msu35
Observing Reality

Posts: 21,660
Joined: Dec 2021
Reputation: 2234
I Root For: Truffles
Location: Tennessee
|
RE: PAC superiority?
(09-07-2025 05:59 PM)Marc Mensa Wrote: (09-07-2025 05:11 PM)msu35 Wrote: (09-07-2025 04:23 PM)Marc Mensa Wrote: (09-07-2025 03:52 PM)msu35 Wrote: (09-07-2025 03:38 PM)Marc Mensa Wrote: Please don’t confuse 1 season with long term viability. The schools which will comprise the PAC, have more resources than programs within the AAC… they just do. Oregon State, Wazzu, SDSU & Fresno’s facilities, fanbases & commitment are more significant than Tulsa’s, Rice’s, UAB’s or Charlotte’s as are Washington State’s. Had the top 4 teams left the AAC and joined the PAC, those schools would have distanced themselves from the rest of the G5 and assured their champion to be the annual representative in playoff. Too, the conference would have been a 5+ bid league in the NCAA basketball tournament. As it is, we’ll remain in a 1 bid league and the AAC will flip flop with the PAC for the football playoff spot.
So then why are you pushing your recency bias?
Clarify
Really?
Yes
Aside from the wishful thinking, you reference the most recent success. If we're talking historical performance, the AAC is tops. Don't fool yourself into thinking they're going to dramatically outspend the top half of the AAC either. USF, for example, has already maxed out revenue sharing to great effect and all of the schools are stepping up the effort.
If they're so superior to the AAC, why are we significantly closer to the ACC than the MWC?. So far this season the AAC has wins against the B1G, B12, and the SEC. I concede your basketball straw man, but that doesn't matter anyway and this is about football. Being in a crap basketball league never hurt anyone, and football drives realignment anyway. An easier path to the tournament can only help.
|
|
| 09-07-2025 06:21 PM |
|
Tiger87
Hall of Famer

Posts: 23,720
Joined: Jan 2012
Reputation: 1743
I Root For: Memphis
Location:
|
RE: PAC superiority?
I was a proponent for the PAC. Now I know that Memphis was working on putting together an offer they thought would get Memphis into the B12. I'm cool with that. But it didn't work. So now, we still need to get out of the AAC. That may very well mean fb to the PAC and everything else to the BEast. We will see.
As for ratings...If you take Memphis out of the AAC, the nPAC is higher rated in ESPN FPI, Sagarin, and Massey. And it's not even close. Even with Memphis in the AAC, the nPAC is higher rated than the AAC in Sagarin and Massey - and basically even in FPI. Even with the success we are having at the top of the conference, there are too many bad teams and it drags the AAC down.
Of course, it's only 2 weeks - so a lot more to play out.
(This post was last modified: 09-07-2025 07:19 PM by Tiger87.)
|
|
| 09-07-2025 07:14 PM |
|
Tiger87
Hall of Famer

Posts: 23,720
Joined: Jan 2012
Reputation: 1743
I Root For: Memphis
Location:
|
RE: PAC superiority?
(09-07-2025 06:21 PM)msu35 Wrote: (09-07-2025 05:59 PM)Marc Mensa Wrote: (09-07-2025 05:11 PM)msu35 Wrote: (09-07-2025 04:23 PM)Marc Mensa Wrote: (09-07-2025 03:52 PM)msu35 Wrote: So then why are you pushing your recency bias?
Clarify
Really?
Yes
Aside from the wishful thinking, you reference the most recent success. If we're talking historical performance, the AAC is tops. Don't fool yourself into thinking they're going to dramatically outspend the top half of the AAC either. USF, for example, has already maxed out revenue sharing to great effect and all of the schools are stepping up the effort.
If they're so superior to the AAC, why are we significantly closer to the ACC than the MWC?. So far this season the AAC has wins against the B1G, B12, and the SEC. I concede your basketball straw man, but that doesn't matter anyway and this is about football. Being in a crap basketball league never hurt anyone, and football drives realignment anyway. An easier path to the tournament can only help.
The discussion has always been about the nPAC - not the MWC. Besides, not even sure what those rankings are. We are not anywhere close to the ACC in Sagarin, Massey or FPI.
|
|
| 09-07-2025 07:26 PM |
|
ncrdbl1
Legend

