Hello There, Guest! Registered users see far less ads! Register today and join our virtual tailgate. (Login — Register)

Post Reply 
2025 CFP Race (who is this year's #11 team? Notre Dame?)
Author Message
bryanw1995 Offline
+12 Hackmaster
*

Posts: 26,944
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3763
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
Post: #81
RE: 2025 CFP Race (North Texas to the playoff!)
(10-30-2025 06:42 PM)Crayton Wrote:  
(10-30-2025 04:04 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(10-30-2025 03:32 PM)Crayton Wrote:  Generally a P2 teams needs 10 wins to get an at large, an M2 needs 11, a G5 12. If we use 50% as the breakpoint, here are the projected exceptions to those rules:

93% 11-1 Navy
80% 10-2 BYU
74% 10-2 Pittsburgh
71% 10-2 Miami
54% 10-2 Utah

42% 10-3 Ohio State
29% 10-2 Ole Miss
24% 10-2 Indiana, Nebraska, Vanderbilt, Texas A&M
24% 11-2 Georgia Tech
16% 10-2 Ohio State
12% 11-2 Virginia
8% 11-1 Houston
1% 11-2 Houston

I'm confused, why is 10-2 OSU so much less likely to get an invite than 10-3 OSU? Losing the B1G CCG shouldn't hurt much, but it has to hurt at least a little bit, right? Also, are you saying that Indiana, Nebraska, Vanderbilt and A&M are all at a 24% to chance to make the CFP at 10-2? That's confusing when we consider the current and remaining SOS for the 4 schools:

A&M: 14 current, also 14 remaining SOS
Vanderbilt: 32, 8
Nebraska: 67, 23
Indiana: 42, 33

I'd also question how an 11-2 GT that lost their CCG + another game, just barely keeps squeaking by substandard opponents, and has a SOS of 82, 43 would get in over either Vanderbilt or A&M.

All of that to say nothing of BYU, Pitt, Utah and Miami:

BYU: 49, 24
Pitt: 91, 16
Miami: 36, 56
Utah: 53, 50

And even Ole Miss ahead of Vandy or A&M seems odd:

Ole Miss: 19, 59

https://www.espn.com/college-football/fpi/_/view/resume

If I'm misreading what you wrote, sorry about that. Are you saying that these are the probabilities that these teams finish with those records?

You’re reading it right. These are the probabilities, given that record, that a team makes the playoff. Strength of Record is the primary way teams are sorted, but there are 3 additional considerations.

1. The biggest additional consideration is that we’re not strictly comparing apples to apples; these teams are not compared against the same set of 12 other potential playoff teams. A 10-2 P2 team would be ranked #3, #4, or worse in their conference. In a scenario where that same team goes 10-3, they were ranked #1 or #2 in their conference, meaning they had ~2 extra at large spots not taken up by conference mates to cushion the blow of a CCG loss (which, yes, would be minor but still something), making the playoff more often than if they were 10-2.

2. How you finish matters. Do you drop your last two games? Does your star player get injured? Human committees tend to have a recency bias to them. A 10-2 A&M or Ohio State likely ended the season with a loss. If there is another 10-2 team like Miami or Pitt who ended with some good wins (and a generally strong eye-test), the committee is going to err on the side of the hot hand (or hot “brand” though I refuse to model that).

3. The underlying FPI that ESPN uses is different than my own. It looks like I have the P4 more as more equal with each other than ESPN does. That could also be a function of me looking at season-ending numbers (after more .500 play within each conference) while the numbers you cite are current/future SOR after only 9 weeks. Not sure.

I know there were a few specific examples included in your post, but I may dive deeper into a handful of those next week. Explorations like that can help uncover ways to change and improve my model.

We don't need to use ESPN's SOS metric. How about Sagarin's?

A&M: 11
OSU: 22
BYU: 49
Indiana: 50
Alabama: 4
Georgia: 8
Ole Miss: 23
Utah: 43
Oregon: 44
Pitt: 64
etc etc

