is pressing the idea of conference sponsored “wild card” games as another revenue source. The fact is that the opportunities for out-of-conference scheduling is being dramatically cut, while the financial benefits of conference participation is being enhanced.

Surviving as an independent has meant earning less money. Financially, ND earns $13M to $15M per year more from the ACC than it would in the Big East…and the gap will continue to grow as football-based media payouts outperform basketball growth. The ACC didn’t force ND to leave the Big East, ND made its decision and it has worked well for its football program.

It’s impossible to predict who (ND or the ACC) will have more leverage in 2036, or whether either party even wants leverage. The fact that ND recently publicly advocated for ACC expansion and signed a long-term football annual game contract (outside of the ACC commitment) with Clemson indicates that ND administrators have the opposite perspective on the ACC than what you are suggesting. As odd as it sounds, IMHO ND administrators are acting as a leader of the conference. That’s what is causing so much agitation amongst the football independent old-guard.

I have long opposed the details of the deal between ND and the ACC. Not the deal itself, ND had to do a deal with the Big East collapsing (largely as a result of ACC poaching, btw). But IMO the Irish paid too high a price with the five game commitment. Poor negotiating IMO.

That said, I agree with your general point - there has never been any evidence that ND admins share my belief. They have seemed happy with the deal all along. That mystifies me. Far too many ACC games on the ND schedule, IMO.
(This post was last modified: 11-25-2025 05:37 PM by quo vadis.)
11-25-2025 05:34 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bullet Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 83,874
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5067
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
Post: #85
RE: Cold war part deux- ND vs. The ACC
(11-25-2025 05:34 PM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(11-25-2025 05:19 PM)Wahoowa84 Wrote:  
(11-25-2025 02:06 PM)tf8693 Wrote:  
(11-22-2025 09:14 PM)XLance Wrote:  
(11-22-2025 10:05 AM)ken d Wrote:  Would the ACC consider allowing ND to remain in the conference for Olympic sports, and just do away with the five game football commitment? The latter doesn't seem to benefit either side very much. It often hurts the Irish SOS, and it almost always hurts the ACC W-L record OOC.

Maybe it would be better for both sides for ND to schedule the top ACC brands instead of rotating through all 17 schools. Adjust the financial package and move on.

Not a chance, unless there is significant monetary compensation.

LOL. I love how defensive certain posters get about the ACC's contractual rights viz. Notre Dame. It's especially amusing when you consider that many of them root for a team that already has one foot out the ACC door anyway.

A few points to consider here:

1. ND fans are in near universal agreement that ND's football obligation to the ACC is excessive. There is ample evidence, albeit of an anecdotal nature, both in this thread and elsewhere on this board. (By way of comparison, there probably is not near universal agreement among ND fans as to the time of day.)

2. As Domer 1978 observed, ND's Administration is extremely tight-lipped about such things, but nevertheless listens to its fanbase.

3. The ACC's GoR is set to expire in 2036, at which time ND's obligation to the ACC would cease unless it were to be extended.

4. Previously, the ACC prematurely extended its media rights deal in an effort to extend its GoR, and in so doing, it left a great deal of money on the table. That caused the ACC to draw criticism from certain of its members, including, but not limited to, the one Lance roots for.

5. While the ACC has, thus far, escaped being the victim of any major raiding in conference realignment, it is unlikely to be as fortunate in the next round.

6. The fact set forth in #5 above puts the ACC in a weaker position than it was in 2012. By contrast, Notre Dame is in a stronger position than it was in 2012.

Based on all of the foregoing (and I don't think there is much argument with the facts above as I have laid them out), I would surmise that, in all likelihood, by 2036 if not sooner, either ND's football game obligation to the ACC will be significantly reduced, or the relationship between ND and the ACC will end. On the bright side, Lance, the school you root for will be out of the ACC by that time or shortly thereafter.

Regarding point 6.

You’re looking at things through rose colored glasses. The P4 have already agreed to expand to 9-game conference schedules. The P2 are contemplating a conference regular season challenge to generate more media revenue. The B1G commissioner is pressing the idea of conference sponsored “wild card” games as another revenue source. The fact is that the opportunities for out-of-conference scheduling is being dramatically cut, while the financial benefits of conference participation is being enhanced.

Surviving as an independent has meant earning less money. Financially, ND earns $13M to $15M per year more from the ACC than it would in the Big East…and the gap will continue to grow as football-based media payouts outperform basketball growth. The ACC didn’t force ND to leave the Big East, ND made its decision and it has worked well for its football program.

It’s impossible to predict who (ND or the ACC) will have more leverage in 2036, or whether either party even wants leverage. The fact that ND recently publicly advocated for ACC expansion and signed a long-term football annual game contract (outside of the ACC commitment) with Clemson indicates that ND administrators have the opposite perspective on the ACC than what you are suggesting. As odd as it sounds, IMHO ND administrators are acting as a leader of the conference. That’s what is causing so much agitation amongst the football independent old-guard.

I have long opposed the details of the deal between ND and the ACC. Not the deal itself, ND had to do a deal with the Big East collapsing (largely as a result of ACC poaching, btw). But IMO the Irish paid too high a price with the five game commitment. Poor negotiating IMO.

That said, I agree with your general point - there has never been any evidence that ND admins share my belief. They have seemed happy with the deal all along. That mystifies me. Far too many ACC games on the ND schedule, IMO.

Big 12 offered 6. ACC offered 5. SEC and Big Ten were all or nothing. Big East would be death for their non-rev sports and at least some of the Big East ADs were very unenthused about ND non-revs backed by fb revenues dominating the conference. ND was having to deal with a really ugly late season schedule. The Big Ten and Big 12 were playing conference games and the SEC was playing conference or patsy games.
(This post was last modified: 11-25-2025 05:42 PM by bullet.)
11-25-2025 05:40 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Gitanole Offline
Barista
*

Posts: 13,916
Joined: May 2016
Reputation: 2818
I Root For: Florida State
Location: Speared Turf
Post: #86
RE: Cold war part deux- ND vs. The ACC
(11-22-2025 08:58 AM)tf8693 Wrote:  I would assume (I could be wrong about this) that as long as the ACC agreement holds, ND has some kind of commitment to the ACC to accept an ACC-affiliated bowl in all years where ND is bowl-eligible but has not been selected for the CFP.

If the agreement is terminated, who knows? One thing even the most ardent ND hater can't honestly call ND is a bowl game whore. In fact, Notre Dame had a no bowl games policy from 1925 to 1969, and the only reason it changed was because ND's Administration feared that ND would never win another national championship with a no bowl games policy (it also helped to make that decision easier to swallow when ND changed its academic calendar around the same time so that school would no longer be in session during bowl season). Point is, unless ND continues a similar arrangement with either the ACC or Big XII, it's not at all unreasonable to assume that ND very well may go to a *CFP or bust* policy on the off-season.

The alternative would be for ND to negotiate its own contingent arrangement with one of the non-playoff bowls, or perhaps in combination with Michigan and USC if those schools leave the Big Ten.

A Notre Dame that disengages from the ACC could always do this. In effect it would just run the tape back on how things went together when the Irish joined. The school and the conference essentially merged their bowl possibilities and improved their ability to negotiate more agreements—which the ACC promptly went out and did.

At the time this helped to counter a Dennis Dodd/CBS-fueled narrative that, thanks to a SEC-B12 Cotton Bowl co-op, the ACC was doomed to lose out in a world heading for B10+PAC, SEC+B12 bowl honeymoon vacay.
(This post was last modified: 11-25-2025 05:43 PM by Gitanole.)
11-25-2025 05:41 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Gitanole Offline
Barista
*

Posts: 13,916
Joined: May 2016
Reputation: 2818
I Root For: Florida State
Location: Speared Turf
Post: #87
RE: Cold war part deux- ND vs. The ACC
(11-22-2025 10:05 AM)ken d Wrote:  ....
Maybe it would be better for both sides for ND to schedule the top ACC brands instead of rotating through all 17 schools. Adjust the financial package and move on.

