"According to a statement by the leaders behind the SHC, this event typically brings in roughly 50,000 visitors, sold out area hotels, and more than $20 million into the local economy."
So Fred Jones says it and we believe it?
They've never had 50k at the game. And with the 25-30k they normally have, how many of those are local and not bringing ANY money to the local economy?
Call me skeptical. As Deion said in the interview about why he pulled out, it's a hustle.
You can question the numbers and attendance vs. tickets sold, but they averaged over 50k from 1994 - 2000, had a dip to 28k the year of 9/11/2001, then back up to averaging over 50k (or very close to it) until Jackson State dropped out in 2023 (no game COVID year).
12 of the 34 games broke 50,000 and all were JSU/TSU games.
Last three games averaged 27,181.
UAPB just doesn't have a following.
If they can't get either TSU or JSU back then it needs to move elsewhere.
Those are numbers said by Fred, printed by the media, and quoted by politicians. He says a number. The media promotes it for their own agenda. Politicians quote it to support subsidizing the game, to get kickbacks.
I've gone back and looked at photos from previous years. 50k in that stadium looks packed. There are no photos that I've seen that look anywhere close to that.
Present credible evidence, or quit promoting the lies.
"According to a statement by the leaders behind the SHC, this event typically brings in roughly 50,000 visitors, sold out area hotels, and more than $20 million into the local economy."
So Fred Jones says it and we believe it?
They've never had 50k at the game. And with the 25-30k they normally have, how many of those are local and not bringing ANY money to the local economy?
Call me skeptical. As Deion said in the interview about why he pulled out, it's a hustle.
In all my years in Memphis I never understood why the city wasted their time with Fred Jones. It's just a ballgame and it always seemed the costs to clean up after the game would about match whatever profits were expected. And it seemed that he had this power over the city and the Liberty Bowl.
Yeah, could you IMAGINE if the city sent a clean-up bill to the 2 schools proportionate to the clean-up bill Memphis In May BBQ Contest got in their last year @ Tom Lee Park?
"According to a statement by the leaders behind the SHC, this event typically brings in roughly 50,000 visitors, sold out area hotels, and more than $20 million into the local economy."
So Fred Jones says it and we believe it?
They've never had 50k at the game. And with the 25-30k they normally have, how many of those are local and not bringing ANY money to the local economy?
Call me skeptical. As Deion said in the interview about why he pulled out, it's a hustle.
You can question the numbers and attendance vs. tickets sold, but they averaged over 50k from 1994 - 2000, had a dip to 28k the year of 9/11/2001, then back up to averaging over 50k (or very close to it) until Jackson State dropped out in 2023 (no game COVID year).
12 of the 34 games broke 50,000 and all were JSU/TSU games.
Last three games averaged 27,181.
UAPB just doesn't have a following.
If they can't get either TSU or JSU back then it needs to move elsewhere.
Those are numbers said by Fred, printed by the media, and quoted by politicians. He says a number. The media promotes it for their own agenda. Politicians quote it to support subsidizing the game, to get kickbacks.
I've gone back and looked at photos from previous years. 50k in that stadium looks packed. There are no photos that I've seen that look anywhere close to that.
Present credible evidence, or quit promoting the lies.
A large part of that 50k number is probably tickets bought by companies to sponsor the game. Tickets sold does not equal butts in seats, but is commonly the number given to media.
The rule of thumb has always been that every dollar spent by tourist turns over in the local economy 7 times.
....
So, in other words, it only takes 7 taxable events to turn that 1 dollar into a statistical zero... hilarious. But at the same time... not.
If a dollar does turn over 7 times in the local economy, that $1 produces around $0.69 in tax revenue.
Actually closer to $0.49 assuming a 10% tax rate. That $1 decreases by the amount of tax taken each of the 7 times it turns over.
Excuse me while I push my horn-rimmed glasses up the bridge of my nose.... After the 7th transaction, the dollar has turned into 47.8 cents (at roughly 10% sales tax), but that doesn't even account for the fact that when you spend that dollar at the counter of any business that pays employees, an additional 7.65% tax is taken out for any portion of that dollar that goes to payroll. It would be almost impossible to calculate for multiple transactions, let alone 7, but suffice to say, that dollar shrinks pretty fast.
The rule of thumb has always been that every dollar spent by tourist turns over in the local economy 7 times.
....
So, in other words, it only takes 7 taxable events to turn that 1 dollar into a statistical zero... hilarious. But at the same time... not.
If a dollar does turn over 7 times in the local economy, that $1 produces around $0.69 in tax revenue.
Actually closer to $0.49 assuming a 10% tax rate. That $1 decreases by the amount of tax taken each of the 7 times it turns over.
Excuse me while I push my horn-rimmed glasses up the bridge of my nose.... After the 7th transaction, the dollar has turned into 47.8 cents (at roughly 10% sales tax), but that doesn't even account for the fact that when you spend that dollar at the counter of any business that pays employees, an additional 7.65% tax is taken out for any portion of that dollar that goes to payroll. It would be almost impossible to calculate for multiple transactions, let alone 7, but suffice to say, that dollar shrinks pretty fast.
My calculator has different results.
Each time that dollar is used it create $0.0975 in tax revenue.
(10-02-2025 02:00 PM)geosnooker2000 Wrote: So, in other words, it only takes 7 taxable events to turn that 1 dollar into a statistical zero... hilarious. But at the same time... not.
If a dollar does turn over 7 times in the local economy, that $1 produces around $0.69 in tax revenue.
Actually closer to $0.49 assuming a 10% tax rate. That $1 decreases by the amount of tax taken each of the 7 times it turns over.
Excuse me while I push my horn-rimmed glasses up the bridge of my nose.... After the 7th transaction, the dollar has turned into 47.8 cents (at roughly 10% sales tax), but that doesn't even account for the fact that when you spend that dollar at the counter of any business that pays employees, an additional 7.65% tax is taken out for any portion of that dollar that goes to payroll. It would be almost impossible to calculate for multiple transactions, let alone 7, but suffice to say, that dollar shrinks pretty fast.
My calculator has different results.
Each time that dollar is used it create $0.0975 in tax revenue.
After 7 times you end up with $0.6825.
$0.51 @ 9.75%.
You don't have the whole dollar after the first bite of tax is taken out. So you have to subtract the tax from the dollar each iteration.
And that's if you believe that 7x assumption to begin with (I don't). With the global economy, it's more like 3-4 times.
In addition, many of those folks are spending in Southaven and Olive Branch. So sorta kinda the local economy, but not really for Memphis infrastructure. Plus, a lower tax rate.
(This post was last modified: 10-03-2025 08:08 AM by Tiger87.)
Yeah, admittedly, I went the simple-to-understand route of multiplying each transaction by .9, and after 7 times, the result was what I said it was. I went the simpler route because,as I said, it's actually worse than that because of the payroll tax.