Hello There, Guest! Registered users see far less ads! Register today and join our virtual tailgate. (Login — Register)

Post Reply 
2025 CFP Race (who is this year's #11 team? Notre Dame?)
Author Message
bryanw1995 Offline
+12 Hackmaster
*

Posts: 26,944
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3763
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
Post: #141
RE: 2025 CFP Race (10 wins won't be enough for teams like Vandy and Georgia)
(11-24-2025 08:21 AM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(11-23-2025 12:09 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(11-23-2025 12:02 PM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(11-23-2025 11:59 AM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  Looks like you’re overstating BYU’s odds, as the committee has them behind OU, Alabama and ND right now, despite the fact that their resume looks eerily similar to Ole Miss’ and Oregon’s. What’s the difference between those 3 schools…similar SOR, similar top win for all 3, nearly identical SOS…oh, wait, I got it, one of them is not in the P2. I firmly believe that if BYU was in the B1G or SEC, they’d be in the 6-8 range right now instead of #11.

Probably. Then again if BYU were in the SEC I don't think they'd be 10-1 either.

In any event, I believe BYU has a clear path - they beat UCF they are in nB12 title game, and win that and they are in the playoffs. I can't feel that bad for a team that controls its destiny.

I think they’d have the same record as Oregon or Ole Miss if they’d played their schedules. Not every team in the SEC has a top 10 SOS.

Oregon SOS 24
BYU SOS 28
Ole Miss SOS 33

IMO, metrics like SOR and SOS are great, and among the very best we have to go on, but there are IMO intangibles about playing an SEC schedule that probably can't be quantified, the "meat grinder" aspect. IMO, BYU just does not have the athletes to stand up to the rigors of an SEC schedule. They would get worn down in a way they do not in the nB12.

For example, to be 10-1 right now, BYU would have to win 2 out of 3 games vs LSU, Oklahoma and Georgia, all played within a 28 day period. I think they lose at least two of those right there.

They'd also have to avoid upsets against talented underachievers like Florida and South Carolina. They'd have to beat arguably the best G5 team in Tulane. Heck, even bad teams like Mississippi State and Arkansas probably have as much talent as they do. They'd be favored and likely to win any of those games, but IMO a loss in at least one is likely.

So I don't see it, but that's just MO.

It's disingenuous for us to say on the one hand "the SEC should get more teams in the CFP b/c our schedules are so incredibly difficult across the board", but then turn around when one of our teams is getting compared to a team with a similar SOS or SOR and say "but, but, you didn't play OU and Georgia". I've even seen people say that A&M got a light schedule b/c we missed Georgia and Alabama this season. Well, our SOS is still #23, which btw is only 1 better than Oregon's 24 and 5 better than BYU's 28, and we helped Louisiana's Governor realize his lifelong dream of becoming the new LSU AD. A high SOS or SOR is directly comparable. The Big 12 is always competitive, and this year is no exception. It's not like BYU is cruising through an AAC or ACC schedule and looking like heroes over there against a bunch of weaklings, they're facing a war every weekend, just like Oregon and Ole Miss are.

Saying "SEC games are tougher b/c you're playing SEC opponents" might mean something to you or me, but there's no point in saying that to a Committee that we (halfway) control that is tasked with finding teams to put into a National Playoff. If we don't want the money from the National Playoff, we can always just run an SEC-only playoff in the future I guess, but, while we have a Committee for all of FBS that we largely assembled and are responsible for, we need reasonable ways to compare SEC teams to others. Would you rather the Committee use "Miami beat Syracuse by 50 while Vanderbilt only beat Tennessee by 14 so Miami must be better b/c eye test", or "Miami's had a really good year but their SOS is only 43 while Vanderbilt's is 21 so we think that Vanderbilt is the stronger team"? Because those are both probably conversations going on at CFP Committee HQ.
11-24-2025 12:35 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bryanw1995 Offline
+12 Hackmaster
*

Posts: 26,944
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3763
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
Post: #142
RE: 2025 CFP Race (10 wins won't be enough for teams like Vandy and Georgia)
(11-24-2025 10:03 AM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(11-24-2025 09:56 AM)WhoseHouse? Wrote:  
(11-23-2025 12:02 PM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(11-23-2025 11:59 AM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  Looks like you’re overstating BYU’s odds, as the committee has them behind OU, Alabama and ND right now, despite the fact that their resume looks eerily similar to Ole Miss’ and Oregon’s. What’s the difference between those 3 schools…similar SOR, similar top win for all 3, nearly identical SOS…oh, wait, I got it, one of them is not in the P2. I firmly believe that if BYU was in the B1G or SEC, they’d be in the 6-8 range right now instead of #11.

Probably. Then again if BYU were in the SEC I don't think they'd be 10-1 either.

In any event, I believe BYU has a clear path - they beat UCF they are in nB12 title game, and win that and they are in the playoffs. I can't feel that bad for a team that controls its destiny.

Didn’t have that energy with Bama last year lol

The nB12 is IMO different. You don't face the same challenges as in the SEC, so I have less sympathy for teams that control their fate and don't get it done. In the SEC, it's almost impossible for anyone to do that, the competition is just much tougher. That's why the SEC should join the B1G in demanding 4 autobids, to avoid travesties like last year.

To me, given BYU's nB12 membership, getting in with two losses to Texas Tech is asking for too much unless some significant upsets happen among the top 8-12 teams this week. The league is not a two-bid league in a 12-team playoff, as they say in hoops. Root for ND to lose to Stanford, Alabama to lose to Auburn, Oklahoma to lose to LSU, maybe something else and there might be a spot for a BYU that loses the CCG and finishes 11-2 or whatever.

You keep saying that, but 3 SEC bids one year and 5 the next is preferable to 4 every single year, if only b/c it gets thousands of people like you and me arguing about it over the digital water cooler for the entire offseason (and in-season now apparently, too). And if we have a down year and only get 3, or if the ACC or Big 12 has a aolid year and THEY get 3 instead of just 1 or 2 (as could still happen with the Big 12 this year), then I think that should be acceptable, even desirable. If we expand enough and can get multiple bids + plenty of at larges, great, but I don't know that there's much enthusiasm for going beyond 16. Maybe 18 with 3-3-3-3-1-5 gets traction, or 16 with 3-3-3-3-1-3? Might be the next CFP contract before we make major changes though.
11-24-2025 12:46 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
GoBuckeyes1047 Offline
All American
*

Posts: 3,075
Joined: Jan 2021
Reputation: 302
I Root For: Ohio State
Location:
Post: #143
RE: 2025 CFP Race (10 wins won't be enough for teams like Vandy and Georgia)
(11-24-2025 12:46 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(11-24-2025 10:03 AM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(11-24-2025 09:56 AM)WhoseHouse? Wrote:  
(11-23-2025 12:02 PM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(11-23-2025 11:59 AM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  Looks like you’re overstating BYU’s odds, as the committee has them behind OU, Alabama and ND right now, despite the fact that their resume looks eerily similar to Ole Miss’ and Oregon’s. What’s the difference between those 3 schools…similar SOR, similar top win for all 3, nearly identical SOS…oh, wait, I got it, one of them is not in the P2. I firmly believe that if BYU was in the B1G or SEC, they’d be in the 6-8 range right now instead of #11.

Probably. Then again if BYU were in the SEC I don't think they'd be 10-1 either.