This can already happen. As I recall it, the conference makes up that part of the ND schedule. The ACC can move to a ‘brands’ approach over a rotation approach any time the parties want.
11-25-2025 05:47 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
XLance Online
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 17,155
Joined: Mar 2008
Reputation: 1262
I Root For: Carolina
Location: Greensboro, NC
Post: #88
RE: Cold war part deux- ND vs. The ACC
(11-25-2025 05:40 PM)bullet Wrote:  
(11-25-2025 05:34 PM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(11-25-2025 05:19 PM)Wahoowa84 Wrote:  
(11-25-2025 02:06 PM)tf8693 Wrote:  
(11-22-2025 09:14 PM)XLance Wrote:  Not a chance, unless there is significant monetary compensation.

LOL. I love how defensive certain posters get about the ACC's contractual rights viz. Notre Dame. It's especially amusing when you consider that many of them root for a team that already has one foot out the ACC door anyway.

A few points to consider here:

1. ND fans are in near universal agreement that ND's football obligation to the ACC is excessive. There is ample evidence, albeit of an anecdotal nature, both in this thread and elsewhere on this board. (By way of comparison, there probably is not near universal agreement among ND fans as to the time of day.)

2. As Domer 1978 observed, ND's Administration is extremely tight-lipped about such things, but nevertheless listens to its fanbase.

3. The ACC's GoR is set to expire in 2036, at which time ND's obligation to the ACC would cease unless it were to be extended.

4. Previously, the ACC prematurely extended its media rights deal in an effort to extend its GoR, and in so doing, it left a great deal of money on the table. That caused the ACC to draw criticism from certain of its members, including, but not limited to, the one Lance roots for.

5. While the ACC has, thus far, escaped being the victim of any major raiding in conference realignment, it is unlikely to be as fortunate in the next round.

6. The fact set forth in #5 above puts the ACC in a weaker position than it was in 2012. By contrast, Notre Dame is in a stronger position than it was in 2012.

Based on all of the foregoing (and I don't think there is much argument with the facts above as I have laid them out), I would surmise that, in all likelihood, by 2036 if not sooner, either ND's football game obligation to the ACC will be significantly reduced, or the relationship between ND and the ACC will end. On the bright side, Lance, the school you root for will be out of the ACC by that time or shortly thereafter.

Regarding point 6.

You’re looking at things through rose colored glasses. The P4 have already agreed to expand to 9-game conference schedules. The P2 are contemplating a conference regular season challenge to generate more media revenue. The B1G commissioner is pressing the idea of conference sponsored “wild card” games as another revenue source. The fact is that the opportunities for out-of-conference scheduling is being dramatically cut, while the financial benefits of conference participation is being enhanced.

Surviving as an independent has meant earning less money. Financially, ND earns $13M to $15M per year more from the ACC than it would in the Big East…and the gap will continue to grow as football-based media payouts outperform basketball growth. The ACC didn’t force ND to leave the Big East, ND made its decision and it has worked well for its football program.

It’s impossible to predict who (ND or the ACC) will have more leverage in 2036, or whether either party even wants leverage. The fact that ND recently publicly advocated for ACC expansion and signed a long-term football annual game contract (outside of the ACC commitment) with Clemson indicates that ND administrators have the opposite perspective on the ACC than what you are suggesting. As odd as it sounds, IMHO ND administrators are acting as a leader of the conference. That’s what is causing so much agitation amongst the football independent old-guard.

I have long opposed the details of the deal between ND and the ACC. Not the deal itself, ND had to do a deal with the Big East collapsing (largely as a result of ACC poaching, btw). But IMO the Irish paid too high a price with the five game commitment. Poor negotiating IMO.

That said, I agree with your general point - there has never been any evidence that ND admins share my belief. They have seemed happy with the deal all along. That mystifies me. Far too many ACC games on the ND schedule, IMO.

Big 12 offered 6. ACC offered 5. SEC and Big Ten were all or nothing. Big East would be death for their non-rev sports and at least some of the Big East ADs were very unenthused about ND non-revs backed by fb revenues dominating the conference. ND was having to deal with a really ugly late season schedule. The Big Ten and Big 12 were playing conference games and the SEC was playing conference or patsy games.

Those old alums that post on Rock's House at NDNation started to throw up in their mouths at the prospect of playing a schedule in places like, Ames, Lubbock, Stillwater. Manhattan and Waco. The chance of that deal going through with the Big 12 at even two games per year was going over like the proverbial "screen door on a submarine".
11-26-2025 12:00 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Wahoowa84 Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,437
Joined: Oct 2017
Reputation: 1176
I Root For: UVa
Location:
Post: #89
RE: Cold war part deux- ND vs. The ACC
(11-25-2025 05:40 PM)bullet Wrote:  
(11-25-2025 05:34 PM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(11-25-2025 05:19 PM)Wahoowa84 Wrote:  
(11-25-2025 02:06 PM)tf8693 Wrote:  
(11-22-2025 09:14 PM)XLance Wrote:  Not a chance, unless there is significant monetary compensation.

LOL. I love how defensive certain posters get about the ACC's contractual rights viz. Notre Dame. It's especially amusing when you consider that many of them root for a team that already has one foot out the ACC door anyway.

A few points to consider here:

1. ND fans are in near universal agreement that ND's football obligation to the ACC is excessive. There is ample evidence, albeit of an anecdotal nature, both in this thread and elsewhere on this board. (By way of comparison, there probably is not near universal agreement among ND fans as to the time of day.)

2. As Domer 1978 observed, ND's Administration is extremely tight-lipped about such things, but nevertheless listens to its fanbase.

3. The ACC's GoR is set to expire in 2036, at which time ND's obligation to the ACC would cease unless it were to be extended.

4. Previously, the ACC prematurely extended its media rights deal in an effort to extend its GoR, and in so doing, it left a great deal of money on the table. That caused the ACC to draw criticism from certain of its members, including, but not limited to, the one Lance roots for.

5. While the ACC has, thus far, escaped being the victim of any major raiding in conference realignment, it is unlikely to be as fortunate in the next round.

6. The fact set forth in #5 above puts the ACC in a weaker position than it was in 2012. By contrast, Notre Dame is in a stronger position than it was in 2012.

Based on all of the foregoing (and I don't think there is much argument with the facts above as I have laid them out), I would surmise that, in all likelihood, by 2036 if not sooner, either ND's football game obligation to the ACC will be significantly reduced, or the relationship between ND and the ACC will end. On the bright side, Lance, the school you root for will be out of the ACC by that time or shortly thereafter.

Regarding point 6.

You’re looking at things through rose colored glasses. The P4 have already agreed to expand to 9-game conference schedules. The P2 are contemplating a conference regular season challenge to generate more media revenue. The B1G commissioner is pressing the idea of conference sponsored “wild card” games as another revenue source. The fact is that the opportunities for out-of-conference scheduling is being dramatically cut, while the financial benefits of conference participation is being enhanced.

Surviving as an independent has meant earning less money. Financially, ND earns $13M to $15M per year more from the ACC than it would in the Big East…and the gap will continue to grow as football-based media payouts outperform basketball growth. The ACC didn’t force ND to leave the Big East, ND made its decision and it has worked well for its football program.

It’s impossible to predict who (ND or the ACC) will have more leverage in 2036, or whether either party even wants leverage. The fact that ND recently publicly advocated for ACC expansion and signed a long-term football annual game contract (outside of the ACC commitment) with Clemson indicates that ND administrators have the opposite perspective on the ACC than what you are suggesting. As odd as it sounds, IMHO ND administrators are acting as a leader of the conference. That’s what is causing so much agitation amongst the football independent old-guard.

