Hello There, Guest! Registered users see far less ads! Register today and join our virtual tailgate. (Login — Register)


Post Reply 
Mid-Major Realignment About to Happen Again?
Author Message
Bookmark and Share
Herd6993 Offline
Special Teams
*

Posts: 635
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation: 94
I Root For: Marshall
Location:
Post: #1241
RE: Mid-Major Realignment About to Happen Again?
I think Chief alluded to it in another post. If Memphis and Tulane leave, the future look of the AAC and SBC will depend on ESPN's view.
(This post was last modified: 10-02-2024 04:43 PM by Herd6993.)
10-02-2024 04:43 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
GSUALUM17 Offline
All American
*

Posts: 4,620
Joined: Sep 2017
Reputation: 212
I Root For: Georgia State University
Location:
Post: #1242
RE: Mid-Major Realignment About to Happen Again?
(10-02-2024 01:38 PM)ChooChoo Wrote:  I’m conflicted on where GSU should be. UAB, Charlotte, USF, Memphis, UTSA, Temple.. they’re all big urban research schools that match our profile. It’s very appealing to be in a like minded “airport” league with some basketball and bowl access success. Throw in the academies, metro Dallas, and the town Atlantans hate the most, New Orleans (Tulane), and there’s some really intriguing schools to match up with.
Having said that, the SBC is clearly on the move up. It’s very regional, where the campuses are a major focal point, and the rivalries are real. We also have our biggest attendance draw within it. Institutionally, we stick out like a sore thumb. So who knows. Do we remain the oddball in a stable conference or a round peg in a conference with more money but 75% of the schools wish they were somewhere else?
Best case scenario would be the majority of the western AAC is poached by the PAC and MWC, and the AAC backfills with a big chunk of the SBC.

I see your point.

There is something to being together with likeminded institutions with similar mission statements. Moreover, Atlanta identifies with other cities. Regionalism isn't that important to us. We already have existing feuds with other large metropolitan areas. Atlantans LOATHE Philly. We HATE New Orleans. Screw overrated NYC teams. Charlotte? It's ATL's little brother wannabe.

That said, SBC is a perfectly good home and SBC is never kicking us out, what would convince a risk-averse GSU administrator to leave? It gave us a launchpad to start D1 football. Travel is great for Olympic sports. Money is decent all things considering. ESPN gives SBC the exposure for its G5 content. Most importantly, SBC has been fair and never gave us a reason to be uncommitted.
10-02-2024 05:41 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
MUther Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 9,911
Joined: Jun 2002
Reputation: 729
I Root For: Marshall
Location:

CrappiesCrappies
Post: #1243
RE: Mid-Major Realignment About to Happen Again?
(09-30-2024 07:46 AM)SkullyMaroo Wrote:  
(09-30-2024 06:57 AM)NewfieHerdFan Wrote:  
(09-29-2024 11:18 PM)JMURocks Wrote:  
(09-29-2024 09:54 PM)chiefsfan Wrote:  
(09-29-2024 09:47 PM)RockyMtnHerd Wrote:  Chief, any intel on who the interested MAC schools might be? If NIU and/or Toledo move, that is.

I am assuming Ohio, reasonably there's a world where Toledo would prefer moving all sports here over the MWC football only, but if they don't move I don't think Ohio moves. Have I actually checked? No, largely because I never considered the MWC would go after NIU or Toledo to begin with.

Would SBC actually consider adding a northern school like Toledo?

If Texas State leaves, I think we reach out to Toledo (good football and basketball) to gauge interest. Or, go to 14, and try to add Toledo, WKU, and a third team. Liberty? I'd really like Ohio University to refocus and put more energy into their major sports. Basketball has been good and their football has potential.

Why are we so fascinated on these MAC teams out of our footprint? A lot of Marshall fans have brought up Ohio/Toledo. If you want to be in a league with them you could move back to the MAC. Otherwise Toledo isn’t close to anyone and we need to forget them. They’re closest to Marshall but that’s still about 280 miles away. And in the strange event we did bring in Toledo, who moves to the West division, Georgia Southern or Georgia State?

Not this Marshall fan. We play them still more than I care for. I get close, cheap games, but it does nothing for the fans. MAC doesn't travel at all. They don't care about their teams when Ohio St or Michigan are playing. A sellout to them is five fans wearing scarlet and gray or blue and maize. They don't think in southern terms. They don't fit here. Beginning to think some of the Herdfans don't fit here, either.

Who the west picks, if it comes to that, is none of our business. We are new here and it affects us not at all. Hard pass on the rust belt, given a say, though.
10-02-2024 05:47 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
memphistiger! Offline
Water Engineer
*

Posts: 41
Joined: Mar 2011
Reputation: 9
I Root For: memphis
Location:
Post: #1244
RE: Mid-Major Realignment About to Happen Again?
(10-02-2024 03:17 PM)AppManDG Wrote:  
(10-02-2024 01:38 PM)ChooChoo Wrote:  I’m conflicted on where GSU should be. UAB, Charlotte, USF, Memphis, UTSA, Temple.. they’re all big urban research schools that match our profile. It’s very appealing to be in a like minded “airport” league with some basketball and bowl access success. Throw in the academies, metro Dallas, and the town Atlantans hate the most, New Orleans (Tulane), and there’s some really intriguing schools to match up with.
Having said that, the SBC is clearly on the move up. It’s very regional, where the campuses are a major focal point, and the rivalries are real. We also have our biggest attendance draw within it. Institutionally, we stick out like a sore thumb. So who knows. Do we remain the oddball in a stable conference or a round peg in a conference with more money but 75% of the schools wish they were somewhere else?
Best case scenario would be the majority of the western AAC is poached by the PAC and MWC, and the AAC backfills with a big chunk of the SBC.