In any event, I believe BYU has a clear path - they beat UCF they are in nB12 title game, and win that and they are in the playoffs. I can't feel that bad for a team that controls its destiny.

Didn’t have that energy with Bama last year lol

The nB12 is IMO different. You don't face the same challenges as in the SEC, so I have less sympathy for teams that control their fate and don't get it done. In the SEC, it's almost impossible for anyone to do that, the competition is just much tougher. That's why the SEC should join the B1G in demanding 4 autobids, to avoid travesties like last year.

To me, given BYU's nB12 membership, getting in with two losses to Texas Tech is asking for too much unless some significant upsets happen among the top 8-12 teams this week. The league is not a two-bid league in a 12-team playoff, as they say in hoops. Root for ND to lose to Stanford, Alabama to lose to Auburn, Oklahoma to lose to LSU, maybe something else and there might be a spot for a BYU that loses the CCG and finishes 11-2 or whatever.

You keep saying that, but 3 SEC bids one year and 5 the next is preferable to 4 every single year, if only b/c it gets thousands of people like you and me arguing about it over the digital water cooler for the entire offseason (and in-season now apparently, too). And if we have a down year and only get 3, or if the ACC or Big 12 has a aolid year and THEY get 3 instead of just 1 or 2 (as could still happen with the Big 12 this year), then I think that should be acceptable, even desirable. If we expand enough and can get multiple bids + plenty of at larges, great, but I don't know that there's much enthusiasm for going beyond 16. Maybe 18 with 3-3-3-3-1-5 gets traction, or 16 with 3-3-3-3-1-3? Might be the next CFP contract before we make major changes though.

I don't think 3/3/3/3/1+3 moves the needle for the SEC and probably not for the B1G, but I think 4/4/3/3/1+3 or 3/3/3/3/1+5 would. I know the SEC don't want to move beyond 16 teams, but adding 2 games to the proposed 16 team CFP for 18 teams should be reasonable enough as with 2 double byes, it maintains the value of the CCGs and allows for the creation of the WCGs. I will say for the B1G and SEC, I don't think there's value for the 3 bids as most years, the 2 teams participating in a 3v4 WCG are likely already in (inside the top 18) so I think you need that 4th bid for the B1G and SEC to add value for WCGs so I think it needs to be 4/4/3/3/1+3. 3 bids each for the ACC and B12 is more than generous enough. I could see the SEC, however, opt for 3/3/3/3/1+5 though if they think they could get more than 6 bids frequent enough.
11-24-2025 01:10 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
quo vadis Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 56,023
Joined: Aug 2008
Reputation: 3198
I Root For: Notre Dame/USF/G'Town
Location: New Orleans
Post: #144
RE: 2025 CFP Race (10 wins won't be enough for teams like Vandy and Georgia)
(11-24-2025 12:46 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(11-24-2025 10:03 AM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(11-24-2025 09:56 AM)WhoseHouse? Wrote:  
(11-23-2025 12:02 PM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(11-23-2025 11:59 AM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  Looks like you’re overstating BYU’s odds, as the committee has them behind OU, Alabama and ND right now, despite the fact that their resume looks eerily similar to Ole Miss’ and Oregon’s. What’s the difference between those 3 schools…similar SOR, similar top win for all 3, nearly identical SOS…oh, wait, I got it, one of them is not in the P2. I firmly believe that if BYU was in the B1G or SEC, they’d be in the 6-8 range right now instead of #11.

Probably. Then again if BYU were in the SEC I don't think they'd be 10-1 either.

In any event, I believe BYU has a clear path - they beat UCF they are in nB12 title game, and win that and they are in the playoffs. I can't feel that bad for a team that controls its destiny.

Didn’t have that energy with Bama last year lol

The nB12 is IMO different. You don't face the same challenges as in the SEC, so I have less sympathy for teams that control their fate and don't get it done. In the SEC, it's almost impossible for anyone to do that, the competition is just much tougher. That's why the SEC should join the B1G in demanding 4 autobids, to avoid travesties like last year.

To me, given BYU's nB12 membership, getting in with two losses to Texas Tech is asking for too much unless some significant upsets happen among the top 8-12 teams this week. The league is not a two-bid league in a 12-team playoff, as they say in hoops. Root for ND to lose to Stanford, Alabama to lose to Auburn, Oklahoma to lose to LSU, maybe something else and there might be a spot for a BYU that loses the CCG and finishes 11-2 or whatever.

You keep saying that, but 3 SEC bids one year and 5 the next is preferable to 4 every single year, if only b/c it gets thousands of people like you and me arguing about it over the digital water cooler for the entire offseason (and in-season now apparently, too). And if we have a down year and only get 3, or if the ACC or Big 12 has a aolid year and THEY get 3 instead of just 1 or 2 (as could still happen with the Big 12 this year), then I think that should be acceptable, even desirable. If we expand enough and can get multiple bids + plenty of at larges, great, but I don't know that there's much enthusiasm for going beyond 16. Maybe 18 with 3-3-3-3-1-5 gets traction, or 16 with 3-3-3-3-1-3? Might be the next CFP contract before we make major changes though.

FWIW, when I say the SEC should join the B1G in demanding 4 autobids, I am not proposing that as a simultaneous floor and ceiling, just a floor. If a 5th or more SEC team is qualified they should get in too. But never less than four.

IMO, given the performance and brand power of the P2, a 4-4-2-2-1 model for a 16-team playoff is appropriate. There is no way the ACC and nB12 should be on a structural par with the B1G and SEC.
(This post was last modified: 11-24-2025 02:03 PM by quo vadis.)
11-24-2025 01:57 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Crayton Online
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,310
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation: 379
I Root For: Florida
Location:
Post: #145
RE: 2025 CFP Race (10 wins won't be enough for teams like Vandy and Georgia)
(11-24-2025 12:16 PM)DirtyDukes Wrote:  
(11-23-2025 11:40 AM)Crayton Wrote:  JMU also slips a bit after their narrow victory over WSU.
[Image: attachment.php?aid=12252]

I know, I know UNT beat the brakes off them earlier in like week 3 this season, but we beat a WSU by 4 who lost to #19 UVA by 2 and #4 Ole Miss by 3 in October.

Wazzu is well travelled this year. JMU fans should be crunching the numbers on how the other “Duke” team wins the ACC, though (as seen in the graphic) excessive style points could also get the Dukes in over a 3-loss AAC/ACC champ. … of course the media would be pressuring the committee NOT to take JMU in that circumstance.
11-24-2025 01:59 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
YNot Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,082
Joined: May 2014
Reputation: 388
I Root For: BYU
Location:
Post: #146
RE: 2025 CFP Race (10 wins won't be enough for teams like Vandy and Georgia)
(11-24-2025 12:35 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(11-24-2025 08:21 AM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(11-23-2025 12:09 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(11-23-2025 12:02 PM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(11-23-2025 11:59 AM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  Looks like you’re overstating BYU’s odds, as the committee has them behind OU, Alabama and ND right now, despite the fact that their resume looks eerily similar to Ole Miss’ and Oregon’s. What’s the difference between those 3 schools…similar SOR, similar top win for all 3, nearly identical SOS…oh, wait, I got it, one of them is not in the P2. I firmly believe that if BYU was in the B1G or SEC, they’d be in the 6-8 range right now instead of #11.

Probably. Then again if BYU were in the SEC I don't think they'd be 10-1 either.

In any event, I believe BYU has a clear path - they beat UCF they are in nB12 title game, and win that and they are in the playoffs. I can't feel that bad for a team that controls its destiny.

