CSNbbs
Rank the American after Week 4 - Printable Version

+- CSNbbs (https://csnbbs.com)
+-- Forum: Active Boards (/forum-769.html)
+--- Forum: Americanbbs (/forum-460.html)
+---- Forum: American Conference Talk (/forum-409.html)
+---- Thread: Rank the American after Week 4 (/thread-1017387.html)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5


Rank the American after Week 4 - Cubanbull1 - 09-21-2025 09:42 AM

While still early and many haven’t even played a league game. So far it looks to me as follows

Title Contenders by overall records
Memphis 4-0
North Texas 4-0
Navy 3-0
Tulane 3-1
USF 3-1

Spoilers
Rice 3-1
ECU 2-2
UTSA 2-2
Tulsa 2-2
Army 1-2

Long shots
UAB 2-2
Temple 2-2
FAU 1-2
Charlotte 1-3


RE: Rank the American after Week 4 - FAU Connoisseur! - 09-21-2025 10:12 AM

1. Memphis
2. USF
3. Navy
4. UNT
5. Tulane
6. ECU
7. Army
8. UTSA
9. Tulsa
10. Rice
11. Temple
12. UAB
13. FAU
14. Charlotte


RE: Rank the American after Week 4 - Tiger1983 - 09-21-2025 10:12 AM

My musings are based on impact of week 4 games on enhancing the conference's profile.

Good
Memphis
Tulsa
UTSA

Bad
ECU

Neutral
Tulane
UAB
Rice
Charlotte
Temple
Army
North Texas
USF


RE: Rank the American after Week 4 - Tiger1983 - 09-21-2025 10:14 AM

FWIW




RE: Rank the American after Week 4 - Ned Low - 09-21-2025 11:21 AM

1. Memphis
2. USF
3. Tulane
4. UNT
5. Navy
6. Army
7. ECU
8. UTSA
9. Rice
10. Tulsa
11. Temple
12. UAB
13. FAU
14. Charlotte

The conference has absolutely improved when compared to last season. Memphis leads the pack for sure and is the team to beat based on the eye test so far.

Rice is absolutely the most improved team. Tulsa strikes me as a team that will be dangerous, especially by the end of the season.

As for UTSA and ECU, their best ball is likely ahead of them.

ECU specifically can beat any team in the conference... and we can also lose to any team in the conference. We have got to stop shooting ourselves in the foot with penalties and such.


RE: Rank the American after Week 4 - ghostofclt! - 09-21-2025 11:34 AM

clt says you have Charlotte too high


RE: Rank the American after Week 4 - Tiger1983 - 09-21-2025 11:44 AM

Here are the early results per Massey Composite with only nine sources. I may update it later in the week.

American total average (81.6)
American legacy average (67.9) (Army excluded)
American Former CUSA6 (99.3)

SBC total average (97.1)
MWC total average (89.7)
Future PAC total average (80.9)


RE: Rank the American after Week 4 - tigerjeb - 09-21-2025 01:13 PM

1. Memphis
2. Tulane
3. USF
4. Navy
5. UNT
6. UTSA
7. ECU
8. Rice
9. Tulsa
10. Army
11. Temple
12. UAB
13. FAU
14. Charlotte


RE: Rank the American after Week 4 - goliath74 - 09-21-2025 02:05 PM

1. Memphis
2. UNT
3. USF
4. Tulane
5. Navy
6. UTSA
7. Tulsa
8. Rice
9. ECU
10. Army
11. UAB
12. Temple
13. FAU
14. Charlotte


RE: Rank the American after Week 4 - Side.Show.Joe - 09-21-2025 03:01 PM

1. Memphis
2. South Florida
3. Tulane
4. Navy
5. North Texas
6. ECU
7. Army
8. UTSA
9. Rice
10. Tulsa
11. Temple
12. UAB
13. FAU
14. Charlotte

I wish I could place my Mean Green higher on this list, but the Army game never should have had to go into overtime.


RE: Rank the American after Week 4 - msu35 - 09-21-2025 03:20 PM

More uncertainty within tiers. Less so between.

Tier 1
- - -
Memphis
South Florida
Tulane

Tier 2
- - -
North Texas
Navy
ECU
Army

Tier 3
- - -
UTSA
Rice

Tier 4
- - -
Tulsa
Temple

Tier 5
- - -
UAB
FAU
Charlotte


RE: Rank the American after Week 4 - BullsFanInTX - 09-21-2025 03:33 PM

May rank later, however, just a point. I see everyone is placing Memphis ahead of USF. It is so much easier to get up for one big game than 3 straight big games. Winning 2 out of 3 tough games is harder than just winning one off. Everyone knows Memphis would have also lost to Miami, at Miami as well. Maybe you could say Memphis would have also blown out Boise and beat Florida, but I would venture to say, that Florida has a higher talent base than Ark given pretty much any measure. We will find out when they play, but I can't see a whole lot of justification for placing Memphis ahead of USF in every ranking.


RE: Rank the American after Week 4 - msu35 - 09-21-2025 03:41 PM

(09-21-2025 03:33 PM)BullsFanInTX Wrote:  May rank later, however, just a point. I see everyone is placing Memphis ahead of USF. It is so much easier to get up for one big game than 3 straight big games. Winning 2 out of 3 tough games is harder than just winning one off. Everyone knows Memphis would have also lost to Miami, at Miami as well. Maybe you could say Memphis would have also blown out Boise and beat Florida, but I would venture to say, that Florida has a higher talent base than Ark given pretty much any measure. We will find out when they play, but I can't see a whole lot of justification for placing Memphis ahead of USF in every ranking.

