Memphis Yankee
Hall of Famer

Posts: 15,392
Joined: Oct 2017
Reputation: 1943
I Root For: Memphis
Location: Lake Mills, WI
|
RE: Rank the American after Week 4
(09-21-2025 11:21 AM)Ned Low Wrote: 1. Memphis
2. USF
3. Tulane
4. UNT
5. Navy
6. Army
7. ECU
8. UTSA
9. Rice
10. Tulsa
11. Temple
12. UAB
13. FAU
14. Charlotte
The conference has absolutely improved when compared to last season. Memphis leads the pack for sure and is the team to beat based on the eye test so far.
Rice is absolutely the most improved team. Tulsa strikes me as a team that will be dangerous, especially by the end of the season.
As for UTSA and ECU, their best ball is likely ahead of them.
ECU specifically can beat any team in the conference... and we can also lose to any team in the conference. We have got to stop shooting ourselves in the foot with penalties and such.
Just way too many good teams in our conference right now. I think today we win the beauty contest, but conference play is going to be brutal. Anything can happen.
My concern is we'll cannibalize each other and end up with a two or three loss team.
|
|
| 09-21-2025 08:06 PM |
|
Memphis Yankee
Hall of Famer

Posts: 15,392
Joined: Oct 2017
Reputation: 1943
I Root For: Memphis
Location: Lake Mills, WI
|
RE: Rank the American after Week 4
(09-21-2025 03:01 PM)Side.Show.Joe Wrote: 1. Memphis
2. South Florida
3. Tulane
4. Navy
5. North Texas
6. ECU
7. Army
8. UTSA
9. Rice
10. Tulsa
11. Temple
12. UAB
13. FAU
14. Charlotte
I wish I could place my Mean Green higher on this list, but the Army game never should have had to go into overtime.
I have North Texas higher than you do Joe. Maybe even as high as second. Army has a good team with a funky offense. Just win and keep moving on.
|
|
| 09-21-2025 08:12 PM |
|
Memphis Yankee
Hall of Famer

Posts: 15,392
Joined: Oct 2017
Reputation: 1943
I Root For: Memphis
Location: Lake Mills, WI
|
RE: Rank the American after Week 4
Make your list then. It's an open forum.
|
|
| 09-21-2025 08:30 PM |
|
Ourland
Hall of Famer

Posts: 10,318
Joined: Apr 2017
Reputation: 990
I Root For: The Rice Owls
Location: Galveston
|
RE: Rank the American after Week 4
South Florida
Memphis
Navy
Tulane
North Texas
UTSA
East Carolina
Army
Tulsa
Rice
Temple
Charlotte
FAU
UAB
It's a better conference, top to bottom, than at last year. More parity.
(This post was last modified: 09-21-2025 09:01 PM by Ourland.)
|
|
| 09-21-2025 08:57 PM |
|
Memphis Yankee
Hall of Famer

Posts: 15,392
Joined: Oct 2017
Reputation: 1943
I Root For: Memphis
Location: Lake Mills, WI
|
RE: Rank the American after Week 4
|
|
| 09-21-2025 09:31 PM |
|
Frank Grimes
One of "Kent's People"

Posts: 3,764
Joined: Jul 2023
Reputation: 687
I Root For: UAB,Springfield Isotopes
Location: 205/Springfield
|
RE: Rank the American after Week 4
(09-21-2025 03:20 PM)msu35 Wrote: More uncertainty within tiers. Less so between.
Tier 1
- - -
Memphis
South Florida
Tulane
Tier 2
- - -
North Texas
Navy
ECU
Army
Tier 3
- - -
UTSA
Rice
Tier 4
- - -
Tulsa
Temple
Tier 5
- - -
UAB
FAU
Charlotte
I'd move Army to Tier 3. But I think this is spot-on otherwise.
|
|
| 09-21-2025 10:04 PM |
|
Tiger1983
BBA

Posts: 41,589
Joined: Apr 2006
Reputation: 2987
I Root For: Tigers - GTG!
Location: The enemy’s lair
 
|
RE: Rank the American after Week 4
Here are the early results per Massey Composite with 30 sources. I may update it later in the week.
American total average (78.8)
American legacy average (64.6) (Army excluded)
American Former CUSA6 (97.2)
SBC total average (98.1)
MWC total average (88.2)
Future PAC total average (82.8)
Below are the American rankings by school:
1. Memphis (31)
2. North Tx (40)
3. USF (41)
4. Tulane (44)
5. Navy (48)
6. Army (68)
7. ECU (71)
8. UTSA (76)
9. Rice (97)
10. Temple (100)
11. UAB (112)
12. Tulsa (117)
13. FAU (125)
14. Charlotte (133)
|
|
| 09-22-2025 07:37 AM |
|
Pirate Rep
1st String

