(01-27-2020 11:02 AM)johnbragg Wrote: (01-27-2020 12:39 AM)BruceMcF Wrote: This is where the question of "proportional to what" comes in. If the Boise State bonus was bumped up 33% to 2.4m, that would mean somewhere around $3.75m per school, so around $6.15m for Boise ... 64% more than everyone else rather than 240% more.
And something like that would be the bargaining range for the negotiations, but the most likely sticking point is the permanent aristocratic status for Boise.
That was settled in 2012. The Mountain West signed the deal.
Quote:They can, if they are wise, negotiate a transition into a strong performance bonus system which would be likely to serve Boise State well ... eg a 4:3:2:1 top four performance pool, and a OTA / Major Network media appearance pool ...
They had that, the MWC couldn't afford the bonuses, so they renegotiated it to a flat fee for Boise State.
About the bolded .... first, one could say the same thing about Boise's demand for a proportional bonus in this new deal, that this was settled in 2016 when they agreed to the flat $1.8m. Bottom line is, despite the existence of agreements, both sides can always ask for a change. Doesn't mean the other side has to accommodate them, but they can ask.
Second, IIRC, the decision to make the bonus a flat rate was mutual, not something the MW pushed for moreso than Boise. The nature of the 2012 deal meant that the bonus varied, and one thing administrators of all stripes hate is revenue uncertainty. The MW didn't like not knowing exactly how much they had to pay each year, and Boise didn't like not knowing how much they would get. So they agreed to nail it down at $1.8m as that was the average it had been fluctuating around since 2012.
Also, the 2012 deal didn't really give Boise aristocratic status. It was a bonus that anyone could have earned, it wasn't just for Boise. It just offered bonuses to teams that played a 'nationally televised' game, specified as a game on ESPN, ESPN2, FOX, NBC, CBS, or ABC. A team got $300k for any such game not on a Saturday, and $500k if the game happened on a Saturday. But it didn't apply just to Boise, if Boise had played Michigan on a Friday night on ESPN they would get $300k, and if Fresno had played Notre Dame on Saturday on NBC, Fresno would have gotten $500k. It didn't single out Boise at all.
In contrast, the 2016 amendment did elevate Boise, as it specifies that Boise and only Boise gets the $1.8m, even if Boise never plays in a nationally televised game and other schools do. Boise alone gets the bonus, and it is a guaranteed $1.8m.