Posts: 31,082
Joined: Nov 2005
Reputation: 608
I Root For: Memphis Tigers
Location: Horn Lake
|
RE: PAC superiority?
(09-07-2025 07:14 PM)Tiger87 Wrote: I was a proponent for the PAC. Now I know that Memphis was working on putting together an offer they thought would get Memphis into the B12. I'm cool with that. But it didn't work. So now, we still need to get out of the AAC. That may very well mean fb to the PAC and everything else to the BEast. We will see.
As for ratings...If you take Memphis out of the AAC, the nPAC is higher rated in ESPN FPI, Sagarin, and Massey. And it's not even close. Even with Memphis in the AAC, the nPAC is higher rated than the AAC in Sagarin and Massey - and basically even in FPI. Even with the success we are having at the top of the conference, there are too many bad teams and it drags the AAC down.
Of course, it's only 2 weeks - so a lot more to play out.
not close to being true.
USF 38, Tulane 45 and Tigers 47 higher in the FPI than Boise 57 who is highest in nPAC.
Next highest nPAC are Texas St 67, Fresno 74, WSU 87, USU 97
Next highest American are ECU 69 and Navy 71, UTSA 77, Army 81, Temple 83, N Texas 88, FAU 94
Half the nPAC is 100 or worse.
28% of American is 100 or worse
|
|
| 09-08-2025 06:15 AM |
|
ncrdbl1
Legend

Posts: 31,082
Joined: Nov 2005
Reputation: 608
I Root For: Memphis Tigers
Location: Horn Lake
|
RE: PAC superiority?
Sangarin is trying to pull some bull****.
He's ranking the Sun Belt East and West separately.
So the SBCW can be highest G6 ahead of the American.
|
|
| 09-08-2025 06:28 AM |
|
msu35
Observing Reality

Posts: 21,660
Joined: Dec 2021
Reputation: 2234
I Root For: Truffles
Location: Tennessee
|
RE: PAC superiority?
(09-07-2025 07:26 PM)Tiger87 Wrote: (09-07-2025 06:21 PM)msu35 Wrote: (09-07-2025 05:59 PM)Marc Mensa Wrote: (09-07-2025 05:11 PM)msu35 Wrote: (09-07-2025 04:23 PM)Marc Mensa Wrote: Clarify
Really?
Yes
Aside from the wishful thinking, you reference the most recent success. If we're talking historical performance, the AAC is tops. Don't fool yourself into thinking they're going to dramatically outspend the top half of the AAC either. USF, for example, has already maxed out revenue sharing to great effect and all of the schools are stepping up the effort.
If they're so superior to the AAC, why are we significantly closer to the ACC than the MWC?. So far this season the AAC has wins against the B1G, B12, and the SEC. I concede your basketball straw man, but that doesn't matter anyway and this is about football. Being in a crap basketball league never hurt anyone, and football drives realignment anyway. An easier path to the tournament can only help.
The discussion has always been about the nPAC - not the MWC. Besides, not even sure what those rankings are. We are not anywhere close to the ACC in Sagarin, Massey or FPI.
|
|
| 09-08-2025 09:11 AM |
|
msu35
Observing Reality

Posts: 21,660
Joined: Dec 2021
Reputation: 2234
I Root For: Truffles
Location: Tennessee
|
RE: PAC superiority?
Another data point. After week two, the AAC overwhelmingly has the most undefeated programs in the G6 by leaps and bounds.
|
|
| 09-08-2025 09:14 AM |
|
msu35
Observing Reality

Posts: 21,660
Joined: Dec 2021
Reputation: 2234
I Root For: Truffles
Location: Tennessee
|
RE: PAC superiority?
(09-07-2025 07:26 PM)Tiger87 Wrote: The discussion has always been about the nPAC - not the MWC. Besides, not even sure what those rankings are. We are not anywhere close to the ACC in Sagarin, Massey or FPI.
Where do you think the "nPAC" is pulling from? I'll give you a hint: starts with "m" and ends with "c" in case you're still (or pretending to be) confused. Hard to have honest discussions with people when they want to be among the smartest people or the dumbest people on the board, depending on what suits their agenda in the moment.
|
|
| 09-08-2025 09:20 AM |
|
Tiger87
Hall of Famer