Sagarin and ESPN seem to be pretty close right now, and with the new instructions to the CFP Committee to factor in SOS, I think that is likely to be given more weight this year. Ie, Indiana gets less credit by blowing out bad teams by 50 than they did last year, and OSU gets more credit for the #22 SOS than they did last year. Indiana's one good win, on the road @ Oregon was nice, but they've mostly played cupcakes otherwise. OSU, by contrast, has played a much more difficult schedule but hasn't blown out their (on avg) much tougher opponents by as many points. This can also be used to compare schools of different conferences, but it's even more instructive when comparing, say, Vanderbilt to Georgia to Ole Miss if all 3 end with the same record. Maybe that just means that the Committee gets them in right order from 8-10, but it also could mean that it gets them in the right order from 10-12, meaning that 1 or 2 of them are left out, and it's the CORRECT one or 2 that get left out instead of the team that won their last game sneaking in despite a weaker overall resume.
11-02-2025 12:18 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
AuzGrams Offline
Banned

Posts: 2,229
Joined: May 2012
I Root For: Utah, UVU, North Dakota
Location: Colorado
Post: #82
RE: 2025 CFP Race (North Texas to the playoff!)
What makes Miami (FL) better than Utah for an at-large playoff spot?

SOS?
(This post was last modified: 11-02-2025 12:35 PM by AuzGrams.)
11-02-2025 12:32 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Crayton Online
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,310
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation: 379
I Root For: Florida
Location:
Post: #83
RE: 2025 CFP Race (North Texas to the playoff!)
(11-02-2025 12:18 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(10-30-2025 06:42 PM)Crayton Wrote:  
(10-30-2025 04:04 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(10-30-2025 03:32 PM)Crayton Wrote:  Generally a P2 teams needs 10 wins to get an at large, an M2 needs 11, a G5 12. If we use 50% as the breakpoint, here are the projected exceptions to those rules:

93% 11-1 Navy
80% 10-2 BYU
74% 10-2 Pittsburgh
71% 10-2 Miami
54% 10-2 Utah

42% 10-3 Ohio State
29% 10-2 Ole Miss
24% 10-2 Indiana, Nebraska, Vanderbilt, Texas A&M
24% 11-2 Georgia Tech
16% 10-2 Ohio State
12% 11-2 Virginia
8% 11-1 Houston
1% 11-2 Houston

I'm confused, why is 10-2 OSU so much less likely to get an invite than 10-3 OSU? Losing the B1G CCG shouldn't hurt much, but it has to hurt at least a little bit, right? Also, are you saying that Indiana, Nebraska, Vanderbilt and A&M are all at a 24% to chance to make the CFP at 10-2? That's confusing when we consider the current and remaining SOS for the 4 schools:

A&M: 14 current, also 14 remaining SOS
Vanderbilt: 32, 8
Nebraska: 67, 23
Indiana: 42, 33

I'd also question how an 11-2 GT that lost their CCG + another game, just barely keeps squeaking by substandard opponents, and has a SOS of 82, 43 would get in over either Vanderbilt or A&M.

All of that to say nothing of BYU, Pitt, Utah and Miami:

BYU: 49, 24
Pitt: 91, 16
Miami: 36, 56
Utah: 53, 50

And even Ole Miss ahead of Vandy or A&M seems odd:

Ole Miss: 19, 59

https://www.espn.com/college-football/fpi/_/view/resume

If I'm misreading what you wrote, sorry about that. Are you saying that these are the probabilities that these teams finish with those records?

You’re reading it right. These are the probabilities, given that record, that a team makes the playoff. Strength of Record is the primary way teams are sorted, but there are 3 additional considerations.

1. The biggest additional consideration is that we’re not strictly comparing apples to apples; these teams are not compared against the same set of 12 other potential playoff teams. A 10-2 P2 team would be ranked #3, #4, or worse in their conference. In a scenario where that same team goes 10-3, they were ranked #1 or #2 in their conference, meaning they had ~2 extra at large spots not taken up by conference mates to cushion the blow of a CCG loss (which, yes, would be minor but still something), making the playoff more often than if they were 10-2.

2. How you finish matters. Do you drop your last two games? Does your star player get injured? Human committees tend to have a recency bias to them. A 10-2 A&M or Ohio State likely ended the season with a loss. If there is another 10-2 team like Miami or Pitt who ended with some good wins (and a generally strong eye-test), the committee is going to err on the side of the hot hand (or hot “brand” though I refuse to model that).

3. The underlying FPI that ESPN uses is different than my own. It looks like I have the P4 more as more equal with each other than ESPN does. That could also be a function of me looking at season-ending numbers (after more .500 play within each conference) while the numbers you cite are current/future SOR after only 9 weeks. Not sure.

I know there were a few specific examples included in your post, but I may dive deeper into a handful of those next week. Explorations like that can help uncover ways to change and improve my model.

We don't need to use ESPN's SOS metric. How about Sagarin's?