I tend to agree with many of your points. Some might think it's a good thing to mix Urban and rural schools, but at the same time the universities themselves are far different. Larger urban schools tend to look at things a lot differently. It's always seemed to me the Sun Belt in it's original form for basketball was a much better arrangement for those universities. Since they had a football program, the addition of WKU was a bit of an departure from the "base" at the time. It was definitely a made for TV basketball conference. While most of those schools have added football there is still a cultural differences in the make-up of urban & rural schools.

Rural - < 100K non-student population of town
ECU – 88,000
A State – 78,500
Texas State – 72,000
JMU – 52,400
USM – 49,000
ULM – 47,700
Marshall – 46,000
GA Southern – 34,500
Coastal – 25,000
App – 19,700
Troy – 17,500

Urban > 100K non-student population of town
N Texas – metro area 6.8 million
GA State – metro area 6 million
Rice – metro area 6 million
Temple – metro 5.5 million
USTA – 2.5 million
Charlotte – metro area 2 million
ODU – metro area 1.8 million
FAU – metro area 1.5 million
Tulane – 1 million
Memphis – 650,000
Tulsa – 420,000
USF – 400,000
UAB – 200,000
USA – 190,000
Louisiana – 121,500
No offense intended, but fyi, the Memphis metro population is 1.3 million. You are correct that the city proper is approximately 600k. Best of luck to the Belt teams.
10-02-2024 09:08 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
arkstfan Away
Sorry folks
*

Posts: 26,138
Joined: Feb 2004
Reputation: 1040
I Root For: Fresh Starts
Location:
Post: #1245
RE: Mid-Major Realignment About to Happen Again?
(10-02-2024 03:17 PM)AppManDG Wrote:  
(10-02-2024 01:38 PM)ChooChoo Wrote:  I’m conflicted on where GSU should be. UAB, Charlotte, USF, Memphis, UTSA, Temple.. they’re all big urban research schools that match our profile. It’s very appealing to be in a like minded “airport” league with some basketball and bowl access success. Throw in the academies, metro Dallas, and the town Atlantans hate the most, New Orleans (Tulane), and there’s some really intriguing schools to match up with.
Having said that, the SBC is clearly on the move up. It’s very regional, where the campuses are a major focal point, and the rivalries are real. We also have our biggest attendance draw within it. Institutionally, we stick out like a sore thumb. So who knows. Do we remain the oddball in a stable conference or a round peg in a conference with more money but 75% of the schools wish they were somewhere else?
Best case scenario would be the majority of the western AAC is poached by the PAC and MWC, and the AAC backfills with a big chunk of the SBC.

I tend to agree with many of your points. Some might think it's a good thing to mix Urban and rural schools, but at the same time the universities themselves are far different. Larger urban schools tend to look at things a lot differently. It's always seemed to me the Sun Belt in it's original form for basketball was a much better arrangement for those universities. Since they had a football program, the addition of WKU was a bit of an departure from the "base" at the time. It was definitely a made for TV basketball conference. While most of those schools have added football there is still a cultural differences in the make-up of urban & rural schools.

Rural - < 100K non-student population of town
ECU – 88,000
A State – 78,500
Texas State – 72,000
JMU – 52,400
USM – 49,000
ULM – 47,700
Marshall – 46,000
GA Southern – 34,500
Coastal – 25,000
App – 19,700
Troy – 17,500

Urban > 100K non-student population of town
N Texas – metro area 6.8 million
GA State – metro area 6 million
Rice – metro area 6 million
Temple – metro 5.5 million
USTA – 2.5 million
Charlotte – metro area 2 million
ODU – metro area 1.8 million
FAU – metro area 1.5 million
Tulane – 1 million
Memphis – 650,000
Tulsa – 420,000
USF – 400,000
UAB – 200,000
USA – 190,000
Louisiana – 121,500

That’s point I hit often.

Boiled down, a conference is a business partnership or trade association and it matters if you and your partners have shared values and perspectives.

I always think about the story of Mizzou’s leadership visiting with SEC officials before the move and asking about departure fees and notice. Response was we don’t have departure fees or notice requirements. Why would we try to keep someone who wants to leave?

Obviously these days you have to add financial protections but I don’t really want to waste time on someone who is constantly focusing on how to get out. Just get better and if you do that and opportunity arises figure out what is best but don’t waste your life wishing for what you can’t control and getting an invite elsewhere isn’t in your control.

Just makes sense to work with compatible partners because it may be a many decades partnership
10-02-2024 09:29 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bit_9 Offline
Moderator
*

Posts: 11,220
Joined: May 2012
Reputation: 318
I Root For: ODU
Location:
Post: #1246
RE: Mid-Major Realignment About to Happen Again?
(10-02-2024 09:29 PM)arkstfan Wrote:  That’s point I hit often.

Boiled down, a conference is a business partnership or trade association and it matters if you and your partners have shared values and perspectives.

I always think about the story of Mizzou’s leadership visiting with SEC officials before the move and asking about departure fees and notice. Response was we don’t have departure fees or notice requirements. Why would we try to keep someone who wants to leave?

Obviously these days you have to add financial protections but I don’t really want to waste time on someone who is constantly focusing on how to get out. Just get better and if you do that and opportunity arises figure out what is best but don’t waste your life wishing for what you can’t control and getting an invite elsewhere isn’t in your control.

Just makes sense to work with compatible partners because it may be a many decades partnership

That's my take as well. After the first few seasons in CUSA it was clear as day we weren't a cultural fit with that group. At least not as a fan base, go read the 1000 posts. =]

But, if you want out and it's not a good fit, no hard feelings and best of luck! Just like in the private sector or business world. If I have an employee that's not fitting in, I'll help them find a new landing pad somewhere else as it's win-win for the culture of my team and that person's sanity as well.
10-03-2024 06:35 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
AppManDG Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 6,357
Joined: Aug 2010
Reputation: 321
I Root For: App State
Location: Gastonia, NC
Post: #1247
RE: Mid-Major Realignment About to Happen Again?
(10-02-2024 09:29 PM)arkstfan Wrote:  
(10-02-2024 03:17 PM)AppManDG Wrote:  
(10-02-2024 01:38 PM)ChooChoo Wrote:  I’m conflicted on where GSU should be. UAB, Charlotte, USF, Memphis, UTSA, Temple.. they’re all big urban research schools that match our profile. It’s very appealing to be in a like minded “airport” league with some basketball and bowl access success. Throw in the academies, metro Dallas, and the town Atlantans hate the most, New Orleans (Tulane), and there’s some really intriguing schools to match up with.
Having said that, the SBC is clearly on the move up. It’s very regional, where the campuses are a major focal point, and the rivalries are real. We also have our biggest attendance draw within it. Institutionally, we stick out like a sore thumb. So who knows. Do we remain the oddball in a stable conference or a round peg in a conference with more money but 75% of the schools wish they were somewhere else?
Best case scenario would be the majority of the western AAC is poached by the PAC and MWC, and the AAC backfills with a big chunk of the SBC.