Posts: 1,641
Joined: Dec 2012
Reputation: 324
I Root For: East Carolina
Location:
|
RE: Rank the American after Week 4
(09-21-2025 10:04 PM)Frank Grimes Wrote: (09-21-2025 03:20 PM)msu35 Wrote: More uncertainty within tiers. Less so between.
Tier 1
- - -
Memphis
South Florida
Tulane
Tier 2
- - -
North Texas
Navy
ECU
Army
Tier 3
- - -
UTSA
Rice
Tier 4
- - -
Tulsa
Temple
Tier 5
- - -
UAB
FAU
Charlotte
I'd move Army to Tier 3. But I think this is spot-on otherwise.
This is pretty well the most accurate.
If there was a brain fart poll ECU would when that hands down after the BYU performance. I've never seen such a mental breakdown beginning in the last 5 minutes of the 2nd quarter swinging the game before halftime ten points that should be tied going into the half.
(This post was last modified: 09-22-2025 07:47 AM by Pirate Rep.)
|
|
| 09-22-2025 07:47 AM |
|
TripleA
Legend

Posts: 83,969
Joined: Jun 2008
Reputation: 5726
I Root For: Nice weather
Location: Following the sun
|
RE: Rank the American after Week 4
I think this early, it's more accurate to use tiers. And of course, as we enter conference play, before long, we can just use conference standings, lol.
So here are my tiers (no order, just alphabetically within tiers):
T1: Memphis, USF
T2: Navy, North Texas, Tulane
T3: Rice
T4: Everybody else (almost)
T5: Charlotte
(This post was last modified: 09-22-2025 07:48 AM by TripleA.)
|
|
| 09-22-2025 07:48 AM |
|
b0ndsj0ns
Legend

Posts: 30,775
Joined: Oct 2009
Reputation: 1639
I Root For: ECU
Location:
|
RE: Rank the American after Week 4
I'll go
Memphis/USF tied at the top
Tulane
UNT
Navy
Hodge podge group of Army/ECU/UTSA/Tulsa/Rice (I think you can throw them in any order and I wouldn't be able to argue hard for or against)
Temple
UAB
FAU
Charlotte
|
|
| 09-22-2025 08:10 AM |
|
b0ndsj0ns
Legend

Posts: 30,775
Joined: Oct 2009
Reputation: 1639
I Root For: ECU
Location:
|
RE: Rank the American after Week 4
(09-22-2025 07:47 AM)Pirate Rep Wrote: (09-21-2025 10:04 PM)Frank Grimes Wrote: (09-21-2025 03:20 PM)msu35 Wrote: More uncertainty within tiers. Less so between.
Tier 1
- - -
Memphis
South Florida
Tulane
Tier 2
- - -
North Texas
Navy
ECU
Army
Tier 3
- - -
UTSA
Rice
Tier 4
- - -
Tulsa
Temple
Tier 5
- - -
UAB
FAU
Charlotte
I'd move Army to Tier 3. But I think this is spot-on otherwise.
This is pretty well the most accurate.
If there was a brain fart poll ECU would when that hands down after the BYU performance. I've never seen such a mental breakdown beginning in the last 5 minutes of the 2nd quarter swinging the game before halftime ten points that should be tied going into the half.
I don't think you can put ECU in that tier 2. Talent wise I think you can, but clearly there's something missing upstairs with both the coaching and the players.
|
|
| 09-22-2025 08:12 AM |
|
USF_Bullsharks
Special Teams

Posts: 936
Joined: May 2025
Reputation: 287
I Root For: USF
Location:
|
RE: Rank the American after Week 4
(09-21-2025 03:33 PM)BullsFanInTX Wrote: May rank later, however, just a point. I see everyone is placing Memphis ahead of USF. It is so much easier to get up for one big game than 3 straight big games. Winning 2 out of 3 tough games is harder than just winning one off. Everyone knows Memphis would have also lost to Miami, at Miami as well. Maybe you could say Memphis would have also blown out Boise and beat Florida, but I would venture to say, that Florida has a higher talent base than Ark given pretty much any measure. We will find out when they play, but I can't see a whole lot of justification for placing Memphis ahead of USF in every ranking.
I disagree, but I also agree if you changed the narrative to "dropping Tulane so far". They lost to a good Ole Miss squad. I will hesitate to put USF ahead of Memphis and Tulane until we beat them in conference, and we don't even play Tulane this year.
Tulane
Memphis
USF
UNT
ECU
Navy
Army
Rice
UTSA
Tulsa
Temple
Charlotte
FAU
UAB
Owlficial rankings:
Rice
Temple
FAU
|
|
| 09-22-2025 08:44 AM |
|
owl at the moon
Eastern Screech Owl

