(10-19-2022 05:33 PM)Sitting bull Wrote: (10-19-2022 04:01 PM)The Cutter of Bish Wrote: I guess my question would be to those who speak toward Stony Brook’s grim prospects of advancement up to the FBS level/MAC: what was the Seawolves 2020 campaign doing, or had in mind?
The plans for the stadium they wanted, and the big language they used to describe their future…you just don’t build or say that unless you have someplace lined up.
That’s always been my take on Stony since the campaign. There had to be something there, right?
W&M played at Stony Brook two weeks ago. There were 3,500 people there. W&M hasn’t had a crowd that small in 50 years.
Points like this remind me now of whatever "thrust" there was for Villanova to move football to the Big East. The year they won the title (2009), the three teams they hosted (Holy Cross, UNH, and William & Mary) all had familiarity with VU in the sport to some degree (two obviously being conference rivals). No game drew 4,500. The William & Mary semifinal was shy of 4,200 (UNH was a bit over 2,500). Plans on a possible upgrade considered Citizens Bank Park, to account for the invisible 40,000 more fans the program had in spirit, but not butts parked on bleachers in the Main Line school's stadium.
We know Villanova, deep down, didn't want that move (one "kill shot" was their then-AD launching a $80 million campaign for improvements to the basketball arena while there was still a pulse, but no brain activity, for the football move). Stony Brook did/does, even going so far as trying to reallocate funds not raised in the campaign to use toward the stadium expansion, like what Colorado State did. That campaign was a timely call for a show of resources, but proved its cupboards were bare. And seemingly still are. But, as these big projects come from some motivator, I'm curious to whom was the "subject of their gaze?"
(10-19-2022 04:48 PM)GreatDane96 Wrote: They've had similar campaigns since 1999. You misread what we have wrote. Their chances aren't grim due to want they want; they are grim because they don't fit the MAC geographic profile. A new eastern based football league...that's a very different story.
Yours is not the only voice on this. It's a composite of many opinions expressed across numerous resources, media, and forums. The greater impression you mischaracterize isn't rooted in geographic fit. It's rooted in a misalignment between a greater ambitious mission but lacking resources and support (similar to Sitting bull's point about interest in a conference game). Stony Brook's campaign still came at a time when such projects were prompted by conversations of interest with conference administrators or other school leadership. I don't think it was "building for the sake of keeping up," but, there's nothing out there to support that opinion.
I lived in NYC, and know Stony Brook's location s-u-c-k-s. It would be an issue for any conference they would join at the FBS level (it's an issue now). The MAC might only be the best academic/institutional fit, but, as others have reminded us about its football past, it's also a conference that has stretched to UMass, UConn, Temple, and UCF. It's not like SBU to the MAC is the same as Gonzaga to the Big East, but it's still a pain.
It's moot now, though. The stadium project didn't go through. If there ever was interest in SBU from the MAC or anyone, that story isn't continuing anytime soon.