Posts: 23,720
Joined: Jan 2012
Reputation: 1743
I Root For: Memphis
Location:
|
RE: PAC superiority?
(09-08-2025 06:15 AM)ncrdbl1 Wrote: (09-07-2025 07:14 PM)Tiger87 Wrote: I was a proponent for the PAC. Now I know that Memphis was working on putting together an offer they thought would get Memphis into the B12. I'm cool with that. But it didn't work. So now, we still need to get out of the AAC. That may very well mean fb to the PAC and everything else to the BEast. We will see.
As for ratings...If you take Memphis out of the AAC, the nPAC is higher rated in ESPN FPI, Sagarin, and Massey. And it's not even close. Even with Memphis in the AAC, the nPAC is higher rated than the AAC in Sagarin and Massey - and basically even in FPI. Even with the success we are having at the top of the conference, there are too many bad teams and it drags the AAC down.
Of course, it's only 2 weeks - so a lot more to play out.
not close to being true.
USF 38, Tulane 45 and Tigers 47 higher in the FPI than Boise 57 who is highest in nPAC.
Next highest nPAC are Texas St 67, Fresno 74, WSU 87, USU 97
Next highest American are ECU 69 and Navy 71, UTSA 77, Army 81, Temple 83, N Texas 88, FAU 94
Half the nPAC is 100 or worse.
28% of American is 100 or worse
Oh, it's absolutely true just the way I stated it. You're just looking at the top teams(cherry picking) - leaving out the AAC bottom feeders. You're also misrepresenting how many of the teams are "100 or worse". The nPAC has 2 out of 8 (25%). The AAC has 4 out of 14 (29%).
FPI is my least favorite of the power ranking algorithms, but we'll use it since you seem to like it (positive numbers are better):
nPAC composite FPI with Memphis = -3.71
AAC w Memphis = -4.53
nPAC without Memphis = -4.89
AAC without Memphis = -5.32
Apart from Memphis, the AAC has 2 other teams with a positive FPI - USF, Tulane. The nPAC has the same - Boise, Texas St.
The problem - as always - is the AAC has 11 teams with a negative FPI.
The nPAC has 6.
Put Memphis in the PAC, and it ain't close. The nPAC without Memphis is pretty evenly ranked with the current AAC WITH Memphis. And Massey & KenPom have margins even more favorable to the nPAC (which is why you are using FPI, I'm sure).
|
|
| 09-08-2025 09:32 AM |
|
Tiger87
Hall of Famer

Posts: 23,720
Joined: Jan 2012
Reputation: 1743
I Root For: Memphis
Location:
|
RE: PAC superiority?
(09-08-2025 06:28 AM)ncrdbl1 Wrote: Sangarin is trying to pull some bull****.
He's ranking the Sun Belt East and West separately.
So the SBCW can be highest G6 ahead of the American.
LOL
and you accuse others of conspiracy theories...
Sagarin ALWAYS ranks conferences with divisions, by divisions. Been doing this for years. There were times back in the old days, where the AAC would be ranked higher than one side of the PAC or ACC.
|
|
| 09-08-2025 09:34 AM |
|
Tiger87
Hall of Famer

