Hello There, Guest! Registered users see far less ads! Register today and join our virtual tailgate. (Login — Register)

Post Reply 
So, What Exactly Would It Take To Make The ACC Competitive In Revenue?
Author Message
Thiefery Offline
Special Teams
*

Posts: 744
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation: 33
I Root For: TEXAS
Location:
Post: #61
RE: So, What Exactly Would It Take To Make The ACC Competitive In Revenue?
(05-20-2021 11:45 AM)XLance Wrote:  
(05-20-2021 08:17 AM)Fighting Muskie Wrote:  This thread is focused on redistribution of programs to put the ACC in a competitive position but I think you could also tackle this from the other direction to create a competitive Big 12:

To Big Ten: Pittsburgh, Notre Dame
To SEC: UNC, Duke
To Big 12: Louisville, VT, UVA, NC St, Clemson, GT, Florida St, Miami

To Big East: Syracuse, BC, WF

12 out of the 15 schools should be enough to vote to disband the ACC and nullify the GOR and 10 of those 12 would conceivably be moving to ESPN properties.

WVU joins the ACC schools to form the Big 18 East.


It's a foregone conclusion: The Big 12 will cease to exist....soon.

ahhh is this 2011 again??
05-20-2021 02:28 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Fighting Muskie Offline
Senior Chief Realignmentologist
*

Posts: 15,074
Joined: Sep 2016
Reputation: 1214
I Root For: Bishop Sycamore
Location: Secret Lair
Post: #62
RE: So, What Exactly Would It Take To Make The ACC Competitive In Revenue?
(05-20-2021 12:06 PM)LeeNobody Wrote:  First time posting here. What would a per school revenue for the ACC if it where to split between the football first schools and the basketball first schools.The ACC is divided between two wings, the “football first wing” of Clemson, Florida State, Georgia Tech, Virginia Tech, Miami, Louisville, and Pitt and the “basketball first wing” of North Carolina schools, Virginia, Syracuse, and Boston College. The “football first wing” motivated in part by the desire to be competitive in with their in-state SEC rivalries come to conclusion that their fates are better tied together as a group than with the “basketball first wing”.

Believing the media rights of “football first wing” will yield a better per school revenue payout than the ACC, a more amicable divorce is arranged than the Big East AAC Split. The ACC branding and conference infrastructure will stay with the [basketball-first teams], while the Orange Bowl Tie in, and Conference Championship game contracts will leave with the “football first wing”. The “football first wing” will then take on a new conference name and branding - for discussion purposes, titled the “Metro Conference”

The Metro Conference would likely invite WVU or Cincinnati to bring the Conference to 8 teams. Both would be willing to accept as the new conference would be appealing to fanbases, and potentially upgrade revenue:

The Result:
ACC: UNC, Duke, Wake Forest, NC State, Syracuse, Boston College, Virginia

Metro: Georgia Tech, Clemson, Florida State, Louisville, Virginia Tech, Miami, WVU/Cincinnati, and Pitt

With the pie being split less ways so per team revenue would be higher for the new TV deal. Potentially Warner Media/Discovery might be the target to pick up metro rights since amazon and netflix haven't been interested. Potentially BC and NCState may tag along to create an even more valuable Metro. Less overlap in markets.

Thoughts?

I like the concept. I think your Metro conference might be better off if they merged into the Big 12 (either the whole Big 12 or with a faction that included Texas and Oklahoma).


I think it’s time for basketball schools to stop pretending that they are football schools as well when it’s abundantly clear they aren’t investing in football.
05-20-2021 02:33 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
schmolik Offline
CSNBB's Big 10 Cheerleader
*

Posts: 12,622
Joined: Sep 2019
Reputation: 1098
I Root For: UIUC, PSU, Nova
Location: Philadelphia Suburbs
Post: #63
RE: So, What Exactly Would It Take To Make The ACC Competitive In Revenue?
(05-20-2021 02:33 PM)Fighting Muskie Wrote:  I think it’s time for basketball schools to stop pretending that they are football schools as well when it’s abundantly clear they aren’t investing in football.

I don't think Duke, North Carolina, and Virginia are pretending they are football schools, they know what butters their bread. I think Wahoowa84, XLance, esavem, and the other ACC football fans want them to be football schools and are frustrated they aren't. The ACC isn't a football conference, never was, never will be. It shouldn't sacrifice men's basketball excellence to chase being the 3rd best football conference. They keep doing that and we'll see more 2021's when the entire Final Four is west of the Mississippi and schools like Baylor win national championships.
05-20-2021 03:09 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
JRsec Offline
Super Moderator
*

Posts: 44,977
Joined: Mar 2012
Reputation: 13520
I Root For: SEC
Location:
Post: #64
RE: So, What Exactly Would It Take To Make The ACC Competitive In Revenue?
(05-20-2021 03:09 PM)schmolik Wrote:  
(05-20-2021 02:33 PM)Fighting Muskie Wrote:  I think it’s time for basketball schools to stop pretending that they are football schools as well when it’s abundantly clear they aren’t investing in football.

I don't think Duke, North Carolina, and Virginia are pretending they are football schools, they know what butters their bread. I think Wahoowa84, XLance, esavem, and the other ACC football fans want them to be football schools and are frustrated they aren't. The ACC isn't a football conference, never was, never will be. It shouldn't sacrifice men's basketball excellence to chase being the 3rd best football conference. They keep doing that and we'll see more 2021's when the entire Final Four is west of the Mississippi and schools like Baylor win national championships.

As usual you miss the main point. The ACC as a revenue generator may be 4th but they are certainly not 3rd. The fact that they don't have competitive football revenue is precisely why Texas Tech, Baylor, Auburn, Alabama and others have been forging ahead in hoops. They have fat revenue to invest in hoops.