I tend to agree with many of your points. Some might think it's a good thing to mix Urban and rural schools, but at the same time the universities themselves are far different. Larger urban schools tend to look at things a lot differently. It's always seemed to me the Sun Belt in it's original form for basketball was a much better arrangement for those universities. Since they had a football program, the addition of WKU was a bit of an departure from the "base" at the time. It was definitely a made for TV basketball conference. While most of those schools have added football there is still a cultural differences in the make-up of urban & rural schools.

Rural - < 100K non-student population of town
ECU – 88,000
A State – 78,500
Texas State – 72,000
JMU – 52,400
USM – 49,000
ULM – 47,700
Marshall – 46,000
GA Southern – 34,500
Coastal – 25,000
App – 19,700
Troy – 17,500

Urban > 100K non-student population of town
N Texas – metro area 6.8 million
GA State – metro area 6 million
Rice – metro area 6 million
Temple – metro 5.5 million
USTA – 2.5 million
Charlotte – metro area 2 million
ODU – metro area 1.8 million
FAU – metro area 1.5 million
Tulane – 1 million
Memphis – 650,000
Tulsa – 420,000
USF – 400,000
UAB – 200,000
USA – 190,000
Louisiana – 121,500

That’s point I hit often.

Boiled down, a conference is a business partnership or trade association and it matters if you and your partners have shared values and perspectives.

I always think about the story of Mizzou’s leadership visiting with SEC officials before the move and asking about departure fees and notice. Response was we don’t have departure fees or notice requirements. Why would we try to keep someone who wants to leave?

Obviously these days you have to add financial protections but I don’t really want to waste time on someone who is constantly focusing on how to get out. Just get better and if you do that and opportunity arises figure out what is best but don’t waste your life wishing for what you can’t control and getting an invite elsewhere isn’t in your control.

Just makes sense to work with compatible partners because it may be a many decades partnership

Agree 100%. Not a knock on anyone in the league at all. It is just the way it is.
10-03-2024 06:42 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
AppManDG Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 6,357
Joined: Aug 2010
Reputation: 321
I Root For: App State
Location: Gastonia, NC
Post: #1248
RE: Mid-Major Realignment About to Happen Again?
(10-02-2024 09:08 PM)memphistiger! Wrote:  
(10-02-2024 03:17 PM)AppManDG Wrote:  
(10-02-2024 01:38 PM)ChooChoo Wrote:  I’m conflicted on where GSU should be. UAB, Charlotte, USF, Memphis, UTSA, Temple.. they’re all big urban research schools that match our profile. It’s very appealing to be in a like minded “airport” league with some basketball and bowl access success. Throw in the academies, metro Dallas, and the town Atlantans hate the most, New Orleans (Tulane), and there’s some really intriguing schools to match up with.
Having said that, the SBC is clearly on the move up. It’s very regional, where the campuses are a major focal point, and the rivalries are real. We also have our biggest attendance draw within it. Institutionally, we stick out like a sore thumb. So who knows. Do we remain the oddball in a stable conference or a round peg in a conference with more money but 75% of the schools wish they were somewhere else?
Best case scenario would be the majority of the western AAC is poached by the PAC and MWC, and the AAC backfills with a big chunk of the SBC.

I tend to agree with many of your points. Some might think it's a good thing to mix Urban and rural schools, but at the same time the universities themselves are far different. Larger urban schools tend to look at things a lot differently. It's always seemed to me the Sun Belt in it's original form for basketball was a much better arrangement for those universities. Since they had a football program, the addition of WKU was a bit of an departure from the "base" at the time. It was definitely a made for TV basketball conference. While most of those schools have added football there is still a cultural differences in the make-up of urban & rural schools.

Rural - < 100K non-student population of town
ECU – 88,000
A State – 78,500
Texas State – 72,000
JMU – 52,400
USM – 49,000
ULM – 47,700
Marshall – 46,000
GA Southern – 34,500
Coastal – 25,000
App – 19,700
Troy – 17,500

Urban > 100K non-student population of town
N Texas – metro area 6.8 million
GA State – metro area 6 million
Rice – metro area 6 million
Temple – metro 5.5 million
USTA – 2.5 million
Charlotte – metro area 2 million
ODU – metro area 1.8 million
FAU – metro area 1.5 million
Tulane – 1 million
Memphis – 650,000
Tulsa – 420,000
USF – 400,000
UAB – 200,000
USA – 190,000
Louisiana – 121,500
No offense intended, but fyi, the Memphis metro population is 1.3 million. You are correct that the city proper is approximately 600k. Best of luck to the Belt teams.

None taken. The sites I used sometimes gave metro populations and some actual city limit numbers. Either way, the point is the same.
10-03-2024 06:45 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
AppManDG Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 6,357
Joined: Aug 2010
Reputation: 321
I Root For: App State
Location: Gastonia, NC
Post: #1249
RE: Mid-Major Realignment About to Happen Again?
(10-03-2024 06:35 AM)bit_9 Wrote:  
(10-02-2024 09:29 PM)arkstfan Wrote:  That’s point I hit often.

Boiled down, a conference is a business partnership or trade association and it matters if you and your partners have shared values and perspectives.