I have long opposed the details of the deal between ND and the ACC. Not the deal itself, ND had to do a deal with the Big East collapsing (largely as a result of ACC poaching, btw). But IMO the Irish paid too high a price with the five game commitment. Poor negotiating IMO.

That said, I agree with your general point - there has never been any evidence that ND admins share my belief. They have seemed happy with the deal all along. That mystifies me. Far too many ACC games on the ND schedule, IMO.

Big 12 offered 6. ACC offered 5. SEC and Big Ten were all or nothing. Big East would be death for their non-rev sports and at least some of the Big East ADs were very unenthused about ND non-revs backed by fb revenues dominating the conference. ND was having to deal with a really ugly late season schedule. The Big Ten and Big 12 were playing conference games and the SEC was playing conference or patsy games.

That makes a lot of sense. ND ptb had three options:

1. Football independence purity via the Big East - Make less money; scheduling meaningful games after September is difficult; and allow Olympic sports to whither. But dog-gone-it, they would be heroes to the ND purists on these message boards (Fidel Castro and Che Guevara would approve).

2. Capitulate on football independence (join the darkside/Big Ten or become a renegade/SEC) - Makes most money and ensures long-term stability for the athletic department. It also ruins traditions and uniqueness of ND football. A tempting offer to thick-skinned leaders who are not concerned about their legacies.

3. Create some hybrid arrangement (with the ACC or B12) - It commits to some number of annual football games, while leaving yourself exposed to broader trends and hurdles. Second-guessing the details of the contractual terms is just academic punditry...the big picture is that they didn't want options #1 or #2.


With a dozen years of hindsight, ND admins are probably very comfortable with their decision and deal.
11-26-2025 12:37 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
JRsec Offline
Super Moderator
*

Posts: 44,978
Joined: Mar 2012
Reputation: 13521
I Root For: SEC
Location:
Post: #90
RE: Cold war part deux- ND vs. The ACC
(11-26-2025 12:37 PM)Wahoowa84 Wrote:  
(11-25-2025 05:40 PM)bullet Wrote:  
(11-25-2025 05:34 PM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(11-25-2025 05:19 PM)Wahoowa84 Wrote:  
(11-25-2025 02:06 PM)tf8693 Wrote:  LOL. I love how defensive certain posters get about the ACC's contractual rights viz. Notre Dame. It's especially amusing when you consider that many of them root for a team that already has one foot out the ACC door anyway.

A few points to consider here:

1. ND fans are in near universal agreement that ND's football obligation to the ACC is excessive. There is ample evidence, albeit of an anecdotal nature, both in this thread and elsewhere on this board. (By way of comparison, there probably is not near universal agreement among ND fans as to the time of day.)

2. As Domer 1978 observed, ND's Administration is extremely tight-lipped about such things, but nevertheless listens to its fanbase.

3. The ACC's GoR is set to expire in 2036, at which time ND's obligation to the ACC would cease unless it were to be extended.

4. Previously, the ACC prematurely extended its media rights deal in an effort to extend its GoR, and in so doing, it left a great deal of money on the table. That caused the ACC to draw criticism from certain of its members, including, but not limited to, the one Lance roots for.

5. While the ACC has, thus far, escaped being the victim of any major raiding in conference realignment, it is unlikely to be as fortunate in the next round.

6. The fact set forth in #5 above puts the ACC in a weaker position than it was in 2012. By contrast, Notre Dame is in a stronger position than it was in 2012.

Based on all of the foregoing (and I don't think there is much argument with the facts above as I have laid them out), I would surmise that, in all likelihood, by 2036 if not sooner, either ND's football game obligation to the ACC will be significantly reduced, or the relationship between ND and the ACC will end. On the bright side, Lance, the school you root for will be out of the ACC by that time or shortly thereafter.

Regarding point 6.

You’re looking at things through rose colored glasses. The P4 have already agreed to expand to 9-game conference schedules. The P2 are contemplating a conference regular season challenge to generate more media revenue. The B1G commissioner is pressing the idea of conference sponsored “wild card” games as another revenue source. The fact is that the opportunities for out-of-conference scheduling is being dramatically cut, while the financial benefits of conference participation is being enhanced.

Surviving as an independent has meant earning less money. Financially, ND earns $13M to $15M per year more from the ACC than it would in the Big East…and the gap will continue to grow as football-based media payouts outperform basketball growth. The ACC didn’t force ND to leave the Big East, ND made its decision and it has worked well for its football program.

It’s impossible to predict who (ND or the ACC) will have more leverage in 2036, or whether either party even wants leverage. The fact that ND recently publicly advocated for ACC expansion and signed a long-term football annual game contract (outside of the ACC commitment) with Clemson indicates that ND administrators have the opposite perspective on the ACC than what you are suggesting. As odd as it sounds, IMHO ND administrators are acting as a leader of the conference. That’s what is causing so much agitation amongst the football independent old-guard.

I have long opposed the details of the deal between ND and the ACC. Not the deal itself, ND had to do a deal with the Big East collapsing (largely as a result of ACC poaching, btw). But IMO the Irish paid too high a price with the five game commitment. Poor negotiating IMO.

That said, I agree with your general point - there has never been any evidence that ND admins share my belief. They have seemed happy with the deal all along. That mystifies me. Far too many ACC games on the ND schedule, IMO.

Big 12 offered 6. ACC offered 5. SEC and Big Ten were all or nothing. Big East would be death for their non-rev sports and at least some of the Big East ADs were very unenthused about ND non-revs backed by fb revenues dominating the conference. ND was having to deal with a really ugly late season schedule. The Big Ten and Big 12 were playing conference games and the SEC was playing conference or patsy games.

That makes a lot of sense. ND ptb had three options:

1. Football independence purity via the Big East - Make less money; scheduling meaningful games after September is difficult; and allow Olympic sports to whither. But dog-gone-it, they would be heroes to the ND purists on these message boards (Fidel Castro and Che Guevara would approve).

2. Capitulate on football independence (join the darkside/Big Ten or become a renegade/SEC) - Makes most money and ensures long-term stability for the athletic department. It also ruins traditions and uniqueness of ND football. A tempting offer to thick-skinned leaders who are not concerned about their legacies.

3. Create some hybrid arrangement (with the ACC or B12) - It commits to some number of annual football games, while leaving yourself exposed to broader trends and hurdles. Second-guessing the details of the contractual terms is just academic punditry...the big picture is that they didn't want options #1 or #2.


With a dozen years of hindsight, ND admins are probably very comfortable with their decision and deal.

Yes, but the question now is what do the Irish do if the best football programs of the ACC (brand wise) weigh anchor and leave? Herein resided the revocation of permission for FSU and Clemson to leave for the SEC as announced in an ESPN crawler back in 2011. Notre Dame needed the football powers to remain if they were to affiliate.

Now the question is how do you keep those football brands in house, assuage Notre Dame (which is important to ESPN not necessarily the ACC) and make sure that Duke, North Carolina and Virginia are relieved of what a revenue gap will do to their non-revenue sports in the NIL era?

Here's where speculation of two or all three of those to the SEC make sense. The SEC is killing it with football ratings. The schedule will eventually be all P games. Added football strength at this point puts the SEC at a disadvantage to a Big Ten with a smaller top and middle than the SEC and a larger bottom.

Put Duke, UNC, and Virginia with Kentucky and with the SEC money if the priorities for athletic investment remain the same at those schools their basketball thrives with the extra media money, their football remains roughly the same as now, and their non-revenue sports are fully funded without harming the athletic department.

The only serious threat to leave the Big Ten might be USC. Secure the Trojans as a partial like Notre Dame for the ACC and the Irish now have Stanford, Cal and USC in house. Hold onto the rest of the of the ACC and you now have 14 full members and 2 partials.

Pick up one more to the West and one to the East and your can schedule away a lot of the travel. The California teams like their baseball, and Notre Dame has had some recent success with it. You are left with a group of schools more closely aligned in athletic focus.