It's also why a move to the SEC by North Carolina, Duke and Virginia would bathe them in the money they need to remain top tier in all regards in basketball since nobody in the SEC would expect them to do anything other than try on the gridiron and would be happy to have them continue their hoops success. Football money is beginning to dominate many other sports because when your University earns 150 million or more a year it sets all of your athletic programs flush enough to compete for coaches and athletes.

And if you will notice it's not just Duke and North Carolina that have slipped, but Kansas and Kentucky as well, and until this past year UCLA, and certainly Indiana. Football revenue floats basketball opportunities. It's not the other way around. How's being in a non football centered league helped Connecticut and Villanova? Big East basketball has been okay but nowhere near their former glory since the breakup of the OBE and the loss of football recognition helped gain exposure for their hoops as well. Now sure there are other reasons but money is the key. And football does generate about 80% of athletic revenue and that's in gate, donations, and media revenue.

If you want to keep your basketball on top you will need a big supply of football revenue with which to do it. And if UNC, Duke, Kentucky, and Kansas have all suffered in football conferences by not generating enough football revenue for themselves outside of media revenue, imagine what it would be like in a basketball only conference. At least UNC and Duke get a decent bang for the buck. Now more than double their revenue and not only can they invest a bit more in football, but they have tremendous war chests to keep their hoops funded. Kentucky's problem is one and dones coupled with a football program which isn't allocated enough to keep pace. They are so used to spending SEC pay that they haven't been frugal in its use. Duke and North Carolina don't have that problem because they've had to exist and compete frugally for 20 years now.
(This post was last modified: 05-20-2021 03:37 PM by JRsec.)
05-20-2021 03:31 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Wahoowa84 Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,435
Joined: Oct 2017
Reputation: 1176
I Root For: UVa
Location:
Post: #65
RE: So, What Exactly Would It Take To Make The ACC Competitive In Revenue?
(05-20-2021 11:10 AM)JRsec Wrote:  
(05-20-2021 10:25 AM)Wahoowa84 Wrote:  
(05-19-2021 08:58 PM)Statefan Wrote:  I disagree with your definition of value being the present value of expected future profits.

I would go as far to assert that college sports has many attributes of regulated monopoly suffering from free riders and an inability to squeeze out "profit" from what is on its face a non-profit activity.

Absolute or intrinsic values in these cases will be different than relative value but most firms are traded and are weighted relatively and easily comparable likes.

You are conflating two different words: valuations and value.

The WSJ publishes (the analysis is performed by IU academics) financial valuations of collegiate athletic departments. Valuation estimates are based on the present value of expected future earnings (generally "profits" or discretionary/free cash flow). Given uncertainty in future events, whether or not these valuation estimates are reasonable is always in dispute and fluctuating. My statements dealt with financial valuations.

The word "value" has a very different meaning. Financial value could include revenue, expenses, profits, assets, liabilities, etc. "Value" can also be measured in countless other variables: football (attendance or competitive success), fit (geographic distance or rivalries), profile (academic rankings or school size) and other sports (basketball or non-revenue). A school like Duke may provide negligible football value...while still providing conference value in terms of fit, profile and excellence in other sports.

Valuation is a defined financial term; while value is a more subjective and holistic concept.

All words have various usages and those who parse them are usually engaged in dissembling, propaganda, or pure sophistry. In this case it's an attempt to dissemble inasmuch as the gist of the discussion is abundantly clear. Pursue this tactic at your own peril as it is abhorrent behavior in a chat room. This isn't a UVa debate team for the puriant jollies of verbal jousting, nor or our purposes obfuscation.

Okay I said it politely. Now I'll be blunt, you know damn well what we are discussing and it's not the different usages of value. You can pick any data set from gross total revenue to media revenue, to WSJ valuations which carefully explains how it is assessed, to attendance, to television ratings and they all consistently place the ACC 4th or 5th in each. All of them indicate why you are paid what you are paid.

Plainly the only way the ACC catches up will be with football revenue enhancements and to make up the difference that limits you to targets that are top 10 in revenue generation, which translates to valuations of between 800 million to a billion plus, which have top 15 attendance, and are consider national brands which means they draw significant viewer numbers from all over and not just one region. Care to guess which schools can do that and are not already securely in the Big 10 or SEC?

Texas, Notre Dame, Oklahoma

If you want to catch the Big 10 and close the gap on the SEC the only damned way you will do it is with landing all three of those.

Therefore the question of this OP is how to accomplish that feat? What must the ACC concede in order to obtain them? Because if you don't seek to find what it takes to do so you will never make up the gap, which because of the ACC's contractual arrangement and timeline will be outpaced by all 4 of the other conferences getting pay boosts before you can.

This isn't multiple choice! This is the only option you have other than dissolution or simply taking severe lumps for the next 14 to 15 years. This isn't about parsing words, but rather strategizing what it would take to survive what is coming.

At least Notre Dame is a partial and at least the Big 12 is open minded about their options. If these were not preconditions the exercise would be moot. But the option has some degree of possibility. Notre Dame would be cajoled by a move to a champs only format in a breakaway upper tier (which NIL and stipends will likely create) which contains but 4 conferences. So it's doable. What would it take for Texas and Oklahoma to agree? Likely a division of their own and the lure of greater revenue which their inclusion provides anyway. True they could earn more in the Big 10 or SEC, but they like a measure of autonomy and control, as does Notre Dame as does North Carolina, Duke, and Virginia.

So in this hypothetical exercise quit parsing words and try to come up with a plan in which all of those valuable parties can find a peaceful coexistence in the ACC.

I'm not trying to obfuscate nor dissemble anything. To answer your OP question...