I always think about the story of Mizzou’s leadership visiting with SEC officials before the move and asking about departure fees and notice. Response was we don’t have departure fees or notice requirements. Why would we try to keep someone who wants to leave?

Obviously these days you have to add financial protections but I don’t really want to waste time on someone who is constantly focusing on how to get out. Just get better and if you do that and opportunity arises figure out what is best but don’t waste your life wishing for what you can’t control and getting an invite elsewhere isn’t in your control.

Just makes sense to work with compatible partners because it may be a many decades partnership

That's my take as well. After the first few seasons in CUSA it was clear as day we weren't a cultural fit with that group. At least not as a fan base, go read the 1000 posts. =]

But, if you want out and it's not a good fit, no hard feelings and best of luck! Just like in the private sector or business world. If I have an employee that's not fitting in, I'll help them find a new landing pad somewhere else as it's win-win for the culture of my team and that person's sanity as well.

One of the main reasons I was so adamant about Appalachian leaving the SoCon was we needed to be with similar schools. We were a 20K university in conference dominated by small, private institutions we had very little in common with.
10-03-2024 06:58 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
MUther Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 9,911
Joined: Jun 2002
Reputation: 729
I Root For: Marshall
Location:

CrappiesCrappies
Post: #1250
RE: Mid-Major Realignment About to Happen Again?
I would say Louisiana and USA are still very much within the realm of other SBC schools, culturally. I mean the numbers for the definition are basically arbitrary and many of those places on the list were larger within our lifetimes.

I'll take a small town with a greater than 50% market share over a behemoth with less than 1% every damn day, though. That's what SBC teams have in common a lot of the time. The university decisions affect the whole town or city. If GSU flat disappeared one day, Atlanta would barely notice. It would kill Huntington if Marshall disappeared. Same with App, JMU, GS, etc. Universities in small towns tend to be one of the larger employers in the area and a lot of activity revolves around them.
10-03-2024 06:59 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
chiefsfan Offline
No Seriously, they let me be a mod
*

Posts: 46,947
Joined: Sep 2007
Reputation: 1324
I Root For: ASU
Location:
Post: #1251
RE: Mid-Major Realignment About to Happen Again?
(10-03-2024 06:45 AM)AppManDG Wrote:  
(10-02-2024 09:08 PM)memphistiger! Wrote:  
(10-02-2024 03:17 PM)AppManDG Wrote:  
(10-02-2024 01:38 PM)ChooChoo Wrote:  I’m conflicted on where GSU should be. UAB, Charlotte, USF, Memphis, UTSA, Temple.. they’re all big urban research schools that match our profile. It’s very appealing to be in a like minded “airport” league with some basketball and bowl access success. Throw in the academies, metro Dallas, and the town Atlantans hate the most, New Orleans (Tulane), and there’s some really intriguing schools to match up with.
Having said that, the SBC is clearly on the move up. It’s very regional, where the campuses are a major focal point, and the rivalries are real. We also have our biggest attendance draw within it. Institutionally, we stick out like a sore thumb. So who knows. Do we remain the oddball in a stable conference or a round peg in a conference with more money but 75% of the schools wish they were somewhere else?
Best case scenario would be the majority of the western AAC is poached by the PAC and MWC, and the AAC backfills with a big chunk of the SBC.

I tend to agree with many of your points. Some might think it's a good thing to mix Urban and rural schools, but at the same time the universities themselves are far different. Larger urban schools tend to look at things a lot differently. It's always seemed to me the Sun Belt in it's original form for basketball was a much better arrangement for those universities. Since they had a football program, the addition of WKU was a bit of an departure from the "base" at the time. It was definitely a made for TV basketball conference. While most of those schools have added football there is still a cultural differences in the make-up of urban & rural schools.

Rural - < 100K non-student population of town
ECU – 88,000
A State – 78,500
Texas State – 72,000
JMU – 52,400
USM – 49,000
ULM – 47,700
Marshall – 46,000
GA Southern – 34,500
Coastal – 25,000
App – 19,700
Troy – 17,500

Urban > 100K non-student population of town
N Texas – metro area 6.8 million
GA State – metro area 6 million
Rice – metro area 6 million
Temple – metro 5.5 million
USTA – 2.5 million
Charlotte – metro area 2 million
ODU – metro area 1.8 million
FAU – metro area 1.5 million
Tulane – 1 million
Memphis – 650,000
Tulsa – 420,000
USF – 400,000
UAB – 200,000
USA – 190,000
Louisiana – 121,500
No offense intended, but fyi, the Memphis metro population is 1.3 million. You are correct that the city proper is approximately 600k. Best of luck to the Belt teams.

None taken. The sites I used sometimes gave metro populations and some actual city limit numbers. Either way, the point is the same.

Memphis metro area is huge, its just unlike other metro areas, many of the surrounding communities in the Memphis area are their own cities. The reasons are varied, At least one area I'm aware of did it to separate themselves from a struggling school system, some did it to keep city services separate and have their own police force.
10-03-2024 07:55 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
ballantyneapp Offline
Banned

Posts: 5,645
Joined: Mar 2018
I Root For: App
Location:
Post: #1252
RE: Mid-Major Realignment About to Happen Again?
(10-02-2024 12:24 PM)chiefsfan Wrote:  Update 4,521,317.42: (I stopped counting)

As has been reported, few in the Sun Belt seriously believed that Texas State would take an MWC offer, and were convinced the Bobcats were holding out for an AAC or PAC 12 offer and were trying to pretend they were leaving to force those leagues to jump.