Who would the SEC get to move to 20? Kansas to complete the basketball branding, or South Florida to grow their second leading Florida state school. Either way the SEC remains very regional.

How does this help ESPN? It puts the ACCN in all of California. It locks down Notre Dame and U.S.C. for the long haul. Strength of schedule will come from scheduling Clemson, FSU, Miami, Georgia Tech and N.C. State and a few games annually with the SEC and all of the money stays in house for ESPN. North Carolina, Virginia and Duke are now with more Southerly peers Vanderbilt, Florida, Texas, Texas A&M and with another large basketball travel crowd not too far away in Kentucky. ESPN gets to double dip North Carolina and Virginia for the conference networks, and it keeps their pay model intact while picking up a major brand in USC. And by the placement of the basketball schools ESPN locks up market dominance in basketball for their Winter lineup.

Make no mistake, no matter what makeshift arrangements were made to initially land Notre Dame, ESPN will work whatever is necessary to keep them and enhance their markets and position with them. U.S.C. completes the bookends keeping the full membership relatively intact.
11-26-2025 01:05 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bryanw1995 Offline
+12 Hackmaster
*

Posts: 26,947
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3763
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
Post: #91
RE: Cold war part deux- ND vs. The ACC
(11-25-2025 05:34 PM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(11-25-2025 05:19 PM)Wahoowa84 Wrote:  
(11-25-2025 02:06 PM)tf8693 Wrote:  
(11-22-2025 09:14 PM)XLance Wrote:  
(11-22-2025 10:05 AM)ken d Wrote:  Would the ACC consider allowing ND to remain in the conference for Olympic sports, and just do away with the five game football commitment? The latter doesn't seem to benefit either side very much. It often hurts the Irish SOS, and it almost always hurts the ACC W-L record OOC.

Maybe it would be better for both sides for ND to schedule the top ACC brands instead of rotating through all 17 schools. Adjust the financial package and move on.

Not a chance, unless there is significant monetary compensation.

LOL. I love how defensive certain posters get about the ACC's contractual rights viz. Notre Dame. It's especially amusing when you consider that many of them root for a team that already has one foot out the ACC door anyway.

A few points to consider here:

1. ND fans are in near universal agreement that ND's football obligation to the ACC is excessive. There is ample evidence, albeit of an anecdotal nature, both in this thread and elsewhere on this board. (By way of comparison, there probably is not near universal agreement among ND fans as to the time of day.)

2. As Domer 1978 observed, ND's Administration is extremely tight-lipped about such things, but nevertheless listens to its fanbase.

3. The ACC's GoR is set to expire in 2036, at which time ND's obligation to the ACC would cease unless it were to be extended.

4. Previously, the ACC prematurely extended its media rights deal in an effort to extend its GoR, and in so doing, it left a great deal of money on the table. That caused the ACC to draw criticism from certain of its members, including, but not limited to, the one Lance roots for.

5. While the ACC has, thus far, escaped being the victim of any major raiding in conference realignment, it is unlikely to be as fortunate in the next round.

6. The fact set forth in #5 above puts the ACC in a weaker position than it was in 2012. By contrast, Notre Dame is in a stronger position than it was in 2012.

Based on all of the foregoing (and I don't think there is much argument with the facts above as I have laid them out), I would surmise that, in all likelihood, by 2036 if not sooner, either ND's football game obligation to the ACC will be significantly reduced, or the relationship between ND and the ACC will end. On the bright side, Lance, the school you root for will be out of the ACC by that time or shortly thereafter.

Regarding point 6.

You’re looking at things through rose colored glasses. The P4 have already agreed to expand to 9-game conference schedules. The P2 are contemplating a conference regular season challenge to generate more media revenue. The B1G commissioner is pressing the idea of conference sponsored “wild card” games as another revenue source. The fact is that the opportunities for out-of-conference scheduling is being dramatically cut, while the financial benefits of conference participation is being enhanced.

Surviving as an independent has meant earning less money. Financially, ND earns $13M to $15M per year more from the ACC than it would in the Big East…and the gap will continue to grow as football-based media payouts outperform basketball growth. The ACC didn’t force ND to leave the Big East, ND made its decision and it has worked well for its football program.

It’s impossible to predict who (ND or the ACC) will have more leverage in 2036, or whether either party even wants leverage. The fact that ND recently publicly advocated for ACC expansion and signed a long-term football annual game contract (outside of the ACC commitment) with Clemson indicates that ND administrators have the opposite perspective on the ACC than what you are suggesting. As odd as it sounds, IMHO ND administrators are acting as a leader of the conference. That’s what is causing so much agitation amongst the football independent old-guard.

I have long opposed the details of the deal between ND and the ACC. Not the deal itself, ND had to do a deal with the Big East collapsing (largely as a result of ACC poaching, btw). But IMO the Irish paid too high a price with the five game commitment. Poor negotiating IMO.

That said, I agree with your general point - there has never been any evidence that ND admins share my belief. They have seemed happy with the deal all along. That mystifies me. Far too many ACC games on the ND schedule, IMO.

ND is getting almost a half share of the ACC, over $20m per year for the past 2 years. It is no exaggeration to say that this agreement has kept you guys out of the clutches of the B1G, and it has every potential to continue doing so in the future. Is 5 games really too great a price for that? Those 5 games also help you guys fill out your schedule, generally against teams that aren't going to be much of a threat to the Irish.

I think that the deal is a huge win-win. It's great for ND b/c it helps keep their revenues competitive with the P2, and it's also great for the ACC b/c they have a Top Brand that is far more interested in holding the Conference together than in splitting for greener pastures.

This little tiff about some ACC social media posts is a huge nothing burger.
(This post was last modified: 11-26-2025 01:13 PM by bryanw1995.)
11-26-2025 01:12 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Thebullinbamaalways Offline
Water Engineer
*

Posts: 19
Joined: Jul 2023
Reputation: 4
I Root For: Alabama and UAB
Location:
Post: #92
RE: Cold war part deux- ND vs. The ACC
(11-21-2025 05:43 PM)Ned Low Wrote:  I would not be upset to see Notre Dame leave the ACC, simply because I could care less about either entity.

However, Notre Dame does come across as a bit whiny here... if any of this "cold war" nonsense is even true. I checked out the ND 247 board and don't see where it's even being discussed.

Miami won the head-to-head and if their final metrics are better, would deserve the nod in my opinion.

Where's Notre Dame going to go for their Olympic sports if they do leave? The Big East? That's a fine conference but frankly is no match for the ACC top-to-bottom.

They won't join the SEC because the SEC likely doesn't want them. The Big Ten? There's no reason for them to accept such an arrangement, either.

Maybe they could join the B12...

Lastly, what does the ACC owe Notre Dame in football? Nothing. They Irish are independents and the conference should promote "one of their own" over another program every day of the week and twice on Sundays.

I think the SEC would welcome ND, but they would have to completely join in all sports, and they would just be an equal partner like the other teams. No special treatment.
11-26-2025 01:14 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
OdinFrigg Offline
Gone Fishing
*

Posts: 3,200
Joined: Oct 2017
Reputation: 923
I Root For: Canine & Avian
Location: 4,250 mi sw of Oslo
Post: #93
RE: Cold war part deux- ND vs. The ACC
(11-26-2025 12:37 PM)Wahoowa84 Wrote:  
(11-25-2025 05:40 PM)bullet Wrote:  
(11-25-2025 05:34 PM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(11-25-2025 05:19 PM)Wahoowa84 Wrote:  
(11-25-2025 02:06 PM)tf8693 Wrote:  LOL. I love how defensive certain posters get about the ACC's contractual rights viz. Notre Dame. It's especially amusing when you consider that many of them root for a team that already has one foot out the ACC door anyway.

A few points to consider here:

1. ND fans are in near universal agreement that ND's football obligation to the ACC is excessive. There is ample evidence, albeit of an anecdotal nature, both in this thread and elsewhere on this board. (By way of comparison, there probably is not near universal agreement among ND fans as to the time of day.)