The ACC should not be trying to match the financial valuations of the SEC or BIG. Trying to lure Texas, Notre Dame (all in) and Oklahoma to the ACC is foolish. The ACC doesn’t have the right foundation for all those blue blood football programs. ESPN may provide initial funding, but the conference would be unstable. IMO, chasing financial valuations (or media payouts) is the wrong way to build a conference.

If Texas, ND and OU actually wanted to collaborate with the ACC on a venture, I believe all parties would be better-off with a greenfield approach. Exclude ESPN from the initial discussions. Determine whether the ACC needs to be dissolved as an entity. Work with the SEC on an acceptable conference alignment that benefits every school that enters the expanded SEC. My vision,
SW division: UT, TTU, TAMU, OU, OSU, Ark, Mizzu and Vandy
S division: LSU, OM, MSU, AL, Aub, Tenn, UK and UL
SE division: UF, FSU, GT, UGA, CU, USC, UNC and Duke
E division: ND, Pitt, Cuse, BC, UVA, VT, NCS and Miami
When a stable arrangement is vetted, then bring in ESPN to calculate the financial potential. If the initial design creates enough value, then determine if adding other schools make sense. You can create 6 divisions of 6 schools. This results in more compact divisions, fewer annual committed games, and more cross-division event-games.

More likely, the ACC needs to just address internal issues. The ACC can better support Clemson, Florida State, Miami and Notre Dame (as a partial member) in their pursuit of national football branding. ACC schools don't invest enough in football and its bowl/media contracts need to be improved. Maybe distribution of media payouts needs to be tied to sources of the revenue; maybe schedules need to be reconsidered. Texas and Oklahoma increased their valuations even after losing brand (TAMU, Nebraska, etc.) programs. The B12 lesson to other conferences...stop chasing TV payouts and focus on the core product. The ACC has diverse schools, a GORs and excellent demographics…a foundation for building organic value.
(This post was last modified: 05-20-2021 04:20 PM by Wahoowa84.)
05-20-2021 03:58 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
JRsec Offline
Super Moderator
*

Posts: 44,977
Joined: Mar 2012
Reputation: 13520
I Root For: SEC
Location:
Post: #66
RE: So, What Exactly Would It Take To Make The ACC Competitive In Revenue?
(05-20-2021 03:58 PM)Wahoowa84 Wrote:  
(05-20-2021 11:10 AM)JRsec Wrote:  
(05-20-2021 10:25 AM)Wahoowa84 Wrote:  
(05-19-2021 08:58 PM)Statefan Wrote:  I disagree with your definition of value being the present value of expected future profits.

I would go as far to assert that college sports has many attributes of regulated monopoly suffering from free riders and an inability to squeeze out "profit" from what is on its face a non-profit activity.

Absolute or intrinsic values in these cases will be different than relative value but most firms are traded and are weighted relatively and easily comparable likes.

You are conflating two different words: valuations and value.

The WSJ publishes (the analysis is performed by IU academics) financial valuations of collegiate athletic departments. Valuation estimates are based on the present value of expected future earnings (generally "profits" or discretionary/free cash flow). Given uncertainty in future events, whether or not these valuation estimates are reasonable is always in dispute and fluctuating. My statements dealt with financial valuations.

The word "value" has a very different meaning. Financial value could include revenue, expenses, profits, assets, liabilities, etc. "Value" can also be measured in countless other variables: football (attendance or competitive success), fit (geographic distance or rivalries), profile (academic rankings or school size) and other sports (basketball or non-revenue). A school like Duke may provide negligible football value...while still providing conference value in terms of fit, profile and excellence in other sports.

Valuation is a defined financial term; while value is a more subjective and holistic concept.

All words have various usages and those who parse them are usually engaged in dissembling, propaganda, or pure sophistry. In this case it's an attempt to dissemble inasmuch as the gist of the discussion is abundantly clear. Pursue this tactic at your own peril as it is abhorrent behavior in a chat room. This isn't a UVa debate team for the puriant jollies of verbal jousting, nor or our purposes obfuscation.

Okay I said it politely. Now I'll be blunt, you know damn well what we are discussing and it's not the different usages of value. You can pick any data set from gross total revenue to media revenue, to WSJ valuations which carefully explains how it is assessed, to attendance, to television ratings and they all consistently place the ACC 4th or 5th in each. All of them indicate why you are paid what you are paid.

Plainly the only way the ACC catches up will be with football revenue enhancements and to make up the difference that limits you to targets that are top 10 in revenue generation, which translates to valuations of between 800 million to a billion plus, which have top 15 attendance, and are consider national brands which means they draw significant viewer numbers from all over and not just one region. Care to guess which schools can do that and are not already securely in the Big 10 or SEC?

Texas, Notre Dame, Oklahoma

If you want to catch the Big 10 and close the gap on the SEC the only damned way you will do it is with landing all three of those.

Therefore the question of this OP is how to accomplish that feat? What must the ACC concede in order to obtain them? Because if you don't seek to find what it takes to do so you will never make up the gap, which because of the ACC's contractual arrangement and timeline will be outpaced by all 4 of the other conferences getting pay boosts before you can.

This isn't multiple choice! This is the only option you have other than dissolution or simply taking severe lumps for the next 14 to 15 years. This isn't about parsing words, but rather strategizing what it would take to survive what is coming.

At least Notre Dame is a partial and at least the Big 12 is open minded about their options. If these were not preconditions the exercise would be moot. But the option has some degree of possibility. Notre Dame would be cajoled by a move to a champs only format in a breakaway upper tier (which NIL and stipends will likely create) which contains but 4 conferences. So it's doable. What would it take for Texas and Oklahoma to agree? Likely a division of their own and the lure of greater revenue which their inclusion provides anyway. True they could earn more in the Big 10 or SEC, but they like a measure of autonomy and control, as does Notre Dame as does North Carolina, Duke, and Virginia.