A&M: 11
OSU: 22
BYU: 49
Indiana: 50
Alabama: 4
Georgia: 8
Ole Miss: 23
Utah: 43
Oregon: 44
Pitt: 64
etc etc

Sagarin and ESPN seem to be pretty close right now, and with the new instructions to the CFP Committee to factor in SOS, I think that is likely to be given more weight this year. Ie, Indiana gets less credit by blowing out bad teams by 50 than they did last year, and OSU gets more credit for the #22 SOS than they did last year. Indiana's one good win, on the road @ Oregon was nice, but they've mostly played cupcakes otherwise. OSU, by contrast, has played a much more difficult schedule but hasn't blown out their (on avg) much tougher opponents by as many points. This can also be used to compare schools of different conferences, but it's even more instructive when comparing, say, Vanderbilt to Georgia to Ole Miss if all 3 end with the same record. Maybe that just means that the Committee gets them in right order from 8-10, but it also could mean that it gets them in the right order from 10-12, meaning that 1 or 2 of them are left out, and it's the CORRECT one or 2 that get left out instead of the team that won their last game sneaking in despite a weaker overall resume.

I pulled out my SOR and FPI-equivalent Top 25s to see how they compare to ESPN's. For the most part they are in line. And so I believe the majority of the differences in ascertaining whether, for example, 10-2 Utah is better/worse positioned to make the playoff than 10-2 Vanderbilt is due to (a) the few differences highlighted below, and/or (b) the fact that I am looking at season-end values, not current.

It is worth noting that ESPN defines their "current" and "future" SOS differently from each other and that their SOR metric is keyed to the strength of their #13 team, rather than shifting depending on the position being evaluated.

One of the big differences I see is that differences between Texas and Tech Tech. These impact the SOR, respectively, of Vanderbilt and Utah.

Power Ranking (ESPN's FPI)
1 1817 Indiana (2)
2 1778 Ohio St (1)
3 1735 Notre Dame (5)
4 1727 Utah (7)
5 1722 Texas Tech (11)
6 1713 Oregon (3)
7 1711 Texas A&M (9)
8 1708 Alabama (4)
9 1706 Miami (12)
10 1702 USC (10)
11 1685 BYU (14)
12 1666 Georgia (6)
13 1663 Florida St (24)
14 1662 Ole Miss (13)
15 1656 Vanderbilt (17)
16 1648 Missouri (18)
17 1649 Oklahoma (16)
18 1646 Washington (23)
19 1644 Iowa (20)
20 1639 Michigan (19)
21 1640 Texas (8)
22 1636 Illinois (28)
23 1627 Pittsburgh (31)
24 1627 Tennessee (15)
25 1623 Louisville (26)

Strength of Record (ESPN's)
1 Ohio St (3)
2 Indiana (2)
3 Texas A&M (1)
4 BYU (4)
5 Alabama (5)
6 Georgia (6)
7 Ole Miss (7)
8 Texas Tech (10)
9 Louisville (13)
10 Notre Dame (15)
11 Texas (9)
12 Utah (23)
13 Oregon (8)
14 Oklahoma (11)
15 Michigan (14)
16 Virginia (17)
17 Miami (18)
18 USC (20)
19 Vanderbilt (12)
20 Washington (21)
21 Illinois (19)
22 North Texas (33)
23 Georgia Tech (16)
24 Cincy (25)
25 Iowa (26)
11-02-2025 04:15 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Crayton Online
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,310
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation: 379
I Root For: Florida
Location:
Post: #84
RE: 2025 CFP Race (North Texas to the playoff!)
(11-02-2025 12:32 PM)AuzGrams Wrote:  What makes Miami (FL) better than Utah for an at-large playoff spot?

SOS?

If both are 10-2? Yes. Of course that is subject to change. Miami's position is highly dependent upon Notre Dame (and secondly FSU) while Utah's is dependent upon TTU/BYU in approximately the same measures. If those opponents start stinking it up (not just losing, but failing to cover by 2 scores or more), the balance between Utah and Miami might shift.
11-02-2025 04:22 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Crayton Online
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,310
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation: 379
I Root For: Florida
Location:
Post: #85
RE: 2025 CFP Race (North Texas to the playoff!)
As BryanW says, Sagarin hews closely to ESPN. It may be worth me diving in deeper to see why my power ratings for Texas, Texas Tech, Georgia, and Florida State are 6+ ranks away from the more public ratings. Could be a coding bug, a poorly weighted metric, or just a flavor I can choose to keep or drop.
11-02-2025 08:04 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
AuzGrams Offline
Banned

Posts: 2,229
Joined: May 2012
I Root For: Utah, UVU, North Dakota
Location: Colorado
Post: #86
RE: 2025 CFP Race (North Texas to the playoff!)
(11-02-2025 04:22 PM)Crayton Wrote:  
(11-02-2025 12:32 PM)AuzGrams Wrote:  What makes Miami (FL) better than Utah for an at-large playoff spot?

