(12-21-2018 01:04 PM)chiefsfan Wrote: (12-21-2018 10:12 AM)bullet Wrote: (12-21-2018 04:01 AM)chiefsfan Wrote: (12-20-2018 06:48 PM)CG_Hawk06 Wrote: (12-20-2018 06:27 PM)THE NC Herd Fan Wrote: Honestly what difference can 2,000 troops make in Syria. If it was 20,000 maybe.
I’m 100% on board with pulling troops out of unwinnable war zones. Why do I say unwinnable? Because Post-WW2 the U.S. has made a decision to simultaneously fight and rebuild infrastructure. The only way to cripple and dismantle an enemy into surrender is to continually level them to a point of feeling unable to exist without quitting. Until then we just drop bombs and lose lives while building and creating a sustainable environment for them to continually fight back. That along with giving away billions in aid to those regions.
Bring ALL of those troops home. Stack them on the border with Mexico and show our Central American neighbors the result of decades of pissing on our kindness at the southern border.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro
Point of order, I don't believe we've had any loss of life in Syria in a while. We're there because the alternative is Russia comes in and does what we're doing now, and Putin ends up controlling way too much of the Middle East than he ever needs his greasy hands on.
But I understand that fear mongering is a major factor in US Politics these days, and its much easier to frighten people of what they don't know in terms of the thousands of people who try and enter the US each day as opposed to what they do know in Russia and China.
You miss the point of Syria. Obama tried in an embarrassingly inept performance to support the rebels. Ours got killed or gave their guns to the al Queda affiliated rebels. The other leg was to support the Kurds in fighting ISIS. President Trump bumped that up and it was enormously successful. The Kurds were not fighting Assad. Russia is helping in the fight against both al Queda affiliated rebels and Democratic Turkish affiliated rebels. Our sides are not fighting.
Yes, but giving Russia unchecked control of an area is an incredibly dangerous game. Putin has made a lot of alarming comments about wanting to return Russia to something more like it was back when it was the USSR, and already just sort of waltzed into Crimea and took control.
I get the desire to bring troops home from the Middle East, but I worry that we are making a mistake that is going to come back and bite us in 10-15 years.
Us being in Syria doesnt change Putins desire or help us in any way. If anything---it only increases the possibility that a Cold War becomes a shooting war. Again--you do understand that we are in Syria in direct defiance of the Syrian government. They don't want us there. We were only there because ISIS was using it as a base of operations. ISIS is basically done. We have no reason to be there anymore.
Russia isnt going to invade the US. Russia isnt going to invade Europe. They have neither the army, money, or capability to do so anymore. Yes, they can make a mess of Europe and even drive well into Europe before we could stop them---but they cant win that war. The Russian Navy has about 160 ships---most of which are corvettes. They have one small aircraft carrier---and it can barely conduct air operations without breaking down.
The US has 313 combat ships---10 super carriers, 10 assault ships that function as small aircraft carriers (they would be similar to the Russian's single carrier--but are far more reliable). The two Navies arent even close.
The US Air Force has about 1,800 combat aircraft. Russia has about 1300. However, when you include the combat aircraft from the Army and Navy, the combat aircraft advantage shifts dramatically. Russia's Army, Navy, and AF has about 4800 combat aircraft. The US has a combined Navy/AF/Army air wing with 14,600 combat aircraft. Then, you'd have to add in all the combined aircraft of the NATO alliance to reach the total number of combat aircraft the Russians would face.
Additionally, since the Russians would be the invaders, they would also be facing fixed and movable SAMS---where as the Allies would mostly be operating over their own territory where the SAM risk was low.
The Russians arent invading---and if they do---it will be the end of their nation, their military, and their future as a great power. They will have to win a war without control of the sea or skies--in an era where anything that can be seen on the battlefield can be killed from the sky. Its impossible for them to win.
Yes, they have a formidable military---but the threat it represents is largely as a powerful defensive deterrent---and as an offensive weapon where it is marshaled to an area near Russia where the US isnt really all that interested in losing assets necessary to oppose the move militarily. Other than its capacity to do significant damage, it is not a threat to take over Europe. What Im trying to say is if Russia ever does something outside of its borders that the US believes is so damaging to US interests that we are willing to spill blood over it---the Russians are going to have no choice but to either back down or be completely decimated.