So in this hypothetical exercise quit parsing words and try to come up with a plan in which all of those valuable parties can find a peaceful coexistence in the ACC.

I'm not trying to obfuscate nor dissemble anything. To answer your OP question...

The ACC should not be trying to match the financial valuations of the SEC or BIG. Trying to lure Texas, Notre Dame (all in) and Oklahoma to the ACC is foolish. The ACC doesn’t have the right foundation for all those blue blood football programs. ESPN may provide initial funding, but the conference would be unstable. IMO, chasing financial valuations (or media payouts) is the wrong way to build a conference.

If Texas, ND and OU actually wanted to collaborate with the ACC on a venture, I believe all parties would be better-off with a greenfield approach. Exclude ESPN from the initial discussions. Determine whether the ACC needs to be dissolved as an entity. Work with the SEC on an acceptable conference alignment that benefits every school that enters the expanded SEC. My vision,
SW division: UT, TTU, TAMU, OU, OSU, Ark, Mizzu and Vandy
S division: LSU, OM, MSU, AL, Aub, Tenn, UK and UL
SE division: UF, FSU, GT, UGA, CU, USC, UNC and Duke
E division: ND, Pitt, Cuse, BC, UVA, VT, NCS and Miami
When a stable arrangement is vetted, then bring in ESPN to calculate the financial potential. If the initial design creates enough value, then determine if adding other schools make sense. You can create 6 divisions of 6 schools. This results in more compact divisions, fewer annual committed games, and more cross-division event-games.

More likely, the ACC needs to just address internal issues. The ACC can better support Clemson, Florida State, Miami and Notre Dame (as a partial member) in their pursuit of national football branding. ACC schools don't invest enough in football and its bowl/media contracts need to be improved. Maybe distribution of media payouts needs to be tied to sources of the revenue; maybe schedules need to be reconsidered. Texas and Oklahoma increased their valuations even after losing brand (TAMU, Nebraska, etc.) programs. The B12 lesson to other conferences...stop chasing TV payouts and focus on the core product. The ACC has diverse schools, a GORs and excellent demographics…a foundation for building organic value.

Okay, so Wake Forest, Iowa State, Kansas, Kansas State, Baylor, Texas Christian, and West Virginia are out initially.

It's an interesting postulation.

I think we head to two leagues but I think that happens after NIL and / or stipends force some out. Then divisions would be easier to set up once you know who is all in and if any G5 want in.

BTW the numbers came in today for 2020:
Big 10: 768.9 million or 51.3 per school
SEC: 728.9 million or 48.6 per school
PAC 12: 533.8 million or 41 million per school (includes a 5 million per team subsidy)
ACC: 496.7 million or about 32.6 million per school (discounting N.D.'s share for all non football)
B12: 409.2 million or 40.9 million per school (plus each schools T3 so UT 17 million more, OU 10 million more, KU 7 million more and everyone else 3 million or less in addition) So total Big 12 distributions should range from ~42.9 million to 57.9 million.

The SEC will also be disbursing an additional 23 million to each member school to offset loss of gate in 2020 and this money will be borrowed against the future contract which may reflect a figure about 3 million more per school than originally believed making the final contract possibly worth in the 350 million range.
(This post was last modified: 05-20-2021 05:09 PM by JRsec.)
05-20-2021 05:06 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Fighting Muskie Offline
Senior Chief Realignmentologist
*

Posts: 15,074
Joined: Sep 2016
Reputation: 1214
I Root For: Bishop Sycamore
Location: Secret Lair
Post: #67
RE: So, What Exactly Would It Take To Make The ACC Competitive In Revenue?
How do you address the internal issues of the ACC without fundamentally altering its membership?

You’ve got a lot of private schools and academically minded institutions that just don’t care that much about succeeding in football or lack the resources to do so.

You can’t turn BC and WF into Georgia and Alabama.
05-20-2021 05:12 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Wahoowa84 Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,435
Joined: Oct 2017
Reputation: 1176
I Root For: UVa
Location:
Post: #68
RE: So, What Exactly Would It Take To Make The ACC Competitive In Revenue?
(05-20-2021 05:12 PM)Fighting Muskie Wrote:  How do you address the internal issues of the ACC without fundamentally altering its membership?

You’ve got a lot of private schools and academically minded institutions that just don’t care that much about succeeding in football or lack the resources to do so.

You can’t turn BC and WF into Georgia and Alabama.

Selecting the right leaders is the starting point. Hiring a commissioner who’s not from the country club was a good decision. When UVA’s AD retired, Georgia’s associate AD was hired (her predecessor came from Penn). Mack Brown is revitalizing UNC football. Recruiting new talent from the BIG and SEC is a good approach; investing in folks with strong resumes also works.

Notre Dame is a small, private, academically-minded school (located in a basketball state). No one questions the Irish’s commitment to football. Small and medium sized schools need to keep growing their football fan bases...or get out of high level college football. I’m optimistic that NIL and compensation for athletes will help clarify the needed commitment to football.
05-20-2021 07:06 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Statefan Offline
Banned

Posts: 3,511
Joined: May 2018
I Root For: .
Location:
Post: #69
RE: So, What Exactly Would It Take To Make The ACC Competitive In Revenue?
(05-20-2021 03:09 PM)schmolik Wrote:  
(05-20-2021 02:33 PM)Fighting Muskie Wrote:  I think it’s time for basketball schools to stop pretending that they are football schools as well when it’s abundantly clear they aren’t investing in football.