And then those leagues did nothing. Leading Texas State to release a statement using the singular form of the word "Conference" and leaving the phrase "At this time" left over everyone's heads. As Shane Mettlen said in his column earlier, was Texas State actually talking to other leagues or were they hoping a very obviously planted rumor about their MWC interest would maybe force other schools to show interest? For their part, Texas State notified the Sun Belt they ahd received an MWC invite as is required, but they have said nothing about other negotiations. Its also worth pointing out that the only actual repudiable source reporting about them in Pete Thammel, which leads me to think someone in the Texas State Athletic Department has a contact with him

So where does that leave the Sun Belt? Back to the waiting game. For my part my sources continue to believe the Bobcats are goners, but at the same time others who I know have sources that are probably better then mine are saying they aren't so sure. I think it belies the whole point here. The Sun Belt has no idea what Texas State is up to.

So here's where we are at for the moment: The PAC 12 needs 1 more, the MWC needs one more. The reality is, the PAC 12 probably takes 2 to make conference scheduling simpler. Despite rumors floating around on Memphis affiliated sites, the story at the moment is the PAC 12 has not yet re-engaged with the AAC schools. Ross Dellinger is reporting that the PAC 12 will probably try to shore up its TV numbers problem and then go back to the AAC. If the AAC says no? Then it gets hairy. Texas State in that case probably remains the best option, but given it may not go over entirely well nationally if you were stuck picking up an SBC school that went 6-6 last season, the PAC 12 will probably exercise some patience.

On the Sun Belt side, we wait on the PAC 12. Beneficially, the league still hopes that the PAC 12 can yank Memphis and Tulane away from the AAC, and this isn't just about the ECU desires of SBC East fans, its the simple reality that the SBC might be a better league than an AAC without Tulane and Memphis. Which the league office believes would be enough to go back to ESPN and request more money reflecting that standing, which then gives us the finances to bring in whoever we want and hold onto our own schools amid AAC interest. It also might be enough for the AAC to go after Texas State, which almost has to happen for the SBC to really make the push many want.

Make no mistake, the idea of creating two separate divisions in which every team in each division is within driving distance of one another and considered rivals amongst its fans is a HUGE desire of the conference office. Gill wants to be considiered the Top G5 league in this part of the US. And its perfectly doable if the PAC 12 can ever figure out its own issues.

thanks for the update.

having Navy and Army probably brings enough TV value for the AAC to still make more, but it might bring it to "its more but not enough to make someone jump" status.

Still don't think we could land ECU in this scenario
10-03-2024 08:01 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
chiefsfan Offline
No Seriously, they let me be a mod
*

Posts: 46,947
Joined: Sep 2007
Reputation: 1324
I Root For: ASU
Location:
Post: #1253
RE: Mid-Major Realignment About to Happen Again?
(10-03-2024 08:01 AM)ballantyneapp Wrote:  
(10-02-2024 12:24 PM)chiefsfan Wrote:  Update 4,521,317.42: (I stopped counting)

As has been reported, few in the Sun Belt seriously believed that Texas State would take an MWC offer, and were convinced the Bobcats were holding out for an AAC or PAC 12 offer and were trying to pretend they were leaving to force those leagues to jump.

And then those leagues did nothing. Leading Texas State to release a statement using the singular form of the word "Conference" and leaving the phrase "At this time" left over everyone's heads. As Shane Mettlen said in his column earlier, was Texas State actually talking to other leagues or were they hoping a very obviously planted rumor about their MWC interest would maybe force other schools to show interest? For their part, Texas State notified the Sun Belt they ahd received an MWC invite as is required, but they have said nothing about other negotiations. Its also worth pointing out that the only actual repudiable source reporting about them in Pete Thammel, which leads me to think someone in the Texas State Athletic Department has a contact with him

So where does that leave the Sun Belt? Back to the waiting game. For my part my sources continue to believe the Bobcats are goners, but at the same time others who I know have sources that are probably better then mine are saying they aren't so sure. I think it belies the whole point here. The Sun Belt has no idea what Texas State is up to.

So here's where we are at for the moment: The PAC 12 needs 1 more, the MWC needs one more. The reality is, the PAC 12 probably takes 2 to make conference scheduling simpler. Despite rumors floating around on Memphis affiliated sites, the story at the moment is the PAC 12 has not yet re-engaged with the AAC schools. Ross Dellinger is reporting that the PAC 12 will probably try to shore up its TV numbers problem and then go back to the AAC. If the AAC says no? Then it gets hairy. Texas State in that case probably remains the best option, but given it may not go over entirely well nationally if you were stuck picking up an SBC school that went 6-6 last season, the PAC 12 will probably exercise some patience.

On the Sun Belt side, we wait on the PAC 12. Beneficially, the league still hopes that the PAC 12 can yank Memphis and Tulane away from the AAC, and this isn't just about the ECU desires of SBC East fans, its the simple reality that the SBC might be a better league than an AAC without Tulane and Memphis. Which the league office believes would be enough to go back to ESPN and request more money reflecting that standing, which then gives us the finances to bring in whoever we want and hold onto our own schools amid AAC interest. It also might be enough for the AAC to go after Texas State, which almost has to happen for the SBC to really make the push many want.

Make no mistake, the idea of creating two separate divisions in which every team in each division is within driving distance of one another and considered rivals amongst its fans is a HUGE desire of the conference office. Gill wants to be considiered the Top G5 league in this part of the US. And its perfectly doable if the PAC 12 can ever figure out its own issues.

thanks for the update.

having Navy and Army probably brings enough TV value for the AAC to still make more, but it might bring it to "its more but not enough to make someone jump" status.

Still don't think we could land ECU in this scenario

I don't either. I think the plan with ECU has shifted from invite them to play to try and elevate ourselves ahead of the AAC.

But Memphis and Tulane have to go for that to happen.
10-03-2024 08:25 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
arkstfan Away
Sorry folks
*

Posts: 26,138
Joined: Feb 2004
Reputation: 1040
I Root For: Fresh Starts
Location:
Post: #1254
RE: Mid-Major Realignment About to Happen Again?
(10-03-2024 06:59 AM)MUther Wrote:  I would say Louisiana and USA are still very much within the realm of other SBC schools, culturally. I mean the numbers for the definition are basically arbitrary and many of those places on the list were larger within our lifetimes.