SOS?

If both are 10-2? Yes. Of course that is subject to change. Miami's position is highly dependent upon Notre Dame (and secondly FSU) while Utah's is dependent upon TTU/BYU in approximately the same measures. If those opponents start stinking it up (not just losing, but failing to cover by 2 scores or more), the balance between Utah and Miami might shift.

Rankings are just a baseline. I’m not sure why folks take anything into consideration besides CFB Playoff.
11-02-2025 08:32 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bryanw1995 Offline
+12 Hackmaster
*

Posts: 26,944
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3763
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
Post: #87
RE: 2025 CFP Race (North Texas to the playoff!)
(11-02-2025 04:22 PM)Crayton Wrote:  
(11-02-2025 12:32 PM)AuzGrams Wrote:  What makes Miami (FL) better than Utah for an at-large playoff spot?

SOS?

If both are 10-2? Yes. Of course that is subject to change. Miami's position is highly dependent upon Notre Dame (and secondly FSU) while Utah's is dependent upon TTU/BYU in approximately the same measures. If those opponents start stinking it up (not just losing, but failing to cover by 2 scores or more), the balance between Utah and Miami might shift.

What do you think about the latest AP poll that has ND at 10 and Miami at 18? I'm getting sniffs of last year's unfairly low BYU ranking that allowed SMU to sneak into the CFP despite the h2h loss to BYU, very weak SOS and zero quality wins. ND has beaten USC as their only ranked win, Miami has beaten ND, and both have a comparable SOS overall. Would the committee even look at the AP poll, or could they use their BS "eye test" and determine that ND is just a lot better than Miami and thus ignore the h2h?
11-02-2025 08:42 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
HP-TBDPITL Online
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,527
Joined: Jun 2010
Reputation: 250
I Root For: College Sports
Location:
Post: #88
RE: 2025 CFP Race (North Texas to the playoff!)
(11-02-2025 08:42 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(11-02-2025 04:22 PM)Crayton Wrote:  
(11-02-2025 12:32 PM)AuzGrams Wrote:  What makes Miami (FL) better than Utah for an at-large playoff spot?

SOS?

If both are 10-2? Yes. Of course that is subject to change. Miami's position is highly dependent upon Notre Dame (and secondly FSU) while Utah's is dependent upon TTU/BYU in approximately the same measures. If those opponents start stinking it up (not just losing, but failing to cover by 2 scores or more), the balance between Utah and Miami might shift.

What do you think about the latest AP poll that has ND at 10 and Miami at 18? I'm getting sniffs of last year's unfairly low BYU ranking that allowed SMU to sneak into the CFP despite the h2h loss to BYU, very weak SOS and zero quality wins. ND has beaten USC as their only ranked win, Miami has beaten ND, and both have a comparable SOS overall. Would the committee even look at the AP poll, or could they use their BS "eye test" and determine that ND is just a lot better than Miami and thus ignore the h2h?

Here are the criteria for ranking by the CFP

On field performance
Strength of Schedule
Head to Head Results
Conference championships
Common Opponents
Record Strength
Player & Coach Availability

The ridiculous "eye test" is not a legit reason for ranking. Neither is what conference you play in.

It is more likely the AP & Coaches poll is having both of those things come into play.

As I pointed out in the other thread, all 5 media members picked Navy to beat North Texas on Sat during Gameday. All five were wrong.
11-03-2025 11:04 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
TrojanCampaign Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 6,086
Joined: Sep 2011
Reputation: 335
I Root For: USC, AAMU,
Location: Huntsville
Post: #89
RE: 2025 CFP Race (North Texas to the playoff!)
I think Utah might sneak into the playoff depending on where they are ranked tomorrow.

Several teams like Oklahoma, Texas, Texas AM, still have to play each other.
11-03-2025 12:00 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
HP-TBDPITL Online
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,527
Joined: Jun 2010
Reputation: 250
I Root For: College Sports
Location:
Post: #90
RE: 2025 CFP Race (North Texas to the playoff!)
(11-03-2025 12:00 PM)TrojanCampaign Wrote:  I think Utah might sneak into the playoff depending on where they are ranked tomorrow.