I don't think Duke, North Carolina, and Virginia are pretending they are football schools, they know what butters their bread. I think Wahoowa84, XLance, esavem, and the other ACC football fans want them to be football schools and are frustrated they aren't. The ACC isn't a football conference, never was, never will be. It shouldn't sacrifice men's basketball excellence to chase being the 3rd best football conference. They keep doing that and we'll see more 2021's when the entire Final Four is west of the Mississippi and schools like Baylor win national championships.

Factually untrue.
05-20-2021 07:58 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Hokie Mark Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 26,873
Joined: Sep 2011
Reputation: 2008
I Root For: VT, ACC teams
Location: Greensboro, NC
Post: #70
RE: So, What Exactly Would It Take To Make The ACC Competitive In Revenue?
(05-20-2021 07:58 PM)Statefan Wrote:  
(05-20-2021 03:09 PM)schmolik Wrote:  
(05-20-2021 02:33 PM)Fighting Muskie Wrote:  I think it’s time for basketball schools to stop pretending that they are football schools as well when it’s abundantly clear they aren’t investing in football.

I don't think Duke, North Carolina, and Virginia are pretending they are football schools, they know what butters their bread. I think Wahoowa84, XLance, esavem, and the other ACC football fans want them to be football schools and are frustrated they aren't. The ACC isn't a football conference, never was, never will be. It shouldn't sacrifice men's basketball excellence to chase being the 3rd best football conference. They keep doing that and we'll see more 2021's when the entire Final Four is west of the Mississippi and schools like Baylor win national championships.

Factually untrue.

schmolik seems to be trolling the ACC... no, patronizing is probably a better term.
05-20-2021 08:19 PM
Visit this user's website Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Statefan Offline
Banned

Posts: 3,511
Joined: May 2018
I Root For: .
Location:
Post: #71
RE: So, What Exactly Would It Take To Make The ACC Competitive In Revenue?
(05-20-2021 08:19 PM)Hokie Mark Wrote:  
(05-20-2021 07:58 PM)Statefan Wrote:  
(05-20-2021 03:09 PM)schmolik Wrote:  
(05-20-2021 02:33 PM)Fighting Muskie Wrote:  I think it’s time for basketball schools to stop pretending that they are football schools as well when it’s abundantly clear they aren’t investing in football.

I don't think Duke, North Carolina, and Virginia are pretending they are football schools, they know what butters their bread. I think Wahoowa84, XLance, esavem, and the other ACC football fans want them to be football schools and are frustrated they aren't. The ACC isn't a football conference, never was, never will be. It shouldn't sacrifice men's basketball excellence to chase being the 3rd best football conference. They keep doing that and we'll see more 2021's when the entire Final Four is west of the Mississippi and schools like Baylor win national championships.

Factually untrue.

schmolik seems to be trolling the ACC... no, patronizing is probably a better term.

Not taking the records from 1933 to 1953 causes people not to understand where the ACC came from and makes them think it just appeared. They don't realize that the ACC was formed to kick out certain schools from the SoCon.

As to football and the ACC:

1962 - Duke finishes 14th
1961 - Duke 20th
1960 - Duke 10th
1959 - Clemson 11th
1958 - Clemson 12th, South Carolina 15th
1957 - NC State 15th, Duke 16th
1956 - Clemson 19th
1955 - Maryland 3rd, Duke 18th
1954 - Maryland 8th, Duke 14th
1953 - Maryland 1st, Duke 15th

ACC formed out of Southern Conference to get rid of West Va, VT, William and Mary, Richmond, etc.
1952 - Maryland 8th, Duke 16th
1951 - Maryland 3rd, Clemson 19th
1950 - Clemson 10th (undefeated)
West Va voted into Southern Conference
1949 - Maryland 14th, UNC 19th
1948 - UNC 3rd, Clemson 11th (undefeated), William and Mary, 17th, WF 20th
1947 - UNC 9th, William and Mary 14th, NC State 17th, Duke 19th
1946 - UNC 9th, NC State 18th
1945 - Duke 13th, WF 19th
1944 - Duke 11th
1943 - Duke 7th
1942 - William and Mary 14th
1941 - Duke 2nd
1940 - Duke 16th
1939 - Duke 8th, Clemson 12th
1938 - Duke 3rd
1937 - UNC 19th, Duke 20th
Wake Forest and others added to SoCon
UVa exist the Southern Conference
1936 - Duke 11th
Pre Poll Era
1935 - UNC 8-1, Duke 8-2
1934 - UNC 7-1-1, Duke 7-2
1933 - Duke 9-1
SEC 13 exit 23 member Southern Conference

The Southern Conference and ACC are a football created and oriented conference from the time it was created in 1921, It is not until the 800 SAT rule is passed in 1962 that the ACC becomes anything other than a football oriented conference.

You will not see Virginia ranked here. As an independent between 1937 and 1952 UVa was ranked 7 times and finished as high as 13 and 20. They were 8-1 in 1951 and 1941, 7-2 in 1945 and 1947, and 8-2 in 1950 and 1952.

That means when the ACC dumped the SoCon and added back UVa, it did so with a top 5 program (Maryland) and 3 top 20 programs (Duke, Clemson, and UNC) and 3 lesser programs, all of which had been ranked in the top 20 in the prior decade (UVa, NC State, and Wake Forest). This is part of the reason that the ACC champion had the Orange Bowl tie-in.

Just because UNC won the basketball national championship in 1957, that victory did not make the ACC a basketball conference. UNC sells that trope because their football fell off after 1949 and even though they hired Jim Tatum from Maryland, he died from Rocky Mountain Spotted Fever before he coached the first game at UNC. Tatum's death is what allowed Duke to pass the 800 SAT rule in 1962. If Tatum is alive and at UNC, that rule does not pass and Duke might have exited the league in the 1960's.