2. As Domer 1978 observed, ND's Administration is extremely tight-lipped about such things, but nevertheless listens to its fanbase.

3. The ACC's GoR is set to expire in 2036, at which time ND's obligation to the ACC would cease unless it were to be extended.

4. Previously, the ACC prematurely extended its media rights deal in an effort to extend its GoR, and in so doing, it left a great deal of money on the table. That caused the ACC to draw criticism from certain of its members, including, but not limited to, the one Lance roots for.

5. While the ACC has, thus far, escaped being the victim of any major raiding in conference realignment, it is unlikely to be as fortunate in the next round.

6. The fact set forth in #5 above puts the ACC in a weaker position than it was in 2012. By contrast, Notre Dame is in a stronger position than it was in 2012.

Based on all of the foregoing (and I don't think there is much argument with the facts above as I have laid them out), I would surmise that, in all likelihood, by 2036 if not sooner, either ND's football game obligation to the ACC will be significantly reduced, or the relationship between ND and the ACC will end. On the bright side, Lance, the school you root for will be out of the ACC by that time or shortly thereafter.

Regarding point 6.

You’re looking at things through rose colored glasses. The P4 have already agreed to expand to 9-game conference schedules. The P2 are contemplating a conference regular season challenge to generate more media revenue. The B1G commissioner is pressing the idea of conference sponsored “wild card” games as another revenue source. The fact is that the opportunities for out-of-conference scheduling is being dramatically cut, while the financial benefits of conference participation is being enhanced.

Surviving as an independent has meant earning less money. Financially, ND earns $13M to $15M per year more from the ACC than it would in the Big East…and the gap will continue to grow as football-based media payouts outperform basketball growth. The ACC didn’t force ND to leave the Big East, ND made its decision and it has worked well for its football program.

It’s impossible to predict who (ND or the ACC) will have more leverage in 2036, or whether either party even wants leverage. The fact that ND recently publicly advocated for ACC expansion and signed a long-term football annual game contract (outside of the ACC commitment) with Clemson indicates that ND administrators have the opposite perspective on the ACC than what you are suggesting. As odd as it sounds, IMHO ND administrators are acting as a leader of the conference. That’s what is causing so much agitation amongst the football independent old-guard.

I have long opposed the details of the deal between ND and the ACC. Not the deal itself, ND had to do a deal with the Big East collapsing (largely as a result of ACC poaching, btw). But IMO the Irish paid too high a price with the five game commitment. Poor negotiating IMO.

That said, I agree with your general point - there has never been any evidence that ND admins share my belief. They have seemed happy with the deal all along. That mystifies me. Far too many ACC games on the ND schedule, IMO.

Big 12 offered 6. ACC offered 5. SEC and Big Ten were all or nothing. Big East would be death for their non-rev sports and at least some of the Big East ADs were very unenthused about ND non-revs backed by fb revenues dominating the conference. ND was having to deal with a really ugly late season schedule. The Big Ten and Big 12 were playing conference games and the SEC was playing conference or patsy games.

That makes a lot of sense. ND ptb had three options:

1. Football independence purity via the Big East - Make less money; scheduling meaningful games after September is difficult; and allow Olympic sports to whither. But dog-gone-it, they would be heroes to the ND purists on these message boards (Fidel Castro and Che Guevara would approve).

2. Capitulate on football independence (join the darkside/Big Ten or become a renegade/SEC) - Makes most money and ensures long-term stability for the athletic department. It also ruins traditions and uniqueness of ND football. A tempting offer to thick-skinned leaders who are not concerned about their legacies.

3. Create some hybrid arrangement (with the ACC or B12) - It commits to some number of annual football games, while leaving yourself exposed to broader trends and hurdles. Second-guessing the details of the contractual terms is just academic punditry...the big picture is that they didn't want options #1 or #2.


With a dozen years of hindsight, ND admins are probably very comfortable with their decision and deal.

Fine post there, Wahoowa84.

One can visualize it now. In fifteen years, the inaugural Castro-Guevara Bowl in Havana. Notre Dame is designated the host team, playing the last year’s national champion, Liberty University.

Some lucky fan gets to drive to the game in a 1956 Studebaker Commander, now with a Russian made engine. Studebakers were made in South Bend, so that adds to the nostalgia effect.


[Image: studebaker-commander-havana-cuba-june-ol...141631.jpg]
11-26-2025 02:00 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Wahoowa84 Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,437
Joined: Oct 2017
Reputation: 1176
I Root For: UVa
Location:
Post: #94
RE: Cold war part deux- ND vs. The ACC
(11-26-2025 01:05 PM)JRsec Wrote:  
(11-26-2025 12:37 PM)Wahoowa84 Wrote:  
(11-25-2025 05:40 PM)bullet Wrote:  
(11-25-2025 05:34 PM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(11-25-2025 05:19 PM)Wahoowa84 Wrote:  Regarding point 6.

You’re looking at things through rose colored glasses. The P4 have already agreed to expand to 9-game conference schedules. The P2 are contemplating a conference regular season challenge to generate more media revenue. The B1G commissioner is pressing the idea of conference sponsored “wild card” games as another revenue source. The fact is that the opportunities for out-of-conference scheduling is being dramatically cut, while the financial benefits of conference participation is being enhanced.

Surviving as an independent has meant earning less money. Financially, ND earns $13M to $15M per year more from the ACC than it would in the Big East…and the gap will continue to grow as football-based media payouts outperform basketball growth. The ACC didn’t force ND to leave the Big East, ND made its decision and it has worked well for its football program.

It’s impossible to predict who (ND or the ACC) will have more leverage in 2036, or whether either party even wants leverage. The fact that ND recently publicly advocated for ACC expansion and signed a long-term football annual game contract (outside of the ACC commitment) with Clemson indicates that ND administrators have the opposite perspective on the ACC than what you are suggesting. As odd as it sounds, IMHO ND administrators are acting as a leader of the conference. That’s what is causing so much agitation amongst the football independent old-guard.

I have long opposed the details of the deal between ND and the ACC. Not the deal itself, ND had to do a deal with the Big East collapsing (largely as a result of ACC poaching, btw). But IMO the Irish paid too high a price with the five game commitment. Poor negotiating IMO.

That said, I agree with your general point - there has never been any evidence that ND admins share my belief. They have seemed happy with the deal all along. That mystifies me. Far too many ACC games on the ND schedule, IMO.

Big 12 offered 6. ACC offered 5. SEC and Big Ten were all or nothing. Big East would be death for their non-rev sports and at least some of the Big East ADs were very unenthused about ND non-revs backed by fb revenues dominating the conference. ND was having to deal with a really ugly late season schedule. The Big Ten and Big 12 were playing conference games and the SEC was playing conference or patsy games.

That makes a lot of sense. ND ptb had three options:

1. Football independence purity via the Big East - Make less money; scheduling meaningful games after September is difficult; and allow Olympic sports to whither. But dog-gone-it, they would be heroes to the ND purists on these message boards (Fidel Castro and Che Guevara would approve).

2. Capitulate on football independence (join the darkside/Big Ten or become a renegade/SEC) - Makes most money and ensures long-term stability for the athletic department. It also ruins traditions and uniqueness of ND football. A tempting offer to thick-skinned leaders who are not concerned about their legacies.

3. Create some hybrid arrangement (with the ACC or B12) - It commits to some number of annual football games, while leaving yourself exposed to broader trends and hurdles. Second-guessing the details of the contractual terms is just academic punditry...the big picture is that they didn't want options #1 or #2.


With a dozen years of hindsight, ND admins are probably very comfortable with their decision and deal.

Yes, but the question now is what do the Irish do if the best football programs of the ACC (brand wise) weigh anchor and leave? Herein resided the revocation of permission for FSU and Clemson to leave for the SEC as announced in an ESPN crawler back in 2011. Notre Dame needed the football powers to remain if they were to affiliate.