Posts: 23,720
Joined: Jan 2012
Reputation: 1743
I Root For: Memphis
Location:
|
RE: PAC superiority?
(09-08-2025 09:11 AM)msu35 Wrote: (09-07-2025 07:26 PM)Tiger87 Wrote: (09-07-2025 06:21 PM)msu35 Wrote: (09-07-2025 05:59 PM)Marc Mensa Wrote: (09-07-2025 05:11 PM)msu35 Wrote: Really?
Yes
Aside from the wishful thinking, you reference the most recent success. If we're talking historical performance, the AAC is tops. Don't fool yourself into thinking they're going to dramatically outspend the top half of the AAC either. USF, for example, has already maxed out revenue sharing to great effect and all of the schools are stepping up the effort.
If they're so superior to the AAC, why are we significantly closer to the ACC than the MWC?. So far this season the AAC has wins against the B1G, B12, and the SEC. I concede your basketball straw man, but that doesn't matter anyway and this is about football. Being in a crap basketball league never hurt anyone, and football drives realignment anyway. An easier path to the tournament can only help.
The discussion has always been about the nPAC - not the MWC. Besides, not even sure what those rankings are. We are not anywhere close to the ACC in Sagarin, Massey or FPI.
Fornelli, lol
It's telling that Massey uses a composite of 28 different rankings, and Fornelli is not on the list.
|
|
| 09-08-2025 09:38 AM |
|
Tiger87
Hall of Famer

Posts: 23,720
Joined: Jan 2012
Reputation: 1743
I Root For: Memphis
Location:
|
RE: PAC superiority?
(09-08-2025 09:20 AM)msu35 Wrote: (09-07-2025 07:26 PM)Tiger87 Wrote: The discussion has always been about the nPAC - not the MWC. Besides, not even sure what those rankings are. We are not anywhere close to the ACC in Sagarin, Massey or FPI.
Where do you think the "nPAC" is pulling from? I'll give you a hint: starts with "m" and ends with "c" in case you're still (or pretending to be) confused. Hard to have honest discussions with people when they want to be among the smartest people or the dumbest people on the board, depending on what suits their agenda in the moment.
Dude, we don't have to guess. We know EXACTLY the 8 teams that are in the nPAC. So all you have to do is a little bit of math, and viola - you can rank the nPAC.
But for "honest discussions" you want to include the entire MWC - including programs who are NOT going to be in the nPAC. We see it - their bottom programs weight down the MWC too, so you want to insincerely include them to fit your narrative.
|
|
| 09-08-2025 09:41 AM |
|
Marc Mensa
You'll Get Nothing and Like It

Posts: 16,312
Joined: Mar 2004
Reputation: 934
I Root For: The Underdog
Location: Samaria
|
RE: PAC superiority?
(09-08-2025 09:32 AM)Tiger87 Wrote: (09-08-2025 06:15 AM)ncrdbl1 Wrote: (09-07-2025 07:14 PM)Tiger87 Wrote: I was a proponent for the PAC. Now I know that Memphis was working on putting together an offer they thought would get Memphis into the B12. I'm cool with that. But it didn't work. So now, we still need to get out of the AAC. That may very well mean fb to the PAC and everything else to the BEast. We will see.
As for ratings...If you take Memphis out of the AAC, the nPAC is higher rated in ESPN FPI, Sagarin, and Massey. And it's not even close. Even with Memphis in the AAC, the nPAC is higher rated than the AAC in Sagarin and Massey - and basically even in FPI. Even with the success we are having at the top of the conference, there are too many bad teams and it drags the AAC down.
Of course, it's only 2 weeks - so a lot more to play out.
not close to being true.
USF 38, Tulane 45 and Tigers 47 higher in the FPI than Boise 57 who is highest in nPAC.
Next highest nPAC are Texas St 67, Fresno 74, WSU 87, USU 97
Next highest American are ECU 69 and Navy 71, UTSA 77, Army 81, Temple 83, N Texas 88, FAU 94
Half the nPAC is 100 or worse.
28% of American is 100 or worse
Oh, it's absolutely true just the way I stated it. You're just looking at the top teams(cherry picking) - leaving out the AAC bottom feeders. You're also misrepresenting how many of the teams are "100 or worse". The nPAC has 2 out of 8 (25%). The AAC has 4 out of 14 (29%).
FPI is my least favorite of the power ranking algorithms, but we'll use it since you seem to like it (positive numbers are better):
nPAC composite FPI with Memphis = -3.71
AAC w Memphis = -4.53
nPAC without Memphis = -4.89
AAC without Memphis = -5.32
Apart from Memphis, the AAC has 2 other teams with a positive FPI - USF, Tulane. The nPAC has the same - Boise, Texas St.
The problem - as always - is the AAC has 11 teams with a negative FPI.
The nPAC has 6.
Put Memphis in the PAC, and it ain't close. The nPAC without Memphis is pretty evenly ranked with the current AAC WITH Memphis. And Massey & KenPom have margins even more favorable to the nPAC (which is why you are using FPI, I'm sure).
And if Memphis, Tulane, USF & UTSA all moved it would position the PAC as the only G5 conference for contention in the playoff & would make it virtually impossible for the conference to be omitted from future playoff configurations.
|
|
| 09-08-2025 09:42 AM |
|
Tiger87
Hall of Famer