Several teams like Oklahoma, Texas, Texas AM, still have to play each other.

There is almost no chance of that happening. Both BYU and Texas Tech beat them.

Utah would have to win the Big 12 to make it unless those two schools lost two games.
11-03-2025 12:28 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Crayton Online
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,310
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation: 379
I Root For: Florida
Location:
Post: #91
RE: 2025 CFP Race (North Texas to the playoff!)
(11-03-2025 11:04 AM)HP-TBDPITL Wrote:  
(11-02-2025 08:42 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(11-02-2025 04:22 PM)Crayton Wrote:  
(11-02-2025 12:32 PM)AuzGrams Wrote:  What makes Miami (FL) better than Utah for an at-large playoff spot?

SOS?

If both are 10-2? Yes. Of course that is subject to change. Miami's position is highly dependent upon Notre Dame (and secondly FSU) while Utah's is dependent upon TTU/BYU in approximately the same measures. If those opponents start stinking it up (not just losing, but failing to cover by 2 scores or more), the balance between Utah and Miami might shift.

What do you think about the latest AP poll that has ND at 10 and Miami at 18? I'm getting sniffs of last year's unfairly low BYU ranking that allowed SMU to sneak into the CFP despite the h2h loss to BYU, very weak SOS and zero quality wins. ND has beaten USC as their only ranked win, Miami has beaten ND, and both have a comparable SOS overall. Would the committee even look at the AP poll, or could they use their BS "eye test" and determine that ND is just a lot better than Miami and thus ignore the h2h?

Here are the criteria for ranking by the CFP

On field performance
Strength of Schedule
Head to Head Results
Conference championships
Common Opponents
Record Strength
Player & Coach Availability

The ridiculous "eye test" is not a legit reason for ranking. Neither is what conference you play in.

It is more likely the AP & Coaches poll is having both of those things come into play.

As I pointed out in the other thread, all 5 media members picked Navy to beat North Texas on Sat during Gameday. All five were wrong.

“On field performance” is the eye-test and is a legitimate rationale for ranking. Quantifying “on field performance” is the trouble and why there are a plethora of models trying to capture its value.

To Bryan’s question, I have them about the same as the AP (see a few posts up), with Miami 1 spot ahead at #17. Some of it is that recency bias. Miami lost the day before, Notre Dame lost 2 months ago. But also A&M makes Notre Dame’s schedule that much more formidable.
11-03-2025 01:19 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Crayton Online
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,310
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation: 379
I Root For: Florida
Location:
Post: #92
RE: 2025 CFP Race (North Texas to the playoff!)
(11-03-2025 12:28 PM)HP-TBDPITL Wrote:  
(11-03-2025 12:00 PM)TrojanCampaign Wrote:  I think Utah might sneak into the playoff depending on where they are ranked tomorrow.

Several teams like Oklahoma, Texas, Texas AM, still have to play each other.

There is almost no chance of that happening. Both BYU and Texas Tech beat them.

Utah would have to win the Big 12 to make it unless those two schools lost two games.

Utah lost to 2 Top 10 teams and beat 1 Top 25 team. Better than 2-loss Notre Dame.

Notre Dame has great chances as a 10-2 team, but if Utah finishes 10-2 they won’t be too far behind.
11-03-2025 01:52 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
The Beaver Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 7,341
Joined: Apr 2024
Reputation: 955
I Root For: Penn State
Location:
Post: #93
RE: 2025 CFP Race (North Texas to the playoff!)
Yeah, Utah isn't out yet though they have a high hill to climb with BYU and TTU.
11-03-2025 01:55 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
YNot Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,082
Joined: May 2014
Reputation: 388
I Root For: BYU
Location:
Post: #94
RE: 2025 CFP Race (North Texas to the playoff!)
(11-03-2025 01:52 PM)Crayton Wrote:  
(11-03-2025 12:28 PM)HP-TBDPITL Wrote:  
(11-03-2025 12:00 PM)TrojanCampaign Wrote:  I think Utah might sneak into the playoff depending on where they are ranked tomorrow.

Several teams like Oklahoma, Texas, Texas AM, still have to play each other.

There is almost no chance of that happening. Both BYU and Texas Tech beat them.

Utah would have to win the Big 12 to make it unless those two schools lost two games.