Now the question is how do you keep those football brands in house, assuage Notre Dame (which is important to ESPN not necessarily the ACC) and make sure that Duke, North Carolina and Virginia are relieved of what a revenue gap will do to their non-revenue sports in the NIL era?

Here's where speculation of two or all three of those to the SEC make sense. The SEC is killing it with football ratings. The schedule will eventually be all P games. Added football strength at this point puts the SEC at a disadvantage to a Big Ten with a smaller top and middle than the SEC and a larger bottom.

Put Duke, UNC, and Virginia with Kentucky and with the SEC money if the priorities for athletic investment remain the same at those schools their basketball thrives with the extra media money, their football remains roughly the same as now, and their non-revenue sports are fully funded without harming the athletic department.

The only serious threat to leave the Big Ten might be USC. Secure the Trojans as a partial like Notre Dame for the ACC and the Irish now have Stanford, Cal and USC in house. Hold onto the rest of the of the ACC and you now have 14 full members and 2 partials.

Pick up one more to the West and one to the East and your can schedule away a lot of the travel. The California teams like their baseball, and Notre Dame has had some recent success with it. You are left with a group of schools more closely aligned in athletic focus.

Who would the SEC get to move to 20? Kansas to complete the basketball branding, or South Florida to grow their second leading Florida state school. Either way the SEC remains very regional.

How does this help ESPN? It puts the ACCN in all of California. It locks down Notre Dame and U.S.C. for the long haul. Strength of schedule will come from scheduling Clemson, FSU, Miami, Georgia Tech and N.C. State and a few games annually with the SEC and all of the money stays in house for ESPN. North Carolina, Virginia and Duke are now with more Southerly peers Vanderbilt, Florida, Texas, Texas A&M and with another large basketball travel crowd not too far away in Kentucky. ESPN gets to double dip North Carolina and Virginia for the conference networks, and it keeps their pay model intact while picking up a major brand in USC. And by the placement of the basketball schools ESPN locks up market dominance in basketball for their Winter lineup.

Make no mistake, no matter what makeshift arrangements were made to initially land Notre Dame, ESPN will work whatever is necessary to keep them and enhance their markets and position with them. U.S.C. completes the bookends keeping the full membership relatively intact.


If ESPN has a shot at building a relationship with a football blue blood like USC, they will take it. USC is behaving somewhat as a free agent in the Big Ten, which is odd given the reputation for collegiality within the oldest conference. Adding fuel to the fire, the top brands are seeking disproportionate revenue and Michigan is being pressured to agree to the PE deal…that’s a lot of public turmoil for a conference that should be celebrating a football resurgence.

The more likely scenario is that the Big Ten will resolve its internal frictions. USC and Michigan will join forces to promote expansion with Cal & Stanford (USC athletes will face less travel; and Michigan will continue to build its academic fiefdom). OSU and PSU will get disproportionate revenue without the awkward PE fig-leaf.
11-26-2025 02:38 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Wahoowa84 Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,437
Joined: Oct 2017
Reputation: 1176
I Root For: UVa
Location:
Post: #95
RE: Cold war part deux- ND vs. The ACC
(11-26-2025 02:00 PM)OdinFrigg Wrote:  
(11-26-2025 12:37 PM)Wahoowa84 Wrote:  
(11-25-2025 05:40 PM)bullet Wrote:  
(11-25-2025 05:34 PM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(11-25-2025 05:19 PM)Wahoowa84 Wrote:  Regarding point 6.

You’re looking at things through rose colored glasses. The P4 have already agreed to expand to 9-game conference schedules. The P2 are contemplating a conference regular season challenge to generate more media revenue. The B1G commissioner is pressing the idea of conference sponsored “wild card” games as another revenue source. The fact is that the opportunities for out-of-conference scheduling is being dramatically cut, while the financial benefits of conference participation is being enhanced.

Surviving as an independent has meant earning less money. Financially, ND earns $13M to $15M per year more from the ACC than it would in the Big East…and the gap will continue to grow as football-based media payouts outperform basketball growth. The ACC didn’t force ND to leave the Big East, ND made its decision and it has worked well for its football program.

It’s impossible to predict who (ND or the ACC) will have more leverage in 2036, or whether either party even wants leverage. The fact that ND recently publicly advocated for ACC expansion and signed a long-term football annual game contract (outside of the ACC commitment) with Clemson indicates that ND administrators have the opposite perspective on the ACC than what you are suggesting. As odd as it sounds, IMHO ND administrators are acting as a leader of the conference. That’s what is causing so much agitation amongst the football independent old-guard.

I have long opposed the details of the deal between ND and the ACC. Not the deal itself, ND had to do a deal with the Big East collapsing (largely as a result of ACC poaching, btw). But IMO the Irish paid too high a price with the five game commitment. Poor negotiating IMO.

That said, I agree with your general point - there has never been any evidence that ND admins share my belief. They have seemed happy with the deal all along. That mystifies me. Far too many ACC games on the ND schedule, IMO.

Big 12 offered 6. ACC offered 5. SEC and Big Ten were all or nothing. Big East would be death for their non-rev sports and at least some of the Big East ADs were very unenthused about ND non-revs backed by fb revenues dominating the conference. ND was having to deal with a really ugly late season schedule. The Big Ten and Big 12 were playing conference games and the SEC was playing conference or patsy games.

That makes a lot of sense. ND ptb had three options:

1. Football independence purity via the Big East - Make less money; scheduling meaningful games after September is difficult; and allow Olympic sports to whither. But dog-gone-it, they would be heroes to the ND purists on these message boards (Fidel Castro and Che Guevara would approve).

2. Capitulate on football independence (join the darkside/Big Ten or become a renegade/SEC) - Makes most money and ensures long-term stability for the athletic department. It also ruins traditions and uniqueness of ND football. A tempting offer to thick-skinned leaders who are not concerned about their legacies.

3. Create some hybrid arrangement (with the ACC or B12) - It commits to some number of annual football games, while leaving yourself exposed to broader trends and hurdles. Second-guessing the details of the contractual terms is just academic punditry...the big picture is that they didn't want options #1 or #2.


With a dozen years of hindsight, ND admins are probably very comfortable with their decision and deal.

Fine post there, Wahoowa84.

One can visualize it now. In fifteen years, the inaugural Castro-Guevara Bowl in Havana. Notre Dame is designated the host team, playing the last year’s national champion, Liberty University.

Some lucky fan gets to drive to the game in a 1956 Studebaker Commander, now with a Russian made engine. Studebakers were made in South Bend, so that adds to the nostalgia effect.


[Image: studebaker-commander-havana-cuba-june-ol...141631.jpg]
LOL…thanks for going with the train of thought.

As an aside, I was going to end option #2 with “a Faustian bargain”, but thought that was over the top and confusing given that ND actually had a Faust as coach.
11-26-2025 02:54 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
XLance Online
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 17,155
Joined: Mar 2008
Reputation: 1262
I Root For: Carolina
Location: Greensboro, NC
Post: #96
RE: Cold war part deux- ND vs. The ACC
(11-26-2025 02:00 PM)OdinFrigg Wrote:  
(11-26-2025 12:37 PM)Wahoowa84 Wrote:  
(11-25-2025 05:40 PM)bullet Wrote:  
(11-25-2025 05:34 PM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(11-25-2025 05:19 PM)Wahoowa84 Wrote:  Regarding point 6.

You’re looking at things through rose colored glasses. The P4 have already agreed to expand to 9-game conference schedules. The P2 are contemplating a conference regular season challenge to generate more media revenue. The B1G commissioner is pressing the idea of conference sponsored “wild card” games as another revenue source. The fact is that the opportunities for out-of-conference scheduling is being dramatically cut, while the financial benefits of conference participation is being enhanced.