Posts: 21,714
Joined: Aug 2013
Reputation: 3102
I Root For: rice,smu,uh,unt
Location: 23 mbps from csnbbs
|
Rank the American after Week 4
(09-22-2025 07:48 AM)TripleA Wrote: I think this early, it's more accurate to use tiers. And of course, as we enter conference play, before long, we can just use conference standings, lol.
So here are my tiers (no order, just alphabetically within tiers):
T1: Memphis, USF
T2: Navy, North Texas, Tulane
T3: Rice
T4: Everybody else (almost)
T5: Charlotte
Those look pretty accurate.
I reverse engineered your methodology…
T1. Do you have a truly impressive P4 win under your belt?
T2. Do you have two of the following: P5 wins or Conference Wins?
T3. Are you unbeaten in conference without any truly embarrassing showings?
T4. Are you a lot better than Monmouth?
T5. Are you 2-0 all-time vs ECU?
|
|
| 09-22-2025 08:52 AM |
|
msu35
Observing Reality

Posts: 21,642
Joined: Dec 2021
Reputation: 2234
I Root For: Truffles
Location: Tennessee
|
RE: Rank the American after Week 4
(09-22-2025 08:44 AM)USF_Bullsharks Wrote: (09-21-2025 03:33 PM)BullsFanInTX Wrote: May rank later, however, just a point. I see everyone is placing Memphis ahead of USF. It is so much easier to get up for one big game than 3 straight big games. Winning 2 out of 3 tough games is harder than just winning one off. Everyone knows Memphis would have also lost to Miami, at Miami as well. Maybe you could say Memphis would have also blown out Boise and beat Florida, but I would venture to say, that Florida has a higher talent base than Ark given pretty much any measure. We will find out when they play, but I can't see a whole lot of justification for placing Memphis ahead of USF in every ranking.
I disagree, but I also agree if you changed the narrative to "dropping Tulane so far". They lost to a good Ole Miss squad. I will hesitate to put USF ahead of Memphis and Tulane until we beat them in conference, and we don't even play Tulane this year.
Tulane
Memphis
USF
UNT
ECU
Navy
Army
Rice
UTSA
Tulsa
Temple
Charlotte
FAU
UAB
Owlficial rankings:
Rice
Temple
FAU
Tulane over Memphis? Comparing common opponents of opponents, I don't think so. Memphis beat Arkansas. Close game, but we shot ourselves in the foot with two high risk gimmicks (nonsensical onside kick and a stupid pass by our running back for a pick) that lead to a halftime deficit of 18. We held the Hogs to three points in the second half. The same Hogs that lost to Oxford on the last moments of the game by 6. Wasn't Tulane blown out in spectacular fashion? Similar to USF at Miami.
|
|
| 09-22-2025 08:56 AM |
|
TigerBill
Imperator Optimus Maximus

Posts: 43,116
Joined: Feb 2004
Reputation: 2581
I Root For: Liberation
Location: Purgatory
|
RE: Rank the American after Week 4
(09-22-2025 07:48 AM)TripleA Wrote: I think this early, it's more accurate to use tiers. And of course, as we enter conference play, before long, we can just use conference standings, lol.
So here are my tiers (no order, just alphabetically within tiers):
T1: Memphis, USF
T2: Navy, North Texas, Tulane
T3: Rice
T4: Everybody else (almost)
T5: Charlotte
Totally agree here. You can pick between USF, Memphis, or even Navy, UNT and Tulane at this point. USF has a loss, true, but they also beat Florida on the road.
|
|
| 09-22-2025 09:18 AM |
|
msu35
Observing Reality

Posts: 21,642
Joined: Dec 2021
Reputation: 2234
I Root For: Truffles
Location: Tennessee
|
RE: Rank the American after Week 4
(09-22-2025 09:18 AM)TigerBill Wrote: (09-22-2025 07:48 AM)TripleA Wrote: I think this early, it's more accurate to use tiers. And of course, as we enter conference play, before long, we can just use conference standings, lol.
So here are my tiers (no order, just alphabetically within tiers):
T1: Memphis, USF
T2: Navy, North Texas, Tulane
T3: Rice
T4: Everybody else (almost)
T5: Charlotte
Totally agree here. You can pick between USF, Memphis, or even Navy, UNT and Tulane at this point. USF has a loss, true, but they also beat Florida on the road.
Currently 1-3 Florida in a very low scoring game. We beat FSU in Tallahassee last year. How did that win age?
|
|
| 09-22-2025 09:20 AM |
|
DowdyPirate
Heisman