Utah lost to 2 Top 10 teams and beat 1 Top 25 team. Better than 2-loss Notre Dame.

Notre Dame has great chances as a 10-2 team, but if Utah finishes 10-2 they won’t be too far behind.

Depends on where everyone finishes in the rankings but currently seems like a tight comparison between Utah and Notre Dame:

UTAH
Overall: 7-2
v. top10: 0-2
v. top25: 1-2
v. bowl: 2-2
road: 3-1
Key wins: #25 Cincinnati by 31
Key losses: @#8 BYU by 3, #9 Texas Tech by 24

NOTRE DAME
Overall: 6-2
v. top10: 0-1
v. top25: 1-2
v. bowl: 3-2
road: 2-1
Key wins: #20 USC by 10
Key losses: #3 Texas A&M by 1, @#18 Miami by 3

Utah needs both BYU and Texas Tech to finish strong and Cincinnati to stay in the rankings or ASU to move in. Notre Dame needs Texas A&M to finish strong and Miami and USC to stay in the rankings.

Great. Now I need a shower after looking through my rival's schedule and record and making their case for the CFP.
11-03-2025 06:18 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Crayton Online
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,310
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation: 379
I Root For: Florida
Location:
Post: #95
RE: 2025 CFP Race (North Texas to the playoff!)
(11-02-2025 09:21 AM)Crayton Wrote:  A couple upsets in the ACC mean that Louisville (not Georgia Tech) is now the most likely conference champion. Miami? Still clinging to an at large spot; too bad the simulation doesn't include the Cristobal choke quotient.

North Texas (!) is now the forerunner for the G5 spot. They passed their last big test before the American Championship. JMU is within striking distance of 2-loss American champs not named USF as well as near 3-loss ACC champs SMU/Duke. San Diego State likely needs those teams to have 1 additional loss to pass them.

Oregon finally reclaims a playoff spot. Though honestly they should have had it the last two weeks as well, as I continue to refine my presentation.

As the number of contenders dwindled, teams will start appearing in multiple locations in the grid.

[Image: attachment.php?aid=12220]

Updated this week's to include a new green section (suggestions welcome on color coding) documenting teams with <50% chance of making the playoff. With the possibility of so many 10-win teams, it will be fun to debate which ones should be left on the outside looking in.
(This post was last modified: 11-04-2025 06:17 PM by Crayton.)
11-04-2025 06:13 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
billybobby777 Offline
The REAL BillyBobby
*

Posts: 14,623
Joined: May 2013
Reputation: 755
I Root For: ECU, Army
Location: Houston dont sleepon
Post: #96
RE: 2025 CFP Race (North Texas to the playoff!)
(11-04-2025 06:13 PM)Crayton Wrote:  
(11-02-2025 09:21 AM)Crayton Wrote:  A couple upsets in the ACC mean that Louisville (not Georgia Tech) is now the most likely conference champion. Miami? Still clinging to an at large spot; too bad the simulation doesn't include the Cristobal choke quotient.

North Texas (!) is now the forerunner for the G5 spot. They passed their last big test before the American Championship. JMU is within striking distance of 2-loss American champs not named USF as well as near 3-loss ACC champs SMU/Duke. San Diego State likely needs those teams to have 1 additional loss to pass them.

Oregon finally reclaims a playoff spot. Though honestly they should have had it the last two weeks as well, as I continue to refine my presentation.

As the number of contenders dwindled, teams will start appearing in multiple locations in the grid.

[Image: attachment.php?aid=12220]

Updated this week's to include a new green section (suggestions welcome on color coding) documenting teams with <50% chance of making the playoff. With the possibility of so many 10-win teams, it will be fun to debate which ones should be left on the outside looking in.

They’ll cancel the playoffs after Temple plays in it. See Uconner going to the Fiesta Bowl that year was the straw that broke the BCS’s back.
11-04-2025 07:05 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Crayton Online
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,310
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation: 379
I Root For: Florida
Location:
Post: #97
RE: 2025 CFP Race (North Texas to the playoff!)
(11-02-2025 08:04 PM)Crayton Wrote:  As BryanW says, Sagarin hews closely to ESPN. It may be worth me diving in deeper to see why my power ratings for Texas, Texas Tech, Georgia, and Florida State are 6+ ranks away from the more public ratings. Could be a coding bug, a poorly weighted metric, or just a flavor I can choose to keep or drop.

Did a little investigation. (1) My algorithm is working as intended. (2) There may be an opportunity to assign different weights to different games when trying to determine a team's true strength.