I'll take a small town with a greater than 50% market share over a behemoth with less than 1% every damn day, though. That's what SBC teams have in common a lot of the time. The university decisions affect the whole town or city. If GSU flat disappeared one day, Atlanta would barely notice. It would kill Huntington if Marshall disappeared. Same with App, JMU, GS, etc. Universities in small towns tend to be one of the larger employers in the area and a lot of activity revolves around them.

If you look at metro populations (which can be arbitrary of course) only Georgia State, Texas State and Old Dominion are in communities of more than 500,000 and in the case of Texas State it’s the metro coming to them.

I don’t know ODU’s situation well but for 50 years the area has been on many lists of next place to get a team in the big four pro leagues and never been able to land one and more than one list maker knocks the lack of a cohesive effort by the communities.

I just tend to assume that the area functions as if it is actually a bit smaller than it is.
10-03-2024 08:27 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
arkstfan Away
Sorry folks
*

Posts: 26,138
Joined: Feb 2004
Reputation: 1040
I Root For: Fresh Starts
Location:
Post: #1255
RE: Mid-Major Realignment About to Happen Again?
(10-03-2024 07:55 AM)chiefsfan Wrote:  
(10-03-2024 06:45 AM)AppManDG Wrote:  
(10-02-2024 09:08 PM)memphistiger! Wrote:  
(10-02-2024 03:17 PM)AppManDG Wrote:  
(10-02-2024 01:38 PM)ChooChoo Wrote:  I’m conflicted on where GSU should be. UAB, Charlotte, USF, Memphis, UTSA, Temple.. they’re all big urban research schools that match our profile. It’s very appealing to be in a like minded “airport” league with some basketball and bowl access success. Throw in the academies, metro Dallas, and the town Atlantans hate the most, New Orleans (Tulane), and there’s some really intriguing schools to match up with.
Having said that, the SBC is clearly on the move up. It’s very regional, where the campuses are a major focal point, and the rivalries are real. We also have our biggest attendance draw within it. Institutionally, we stick out like a sore thumb. So who knows. Do we remain the oddball in a stable conference or a round peg in a conference with more money but 75% of the schools wish they were somewhere else?
Best case scenario would be the majority of the western AAC is poached by the PAC and MWC, and the AAC backfills with a big chunk of the SBC.

I tend to agree with many of your points. Some might think it's a good thing to mix Urban and rural schools, but at the same time the universities themselves are far different. Larger urban schools tend to look at things a lot differently. It's always seemed to me the Sun Belt in it's original form for basketball was a much better arrangement for those universities. Since they had a football program, the addition of WKU was a bit of an departure from the "base" at the time. It was definitely a made for TV basketball conference. While most of those schools have added football there is still a cultural differences in the make-up of urban & rural schools.

Rural - < 100K non-student population of town
ECU – 88,000
A State – 78,500
Texas State – 72,000
JMU – 52,400
USM – 49,000
ULM – 47,700
Marshall – 46,000
GA Southern – 34,500
Coastal – 25,000
App – 19,700
Troy – 17,500

Urban > 100K non-student population of town
N Texas – metro area 6.8 million
GA State – metro area 6 million
Rice – metro area 6 million
Temple – metro 5.5 million
USTA – 2.5 million
Charlotte – metro area 2 million
ODU – metro area 1.8 million
FAU – metro area 1.5 million
Tulane – 1 million
Memphis – 650,000
Tulsa – 420,000
USF – 400,000
UAB – 200,000
USA – 190,000
Louisiana – 121,500
No offense intended, but fyi, the Memphis metro population is 1.3 million. You are correct that the city proper is approximately 600k. Best of luck to the Belt teams.

None taken. The sites I used sometimes gave metro populations and some actual city limit numbers. Either way, the point is the same.

Memphis metro area is huge, its just unlike other metro areas, many of the surrounding communities in the Memphis area are their own cities. The reasons are varied, At least one area I'm aware of did it to separate themselves from a struggling school system, some did it to keep city services separate and have their own police force.

And many metro Memphis people live in Arkansas or Mississippi.
10-03-2024 08:32 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Flat Tire 2 Offline
1st String
*

Posts: 1,476
Joined: Apr 2007
Reputation: 40
I Root For:
Location:
Post: #1256
RE: Mid-Major Realignment About to Happen Again?
(10-02-2024 05:47 PM)MUther Wrote:  
(09-30-2024 07:46 AM)SkullyMaroo Wrote:  
(09-30-2024 06:57 AM)NewfieHerdFan Wrote:  
(09-29-2024 11:18 PM)JMURocks Wrote:  
(09-29-2024 09:54 PM)chiefsfan Wrote:  I am assuming Ohio, reasonably there's a world where Toledo would prefer moving all sports here over the MWC football only, but if they don't move I don't think Ohio moves. Have I actually checked? No, largely because I never considered the MWC would go after NIU or Toledo to begin with.

Would SBC actually consider adding a northern school like Toledo?

If Texas State leaves, I think we reach out to Toledo (good football and basketball) to gauge interest. Or, go to 14, and try to add Toledo, WKU, and a third team. Liberty? I'd really like Ohio University to refocus and put more energy into their major sports. Basketball has been good and their football has potential.

Why are we so fascinated on these MAC teams out of our footprint? A lot of Marshall fans have brought up Ohio/Toledo. If you want to be in a league with them you could move back to the MAC. Otherwise Toledo isn’t close to anyone and we need to forget them. They’re closest to Marshall but that’s still about 280 miles away. And in the strange event we did bring in Toledo, who moves to the West division, Georgia Southern or Georgia State?

Not this Marshall fan. We play them still more than I care for. I get close, cheap games, but it does nothing for the fans. MAC doesn't travel at all. They don't care about their teams when Ohio St or Michigan are playing. A sellout to them is five fans wearing scarlet and gray or blue and maize. They don't think in southern terms. They don't fit here. Beginning to think some of the Herdfans don't fit here, either.

Who the west picks, if it comes to that, is none of our business. We are new here and it affects us not at all. Hard pass on the rust belt, given a say, though.