Posts: 9,319
Joined: Jan 2014
Reputation: 484
I Root For: ECU
Location:
|
RE: Rank the American after Week 4
(09-22-2025 08:12 AM)b0ndsj0ns Wrote: (09-22-2025 07:47 AM)Pirate Rep Wrote: (09-21-2025 10:04 PM)Frank Grimes Wrote: (09-21-2025 03:20 PM)msu35 Wrote: More uncertainty within tiers. Less so between.
Tier 1
- - -
Memphis
South Florida
Tulane
Tier 2
- - -
North Texas
Navy
ECU
Army
Tier 3
- - -
UTSA
Rice
Tier 4
- - -
Tulsa
Temple
Tier 5
- - -
UAB
FAU
Charlotte
I'd move Army to Tier 3. But I think this is spot-on otherwise.
This is pretty well the most accurate.
If there was a brain fart poll ECU would when that hands down after the BYU performance. I've never seen such a mental breakdown beginning in the last 5 minutes of the 2nd quarter swinging the game before halftime ten points that should be tied going into the half.
I don't think you can put ECU in that tier 2. Talent wise I think you can, but clearly there's something missing upstairs with both the coaching and the players.
Well we will find out in 3 days.
|
|
| 09-22-2025 09:21 AM |
|
Bull
Heisman

Posts: 5,826
Joined: Mar 2011
Reputation: 535
I Root For: USF and the AAC!
Location:
|
RE: Rank the American after Week 4
Multiple teams can be 'great' at the same time.
and speculation is fun!
All I can say is, looking forward to the CCG this season. Could be epic.
|
|
| 09-22-2025 09:47 AM |
|
b0ndsj0ns
Legend

Posts: 30,775
Joined: Oct 2009
Reputation: 1639
I Root For: ECU
Location:
|
RE: Rank the American after Week 4
(09-22-2025 09:21 AM)DowdyPirate Wrote: (09-22-2025 08:12 AM)b0ndsj0ns Wrote: (09-22-2025 07:47 AM)Pirate Rep Wrote: (09-21-2025 10:04 PM)Frank Grimes Wrote: (09-21-2025 03:20 PM)msu35 Wrote: More uncertainty within tiers. Less so between.
Tier 1
- - -
Memphis
South Florida
Tulane
Tier 2
- - -
North Texas
Navy
ECU
Army
Tier 3
- - -
UTSA
Rice
Tier 4
- - -
Tulsa
Temple
Tier 5
- - -
UAB
FAU
Charlotte
I'd move Army to Tier 3. But I think this is spot-on otherwise.
This is pretty well the most accurate.
If there was a brain fart poll ECU would when that hands down after the BYU performance. I've never seen such a mental breakdown beginning in the last 5 minutes of the 2nd quarter swinging the game before halftime ten points that should be tied going into the half.
I don't think you can put ECU in that tier 2. Talent wise I think you can, but clearly there's something missing upstairs with both the coaching and the players.
Well we will find out in 3 days.
We already found out, Army is just going to prove it to anyone holding out hope.
|
|
| 09-22-2025 09:47 AM |
|
Bull
Heisman

Posts: 5,826
Joined: Mar 2011
Reputation: 535
I Root For: USF and the AAC!
Location:
|
RE: Rank the American after Week 4
(09-22-2025 09:20 AM)msu35 Wrote: (09-22-2025 09:18 AM)TigerBill Wrote: (09-22-2025 07:48 AM)TripleA Wrote: I think this early, it's more accurate to use tiers. And of course, as we enter conference play, before long, we can just use conference standings, lol.
So here are my tiers (no order, just alphabetically within tiers):
T1: Memphis, USF
T2: Navy, North Texas, Tulane
T3: Rice
T4: Everybody else (almost)
T5: Charlotte
Totally agree here. You can pick between USF, Memphis, or even Navy, UNT and Tulane at this point. USF has a loss, true, but they also beat Florida on the road.
Currently 1-3 Florida in a very low scoring game. We beat FSU in Tallahassee last year. How did that win age?
Man we've been salivating to beat the Gators for two decades. And you sure don't get many opportunities. IDC if they are 'up' or 'down'... just happy it finally happened!
|
|
| 09-22-2025 09:48 AM |
|