People didn't just wake up one morning in Greensboro and decide to form a country club. Finally the ACC does not morph into a more basketball centric league until South Carolina leaves in 1971. They left at a time when NC State, Maryland, and UNC had top 5 basketball programs. By that point we are 10 years after the 800 SAT rule.
(This post was last modified: 05-20-2021 09:06 PM by Statefan.)
05-20-2021 08:37 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Statefan Offline
Banned

Posts: 3,511
Joined: May 2018
I Root For: .
Location:
Post: #72
RE: So, What Exactly Would It Take To Make The ACC Competitive In Revenue?
(05-20-2021 08:19 PM)Hokie Mark Wrote:  
(05-20-2021 07:58 PM)Statefan Wrote:  
(05-20-2021 03:09 PM)schmolik Wrote:  
(05-20-2021 02:33 PM)Fighting Muskie Wrote:  I think it’s time for basketball schools to stop pretending that they are football schools as well when it’s abundantly clear they aren’t investing in football.

I don't think Duke, North Carolina, and Virginia are pretending they are football schools, they know what butters their bread. I think Wahoowa84, XLance, esavem, and the other ACC football fans want them to be football schools and are frustrated they aren't. The ACC isn't a football conference, never was, never will be. It shouldn't sacrifice men's basketball excellence to chase being the 3rd best football conference. They keep doing that and we'll see more 2021's when the entire Final Four is west of the Mississippi and schools like Baylor win national championships.

Factually untrue.

schmolik seems to be trolling the ACC... no, patronizing is probably a better term.

Ignorance
05-20-2021 09:07 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
AllTideUp Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,744
Joined: Jul 2015
Reputation: 903
I Root For: Alabama & Cincinnati
Location:
Post: #73
RE: So, What Exactly Would It Take To Make The ACC Competitive In Revenue?
(05-20-2021 07:06 PM)Wahoowa84 Wrote:  
(05-20-2021 05:12 PM)Fighting Muskie Wrote:  How do you address the internal issues of the ACC without fundamentally altering its membership?

You’ve got a lot of private schools and academically minded institutions that just don’t care that much about succeeding in football or lack the resources to do so.

You can’t turn BC and WF into Georgia and Alabama.

Selecting the right leaders is the starting point. Hiring a commissioner who’s not from the country club was a good decision. When UVA’s AD retired, Georgia’s associate AD was hired (her predecessor came from Penn). Mack Brown is revitalizing UNC football. Recruiting new talent from the BIG and SEC is a good approach; investing in folks with strong resumes also works.

Notre Dame is a small, private, academically-minded school (located in a basketball state). No one questions the Irish’s commitment to football. Small and medium sized schools need to keep growing their football fan bases...or get out of high level college football. I’m optimistic that NIL and compensation for athletes will help clarify the needed commitment to football.

Fair enough, but ND has been committed to football for over a century. It is a part of their identity and the sole reason many people even know they exist.

Not a comparable situation to Duke or BC or some of the others.

I'm one that thinks the ACC is capable of being more competitive in football, but the economics make it difficult to achieve on a large sweeping scale...at least in a short period of time.

Unfortunately, the ACC should have made this commitment at least 20 years ago. That's assuming they're going to do it tomorrow which is unlikely.
05-20-2021 11:31 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
XLance Online
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 17,154
Joined: Mar 2008
Reputation: 1262
I Root For: Carolina
Location: Greensboro, NC
Post: #74
RE: So, What Exactly Would It Take To Make The ACC Competitive In Revenue?
(05-20-2021 12:34 AM)AllTideUp Wrote:  Why in the world would South Carolina want to go to the ACC? They haven't been a member in decades and left the ACC when the league was far better off. The SEC is a perfect fit for them and they are way better off.

Why would Maryland want to leave the Big Ten when they joined up for better finances only a decade ago?

Why would the Big Ten take Pitt in a scenario like this? They don't add value.

I know we're all just spitballing around here, but is there really a point to offering solutions that distant from reality?

Why?
Because it's a lot easier to maneuver schools on the periphery than to leapfrog one or more schools halfway across the county to make numbers balance.
The committee that is studying the expanded playoff has to address the structure of conferences to tackle a playoff formula.

It's doubtful that any school will be demoted in this round, but getting the public to buy into an expanded playoff is critical. Regionalism is a key and that is a tough task, when the two weakest income conferences' territory runs north/south instead of east/west.

Is there fan value in moving Texas to the ACC? I don't know. I think that move is possible and it does help with the valuation/income problem. But is it good for playoff football?

We know that the Big 12 will go away and those schools need to be placed somewhere. Why not move them to a logical place nearer their homes and make some other logical moves around the edges? It's a lot easier supplement incomes that it is to move large numbers of schools.

ACC
BC, Syracuse, Maryland, West Virginia, VT, Louisville, UVa, Wake Forest, Carolina, Duke, NCSU, Clemson, South Carolina, Georgia Tech, FSU, Miami (Notre Dame-partial)

B1G
Rutgers, Pitt, Penn State, Ohio State, MSU, Michigan, Purdue, Indiana, Illinois, Northwestern, Wisconsin, Minn. Iowa, Iowa State, Kansas, Missouri

SEC,
Florida, Georgia, Tenn., Ky., Auburn, Alabama, Vandy, Ole Miss, MSU, LSU, Arkansas, A&M, Texas, TT, Baylor, TCU

PAC
Nebraska, Kansas State, Oklahoma, OSU, Colorado, Utah, Ariz. ASU, USC, UCLA, Stanford, Cal, Oregon, OSU, WSU, Washington.
05-21-2021 05:00 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Fighting Muskie Offline
Senior Chief Realignmentologist
*

Posts: 15,074
Joined: Sep 2016
Reputation: 1214
I Root For: Bishop Sycamore
Location: Secret Lair
Post: #75
RE: So, What Exactly Would It Take To Make The ACC Competitive In Revenue?
(05-20-2021 08:37 PM)Statefan Wrote:  
(05-20-2021 08:19 PM)Hokie Mark Wrote:  
(05-20-2021 07:58 PM)Statefan Wrote:  
(05-20-2021 03:09 PM)schmolik Wrote:  
(05-20-2021 02:33 PM)Fighting Muskie Wrote:  I think it’s time for basketball schools to stop pretending that they are football schools as well when it’s abundantly clear they aren’t investing in football.