Surviving as an independent has meant earning less money. Financially, ND earns $13M to $15M per year more from the ACC than it would in the Big East…and the gap will continue to grow as football-based media payouts outperform basketball growth. The ACC didn’t force ND to leave the Big East, ND made its decision and it has worked well for its football program.

It’s impossible to predict who (ND or the ACC) will have more leverage in 2036, or whether either party even wants leverage. The fact that ND recently publicly advocated for ACC expansion and signed a long-term football annual game contract (outside of the ACC commitment) with Clemson indicates that ND administrators have the opposite perspective on the ACC than what you are suggesting. As odd as it sounds, IMHO ND administrators are acting as a leader of the conference. That’s what is causing so much agitation amongst the football independent old-guard.

I have long opposed the details of the deal between ND and the ACC. Not the deal itself, ND had to do a deal with the Big East collapsing (largely as a result of ACC poaching, btw). But IMO the Irish paid too high a price with the five game commitment. Poor negotiating IMO.

That said, I agree with your general point - there has never been any evidence that ND admins share my belief. They have seemed happy with the deal all along. That mystifies me. Far too many ACC games on the ND schedule, IMO.

Big 12 offered 6. ACC offered 5. SEC and Big Ten were all or nothing. Big East would be death for their non-rev sports and at least some of the Big East ADs were very unenthused about ND non-revs backed by fb revenues dominating the conference. ND was having to deal with a really ugly late season schedule. The Big Ten and Big 12 were playing conference games and the SEC was playing conference or patsy games.

That makes a lot of sense. ND ptb had three options:

1. Football independence purity via the Big East - Make less money; scheduling meaningful games after September is difficult; and allow Olympic sports to whither. But dog-gone-it, they would be heroes to the ND purists on these message boards (Fidel Castro and Che Guevara would approve).

2. Capitulate on football independence (join the darkside/Big Ten or become a renegade/SEC) - Makes most money and ensures long-term stability for the athletic department. It also ruins traditions and uniqueness of ND football. A tempting offer to thick-skinned leaders who are not concerned about their legacies.

3. Create some hybrid arrangement (with the ACC or B12) - It commits to some number of annual football games, while leaving yourself exposed to broader trends and hurdles. Second-guessing the details of the contractual terms is just academic punditry...the big picture is that they didn't want options #1 or #2.


With a dozen years of hindsight, ND admins are probably very comfortable with their decision and deal.

Fine post there, Wahoowa84.

One can visualize it now. In fifteen years, the inaugural Castro-Guevara Bowl in Havana. Notre Dame is designated the host team, playing the last year’s national champion, Liberty University.

Some lucky fan gets to drive to the game in a 1956 Studebaker Commander, now with a Russian made engine. Studebakers were made in South Bend, so that adds to the nostalgia effect.


[Image: studebaker-commander-havana-cuba-june-ol...141631.jpg]





If they could ride in a 1963 Studebaker Avanti you just might have a deal.

[Image: ?u=https%3A%2F%2Ftse1.mm.bing.net%2Fth%2...ipo=images]


Careful though........ the rumor on the Avanti was the back window would blow out when the car got up to 140 MPH.
11-26-2025 03:16 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
domer1978 Offline
All American
*

Posts: 3,752
Joined: Sep 2012
Reputation: 441
I Root For: Notre Dame/Chaos
Location: Arizona/Georgia
Post: #97
RE: Cold war part deux- ND vs. The ACC
(11-26-2025 01:14 PM)Thebullinbamaalways Wrote:  
(11-21-2025 05:43 PM)Ned Low Wrote:  I would not be upset to see Notre Dame leave the ACC, simply because I could care less about either entity.

However, Notre Dame does come across as a bit whiny here... if any of this "cold war" nonsense is even true. I checked out the ND 247 board and don't see where it's even being discussed.

Miami won the head-to-head and if their final metrics are better, would deserve the nod in my opinion.

Where's Notre Dame going to go for their Olympic sports if they do leave? The Big East? That's a fine conference but frankly is no match for the ACC top-to-bottom.

They won't join the SEC because the SEC likely doesn't want them. The Big Ten? There's no reason for them to accept such an arrangement, either.

Maybe they could join the B12...

Lastly, what does the ACC owe Notre Dame in football? Nothing. They Irish are independents and the conference should promote "one of their own" over another program every day of the week and twice on Sundays.

I think the SEC would welcome ND, but they would have to completely join in all sports, and they would just be an equal partner like the other teams. No special treatment.
The SEC would love to have us, but as an equal member.
11-26-2025 03:36 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
JRsec Offline
Super Moderator
*

Posts: 44,978
Joined: Mar 2012
Reputation: 13521
I Root For: SEC
Location:
Post: #98
RE: Cold war part deux- ND vs. The ACC
(11-26-2025 03:36 PM)domer1978 Wrote:  
(11-26-2025 01:14 PM)Thebullinbamaalways Wrote:  
(11-21-2025 05:43 PM)Ned Low Wrote:  I would not be upset to see Notre Dame leave the ACC, simply because I could care less about either entity.

However, Notre Dame does come across as a bit whiny here... if any of this "cold war" nonsense is even true. I checked out the ND 247 board and don't see where it's even being discussed.

Miami won the head-to-head and if their final metrics are better, would deserve the nod in my opinion.

Where's Notre Dame going to go for their Olympic sports if they do leave? The Big East? That's a fine conference but frankly is no match for the ACC top-to-bottom.

They won't join the SEC because the SEC likely doesn't want them. The Big Ten? There's no reason for them to accept such an arrangement, either.

Maybe they could join the B12...

Lastly, what does the ACC owe Notre Dame in football? Nothing. They Irish are independents and the conference should promote "one of their own" over another program every day of the week and twice on Sundays.

I think the SEC would welcome ND, but they would have to completely join in all sports, and they would just be an equal partner like the other teams. No special treatment.
The SEC would love to have us, but as an equal member.

The SEC will continue with the scheduling agreements, and the ACC will continue with the same contractual arrangements, but N.D. may get a bit more say in who they play from the ACC. I think this is angle most likely to arise out of this. It's less potentially destructive to anyone than the battlelines draw in the Big Ten could be.
11-26-2025 04:18 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bryanw1995 Offline
+12 Hackmaster
*

Posts: 26,947
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3763
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
Post: #99
RE: Cold war part deux- ND vs. The ACC
(11-26-2025 02:54 PM)Wahoowa84 Wrote:  
(11-26-2025 02:00 PM)OdinFrigg Wrote:  
(11-26-2025 12:37 PM)Wahoowa84 Wrote:  
(11-25-2025 05:40 PM)bullet Wrote:  
(11-25-2025 05:34 PM)quo vadis Wrote:  I have long opposed the details of the deal between ND and the ACC. Not the deal itself, ND had to do a deal with the Big East collapsing (largely as a result of ACC poaching, btw). But IMO the Irish paid too high a price with the five game commitment. Poor negotiating IMO.

That said, I agree with your general point - there has never been any evidence that ND admins share my belief. They have seemed happy with the deal all along. That mystifies me. Far too many ACC games on the ND schedule, IMO.

Big 12 offered 6. ACC offered 5. SEC and Big Ten were all or nothing. Big East would be death for their non-rev sports and at least some of the Big East ADs were very unenthused about ND non-revs backed by fb revenues dominating the conference. ND was having to deal with a really ugly late season schedule. The Big Ten and Big 12 were playing conference games and the SEC was playing conference or patsy games.

That makes a lot of sense. ND ptb had three options:

1. Football independence purity via the Big East - Make less money; scheduling meaningful games after September is difficult; and allow Olympic sports to whither. But dog-gone-it, they would be heroes to the ND purists on these message boards (Fidel Castro and Che Guevara would approve).