Posts: 23,720
Joined: Jan 2012
Reputation: 1743
I Root For: Memphis
Location:
|
RE: PAC superiority?
(09-08-2025 09:14 AM)msu35 Wrote: Another data point. After week two, the AAC overwhelmingly has the most undefeated programs in the G6 by leaps and bounds.
Fornelli and Reddit.
Calling the MWC the nPAC
Someone is trying way too hard to convince himself.
(This post was last modified: 09-08-2025 09:43 AM by Tiger87.)
|
|
| 09-08-2025 09:43 AM |
|
msu35
Observing Reality

Posts: 21,660
Joined: Dec 2021
Reputation: 2234
I Root For: Truffles
Location: Tennessee
|
RE: PAC superiority?
(09-08-2025 09:43 AM)Tiger87 Wrote: (09-08-2025 09:14 AM)msu35 Wrote: Another data point. After week two, the AAC overwhelmingly has the most undefeated programs in the G6 by leaps and bounds.
Fornelli and Reddit.
Calling the MWC the nPAC
Someone is trying way too hard to convince himself.
Fornelli is stating an opinion. The Reddit tweet is FACT. Still pretending to be stupid? I'm starting to believe you're not really pretending at this stage.
|
|
| 09-08-2025 09:46 AM |
|
msu35
Observing Reality

Posts: 21,660
Joined: Dec 2021
Reputation: 2234
I Root For: Truffles
Location: Tennessee
|
RE: PAC superiority?
(09-08-2025 09:41 AM)Tiger87 Wrote: (09-08-2025 09:20 AM)msu35 Wrote: (09-07-2025 07:26 PM)Tiger87 Wrote: The discussion has always been about the nPAC - not the MWC. Besides, not even sure what those rankings are. We are not anywhere close to the ACC in Sagarin, Massey or FPI.
Where do you think the "nPAC" is pulling from? I'll give you a hint: starts with "m" and ends with "c" in case you're still (or pretending to be) confused. Hard to have honest discussions with people when they want to be among the smartest people or the dumbest people on the board, depending on what suits their agenda in the moment.
Dude, we don't have to guess. We know EXACTLY the 8 teams that are in the nPAC. So all you have to do is a little bit of math, and viola - you can rank the nPAC.
But for "honest discussions" you want to include the entire MWC - including programs who are NOT going to be in the nPAC. We see it - their bottom programs weight down the MWC too, so you want to insincerely include them to fit your narrative.
Are you really that slow? Do you realize that the PAC schools in the MWC are all far below the AAC and that the bottom of that group is around the same level as Rice and UAB? The only team still undefeated that will make up the PAC is Texas State. Confirmed, you're not pretending.
|
|
| 09-08-2025 09:49 AM |
|
Tiger87
Hall of Famer