I don't think Duke, North Carolina, and Virginia are pretending they are football schools, they know what butters their bread. I think Wahoowa84, XLance, esavem, and the other ACC football fans want them to be football schools and are frustrated they aren't. The ACC isn't a football conference, never was, never will be. It shouldn't sacrifice men's basketball excellence to chase being the 3rd best football conference. They keep doing that and we'll see more 2021's when the entire Final Four is west of the Mississippi and schools like Baylor win national championships.

Factually untrue.

schmolik seems to be trolling the ACC... no, patronizing is probably a better term.

Not taking the records from 1933 to 1953 causes people not to understand where the ACC came from and makes them think it just appeared. They don't realize that the ACC was formed to kick out certain schools from the SoCon.

As to football and the ACC:

1962 - Duke finishes 14th
1961 - Duke 20th
1960 - Duke 10th
1959 - Clemson 11th
1958 - Clemson 12th, South Carolina 15th
1957 - NC State 15th, Duke 16th
1956 - Clemson 19th
1955 - Maryland 3rd, Duke 18th
1954 - Maryland 8th, Duke 14th
1953 - Maryland 1st, Duke 15th

ACC formed out of Southern Conference to get rid of West Va, VT, William and Mary, Richmond, etc.
1952 - Maryland 8th, Duke 16th
1951 - Maryland 3rd, Clemson 19th
1950 - Clemson 10th (undefeated)
West Va voted into Southern Conference
1949 - Maryland 14th, UNC 19th
1948 - UNC 3rd, Clemson 11th (undefeated), William and Mary, 17th, WF 20th
1947 - UNC 9th, William and Mary 14th, NC State 17th, Duke 19th
1946 - UNC 9th, NC State 18th
1945 - Duke 13th, WF 19th
1944 - Duke 11th
1943 - Duke 7th
1942 - William and Mary 14th
1941 - Duke 2nd
1940 - Duke 16th
1939 - Duke 8th, Clemson 12th
1938 - Duke 3rd
1937 - UNC 19th, Duke 20th
Wake Forest and others added to SoCon
UVa exist the Southern Conference
1936 - Duke 11th
Pre Poll Era
1935 - UNC 8-1, Duke 8-2
1934 - UNC 7-1-1, Duke 7-2
1933 - Duke 9-1
SEC 13 exit 23 member Southern Conference

The Southern Conference and ACC are a football created and oriented conference from the time it was created in 1921, It is not until the 800 SAT rule is passed in 1962 that the ACC becomes anything other than a football oriented conference.

You will not see Virginia ranked here. As an independent between 1937 and 1952 UVa was ranked 7 times and finished as high as 13 and 20. They were 8-1 in 1951 and 1941, 7-2 in 1945 and 1947, and 8-2 in 1950 and 1952.

That means when the ACC dumped the SoCon and added back UVa, it did so with a top 5 program (Maryland) and 3 top 20 programs (Duke, Clemson, and UNC) and 3 lesser programs, all of which had been ranked in the top 20 in the prior decade (UVa, NC State, and Wake Forest). This is part of the reason that the ACC champion had the Orange Bowl tie-in.

Just because UNC won the basketball national championship in 1957, that victory did not make the ACC a basketball conference. UNC sells that trope because their football fell off after 1949 and even though they hired Jim Tatum from Maryland, he died from Rocky Mountain Spotted Fever before he coached the first game at UNC. Tatum's death is what allowed Duke to pass the 800 SAT rule in 1962. If Tatum is alive and at UNC, that rule does not pass and Duke might have exited the league in the 1960's.

People didn't just wake up one morning in Greensboro and decide to form a country club. Finally the ACC does not morph into a more basketball centric league until South Carolina leaves in 1971. They left at a time when NC State, Maryland, and UNC had top 5 basketball programs. By that point we are 10 years after the 800 SAT rule.

That’s some interesting data but I actually think it supports the argument that the 1933-1952 SoCon and 1953-1962 ACC were not strong football conferences. Granted this an era where only 20 teams were ranked but in most of those years only 1 maybe 3 SoCon/ACC teams are ranked (1947-1948 are a bit a fluke) and you’ve got undefeated Clemson teams that only manage 10th or 11th in the polls.

Also, that Orange Bowl tie in is a modern thing that I believe began with the BCS. The Orange Bowl was traditionally Big 8 vs At Large from the 70’s until the late 90s.
05-21-2021 07:05 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
XLance Online
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 17,154
Joined: Mar 2008
Reputation: 1262
I Root For: Carolina
Location: Greensboro, NC
Post: #76
RE: So, What Exactly Would It Take To Make The ACC Competitive In Revenue?
(05-19-2021 09:09 PM)Statefan Wrote:  Lance that means forgiving the unforgivable before we alive at the time have died.

That said, maybe it is time for them to come home.

I agree.
It pains me every time I have suggested that the chickens come home to roost, and it's even worse with those liars in College Park, but if we can provide better product to sell for playoff football, with schools we love to hate, it benefits everyone.

Don't even mention West Virginia, but I think that that is the price of our survival. Sometimes, you just have to hold your nose and take your medicine.
05-21-2021 07:46 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bullet Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 83,846
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5067
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
Post: #77
RE: So, What Exactly Would It Take To Make The ACC Competitive In Revenue?
Depends on whether you are trying to make the ACC competitive or its members competitive.