Let us take Florida State as an example. Nobody thinks about them as a Top 25 team because of their 4 straight losses, but Sagarin and FPI have them as borderline Top 25 in their power rankings. I have them closer to #15 (again, in "power", my SOR ranking has them down in the 40s). Sagarin explicitly uses a recency bias when evaluating teams; I would expect FPI to have something similar. Should I follow suit?

In 4 games (Alabama, FCS, Kent St, Wake Forest) Florida State played like an FPI-equivalent +30.9 team. That is world-beater status; Indiana and Ohio State are topping out at +27.8 today. In the other 4 games (Virginia, Miami, Pittsburgh, Stanford) they played like a mediocre +1.6 FPI team.

I currently weight all 8 games equally, but should I? Should early games be discounted? FCS games? Games against teams of unequal strength? This decision could impact tie-breakers between similarly ranked teams (not bad) as well as the SOR/SOS calculation for their opponents (could be dangerous).

Any suggestions?

EDIT: Explored a tweak. Games are weighted based on how equal in strength the two teams are. If they are 2 points apart (using the FPI-like metric), the game is weighted 98%. If they are 50 points apart (like a Top 5 team vs. an FCS opponent) the game is weighted at 50%. This value is then cut in half again if the opponent actually is FCS (I use a generic FCS opponent and so this is probably useful anyway to lessen the impact of different team strengths from that level).

After applying this Florida State dropped from the 13th most difficult opponent to the 17th. Iowa was the other team with a similar-sized change, rising from 19th to 15th. When using this to gauge team's SOR, Texas climbed a spot over Notre Dame to #11, Iowa climbed 2 spots (over Cincy) to #23, and UNT fell 2 spots (behind GT) to #24.

Seems like an overall acceptable change. I wonder if pushing it further would improve results further.
(This post was last modified: 11-04-2025 07:40 PM by Crayton.)
11-04-2025 07:19 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
UofMstateU Online
Legend
*

Posts: 46,182
Joined: Dec 2009
Reputation: 4536
I Root For: Memphis
Location:
Post: #98
RE: 2025 CFP Race (North Texas to the playoff!)
(11-04-2025 07:19 PM)Crayton Wrote:  
(11-02-2025 08:04 PM)Crayton Wrote:  As BryanW says, Sagarin hews closely to ESPN. It may be worth me diving in deeper to see why my power ratings for Texas, Texas Tech, Georgia, and Florida State are 6+ ranks away from the more public ratings. Could be a coding bug, a poorly weighted metric, or just a flavor I can choose to keep or drop.

Did a little investigation. (1) My algorithm is working as intended. (2) There may be an opportunity to assign different weights to different games when trying to determine a team's true strength.

Let us take Florida State as an example. Nobody thinks about them as a Top 25 team because of their 4 straight losses, but Sagarin and FPI have them as borderline Top 25 in their power rankings. I have them closer to #15 (again, in "power", my SOR ranking has them down in the 40s). Sagarin explicitly uses a recency bias when evaluating teams; I would expect FPI to have something similar. Should I follow suit?

In 4 games (Alabama, FCS, Kent St, Wake Forest) Florida State played like an FPI-equivalent +30.9 team. That is world-beater status; Indiana and Ohio State are topping out at +27.8 today. In the other 4 games (Virginia, Miami, Pittsburgh, Stanford) they played like a mediocre +1.6 FPI team.

I currently weight all 8 games equally, but should I? Should early games be discounted? FCS games? Games against teams of unequal strength? This decision could impact tie-breakers between similarly ranked teams (not bad) as well as the SOR/SOS calculation for their opponents (could be dangerous).

Any suggestions?

EDIT: Explored a tweak. Games are weighted based on how equal in strength the two teams are. If they are 2 points apart (using the FPI-like metric), the game is weighted 98%. If they are 50 points apart (like a Top 5 team vs. an FCS opponent) the game is weighted at 50%. This value is then cut in half again if the opponent actually is FCS (I use a generic FCS opponent and so this is probably useful anyway to lessen the impact of different team strengths from that level).

After applying this Florida State dropped from the 13th most difficult opponent to the 17th. Iowa was the other team with a similar-sized change, rising from 19th to 15th. When using this to gauge team's SOR, Texas climbed a spot over Notre Dame to #11, Iowa climbed 2 spots (over Cincy) to #23, and UNT fell 2 spots (behind GT) to #24.