I think they’d have the same record as Oregon or Ole Miss if they’d played their schedules. Not every team in the SEC has a top 10 SOS.

Oregon SOS 24
BYU SOS 28
Ole Miss SOS 33

IMO, metrics like SOR and SOS are great, and among the very best we have to go on, but there are IMO intangibles about playing an SEC schedule that probably can't be quantified, the "meat grinder" aspect. IMO, BYU just does not have the athletes to stand up to the rigors of an SEC schedule. They would get worn down in a way they do not in the nB12.

For example, to be 10-1 right now, BYU would have to win 2 out of 3 games vs LSU, Oklahoma and Georgia, all played within a 28 day period. I think they lose at least two of those right there.

They'd also have to avoid upsets against talented underachievers like Florida and South Carolina. They'd have to beat arguably the best G5 team in Tulane. Heck, even bad teams like Mississippi State and Arkansas probably have as much talent as they do. They'd be favored and likely to win any of those games, but IMO a loss in at least one is likely.

So I don't see it, but that's just MO.

It's disingenuous for us to say on the one hand "the SEC should get more teams in the CFP b/c our schedules are so incredibly difficult across the board", but then turn around when one of our teams is getting compared to a team with a similar SOS or SOR and say "but, but, you didn't play OU and Georgia". I've even seen people say that A&M got a light schedule b/c we missed Georgia and Alabama this season. Well, our SOS is still #23, which btw is only 1 better than Oregon's 24 and 5 better than BYU's 28, and we helped Louisiana's Governor realize his lifelong dream of becoming the new LSU AD. A high SOS or SOR is directly comparable. The Big 12 is always competitive, and this year is no exception. It's not like BYU is cruising through an AAC or ACC schedule and looking like heroes over there against a bunch of weaklings, they're facing a war every weekend, just like Oregon and Ole Miss are.

Saying "SEC games are tougher b/c you're playing SEC opponents" might mean something to you or me, but there's no point in saying that to a Committee that we (halfway) control that is tasked with finding teams to put into a National Playoff. If we don't want the money from the National Playoff, we can always just run an SEC-only playoff in the future I guess, but, while we have a Committee for all of FBS that we largely assembled and are responsible for, we need reasonable ways to compare SEC teams to others. Would you rather the Committee use "Miami beat Syracuse by 50 while Vanderbilt only beat Tennessee by 14 so Miami must be better b/c eye test", or "Miami's had a really good year but their SOS is only 43 while Vanderbilt's is 21 so we think that Vanderbilt is the stronger team"? Because those are both probably conversations going on at CFP Committee HQ.

Also lost in the evaluation is where the games are played.

Ole Miss has played THREE road games so far this year. THREE! @Kentucky, @Georgia, @Oklahoma. Their final road game is @Mississippi State, so Ole Miss will leave the state of Mississippi only THREE times the entire season!

Ole Miss has also only played 7 P4 games...again, with most of those at home. 6-1 against P4.

Meanwhile, BYU has played 9 P4 games, with 5 of those on the road...plus @ECU, over 2,000 miles away.

In its 8-game conference schedule, Ole Miss will play 6 of the bottom 7 SEC teams...and AVOID A&M, Bama, Texas, Vanderbilt, Tennessee, and even Missouri.

What is Ole Miss's record if they had played an extra top-half SEC opponent on the road instead of hosting Tulane or Georgia State...and what if Washington State had been on the road? Ole Miss is more likely 8-3 than 10-1.

Yet, Ole Miss is positioned for a CFP HOME game to maintain the pretense!

W-L:
(6)Ole Miss = 10-1
(11)BYU = 10-1

v. top-10:
(6)OLE MISS = 1-1
(11)BYU = 0-1

v. Ranked:
(6)OLE MISS = 1-1
(11)BYU = 1-1

v. P4:
(11)BYU = 8-1
(6)OLE MISS = 6-1

v. P4 road:
(11)BYU = 4-1
(6)OLE MISS = 2-1

SOR:
(11)BYU = 6
(6)OLE MISS = 7

SOS:
(11)BYU = 28
(6)OLE MISS = 33

Game Control:
(6)OLE MISS = 11
(11)BYU = 14

FP:
(6)OLE MISS = 13
(11)BYU = 15

How is #6 Ole Miss ranked 5 spots ahead of #11 BYU?
(This post was last modified: 11-24-2025 03:57 PM by YNot.)
11-24-2025 02:05 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
quo vadis Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 56,023
Joined: Aug 2008
Reputation: 3198
I Root For: Notre Dame/USF/G'Town
Location: New Orleans
Post: #147
RE: 2025 CFP Race (10 wins won't be enough for teams like Vandy and Georgia)
(11-24-2025 12:35 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(11-24-2025 08:21 AM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(11-23-2025 12:09 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(11-23-2025 12:02 PM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(11-23-2025 11:59 AM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  Looks like you’re overstating BYU’s odds, as the committee has them behind OU, Alabama and ND right now, despite the fact that their resume looks eerily similar to Ole Miss’ and Oregon’s. What’s the difference between those 3 schools…similar SOR, similar top win for all 3, nearly identical SOS…oh, wait, I got it, one of them is not in the P2. I firmly believe that if BYU was in the B1G or SEC, they’d be in the 6-8 range right now instead of #11.

Probably. Then again if BYU were in the SEC I don't think they'd be 10-1 either.

In any event, I believe BYU has a clear path - they beat UCF they are in nB12 title game, and win that and they are in the playoffs. I can't feel that bad for a team that controls its destiny.

I think they’d have the same record as Oregon or Ole Miss if they’d played their schedules. Not every team in the SEC has a top 10 SOS.

Oregon SOS 24
BYU SOS 28
Ole Miss SOS 33

IMO, metrics like SOR and SOS are great, and among the very best we have to go on, but there are IMO intangibles about playing an SEC schedule that probably can't be quantified, the "meat grinder" aspect. IMO, BYU just does not have the athletes to stand up to the rigors of an SEC schedule. They would get worn down in a way they do not in the nB12.

For example, to be 10-1 right now, BYU would have to win 2 out of 3 games vs LSU, Oklahoma and Georgia, all played within a 28 day period. I think they lose at least two of those right there.

They'd also have to avoid upsets against talented underachievers like Florida and South Carolina. They'd have to beat arguably the best G5 team in Tulane. Heck, even bad teams like Mississippi State and Arkansas probably have as much talent as they do. They'd be favored and likely to win any of those games, but IMO a loss in at least one is likely.

So I don't see it, but that's just MO.

It's disingenuous for us to say on the one hand "the SEC should get more teams in the CFP b/c our schedules are so incredibly difficult across the board", but then turn around when one of our teams is getting compared to a team with a similar SOS or SOR and say "but, but, you didn't play OU and Georgia". I've even seen people say that A&M got a light schedule b/c we missed Georgia and Alabama this season. Well, our SOS is still #23, which btw is only 1 better than Oregon's 24 and 5 better than BYU's 28, and we helped Louisiana's Governor realize his lifelong dream of becoming the new LSU AD. A high SOS or SOR is directly comparable. The Big 12 is always competitive, and this year is no exception. It's not like BYU is cruising through an AAC or ACC schedule and looking like heroes over there against a bunch of weaklings, they're facing a war every weekend, just like Oregon and Ole Miss are.