If you are looking only at members, splitting off Coastal and Atlantic into mergers with the Big 10 and SEC makes sense:
Big 10 West: Nebraska, iowa, Minnesota, Wisconsin, Illinois, Northwestern
Big 10 East: Indiana, Purdue, Michigan, Michigan St., Ohio St., Penn St. (or Rutgers)
Big Atlantic North: Notre Dame, Pitt, Virginia Tech, Maryland, Rutgers (or Penn St.)
Big Atlantic South: Miami, Georgia Tech, North Carolina, Duke, Virginia

SEC West: Alabama, Ole Miss, Mississippi St., LSU, Arkansas, Texas A&M
SEC East: Auburn, Florida, Georgia, Kentucky, Tennessee, Vanderbilt
SE Atlantic North: Syracuse, Boston College, Louisville, Missouri, West Virginia
SE Atlantic South: FSU, Clemson, North Carolina St., Wake Forest, South Carolina
05-21-2021 01:39 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bullet Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 83,846
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5067
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
Post: #78
RE: So, What Exactly Would It Take To Make The ACC Competitive In Revenue?
Saving the ACC I like 3 conferences over combining into 2.

ACC North: Notre Dame, Pitt, Syracuse, Boston College, Virginia, Virginia Tech, West Virginia
ACC South: FSU, Miami, Clemson, Georgia Tech, North Carolina, Duke, Wake Forest
SEC West: Alabama, Auburn, Ole Miss, Mississippi St., LSU, Texas A&M, Arkansas
SEC East: Florida, Georgia, Kentucky, Vanderbilt, Tennessee, South Carolina, North Carolina St.
Big 12 North: Oklahoma, Oklahoma St., Kansas, Kansas St., Iowa St., Missouri
Big 12 South: Texas, Texas Tech, Baylor, TCU, Louisville, Cincinnati
05-21-2021 01:45 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Thiefery Offline
Special Teams
*

Posts: 744
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation: 33
I Root For: TEXAS
Location:
Post: #79
RE: So, What Exactly Would It Take To Make The ACC Competitive In Revenue?
(05-21-2021 01:45 PM)bullet Wrote:  Saving the ACC I like 3 conferences over combining into 2.

ACC North: Notre Dame, Pitt, Syracuse, Boston College, Virginia, Virginia Tech, West Virginia
ACC South: FSU, Miami, Clemson, Georgia Tech, North Carolina, Duke, Wake Forest
SEC West: Alabama, Auburn, Ole Miss, Mississippi St., LSU, Texas A&M, Arkansas
SEC East: Florida, Georgia, Kentucky, Vanderbilt, Tennessee, South Carolina, North Carolina St.
Big 12 North: Oklahoma, Oklahoma St., Kansas, Kansas St., Iowa St., Missouri
Big 12 South: Texas, Texas Tech, Baylor, TCU, Louisville, Cincinnati

Rather the Big12 stay as is at 10 than adding both Louisville and Cincy
05-21-2021 02:08 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
JRsec Offline
Super Moderator
*

Posts: 44,977
Joined: Mar 2012
Reputation: 13520
I Root For: SEC
Location:
Post: #80
RE: So, What Exactly Would It Take To Make The ACC Competitive In Revenue?
(05-21-2021 01:45 PM)bullet Wrote:  Saving the ACC I like 3 conferences over combining into 2.

ACC North: Notre Dame, Pitt, Syracuse, Boston College, Virginia, Virginia Tech, West Virginia
ACC South: FSU, Miami, Clemson, Georgia Tech, North Carolina, Duke, Wake Forest
SEC West: Alabama, Auburn, Ole Miss, Mississippi St., LSU, Texas A&M, Arkansas
SEC East: Florida, Georgia, Kentucky, Vanderbilt, Tennessee, South Carolina, North Carolina St.
Big 12 North: Oklahoma, Oklahoma St., Kansas, Kansas St., Iowa St., Missouri
Big 12 South: Texas, Texas Tech, Baylor, TCU, Louisville, Cincinnati

Except Bullet this doesn't address the issues set up as the premise in the OP. Precious little is accomplished in this arrangement to address the value and revenue issues of the ACC. In fact you leave their 3 weakest producers add Notre Dame and rob them of N.C. State and their #2 earner in Louisville, so you can place Missouri in the Big 12 and get rid of your much less valuable outlier WVU.
The Big 12 is the only conference here that is strengthened. You add 2 populous states back to the Big 12 and two academic enhancements along with a solid earner in Louisville. It could be argued that the SEC is slightly better off, but it only further handicaps the ACC.

If the exercise was in coming up with an enhanced and productive Big 12 this would work.
(This post was last modified: 05-21-2021 02:17 PM by JRsec.)
05-21-2021 02:15 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Post Reply 




User(s) browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)


Copyright © 2002-2026 Collegiate Sports Nation Bulletin Board System (CSNbbs), All Rights Reserved.
CSNbbs is an independent fan site and is in no way affiliated to the NCAA or any of the schools and conferences it represents.
This site monetizes links. FTC Disclosure.
We allow third-party companies to serve ads and/or collect certain anonymous information when you visit our web site. These companies may use non-personally identifiable information (e.g., click stream information, browser type, time and date, subject of advertisements clicked or scrolled over) during your visits to this and other Web sites in order to provide advertisements about goods and services likely to be of greater interest to you. These companies typically use a cookie or third party web beacon to collect this information. To learn more about this behavioral advertising practice or to opt-out of this type of advertising, you can visit http://www.networkadvertising.org.
Powered By MyBB, © 2002-2026 MyBB Group.