Posts: 23,720
Joined: Jan 2012
Reputation: 1743
I Root For: Memphis
Location:
|
RE: PAC superiority?
(09-08-2025 09:49 AM)msu35 Wrote: (09-08-2025 09:41 AM)Tiger87 Wrote: (09-08-2025 09:20 AM)msu35 Wrote: (09-07-2025 07:26 PM)Tiger87 Wrote: The discussion has always been about the nPAC - not the MWC. Besides, not even sure what those rankings are. We are not anywhere close to the ACC in Sagarin, Massey or FPI.
Where do you think the "nPAC" is pulling from? I'll give you a hint: starts with "m" and ends with "c" in case you're still (or pretending to be) confused. Hard to have honest discussions with people when they want to be among the smartest people or the dumbest people on the board, depending on what suits their agenda in the moment.
Dude, we don't have to guess. We know EXACTLY the 8 teams that are in the nPAC. So all you have to do is a little bit of math, and viola - you can rank the nPAC.
But for "honest discussions" you want to include the entire MWC - including programs who are NOT going to be in the nPAC. We see it - their bottom programs weight down the MWC too, so you want to insincerely include them to fit your narrative.
Are you really that slow? Do you realize that the PAC schools in the MWC are all far below the AAC and that the bottom of that group is around the same level as Rice and UAB? The only team still undefeated that will make up the PAC is Texas State. Confirmed, you're not pretending.
Dude, I've provided you with the ranking data. Here's how you do that:
1 - list the 8 teams that are in the nPAC
2 - do NOT include other MWC teams who are not going to the nPAC
3 - compare that data set to the existing AAC rankings
Just read the thread and the data provided - post #29 is a good start. You're looking a bit silly trying to call me out.
(This post was last modified: 09-08-2025 10:03 AM by Tiger87.)
|
|
| 09-08-2025 10:01 AM |
|
msu35
Observing Reality

Posts: 21,660
Joined: Dec 2021
Reputation: 2234
I Root For: Truffles
Location: Tennessee
|
RE: PAC superiority?
(09-08-2025 10:01 AM)Tiger87 Wrote: (09-08-2025 09:49 AM)msu35 Wrote: (09-08-2025 09:41 AM)Tiger87 Wrote: (09-08-2025 09:20 AM)msu35 Wrote: (09-07-2025 07:26 PM)Tiger87 Wrote: The discussion has always been about the nPAC - not the MWC. Besides, not even sure what those rankings are. We are not anywhere close to the ACC in Sagarin, Massey or FPI.
Where do you think the "nPAC" is pulling from? I'll give you a hint: starts with "m" and ends with "c" in case you're still (or pretending to be) confused. Hard to have honest discussions with people when they want to be among the smartest people or the dumbest people on the board, depending on what suits their agenda in the moment.
Dude, we don't have to guess. We know EXACTLY the 8 teams that are in the nPAC. So all you have to do is a little bit of math, and viola - you can rank the nPAC.
But for "honest discussions" you want to include the entire MWC - including programs who are NOT going to be in the nPAC. We see it - their bottom programs weight down the MWC too, so you want to insincerely include them to fit your narrative.
Are you really that slow? Do you realize that the PAC schools in the MWC are all far below the AAC and that the bottom of that group is around the same level as Rice and UAB? The only team still undefeated that will make up the PAC is Texas State. Confirmed, you're not pretending.
Dude, I've provided you with the ranking data. Here's how you do that:
1 - list the 8 teams that are in the nPAC
2 - do NOT include other MWC teams who are not going to the nPAC
3 - compare that data set to the existing AAC rankings
Just read the thread and the data provided - post #29 is a good start. You're looking a bit silly trying to call me out.
ESPN power index validates everything I've stated. When your back is against the wall, you always love to deflect or play stupid.
|
|
| 09-08-2025 10:04 AM |
|
msu35
Observing Reality

Posts: 21,660
Joined: Dec 2021
Reputation: 2234
I Root For: Truffles
Location: Tennessee
|
RE: PAC superiority?
(09-08-2025 09:42 AM)Marc Mensa Wrote: And if Memphis, Tulane, USF & UTSA all moved it would position the PAC as the only G5 conference for contention in the playoff & would make it virtually impossible for the conference to be omitted from future playoff configurations.
If, if, if. It was never happening. They had no money to offer. Full stop.
|
|
| 09-08-2025 10:06 AM |
|
BERT56
Resident Slappy

Posts: 5,950
Joined: Sep 2007
Reputation: 800
I Root For: MEMPHIS TIGERS
Location: Memphis Intl. Apt.
|
RE: PAC superiority?
The nPAC legacy schools could come off some of that cheese they have to pay our buyout and it MIGHT be worth our while at some point in the future.
|
|
| 09-08-2025 12:31 PM |
|