Really? Ha ha ha ha.


RE: Rank the American after Week 4 - BullsFanInTX - 09-21-2025 03:49 PM

(09-21-2025 03:41 PM)msu35 Wrote:  
(09-21-2025 03:33 PM)BullsFanInTX Wrote:  May rank later, however, just a point. I see everyone is placing Memphis ahead of USF. It is so much easier to get up for one big game than 3 straight big games. Winning 2 out of 3 tough games is harder than just winning one off. Everyone knows Memphis would have also lost to Miami, at Miami as well. Maybe you could say Memphis would have also blown out Boise and beat Florida, but I would venture to say, that Florida has a higher talent base than Ark given pretty much any measure. We will find out when they play, but I can't see a whole lot of justification for placing Memphis ahead of USF in every ranking.

Really? Ha ha ha ha.

Wonder why all the prognosticators are still predicting USF to the CFP, and not Memphis.

https://www.espn.com/college-football/story/_/id/46334050/college-football-playoff-bowl-projections-following-week-4

https://www.cbssports.com/college-football/news/bowl-projections-miami-florida-state-on-collision-course-to-shake-up-cfp-race-texas-tech-keeps-pace/

https://athlonsports.com/college-football/bowl-projections-2025


RE: Rank the American after Week 4 - msu35 - 09-21-2025 03:54 PM

(09-21-2025 03:49 PM)BullsFanInTX Wrote:  
(09-21-2025 03:41 PM)msu35 Wrote:  
(09-21-2025 03:33 PM)BullsFanInTX Wrote:  May rank later, however, just a point. I see everyone is placing Memphis ahead of USF. It is so much easier to get up for one big game than 3 straight big games. Winning 2 out of 3 tough games is harder than just winning one off. Everyone knows Memphis would have also lost to Miami, at Miami as well. Maybe you could say Memphis would have also blown out Boise and beat Florida, but I would venture to say, that Florida has a higher talent base than Ark given pretty much any measure. We will find out when they play, but I can't see a whole lot of justification for placing Memphis ahead of USF in every ranking.

Really? Ha ha ha ha.

Wonder why all the prognosticators are still predicting USF to the CFP, and not Memphis.

https://www.espn.com/college-football/story/_/id/46334050/college-football-playoff-bowl-projections-following-week-4

https://www.cbssports.com/college-football/news/bowl-projections-miami-florida-state-on-collision-course-to-shake-up-cfp-race-texas-tech-keeps-pace/

https://athlonsports.com/college-football/bowl-projections-2025

They are always completely accurate and never get it wrong at the end of week four. I concede defeat. Bulls for the win.


Rank the American after Week 4 - owl at the moon - 09-21-2025 03:58 PM

(09-21-2025 03:33 PM)BullsFanInTX Wrote:  May rank later, however, just a point. I see everyone is placing Memphis ahead of USF. It is so much easier to get up for one big game than 3 straight big games. Winning 2 out of 3 tough games is harder than just winning one off. Everyone knows Memphis would have also lost to Miami, at Miami as well. Maybe you could say Memphis would have also blown out Boise and beat Florida, but I would venture to say, that Florida has a higher talent base than Ark given pretty much any measure. We will find out when they play, but I can't see a whole lot of justification for placing Memphis ahead of USF in every ranking.


It’s just recency bias IMO.

Both programs are worthy of a national ranking. AP and Coaches are split with regard to which one is more so.


RE: Rank the American after Week 4 - FAU Connoisseur! - 09-21-2025 04:02 PM

(09-21-2025 03:33 PM)BullsFanInTX Wrote:  May rank later, however, just a point. I see everyone is placing Memphis ahead of USF. It is so much easier to get up for one big game than 3 straight big games. Winning 2 out of 3 tough games is harder than just winning one off. Everyone knows Memphis would have also lost to Miami, at Miami as well. Maybe you could say Memphis would have also blown out Boise and beat Florida, but I would venture to say, that Florida has a higher talent base than Ark given pretty much any measure. We will find out when they play, but I can't see a whole lot of justification for placing Memphis ahead of USF in every ranking.

Memphis is undefeated.


RE: Rank the American after Week 4 - Cubanbull1 - 09-21-2025 04:40 PM

It really doesn’t matter who we rank 1-5 etc right now. Most haven’t played conference games yet. As we get into conference season it will be determined on the field. That is why I just put them in groups at the moment.
Is all fun


RE: Rank the American after Week 4 - Tiger1983 - 09-21-2025 06:28 PM

(09-21-2025 03:33 PM)BullsFanInTX Wrote:  May rank later, however, just a point. I see everyone is placing Memphis ahead of USF. It is so much easier to get up for one big game than 3 straight big games. Winning 2 out of 3 tough games is harder than just winning one off. Everyone knows Memphis would have also lost to Miami, at Miami as well. Maybe you could say Memphis would have also blown out Boise and beat Florida, but I would venture to say, that Florida has a higher talent base than Ark given pretty much any measure. We will find out when they play, but I can't see a whole lot of justification for placing Memphis ahead of USF in every ranking.

I tend to agree. I think recency bias plays a role. However, I think Arkansas is probably the best victory for the American to date.


RE: Rank the American after Week 4 - BeatNavy - 09-21-2025 06:30 PM

10th LOL