2. Capitulate on football independence (join the darkside/Big Ten or become a renegade/SEC) - Makes most money and ensures long-term stability for the athletic department. It also ruins traditions and uniqueness of ND football. A tempting offer to thick-skinned leaders who are not concerned about their legacies.

3. Create some hybrid arrangement (with the ACC or B12) - It commits to some number of annual football games, while leaving yourself exposed to broader trends and hurdles. Second-guessing the details of the contractual terms is just academic punditry...the big picture is that they didn't want options #1 or #2.


With a dozen years of hindsight, ND admins are probably very comfortable with their decision and deal.

Fine post there, Wahoowa84.

One can visualize it now. In fifteen years, the inaugural Castro-Guevara Bowl in Havana. Notre Dame is designated the host team, playing the last year’s national champion, Liberty University.

Some lucky fan gets to drive to the game in a 1956 Studebaker Commander, now with a Russian made engine. Studebakers were made in South Bend, so that adds to the nostalgia effect.


[Image: studebaker-commander-havana-cuba-june-ol...141631.jpg]
LOL…thanks for going with the train of thought.

As an aside, I was going to end option #2 with “a Faustian bargain”, but thought that was over the top and confusing given that ND actually had a Faust as coach.

And, like option #2, Faust was a move that nobody liked.
11-26-2025 06:35 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
XLance Online
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 17,155
Joined: Mar 2008
Reputation: 1262
I Root For: Carolina
Location: Greensboro, NC
Post: #100
RE: Cold war part deux- ND vs. The ACC
(11-26-2025 01:05 PM)JRsec Wrote:  
(11-26-2025 12:37 PM)Wahoowa84 Wrote:  
(11-25-2025 05:40 PM)bullet Wrote:  
(11-25-2025 05:34 PM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(11-25-2025 05:19 PM)Wahoowa84 Wrote:  Regarding point 6.

You’re looking at things through rose colored glasses. The P4 have already agreed to expand to 9-game conference schedules. The P2 are contemplating a conference regular season challenge to generate more media revenue. The B1G commissioner is pressing the idea of conference sponsored “wild card” games as another revenue source. The fact is that the opportunities for out-of-conference scheduling is being dramatically cut, while the financial benefits of conference participation is being enhanced.

Surviving as an independent has meant earning less money. Financially, ND earns $13M to $15M per year more from the ACC than it would in the Big East…and the gap will continue to grow as football-based media payouts outperform basketball growth. The ACC didn’t force ND to leave the Big East, ND made its decision and it has worked well for its football program.

It’s impossible to predict who (ND or the ACC) will have more leverage in 2036, or whether either party even wants leverage. The fact that ND recently publicly advocated for ACC expansion and signed a long-term football annual game contract (outside of the ACC commitment) with Clemson indicates that ND administrators have the opposite perspective on the ACC than what you are suggesting. As odd as it sounds, IMHO ND administrators are acting as a leader of the conference. That’s what is causing so much agitation amongst the football independent old-guard.

I have long opposed the details of the deal between ND and the ACC. Not the deal itself, ND had to do a deal with the Big East collapsing (largely as a result of ACC poaching, btw). But IMO the Irish paid too high a price with the five game commitment. Poor negotiating IMO.

That said, I agree with your general point - there has never been any evidence that ND admins share my belief. They have seemed happy with the deal all along. That mystifies me. Far too many ACC games on the ND schedule, IMO.

Big 12 offered 6. ACC offered 5. SEC and Big Ten were all or nothing. Big East would be death for their non-rev sports and at least some of the Big East ADs were very unenthused about ND non-revs backed by fb revenues dominating the conference. ND was having to deal with a really ugly late season schedule. The Big Ten and Big 12 were playing conference games and the SEC was playing conference or patsy games.

That makes a lot of sense. ND ptb had three options:

1. Football independence purity via the Big East - Make less money; scheduling meaningful games after September is difficult; and allow Olympic sports to whither. But dog-gone-it, they would be heroes to the ND purists on these message boards (Fidel Castro and Che Guevara would approve).

2. Capitulate on football independence (join the darkside/Big Ten or become a renegade/SEC) - Makes most money and ensures long-term stability for the athletic department. It also ruins traditions and uniqueness of ND football. A tempting offer to thick-skinned leaders who are not concerned about their legacies.

3. Create some hybrid arrangement (with the ACC or B12) - It commits to some number of annual football games, while leaving yourself exposed to broader trends and hurdles. Second-guessing the details of the contractual terms is just academic punditry...the big picture is that they didn't want options #1 or #2.


With a dozen years of hindsight, ND admins are probably very comfortable with their decision and deal.

Yes, but the question now is what do the Irish do if the best football programs of the ACC (brand wise) weigh anchor and leave? Herein resided the revocation of permission for FSU and Clemson to leave for the SEC as announced in an ESPN crawler back in 2011. Notre Dame needed the football powers to remain if they were to affiliate.

Now the question is how do you keep those football brands in house, assuage Notre Dame (which is important to ESPN not necessarily the ACC) and make sure that Duke, North Carolina and Virginia are relieved of what a revenue gap will do to their non-revenue sports in the NIL era?

Here's where speculation of two or all three of those to the SEC make sense. The SEC is killing it with football ratings. The schedule will eventually be all P games. Added football strength at this point puts the SEC at a disadvantage to a Big Ten with a smaller top and middle than the SEC and a larger bottom.

Put Duke, UNC, and Virginia with Kentucky and with the SEC money if the priorities for athletic investment remain the same at those schools their basketball thrives with the extra media money, their football remains roughly the same as now, and their non-revenue sports are fully funded without harming the athletic department.

The only serious threat to leave the Big Ten might be USC. Secure the Trojans as a partial like Notre Dame for the ACC and the Irish now have Stanford, Cal and USC in house. Hold onto the rest of the of the ACC and you now have 14 full members and 2 partials.

Pick up one more to the West and one to the East and your can schedule away a lot of the travel. The California teams like their baseball, and Notre Dame has had some recent success with it. You are left with a group of schools more closely aligned in athletic focus.

Who would the SEC get to move to 20? Kansas to complete the basketball branding, or South Florida to grow their second leading Florida state school. Either way the SEC remains very regional.

How does this help ESPN? It puts the ACCN in all of California. It locks down Notre Dame and U.S.C. for the long haul. Strength of schedule will come from scheduling Clemson, FSU, Miami, Georgia Tech and N.C. State and a few games annually with the SEC and all of the money stays in house for ESPN. North Carolina, Virginia and Duke are now with more Southerly peers Vanderbilt, Florida, Texas, Texas A&M and with another large basketball travel crowd not too far away in Kentucky. ESPN gets to double dip North Carolina and Virginia for the conference networks, and it keeps their pay model intact while picking up a major brand in USC. And by the placement of the basketball schools ESPN locks up market dominance in basketball for their Winter lineup.

Make no mistake, no matter what makeshift arrangements were made to initially land Notre Dame, ESPN will work whatever is necessary to keep them and enhance their markets and position with them. U.S.C. completes the bookends keeping the full membership relatively intact.

USC as a partial works, but we still need to remove the cancer.
11-26-2025 08:25 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Post Reply 




User(s) browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)


Copyright © 2002-2026 Collegiate Sports Nation Bulletin Board System (CSNbbs), All Rights Reserved.
CSNbbs is an independent fan site and is in no way affiliated to the NCAA or any of the schools and conferences it represents.
This site monetizes links. FTC Disclosure.
We allow third-party companies to serve ads and/or collect certain anonymous information when you visit our web site. These companies may use non-personally identifiable information (e.g., click stream information, browser type, time and date, subject of advertisements clicked or scrolled over) during your visits to this and other Web sites in order to provide advertisements about goods and services likely to be of greater interest to you. These companies typically use a cookie or third party web beacon to collect this information. To learn more about this behavioral advertising practice or to opt-out of this type of advertising, you can visit http://www.networkadvertising.org.
Powered By MyBB, © 2002-2026 MyBB Group.