(10-04-2025 08:35 AM)UIWElite2 Wrote: (10-03-2025 11:21 PM)HawaiiMongoose Wrote: (10-03-2025 08:18 PM)andybible1995 Wrote: (10-03-2025 08:11 PM)UIWElite2 Wrote: Can we stop with the WAC loophole bs? No FCS conference or association of random teams is moving into FBS. It’s not happening, now or ever.
^^^^This
When the NCAA strikes the provision from the bylaws I’ll stop bringing it up when there’s a possibility it might become relevant.
I was posting here 14 years ago when the NCAA put the provision in its bylaws and there was no confusion on the board then about its intent. Just because no conference has been in a good position since to leverage it doesn’t mean it’s BS.
Show me an article from a credible source on a credible website that brings up the possibility of this “wac loophole” being used by any conference since then.
What part of “no conference has been in a good position to leverage it” since the NCAA approved the provision do you not understand?
No article like the one you describe has ever been written, for exactly that reason.
The provision was approved on 1/15/11 (to take effect on 8/1/11) to address a very specific situation. In just the previous six months the WAC had been rocked by these events:
6/11/10 - Boise State’s announcement of its departure
8/18/10 - Fresno State’s and Nevada’s announcements of their departures
11/11/10 - Montana’s announcement that it would not join the WAC
12/10/10 - Hawaii’s announcement of its departure
On the positive side, the WAC had announced on 11/10/10 that UTSA and Texas State would be joining in 2012. However these schools would not complete their transitions to FBS until 2014.
As a consequence of these events, the WAC knew at the end of 2010 that it would only have seven committed football-playing members in 2012, and that two of those would not count towards the eight-full-FBS-member minimum requirement until 2014. Moreover it knew that no already-FBS schools were interested in joining the conference, and that no further FCS schools were prepared to join the WAC in 2012 and complete their FBS transitions by 2014.
In short, the WAC knew with near-certainty that it was on a path to burn through its two-year grace period in 2012 and 2013 and lose its FBS status in 2014.
It was in this context that the so-called WAC exemption was added to the NCAA manual in early 2011. There was significant discussion about it on the WAC board and here on the realignment board. It was evident that the exemption had been designed to allow the WAC to continue soliciting FCS schools with the inducement that by doing so they could apply to move up to FBS even if the conference had lost its FBS conference status. At the time it was thought that if the exemption succeeded in luring even a couple more FCS schools to the WAC, the conference could eventually build back up to eight FBS members and reclaim FBS status.
Over the next four months there was a frenzy of effort by the WAC to cherry pick schools from the Big Sky, but to no avail. It was a hot topic on the boards and reported in the media:
Division I-AA’s own Big Sky Conference … member schools have reportedly rejected at least half a dozen come-ons from the flailing marauders of the West.
https://www.sbnation.com/ncaa-football/2...brush-offs
Long-timers here will recall that it was Big Sky commissioner Doug Fullerton who circled the wagons and convinced his member schools that if they stayed put they could kill WAC football and elevate the Big Sky to the third best football conference in the West.
By May of 2012 the handwriting was on the wall. The WAC exemption wouldn’t save WAC football. On 5/2/12 San Jose State and Utah State announced their departures to the MWC. On 5/3/12 Louisiana Tech and UTSA followed with announcements of their departures to CUSA. Only Idaho, New Mexico State, and Texas State were left as football-playing members and they later found exits as well. Game over.
That was the only circumstance in which the exemption ever came close to having some genuine utility. And it wasn’t really that close. But the exemption is still on the books to this day, and IMHO as long as that’s true it’s not 100% out of the question that someone sometime might figure out some way to gain some kind of advantage from it.