Seems like an overall acceptable change. I wonder if pushing it further would improve results further.


nice job, I know thats a lot of work.

One thing you can do is to run your algorithm over the past 5 years or so to see how its tracking against past results. It could tell you which metrics seem to do better over time.

But at some point it becomes paralysis by analysis.
11-04-2025 07:46 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bryanw1995 Offline
+12 Hackmaster
*

Posts: 26,944
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3763
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
Post: #99
RE: 2025 CFP Race (North Texas to the playoff!)
(11-04-2025 07:19 PM)Crayton Wrote:  
(11-02-2025 08:04 PM)Crayton Wrote:  As BryanW says, Sagarin hews closely to ESPN. It may be worth me diving in deeper to see why my power ratings for Texas, Texas Tech, Georgia, and Florida State are 6+ ranks away from the more public ratings. Could be a coding bug, a poorly weighted metric, or just a flavor I can choose to keep or drop.

Did a little investigation. (1) My algorithm is working as intended. (2) There may be an opportunity to assign different weights to different games when trying to determine a team's true strength.

Let us take Florida State as an example. Nobody thinks about them as a Top 25 team because of their 4 straight losses, but Sagarin and FPI have them as borderline Top 25 in their power rankings. I have them closer to #15 (again, in "power", my SOR ranking has them down in the 40s). Sagarin explicitly uses a recency bias when evaluating teams; I would expect FPI to have something similar. Should I follow suit?

In 4 games (Alabama, FCS, Kent St, Wake Forest) Florida State played like an FPI-equivalent +30.9 team. That is world-beater status; Indiana and Ohio State are topping out at +27.8 today. In the other 4 games (Virginia, Miami, Pittsburgh, Stanford) they played like a mediocre +1.6 FPI team.

I currently weight all 8 games equally, but should I? Should early games be discounted? FCS games? Games against teams of unequal strength? This decision could impact tie-breakers between similarly ranked teams (not bad) as well as the SOR/SOS calculation for their opponents (could be dangerous).

Any suggestions?

EDIT: Explored a tweak. Games are weighted based on how equal in strength the two teams are. If they are 2 points apart (using the FPI-like metric), the game is weighted 98%. If they are 50 points apart (like a Top 5 team vs. an FCS opponent) the game is weighted at 50%. This value is then cut in half again if the opponent actually is FCS (I use a generic FCS opponent and so this is probably useful anyway to lessen the impact of different team strengths from that level).

After applying this Florida State dropped from the 13th most difficult opponent to the 17th. Iowa was the other team with a similar-sized change, rising from 19th to 15th. When using this to gauge team's SOR, Texas climbed a spot over Notre Dame to #11, Iowa climbed 2 spots (over Cincy) to #23, and UNT fell 2 spots (behind GT) to #24.

Seems like an overall acceptable change. I wonder if pushing it further would improve results further.

I think that is a great tweak.
11-04-2025 08:41 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Crayton Online
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,310
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation: 379
I Root For: Florida
Location:
Post: #100
RE: 2025 CFP Race (North Texas to the playoff!)
Virginia lost but still replaced Louisville as the most likely ACC Champ. Miami won but (because Louisville also lost) their SOR fell and they were replaced by Texas Tech joining BYU as Big 12 teams in the likely playoff field.

Oregon's big win has their projected playoff record shifting from 10-2 to 11-1. It looks like At Larges will need to be in the Top 10 to make the playoff.

[Image: attachment.php?aid=12224]


Attached File(s)
.png  2025w11.png (Size: 318.11 KB / Downloads: 175)
(This post was last modified: 11-09-2025 08:18 AM by Crayton.)
11-09-2025 08:18 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Post Reply 




User(s) browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)


Copyright © 2002-2026 Collegiate Sports Nation Bulletin Board System (CSNbbs), All Rights Reserved.
CSNbbs is an independent fan site and is in no way affiliated to the NCAA or any of the schools and conferences it represents.
This site monetizes links. FTC Disclosure.
We allow third-party companies to serve ads and/or collect certain anonymous information when you visit our web site. These companies may use non-personally identifiable information (e.g., click stream information, browser type, time and date, subject of advertisements clicked or scrolled over) during your visits to this and other Web sites in order to provide advertisements about goods and services likely to be of greater interest to you. These companies typically use a cookie or third party web beacon to collect this information. To learn more about this behavioral advertising practice or to opt-out of this type of advertising, you can visit http://www.networkadvertising.org.
Powered By MyBB, © 2002-2026 MyBB Group.