To be honest, Ohio U travels well to Marshall when they they are having a good season. I remember games when Ohio U filled up a complete section at competitive games. The distance between the schools of 81 miles and they have the longest history with Marshall of any team. We should be playing them more often.
10-03-2024 08:40 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
rokamortis Offline
All American
*

Posts: 3,388
Joined: May 2013
Reputation: 179
I Root For: Coastal
Location:
Post: #1257
RE: Mid-Major Realignment About to Happen Again?
(10-03-2024 08:25 AM)chiefsfan Wrote:  
(10-03-2024 08:01 AM)ballantyneapp Wrote:  
(10-02-2024 12:24 PM)chiefsfan Wrote:  Update 4,521,317.42: (I stopped counting)

As has been reported, few in the Sun Belt seriously believed that Texas State would take an MWC offer, and were convinced the Bobcats were holding out for an AAC or PAC 12 offer and were trying to pretend they were leaving to force those leagues to jump.

And then those leagues did nothing. Leading Texas State to release a statement using the singular form of the word "Conference" and leaving the phrase "At this time" left over everyone's heads. As Shane Mettlen said in his column earlier, was Texas State actually talking to other leagues or were they hoping a very obviously planted rumor about their MWC interest would maybe force other schools to show interest? For their part, Texas State notified the Sun Belt they ahd received an MWC invite as is required, but they have said nothing about other negotiations. Its also worth pointing out that the only actual repudiable source reporting about them in Pete Thammel, which leads me to think someone in the Texas State Athletic Department has a contact with him

So where does that leave the Sun Belt? Back to the waiting game. For my part my sources continue to believe the Bobcats are goners, but at the same time others who I know have sources that are probably better then mine are saying they aren't so sure. I think it belies the whole point here. The Sun Belt has no idea what Texas State is up to.

So here's where we are at for the moment: The PAC 12 needs 1 more, the MWC needs one more. The reality is, the PAC 12 probably takes 2 to make conference scheduling simpler. Despite rumors floating around on Memphis affiliated sites, the story at the moment is the PAC 12 has not yet re-engaged with the AAC schools. Ross Dellinger is reporting that the PAC 12 will probably try to shore up its TV numbers problem and then go back to the AAC. If the AAC says no? Then it gets hairy. Texas State in that case probably remains the best option, but given it may not go over entirely well nationally if you were stuck picking up an SBC school that went 6-6 last season, the PAC 12 will probably exercise some patience.

On the Sun Belt side, we wait on the PAC 12. Beneficially, the league still hopes that the PAC 12 can yank Memphis and Tulane away from the AAC, and this isn't just about the ECU desires of SBC East fans, its the simple reality that the SBC might be a better league than an AAC without Tulane and Memphis. Which the league office believes would be enough to go back to ESPN and request more money reflecting that standing, which then gives us the finances to bring in whoever we want and hold onto our own schools amid AAC interest. It also might be enough for the AAC to go after Texas State, which almost has to happen for the SBC to really make the push many want.

Make no mistake, the idea of creating two separate divisions in which every team in each division is within driving distance of one another and considered rivals amongst its fans is a HUGE desire of the conference office. Gill wants to be considiered the Top G5 league in this part of the US. And its perfectly doable if the PAC 12 can ever figure out its own issues.

thanks for the update.

having Navy and Army probably brings enough TV value for the AAC to still make more, but it might bring it to "its more but not enough to make someone jump" status.

Still don't think we could land ECU in this scenario

I don't either. I think the plan with ECU has shifted from invite them to play to try and elevate ourselves ahead of the AAC.

But Memphis and Tulane have to go for that to happen.

Yeah, makes sense about ECU. Just realize the situation is such that it doesn’t make economic sense and move on. Just get better, who knows what happens if/when the ACC blows up.
10-03-2024 08:42 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
mturn017 Offline
ODU Homer
*

Posts: 18,901
Joined: May 2012
Reputation: 1828
I Root For: Old Dominion
Location: Roanoke, VA
Post: #1258
RE: Mid-Major Realignment About to Happen Again?
(10-03-2024 08:27 AM)arkstfan Wrote:  
(10-03-2024 06:59 AM)MUther Wrote:  I would say Louisiana and USA are still very much within the realm of other SBC schools, culturally. I mean the numbers for the definition are basically arbitrary and many of those places on the list were larger within our lifetimes.

I'll take a small town with a greater than 50% market share over a behemoth with less than 1% every damn day, though. That's what SBC teams have in common a lot of the time. The university decisions affect the whole town or city. If GSU flat disappeared one day, Atlanta would barely notice. It would kill Huntington if Marshall disappeared. Same with App, JMU, GS, etc. Universities in small towns tend to be one of the larger employers in the area and a lot of activity revolves around them.

If you look at metro populations (which can be arbitrary of course) only Georgia State, Texas State and Old Dominion are in communities of more than 500,000 and in the case of Texas State it’s the metro coming to them.

I don’t know ODU’s situation well but for 50 years the area has been on many lists of next place to get a team in the big four pro leagues and never been able to land one and more than one list maker knocks the lack of a cohesive effort by the communities.

I just tend to assume that the area functions as if it is actually a bit smaller than it is.

I've been out of the area for many years now but yeah, the area is made up of 7 separate cities pushed next to each other (Hampton Roads, also known as the 7 Cities) . If it were one large county with Norfolk as its seat then there'd obviously be a lot more cohesion.
10-03-2024 09:01 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
NewfieHerdFan Offline
Bench Warmer
*

Posts: 207
Joined: Nov 2003
Reputation: 23
I Root For: Marshall
Location:
Post: #1259
RE: Mid-Major Realignment About to Happen Again?
(10-02-2024 05:47 PM)MUther Wrote:  
(09-30-2024 07:46 AM)SkullyMaroo Wrote:  
(09-30-2024 06:57 AM)NewfieHerdFan Wrote:  
(09-29-2024 11:18 PM)JMURocks Wrote:  
(09-29-2024 09:54 PM)chiefsfan Wrote:  I am assuming Ohio, reasonably there's a world where Toledo would prefer moving all sports here over the MWC football only, but if they don't move I don't think Ohio moves. Have I actually checked? No, largely because I never considered the MWC would go after NIU or Toledo to begin with.