Saying "SEC games are tougher b/c you're playing SEC opponents" might mean something to you or me, but there's no point in saying that to a Committee that we (halfway) control that is tasked with finding teams to put into a National Playoff. If we don't want the money from the National Playoff, we can always just run an SEC-only playoff in the future I guess, but, while we have a Committee for all of FBS that we largely assembled and are responsible for, we need reasonable ways to compare SEC teams to others. Would you rather the Committee use "Miami beat Syracuse by 50 while Vanderbilt only beat Tennessee by 14 so Miami must be better b/c eye test", or "Miami's had a really good year but their SOS is only 43 while Vanderbilt's is 21 so we think that Vanderbilt is the stronger team"? Because those are both probably conversations going on at CFP Committee HQ.

IIRC, I got into this because some said if BYU had done the same thing in the SEC, that they'd be higher-ranked, safer in the CFP. I agreed but then said BYU wouldn't be 10-1 if they played in the SEC. A comparison was then made to Ole Miss's schedule.

And IMO, that comparison supported my point. To have the same record as Ole Miss, BYU would for starters have to win 2 out of 3 versus LSU, Oklahoma and Georgia, and do it within a 4-week period. IMO, that ain't happening. LSU is the obvious win in that scenario, they are obviously a basket case in the SEC (losing conference record), but they are also ahead of all the teams BYU has played this year in FPI and SOR save for Texas Tech and Utah. They are #20 in SOR compared to #17 for Utah, very close. And Utah is BYU's signature win. They would be a very dangerous opponent for BYU and could well win. They have a lot more good players. This is what SEC teams have to face - teams with losing records in the conference that are arguably top 25 on a nationwide basis.

Yes, I agree that while we have an FBS-wide CFP, there have to be common metrics. That's why I favor 4 autobids for the SEC, so we can take that off the table and recognize the reality that the SEC is just a much tougher league than the nB12, as is the B1G. That IMO is a good compromise to having the P2 participate in an all-FBS thing and not have their own event.

Just MO.
(This post was last modified: 11-24-2025 02:15 PM by quo vadis.)
11-24-2025 02:13 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bryanw1995 Offline
+12 Hackmaster
*

Posts: 26,944
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3763
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
Post: #148
RE: 2025 CFP Race (10 wins won't be enough for teams like Vandy and Georgia)
(11-24-2025 02:05 PM)YNot Wrote:  
(11-24-2025 12:35 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(11-24-2025 08:21 AM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(11-23-2025 12:09 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(11-23-2025 12:02 PM)quo vadis Wrote:  Probably. Then again if BYU were in the SEC I don't think they'd be 10-1 either.

In any event, I believe BYU has a clear path - they beat UCF they are in nB12 title game, and win that and they are in the playoffs. I can't feel that bad for a team that controls its destiny.

I think they’d have the same record as Oregon or Ole Miss if they’d played their schedules. Not every team in the SEC has a top 10 SOS.

Oregon SOS 24
BYU SOS 28
Ole Miss SOS 33

IMO, metrics like SOR and SOS are great, and among the very best we have to go on, but there are IMO intangibles about playing an SEC schedule that probably can't be quantified, the "meat grinder" aspect. IMO, BYU just does not have the athletes to stand up to the rigors of an SEC schedule. They would get worn down in a way they do not in the nB12.

For example, to be 10-1 right now, BYU would have to win 2 out of 3 games vs LSU, Oklahoma and Georgia, all played within a 28 day period. I think they lose at least two of those right there.

They'd also have to avoid upsets against talented underachievers like Florida and South Carolina. They'd have to beat arguably the best G5 team in Tulane. Heck, even bad teams like Mississippi State and Arkansas probably have as much talent as they do. They'd be favored and likely to win any of those games, but IMO a loss in at least one is likely.

So I don't see it, but that's just MO.

It's disingenuous for us to say on the one hand "the SEC should get more teams in the CFP b/c our schedules are so incredibly difficult across the board", but then turn around when one of our teams is getting compared to a team with a similar SOS or SOR and say "but, but, you didn't play OU and Georgia". I've even seen people say that A&M got a light schedule b/c we missed Georgia and Alabama this season. Well, our SOS is still #23, which btw is only 1 better than Oregon's 24 and 5 better than BYU's 28, and we helped Louisiana's Governor realize his lifelong dream of becoming the new LSU AD. A high SOS or SOR is directly comparable. The Big 12 is always competitive, and this year is no exception. It's not like BYU is cruising through an AAC or ACC schedule and looking like heroes over there against a bunch of weaklings, they're facing a war every weekend, just like Oregon and Ole Miss are.

Saying "SEC games are tougher b/c you're playing SEC opponents" might mean something to you or me, but there's no point in saying that to a Committee that we (halfway) control that is tasked with finding teams to put into a National Playoff. If we don't want the money from the National Playoff, we can always just run an SEC-only playoff in the future I guess, but, while we have a Committee for all of FBS that we largely assembled and are responsible for, we need reasonable ways to compare SEC teams to others. Would you rather the Committee use "Miami beat Syracuse by 50 while Vanderbilt only beat Tennessee by 14 so Miami must be better b/c eye test", or "Miami's had a really good year but their SOS is only 43 while Vanderbilt's is 21 so we think that Vanderbilt is the stronger team"? Because those are both probably conversations going on at CFP Committee HQ.

Also lost in the evaluation is where the games are played.

Ole Miss has played THREE road games so far this year. THREE! @Kentucky, @Georgia, @Oklahoma. Their final road game is @Mississippi State, so Ole Miss will leave the state of Mississippi only THREE times the entire season!

Ole Miss has also only played 7 P4 games...again, with most of those at home. 6-1 against P4.

Meanwhile, BYU has played 9 P4 games, with 5 of those on the road...plus @ECU, over 2,000 miles away.

In its 8-game conference schedule, Ole Miss will play 6 of the bottom 7 SEC teams...and AVOID A&M, Bama, Texas, Vanderbilt, Tennessee, and even Missouri.

What is Ole Miss's record if they had played an extra top-half SEC opponent on the road instead of hosting Tulane or Georgia State...and what if Washington State had been on the road? Ole Miss is more likely 8-3 than 10-1.

Yet, Ole Miss is positioned for a CFP HOME game to maintain the pretense!

W-L:
(6)Ole Miss = 10-1
(11)BYU = 10-1

v. top-10:
(6)OLE MISS = 1-1
(11)BYU = 0-1

v. Ranked:
(6)OLE MISS = 1-1
(11)BYU = 1-1

v. P4:
(11)BYU = 8-1
(6)OLE MISS = 6-1

v. P4 road:
(11)BYU = 4-1
(6)OLE MISS = 3-1

SOR:
(11)BYU = 6
(6)OLE MISS = 7

SOS:
(11)BYU = 28
(6)OLE MISS = 33

Game Control:
(6)OLE MISS = 11
(11)BYU = 14

FP:
(6)OLE MISS = 13
(11)BYU = 15

How is #6 Ole Miss ranked 5 spots ahead of #11 BYU?

I would say "b/c SEC", but I'll go a step further and say "B/c Kiffin and b/c SEC and b/c they beat then-#4 LSU on Sept 27th". LSU was never the 4th best team in the country, nor were the they really the 10th best team when Vanderbilt played them, nor even the 20th best team when A&M played them, but their over-hyped preseason ranking influenced the decisions that AP voters made earlier in the season and still influence what they vote on to this very day. That narrow win vaulted Ole Miss from #13 to #4, and they've stayed in the top 10 ever since. It's total crap, not necessarily as it relates to Ole Miss since they're in about the right spot, but BYU never had that moment of beating the allegedly 4th best team in the country. It's not really about comparing BYU's resume to Ole Miss', b/c those resumes are darn near the same, it's about being able to step back each week and make changes based upon new information. This is the exact sort of thing that the CFP Committee is supposed to see through as they reevaluate every single team every single week, but last year and this year the members have turned into AP voters and ignored about 90% of the things they were supposed to consider.
11-24-2025 02:15 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
YNot Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,082
Joined: May 2014
Reputation: 388
I Root For: BYU
Location:
Post: #149
RE: 2025 CFP Race (10 wins won't be enough for teams like Vandy and Georgia)
(11-24-2025 08:21 AM)quo vadis Wrote:  IMO, metrics like SOR and SOS are great, and among the very best we have to go on, but there are IMO intangibles about playing an SEC schedule that probably can't be quantified, the "meat grinder" aspect. IMO, BYU just does not have the athletes to stand up to the rigors of an SEC schedule. They would get worn down in a way they do not in the nB12.

For example, to be 10-1 right now, BYU would have to win 2 out of 3 games vs LSU, Oklahoma and Georgia, all played within a 28 day period. I think they lose at least two of those right there.

They'd also have to avoid upsets against talented underachievers like Florida and South Carolina. They'd have to beat arguably the best G5 team in Tulane. Heck, even bad teams like Mississippi State and Arkansas probably have as much talent as they do. They'd be favored and likely to win any of those games, but IMO a loss in at least one is likely.

So I don't see it, but that's just MO.

How would Ole Miss do against @8-3Arizona, 9-2 Utah, @7-4 Iowa State, @10-1 Texas Tech, 7-4 TCU, @ 7-4Cincinnati?

Ole Miss would have to win 2 out of 3 against Utah, @Iowa State, @Texas Tech and 5 of 6, including 4 on the road! They would get worn down in a way they do not in the SEC.

We will never know because Ole Miss only plays 8 conference games and only 4 road games the entire season!
11-24-2025 02:15 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
quo vadis Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 56,023
Joined: Aug 2008
Reputation: 3198
I Root For: Notre Dame/USF/G'Town
Location: New Orleans
Post: #150
RE: 2025 CFP Race (10 wins won't be enough for teams like Vandy and Georgia)
(11-24-2025 02:15 PM)YNot Wrote:  
(11-24-2025 08:21 AM)quo vadis Wrote:  IMO, metrics like SOR and SOS are great, and among the very best we have to go on, but there are IMO intangibles about playing an SEC schedule that probably can't be quantified, the "meat grinder" aspect. IMO, BYU just does not have the athletes to stand up to the rigors of an SEC schedule. They would get worn down in a way they do not in the nB12.

For example, to be 10-1 right now, BYU would have to win 2 out of 3 games vs LSU, Oklahoma and Georgia, all played within a 28 day period. I think they lose at least two of those right there.

They'd also have to avoid upsets against talented underachievers like Florida and South Carolina. They'd have to beat arguably the best G5 team in Tulane. Heck, even bad teams like Mississippi State and Arkansas probably have as much talent as they do. They'd be favored and likely to win any of those games, but IMO a loss in at least one is likely.

So I don't see it, but that's just MO.

How would Ole Miss do against @8-3Arizona, 9-2 Utah, @7-4 Iowa State, @10-1 Texas Tech, 7-4 TCU, @ 7-4Cincinnati?

Ole Miss would have to win 2 out of 3 against Utah, @Iowa State, @Texas Tech and 5 of 6, including 4 on the road! They would get worn down in a way they do not in the SEC.

We will never know because Ole Miss only plays 8 conference games and only 4 road games the entire season!

I can easily see Ole Miss beating all of those nB12 teams. On the other hand, BYU would be very unlikely to win 2 out of 3 versus just LSU, Oklahoma and Georgia. BYU has the #70 talent in the 24/7 rankings. To their credit they are an Engine That Could in the nB12. It would be far tougher in the SEC.

I mean, LSU is a 3-4 team in the SEC. They would be a major challenge to any team in the nB12, any of them, including Texas Tech.

Just go out there and beat Texas Tech in the CCG, and cash your ticket.
(This post was last modified: 11-24-2025 02:24 PM by quo vadis.)
11-24-2025 02:19 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bullet Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 83,873
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5067
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
Post: #151
RE: 2025 CFP Race (10 wins won't be enough for teams like Vandy and Georgia)
P4
Unbeaten 3
1 loss 5
2 loss 9

1 unbeaten and an unbeaten or one loss and another one loss will all be knocked down by CCGs.
A 2 loss in ACC will be knocked down by CCG or before.

I think the 3 unbeatens and Georgia are locks at this point.
11-24-2025 02:21 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bullet Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 83,873
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5067
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
Post: #152
RE: 2025 CFP Race (10 wins won't be enough for teams like Vandy and Georgia)
(11-24-2025 02:19 PM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(11-24-2025 02:15 PM)YNot Wrote:  
(11-24-2025 08:21 AM)quo vadis Wrote:  IMO, metrics like SOR and SOS are great, and among the very best we have to go on, but there are IMO intangibles about playing an SEC schedule that probably can't be quantified, the "meat grinder" aspect. IMO, BYU just does not have the athletes to stand up to the rigors of an SEC schedule. They would get worn down in a way they do not in the nB12.

For example, to be 10-1 right now, BYU would have to win 2 out of 3 games vs LSU, Oklahoma and Georgia, all played within a 28 day period. I think they lose at least two of those right there.

They'd also have to avoid upsets against talented underachievers like Florida and South Carolina. They'd have to beat arguably the best G5 team in Tulane. Heck, even bad teams like Mississippi State and Arkansas probably have as much talent as they do. They'd be favored and likely to win any of those games, but IMO a loss in at least one is likely.

So I don't see it, but that's just MO.

How would Ole Miss do against @8-3Arizona, 9-2 Utah, @7-4 Iowa State, @10-1 Texas Tech, 7-4 TCU, @ 7-4Cincinnati?

Ole Miss would have to win 2 out of 3 against Utah, @Iowa State, @Texas Tech and 5 of 6, including 4 on the road! They would get worn down in a way they do not in the SEC.

We will never know because Ole Miss only plays 8 conference games and only 4 road games the entire season!

I can easily see Ole Miss beating all of those nB12 teams. On the other hand, BYU would be very unlikely to win 2 out of 3 versus just LSU, Oklahoma and Georgia. BYU has the #70 talent in the 24/7 rankings. To their credit they are an Engine That Could in the nB12. It would be far tougher in the SEC.

I mean, LSU is a 3-4 team in the SEC. They would be a major challenge to any team in the nB12, any of them, including Texas Tech.

LSU has lost to 3 top 10 and 1 2nd ten team and all but one of those were close. Just haven't beaten any ranked teams.