Would SBC actually consider adding a northern school like Toledo?

If Texas State leaves, I think we reach out to Toledo (good football and basketball) to gauge interest. Or, go to 14, and try to add Toledo, WKU, and a third team. Liberty? I'd really like Ohio University to refocus and put more energy into their major sports. Basketball has been good and their football has potential.

Why are we so fascinated on these MAC teams out of our footprint? A lot of Marshall fans have brought up Ohio/Toledo. If you want to be in a league with them you could move back to the MAC. Otherwise Toledo isn’t close to anyone and we need to forget them. They’re closest to Marshall but that’s still about 280 miles away. And in the strange event we did bring in Toledo, who moves to the West division, Georgia Southern or Georgia State?

Not this Marshall fan. We play them still more than I care for. I get close, cheap games, but it does nothing for the fans. MAC doesn't travel at all. They don't care about their teams when Ohio St or Michigan are playing. A sellout to them is five fans wearing scarlet and gray or blue and maize. They don't think in southern terms. They don't fit here. Beginning to think some of the Herdfans don't fit here, either.

Who the west picks, if it comes to that, is none of our business. We are new here and it affects us not at all. Hard pass on the rust belt, given a say, though.

Another Herd fan doesn't agree with what I think, so they don't belong here. Umm...OK. 03-lmfao
10-03-2024 09:32 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
ballantyneapp Offline
Banned

Posts: 5,645
Joined: Mar 2018
I Root For: App
Location:
Post: #1260
RE: Mid-Major Realignment About to Happen Again?
(10-03-2024 08:25 AM)chiefsfan Wrote:  
(10-03-2024 08:01 AM)ballantyneapp Wrote:  
(10-02-2024 12:24 PM)chiefsfan Wrote:  Update 4,521,317.42: (I stopped counting)

As has been reported, few in the Sun Belt seriously believed that Texas State would take an MWC offer, and were convinced the Bobcats were holding out for an AAC or PAC 12 offer and were trying to pretend they were leaving to force those leagues to jump.

And then those leagues did nothing. Leading Texas State to release a statement using the singular form of the word "Conference" and leaving the phrase "At this time" left over everyone's heads. As Shane Mettlen said in his column earlier, was Texas State actually talking to other leagues or were they hoping a very obviously planted rumor about their MWC interest would maybe force other schools to show interest? For their part, Texas State notified the Sun Belt they ahd received an MWC invite as is required, but they have said nothing about other negotiations. Its also worth pointing out that the only actual repudiable source reporting about them in Pete Thammel, which leads me to think someone in the Texas State Athletic Department has a contact with him

So where does that leave the Sun Belt? Back to the waiting game. For my part my sources continue to believe the Bobcats are goners, but at the same time others who I know have sources that are probably better then mine are saying they aren't so sure. I think it belies the whole point here. The Sun Belt has no idea what Texas State is up to.

So here's where we are at for the moment: The PAC 12 needs 1 more, the MWC needs one more. The reality is, the PAC 12 probably takes 2 to make conference scheduling simpler. Despite rumors floating around on Memphis affiliated sites, the story at the moment is the PAC 12 has not yet re-engaged with the AAC schools. Ross Dellinger is reporting that the PAC 12 will probably try to shore up its TV numbers problem and then go back to the AAC. If the AAC says no? Then it gets hairy. Texas State in that case probably remains the best option, but given it may not go over entirely well nationally if you were stuck picking up an SBC school that went 6-6 last season, the PAC 12 will probably exercise some patience.

On the Sun Belt side, we wait on the PAC 12. Beneficially, the league still hopes that the PAC 12 can yank Memphis and Tulane away from the AAC, and this isn't just about the ECU desires of SBC East fans, its the simple reality that the SBC might be a better league than an AAC without Tulane and Memphis. Which the league office believes would be enough to go back to ESPN and request more money reflecting that standing, which then gives us the finances to bring in whoever we want and hold onto our own schools amid AAC interest. It also might be enough for the AAC to go after Texas State, which almost has to happen for the SBC to really make the push many want.

Make no mistake, the idea of creating two separate divisions in which every team in each division is within driving distance of one another and considered rivals amongst its fans is a HUGE desire of the conference office. Gill wants to be considiered the Top G5 league in this part of the US. And its perfectly doable if the PAC 12 can ever figure out its own issues.

thanks for the update.

having Navy and Army probably brings enough TV value for the AAC to still make more, but it might bring it to "its more but not enough to make someone jump" status.

Still don't think we could land ECU in this scenario

I don't either. I think the plan with ECU has shifted from invite them to play to try and elevate ourselves ahead of the AAC.

But Memphis and Tulane have to go for that to happen.

definitely the correct approach. We may or may not ever get ECU to join, but we can with or without ECU pass the AAC (with help).
10-03-2024 09:33 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Post Reply 




User(s) browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)


Copyright © 2002-2026 Collegiate Sports Nation Bulletin Board System (CSNbbs), All Rights Reserved.
CSNbbs is an independent fan site and is in no way affiliated to the NCAA or any of the schools and conferences it represents.
This site monetizes links. FTC Disclosure.
We allow third-party companies to serve ads and/or collect certain anonymous information when you visit our web site. These companies may use non-personally identifiable information (e.g., click stream information, browser type, time and date, subject of advertisements clicked or scrolled over) during your visits to this and other Web sites in order to provide advertisements about goods and services likely to be of greater interest to you. These companies typically use a cookie or third party web beacon to collect this information. To learn more about this behavioral advertising practice or to opt-out of this type of advertising, you can visit http://www.networkadvertising.org.
Powered By MyBB, © 2002-2026 MyBB Group.