This is what we do know so far:
SEC vs. Big Ten 2-1
SEC vs. Big 12 3-0
SEC vs. ACC 4-2
SEC vs. ND 1-0
Big Ten vs. Big 12 2-2
Big Ten vs. ACC 2-1
Big Ten vs. ND 0-2
Big 12 vs. ACC 6-1
ACC vs. ND 1-4
11-24-2025 02:26 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
YNot Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,082
Joined: May 2014
Reputation: 388
I Root For: BYU
Location:
Post: #153
RE: 2025 CFP Race (10 wins won't be enough for teams like Vandy and Georgia)
(11-24-2025 02:19 PM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(11-24-2025 02:15 PM)YNot Wrote:  
(11-24-2025 08:21 AM)quo vadis Wrote:  IMO, metrics like SOR and SOS are great, and among the very best we have to go on, but there are IMO intangibles about playing an SEC schedule that probably can't be quantified, the "meat grinder" aspect. IMO, BYU just does not have the athletes to stand up to the rigors of an SEC schedule. They would get worn down in a way they do not in the nB12.

For example, to be 10-1 right now, BYU would have to win 2 out of 3 games vs LSU, Oklahoma and Georgia, all played within a 28 day period. I think they lose at least two of those right there.

They'd also have to avoid upsets against talented underachievers like Florida and South Carolina. They'd have to beat arguably the best G5 team in Tulane. Heck, even bad teams like Mississippi State and Arkansas probably have as much talent as they do. They'd be favored and likely to win any of those games, but IMO a loss in at least one is likely.

So I don't see it, but that's just MO.

How would Ole Miss do against @8-3Arizona, 9-2 Utah, @7-4 Iowa State, @10-1 Texas Tech, 7-4 TCU, @ 7-4Cincinnati?

Ole Miss would have to win 2 out of 3 against Utah, @Iowa State, @Texas Tech and 5 of 6, including 4 on the road! They would get worn down in a way they do not in the SEC.

We will never know because Ole Miss only plays 8 conference games and only 4 road games the entire season!

I can easily see Ole Miss beating all of those nB12 teams. On the other hand, BYU would be very unlikely to win 2 out of 3 versus just LSU, Oklahoma and Georgia. BYU has the #70 talent in the 24/7 rankings. To their credit they are an Engine That Could in the nB12. It would be far tougher in the SEC.

I mean, LSU is a 3-4 team in the SEC. They would be a major challenge to any team in the nB12, any of them, including Texas Tech.

Just go out there and beat Texas Tech in the CCG, and cash your ticket.

Cool, cool, cool. So we're cherry picking just the LSU, Georgia and Oklahoma results and ignoring the Ole Miss team that struggled against Washington State, Kentucky, and Arkansas? ...and we're also ignoring that Ole Miss only leaves the state of Mississippi THREE TIMES the entire season?

Just want to make sure to know where the goalposts are.

No one would be surprised if BYU beat Oklahoma and LSU in games that were a month apart. And no one would be surprised if BYU beat Kentucky, Arkansas, Florida, and South Carolina...and Washington State and Tulane - especially when 5 of those 6 were at home.

I *would be* surprised if Ole Miss won more than 2 out of:
@8-3Arizona
9-2 Utah
@10-1 Texas Tech
@ 7-4 Cincinnati

*Interesting that there were fewer days on the calendar in that @Arizona, Utah...@Texas Tech stretch than in between Ole Miss's stretch of LSU...@Georgia, @Oklahoma...and BYU had @Iowa State in between instead of hosting Washington State.

And, if the CFP committee resorts to 'college team talent' rankings from 24/7 to evaluate teams, the fix is in.

The (apparently) 70th ranked BYU has:
- top-6 strength of resume
- top-10 overall efficiency rank
- top-10 defense
- top-20 offense
- top-15 in game control
- top-15 football power index
- the Big 12's best running back
- freshman of the year candidate
- coach of the year candidate.

Aka, a better resume than 60+ supposedly 'more talented' teams.
11-24-2025 03:34 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
YNot Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,082
Joined: May 2014
Reputation: 388
I Root For: BYU
Location:
Post: #154
RE: 2025 CFP Race (10 wins won't be enough for teams like Vandy and Georgia)
(11-24-2025 02:26 PM)bullet Wrote:  
(11-24-2025 02:19 PM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(11-24-2025 02:15 PM)YNot Wrote:  
(11-24-2025 08:21 AM)quo vadis Wrote:  IMO, metrics like SOR and SOS are great, and among the very best we have to go on, but there are IMO intangibles about playing an SEC schedule that probably can't be quantified, the "meat grinder" aspect. IMO, BYU just does not have the athletes to stand up to the rigors of an SEC schedule. They would get worn down in a way they do not in the nB12.

For example, to be 10-1 right now, BYU would have to win 2 out of 3 games vs LSU, Oklahoma and Georgia, all played within a 28 day period. I think they lose at least two of those right there.

They'd also have to avoid upsets against talented underachievers like Florida and South Carolina. They'd have to beat arguably the best G5 team in Tulane. Heck, even bad teams like Mississippi State and Arkansas probably have as much talent as they do. They'd be favored and likely to win any of those games, but IMO a loss in at least one is likely.

So I don't see it, but that's just MO.

How would Ole Miss do against @8-3Arizona, 9-2 Utah, @7-4 Iowa State, @10-1 Texas Tech, 7-4 TCU, @ 7-4Cincinnati?

Ole Miss would have to win 2 out of 3 against Utah, @Iowa State, @Texas Tech and 5 of 6, including 4 on the road! They would get worn down in a way they do not in the SEC.

We will never know because Ole Miss only plays 8 conference games and only 4 road games the entire season!

I can easily see Ole Miss beating all of those nB12 teams. On the other hand, BYU would be very unlikely to win 2 out of 3 versus just LSU, Oklahoma and Georgia. BYU has the #70 talent in the 24/7 rankings. To their credit they are an Engine That Could in the nB12. It would be far tougher in the SEC.

I mean, LSU is a 3-4 team in the SEC. They would be a major challenge to any team in the nB12, any of them, including Texas Tech.

LSU has lost to 3 top 10 and 1 2nd ten team and all but one of those were close. Just haven't beaten any ranked teams.

This is what we do know so far:
SEC vs. Big Ten 2-1
SEC vs. Big 12 3-0
SEC vs. ACC 4-2
SEC vs. ND 1-0
Big Ten vs. Big 12 2-2
Big Ten vs. ACC 2-1
Big Ten vs. ND 0-2
Big 12 vs. ACC 6-1
ACC vs. ND 1-4

LSU beat Western Kentucky at home by 3 two days ago. And came from behind to beat 2-9 Arkansas by 1 point the previous weekend.
11-24-2025 03:45 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bullet Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 83,873
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5067
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
Post: #155
RE: 2025 CFP Race (10 wins won't be enough for teams like Vandy and Georgia)
(11-24-2025 03:45 PM)YNot Wrote:  
(11-24-2025 02:26 PM)bullet Wrote:  
(11-24-2025 02:19 PM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(11-24-2025 02:15 PM)YNot Wrote:  
(11-24-2025 08:21 AM)quo vadis Wrote:  IMO, metrics like SOR and SOS are great, and among the very best we have to go on, but there are IMO intangibles about playing an SEC schedule that probably can't be quantified, the "meat grinder" aspect. IMO, BYU just does not have the athletes to stand up to the rigors of an SEC schedule. They would get worn down in a way they do not in the nB12.

For example, to be 10-1 right now, BYU would have to win 2 out of 3 games vs LSU, Oklahoma and Georgia, all played within a 28 day period. I think they lose at least two of those right there.

They'd also have to avoid upsets against talented underachievers like Florida and South Carolina. They'd have to beat arguably the best G5 team in Tulane. Heck, even bad teams like Mississippi State and Arkansas probably have as much talent as they do. They'd be favored and likely to win any of those games, but IMO a loss in at least one is likely.

So I don't see it, but that's just MO.

How would Ole Miss do against @8-3Arizona, 9-2 Utah, @7-4 Iowa State, @10-1 Texas Tech, 7-4 TCU, @ 7-4Cincinnati?

Ole Miss would have to win 2 out of 3 against Utah, @Iowa State, @Texas Tech and 5 of 6, including 4 on the road! They would get worn down in a way they do not in the SEC.

We will never know because Ole Miss only plays 8 conference games and only 4 road games the entire season!

I can easily see Ole Miss beating all of those nB12 teams. On the other hand, BYU would be very unlikely to win 2 out of 3 versus just LSU, Oklahoma and Georgia. BYU has the #70 talent in the 24/7 rankings. To their credit they are an Engine That Could in the nB12. It would be far tougher in the SEC.

I mean, LSU is a 3-4 team in the SEC. They would be a major challenge to any team in the nB12, any of them, including Texas Tech.

LSU has lost to 3 top 10 and 1 2nd ten team and all but one of those were close. Just haven't beaten any ranked teams.

This is what we do know so far:
SEC vs. Big Ten 2-1
SEC vs. Big 12 3-0
SEC vs. ACC 4-2
SEC vs. ND 1-0
Big Ten vs. Big 12 2-2
Big Ten vs. ACC 2-1
Big Ten vs. ND 0-2
Big 12 vs. ACC 6-1
ACC vs. ND 1-4

LSU beat Western Kentucky at home by 3 two days ago. And came from behind to beat 2-9 Arkansas by 1 point the previous weekend.

Other than Texas and Notre Dame, Arkansas's other 7 losses were by a combined 26 points and that includes #3 A&M at home and #6 Ole Miss on the road.
11-24-2025 05:05 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bryanw1995 Offline
+12 Hackmaster
*

Posts: 26,944
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3763
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
Post: #156
RE: 2025 CFP Race (10 wins won't be enough for teams like Vandy and Georgia)
(11-24-2025 02:26 PM)bullet Wrote:  
(11-24-2025 02:19 PM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(11-24-2025 02:15 PM)YNot Wrote:  
(11-24-2025 08:21 AM)quo vadis Wrote:  IMO, metrics like SOR and SOS are great, and among the very best we have to go on, but there are IMO intangibles about playing an SEC schedule that probably can't be quantified, the "meat grinder" aspect. IMO, BYU just does not have the athletes to stand up to the rigors of an SEC schedule. They would get worn down in a way they do not in the nB12.

For example, to be 10-1 right now, BYU would have to win 2 out of 3 games vs LSU, Oklahoma and Georgia, all played within a 28 day period. I think they lose at least two of those right there.

They'd also have to avoid upsets against talented underachievers like Florida and South Carolina. They'd have to beat arguably the best G5 team in Tulane. Heck, even bad teams like Mississippi State and Arkansas probably have as much talent as they do. They'd be favored and likely to win any of those games, but IMO a loss in at least one is likely.

So I don't see it, but that's just MO.

How would Ole Miss do against @8-3Arizona, 9-2 Utah, @7-4 Iowa State, @10-1 Texas Tech, 7-4 TCU, @ 7-4Cincinnati?

Ole Miss would have to win 2 out of 3 against Utah, @Iowa State, @Texas Tech and 5 of 6, including 4 on the road! They would get worn down in a way they do not in the SEC.

We will never know because Ole Miss only plays 8 conference games and only 4 road games the entire season!

I can easily see Ole Miss beating all of those nB12 teams. On the other hand, BYU would be very unlikely to win 2 out of 3 versus just LSU, Oklahoma and Georgia. BYU has the #70 talent in the 24/7 rankings. To their credit they are an Engine That Could in the nB12. It would be far tougher in the SEC.

I mean, LSU is a 3-4 team in the SEC. They would be a major challenge to any team in the nB12, any of them, including Texas Tech.

LSU has lost to 3 top 10 and 1 2nd ten team and all but one of those were close. Just haven't beaten any ranked teams.

This is what we do know so far:
SEC vs. Big Ten 2-1
SEC vs. Big 12 3-0
SEC vs. ACC 4-2
SEC vs. ND 1-0
Big Ten vs. Big 12 2-2
Big Ten vs. ACC 2-1
Big Ten vs. ND 0-2
Big 12 vs. ACC 6-1
ACC vs. ND 1-4

LSU was underperforming for weeks before they got into the SEC. Remember how belligerent Kelly was getting with reporters after games? He practically got NUSSMEIER IS FINE tattooed on his forehead. LSU got a huge boost from beating the also overrated Clemson Tigers in week 1, then they were uninspiring in weeks 2 and 3, played a cupcake in week 4, looked uninspiring in defeat to Ole Miss and in victory over USCe, then lost by a combined 42 points to Vandy/A&M/Alabama in their next 3. Then they beat Arky by 1 and Western Freakin' Kentucky by 3? They mostly seem to play down or up to their competition, they're like a Cajun Rorschach Test. I think they'd give OSU a really tough game, and they'd also allow Baylor to give them a really tough game.

I wasn't saying above that the SEC isn't clearly the toughest league this season, as it typically is. I was just saying that even in the SEC, or even in other Conferences that are generally not as tough, some teams play a tougher schedule that others. Last year, OSU played ~ 30 SOS, it was the toughest in the B1G, and it clearly prepared them for the postseason. This season, we see teams like Oregon and BYU that have played a very SEC-like schedule, it's just more 6,7 and 8 win teams from their own Conferences instead of Arkansas, Miss St, Kentucky and USC in the SEC. And it was mostly luck, b/c we all know that LSU, Florida and Auburn will be back again and soon, and USC was ~ #15 last season with a win over the ACC champs. Next season, Ole Miss could have the exact same schedule they had this season and it's the #5 SOS, and BYU could also have the exact same schedule and it's more like #55 b/c some of their opponents fell off a bit. But, for this year, when we have to evaluate not the Conference but the specific team that's up for discussion, it's pretty hard for me as an impartial 3rd party observer to find any daylight between BYU and Oregon, and even as a somewhat biased observer to find much daylight between those 2 and Ole Miss. Now, if we're comparing them to Georgia, OU or Alabama? Ok, those 3 have all played top 10 schedules and all have top 10 wins, there's a clearly line between those 3 and others that are supposed on the same level as them like ND or Texas Tech, or at least a clear line between the difficulty those 3 have had in getting their specific records and the relatively easier road that many others have trodden.

edit: no offense to Texas, you guys ofc have just as difficult of a schedule as any of those others, but that 3rd loss really hurts you comparatively.
(This post was last modified: 11-24-2025 06:02 PM by bryanw1995.)
11-24-2025 06:01 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bullet Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 83,873
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5067
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
Post: #157
RE: 2025 CFP Race (10 wins won't be enough for teams like Vandy and Georgia)
(11-24-2025 06:01 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(11-24-2025 02:26 PM)bullet Wrote:  
(11-24-2025 02:19 PM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(11-24-2025 02:15 PM)YNot Wrote:  
(11-24-2025 08:21 AM)quo vadis Wrote:  IMO, metrics like SOR and SOS are great, and among the very best we have to go on, but there are IMO intangibles about playing an SEC schedule that probably can't be quantified, the "meat grinder" aspect. IMO, BYU just does not have the athletes to stand up to the rigors of an SEC schedule. They would get worn down in a way they do not in the nB12.

For example, to be 10-1 right now, BYU would have to win 2 out of 3 games vs LSU, Oklahoma and Georgia, all played within a 28 day period. I think they lose at least two of those right there.

They'd also have to avoid upsets against talented underachievers like Florida and South Carolina. They'd have to beat arguably the best G5 team in Tulane. Heck, even bad teams like Mississippi State and Arkansas probably have as much talent as they do. They'd be favored and likely to win any of those games, but IMO a loss in at least one is likely.

So I don't see it, but that's just MO.

How would Ole Miss do against @8-3Arizona, 9-2 Utah, @7-4 Iowa State, @10-1 Texas Tech, 7-4 TCU, @ 7-4Cincinnati?

Ole Miss would have to win 2 out of 3 against Utah, @Iowa State, @Texas Tech and 5 of 6, including 4 on the road! They would get worn down in a way they do not in the SEC.

We will never know because Ole Miss only plays 8 conference games and only 4 road games the entire season!

I can easily see Ole Miss beating all of those nB12 teams. On the other hand, BYU would be very unlikely to win 2 out of 3 versus just LSU, Oklahoma and Georgia. BYU has the #70 talent in the 24/7 rankings. To their credit they are an Engine That Could in the nB12. It would be far tougher in the SEC.

I mean, LSU is a 3-4 team in the SEC. They would be a major challenge to any team in the nB12, any of them, including Texas Tech.

LSU has lost to 3 top 10 and 1 2nd ten team and all but one of those were close. Just haven't beaten any ranked teams.

This is what we do know so far:
SEC vs. Big Ten 2-1
SEC vs. Big 12 3-0
SEC vs. ACC 4-2
SEC vs. ND 1-0
Big Ten vs. Big 12 2-2
Big Ten vs. ACC 2-1
Big Ten vs. ND 0-2
Big 12 vs. ACC 6-1
ACC vs. ND 1-4

LSU was underperforming for weeks before they got into the SEC. Remember how belligerent Kelly was getting with reporters after games? He practically got NUSSMEIER IS FINE tattooed on his forehead. LSU got a huge boost from beating the also overrated Clemson Tigers in week 1, then they were uninspiring in weeks 2 and 3, played a cupcake in week 4, looked uninspiring in defeat to Ole Miss and in victory over USCe, then lost by a combined 42 points to Vandy/A&M/Alabama in their next 3. Then they beat Arky by 1 and Western Freakin' Kentucky by 3? They mostly seem to play down or up to their competition, they're like a Cajun Rorschach Test. I think they'd give OSU a really tough game, and they'd also allow Baylor to give them a really tough game.

I wasn't saying above that the SEC isn't clearly the toughest league this season, as it typically is. I was just saying that even in the SEC, or even in other Conferences that are generally not as tough, some teams play a tougher schedule that others. Last year, OSU played ~ 30 SOS, it was the toughest in the B1G, and it clearly prepared them for the postseason. This season, we see teams like Oregon and BYU that have played a very SEC-like schedule, it's just more 6,7 and 8 win teams from their own Conferences instead of Arkansas, Miss St, Kentucky and USC in the SEC. And it was mostly luck, b/c we all know that LSU, Florida and Auburn will be back again and soon, and USC was ~ #15 last season with a win over the ACC champs. Next season, Ole Miss could have the exact same schedule they had this season and it's the #5 SOS, and BYU could also have the exact same schedule and it's more like #55 b/c some of their opponents fell off a bit. But, for this year, when we have to evaluate not the Conference but the specific team that's up for discussion, it's pretty hard for me as an impartial 3rd party observer to find any daylight between BYU and Oregon, and even as a somewhat biased observer to find much daylight between those 2 and Ole Miss. Now, if we're comparing them to Georgia, OU or Alabama? Ok, those 3 have all played top 10 schedules and all have top 10 wins, there's a clearly line between those 3 and others that are supposed on the same level as them like ND or Texas Tech, or at least a clear line between the difficulty those 3 have had in getting their specific records and the relatively easier road that many others have trodden.

edit: no offense to Texas, you guys ofc have just as difficult of a schedule as any of those others, but that 3rd loss really hurts you comparatively.

Florida played 6 teams this year who were ranked in the top 10 at the time they played them. 5 are still ranked. That's a whole lot tougher than Ole Miss. And last year, Ohio St., Oregon and Penn St. all played schedules with an average of around 55 for the Massey composite of their opponents. Indiana was 75. That happens in these mega conferences.
(This post was last modified: 11-24-2025 07:26 PM by bullet.)
11-24-2025 07:25 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Crayton Online
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,310
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation: 379
I Root For: Florida
Location:
Post: #158
RE: 2025 CFP Race (10 wins won't be enough for teams like Vandy and Georgia)
(11-23-2025 04:41 PM)RUScarlets Wrote:  Vandy is out… barring Ole Miss upset or something crazy like Auburn/Furd wins. They have no shot.

UM has a slim shot, but they need to trounce tOSU. TTech probably out with a loss, but I don’t think Vandy jumps them.

They’d have arguably the best win in the nation. I’d put them in the same area as Notre Dame ~75% chance. Even if they went to Indianapolis and lost I’d give ‘em the same odds because it means Oregon lost to Washington and would/should be somewhere below the Wolverines.
11-24-2025 07:43 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bullet Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 83,873
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5067
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
Post: #159
RE: 2025 CFP Race (10 wins won't be enough for teams like Vandy and Georgia)
(11-24-2025 07:43 PM)Crayton Wrote:  
(11-23-2025 04:41 PM)RUScarlets Wrote:  Vandy is out… barring Ole Miss upset or something crazy like Auburn/Furd wins. They have no shot.

UM has a slim shot, but they need to trounce tOSU. TTech probably out with a loss, but I don’t think Vandy jumps them.

They’d have arguably the best win in the nation. I’d put them in the same area as Notre Dame ~75% chance. Even if they went to Indianapolis and lost I’d give ‘em the same odds because it means Oregon lost to Washington and would/should be somewhere below the Wolverines.

Michigan is 0-2 vs. ranked teams this year, losing to OU and USC. Their Big Ten schedule besides Ohio St. included 4 in the middle and the bottom 4. They would need to win the Big Ten to get in.
11-24-2025 07:49 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
AuzGrams Offline
Banned

Posts: 2,229
Joined: May 2012
I Root For: Utah, UVU, North Dakota
Location: Colorado
Post: #160
RE: 2025 CFP Race (10 wins won't be enough for teams like Vandy and Georgia)
What is the record of wins vs bowl eligible teams in FBS?
11-24-2025 08:56 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Post Reply 




User(s) browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)


Copyright © 2002-2026 Collegiate Sports Nation Bulletin Board System (CSNbbs), All Rights Reserved.
CSNbbs is an independent fan site and is in no way affiliated to the NCAA or any of the schools and conferences it represents.
This site monetizes links. FTC Disclosure.
We allow third-party companies to serve ads and/or collect certain anonymous information when you visit our web site. These companies may use non-personally identifiable information (e.g., click stream information, browser type, time and date, subject of advertisements clicked or scrolled over) during your visits to this and other Web sites in order to provide advertisements about goods and services likely to be of greater interest to you. These companies typically use a cookie or third party web beacon to collect this information. To learn more about this behavioral advertising practice or to opt-out of this type of advertising, you can visit http://www.networkadvertising.org.
Powered By MyBB, © 2002-2026 MyBB Group.