RE: Trump just dog whistled for some one to shoot HRC
(08-09-2016 07:43 PM)e-parade Wrote:
(08-09-2016 07:25 PM)solohawks Wrote:
(08-09-2016 07:13 PM)e-parade Wrote:
(08-09-2016 07:00 PM)solohawks Wrote:
(08-09-2016 06:41 PM)e-parade Wrote: We're dealing with laws and court rulings here, so as per that standard please cite a historical reference where this happened.
Also are you seriously suggesting that the supreme court will just make up a decision on a hearing that's not happening? Do you know how things make it to being presented to the supreme court?
I said nothing of the sort. I said courts can neuter amendments with their rulings. You interpreted that as supreme court, why i do not know.
If you want examples of this see the 10th amendment. It is virtually meaningless as the feds control everything of consequence
It's interpreted as the supreme court because the conversation is about "Hillary picking her judges" and the 2nd amendment being taken away by them. Which other judges would be able to make a decision that has federal consequences (let's take gay marriage as an example: states made it legal or illegal, but it wasn't national policy until the supreme court heard the case)? This is a discussion on federal, not state, policy after all. So please, what else could this have been about now that you've brought that up?
Also your statement on the 10th amendment is not what I said. You need to cite historical precedence when dealing with court rulings. You've made a broad stroke claim with no evidence to support it. Also it's entirely inaccurate anyway - it's about the states being able to make their own laws so long as they don't go against the federal constitution. States do have their own laws and they are very different from one another. Take for instance the state of Virginia and the laws about the percentage of the athletic department budget coming from subsidies as compared to what other states have.
The supreme court is not the only court that can neuter amendments
Also the 10th amendment is about the states having all the power the constitution did not explicitly grant the federal government. Here is the full text if you would like to read it
The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States respectively, or to the people.
So, I stand by my statement that the 10th amendment has been neutered
Sure, State courts could potentially neuter a constitutional amendment at the state level...and then they risk it being brought up against the supreme court and being overturned, because that's how the system is designed to work.
But again: this is about judges that Hillary Clinton could appoint as President. The President appoints federal judges, not state judges. This is 100% about federal judges and has been from the start. Any ruling that goes against the 2nd amendment entirely will be brought up through every court until it reaches the Supreme Court, there is quite literally no way the NRA would allow that to happen otherwise. Without a new law coming into effect, there will be no rulings of the sort. Any judge, regardless of where they are appointed (or elected) can only make a ruling on the cases brought to them. If no new laws come into play, then Clinton hasn't effected anything, and any ruling the court makes has nothing to do with her. If new laws come into play, then the house and senate have both approved them and it had nothing to do with the judges Clinton appointed.
Also you still haven't come up with anything of actual substance to prove your claim. Not a single court ruling, not a single actual source other than your own voice. I'm going to go ahead and assume you have nothing other than your personal beliefs on this until you attempt to prove otherwise.
You really need me to cite cases about the powers the states use to have they no longer have?
Here's a few but certainly not all
Death penalty when it's ok - Kennedy v. Louisiana
Abortion regulation - roe v wade
Gun regulatuon- McDonald vs. City of Chicago
RE: Trump just dog whistled for some one to shoot HRC
(08-09-2016 07:43 PM)e-parade Wrote:
(08-09-2016 07:25 PM)solohawks Wrote:
(08-09-2016 07:13 PM)e-parade Wrote:
(08-09-2016 07:00 PM)solohawks Wrote:
(08-09-2016 06:41 PM)e-parade Wrote: We're dealing with laws and court rulings here, so as per that standard please cite a historical reference where this happened.
Also are you seriously suggesting that the supreme court will just make up a decision on a hearing that's not happening? Do you know how things make it to being presented to the supreme court?
I said nothing of the sort. I said courts can neuter amendments with their rulings. You interpreted that as supreme court, why i do not know.
If you want examples of this see the 10th amendment. It is virtually meaningless as the feds control everything of consequence
It's interpreted as the supreme court because the conversation is about "Hillary picking her judges" and the 2nd amendment being taken away by them. Which other judges would be able to make a decision that has federal consequences (let's take gay marriage as an example: states made it legal or illegal, but it wasn't national policy until the supreme court heard the case)? This is a discussion on federal, not state, policy after all. So please, what else could this have been about now that you've brought that up?
Also your statement on the 10th amendment is not what I said. You need to cite historical precedence when dealing with court rulings. You've made a broad stroke claim with no evidence to support it. Also it's entirely inaccurate anyway - it's about the states being able to make their own laws so long as they don't go against the federal constitution. States do have their own laws and they are very different from one another. Take for instance the state of Virginia and the laws about the percentage of the athletic department budget coming from subsidies as compared to what other states have.
The supreme court is not the only court that can neuter amendments
Also the 10th amendment is about the states having all the power the constitution did not explicitly grant the federal government. Here is the full text if you would like to read it
The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States respectively, or to the people.
So, I stand by my statement that the 10th amendment has been neutered
Sure, State courts could potentially neuter a constitutional amendment at the state level...and then they risk it being brought up against the supreme court and being overturned, because that's how the system is designed to work.
But again: this is about judges that Hillary Clinton could appoint as President. The President appoints federal judges, not state judges. This is 100% about federal judges and has been from the start. Any ruling that goes against the 2nd amendment entirely will be brought up through every court until it reaches the Supreme Court, there is quite literally no way the NRA would allow that to happen otherwise. Without a new law coming into effect, there will be no rulings of the sort. Any judge, regardless of where they are appointed (or elected) can only make a ruling on the cases brought to them. If no new laws come into play, then Clinton hasn't effected anything, and any ruling the court makes has nothing to do with her. If new laws come into play, then the house and senate have both approved them and it had nothing to do with the judges Clinton appointed.
Also you still haven't come up with anything of actual substance to prove your claim. Not a single court ruling, not a single actual source other than your own voice. I'm going to go ahead and assume you have nothing other than your personal beliefs on this until you attempt to prove otherwise.
You are on the losing side of that argument.
The more typing you do the more obvious it becomes that you aren't really sure about what you are talking about.
You're leading away from the original point.
Have the powers of the states been eroded by Federal judicial action? The answer is yes, and that isn't an ideological answer; that's a simple fact.
RE: Trump just dog whistled for some one to shoot HRC
(08-09-2016 03:33 PM)Max Power Wrote: The video speaks for itself.
Yep, and it doesn't say what you are insinuating that it says.
But here's my question. How is this somehow inciting people to attack Hillary, but, "What do we want? Dead cops. When do we want them? Now," somehow not inciting people to attack law enforcement officers? Where is the distinction?
RE: Trump just dog whistled for some one to shoot HRC
(08-09-2016 07:43 PM)e-parade Wrote:
(08-09-2016 07:25 PM)solohawks Wrote:
(08-09-2016 07:13 PM)e-parade Wrote:
(08-09-2016 07:00 PM)solohawks Wrote:
(08-09-2016 06:41 PM)e-parade Wrote: We're dealing with laws and court rulings here, so as per that standard please cite a historical reference where this happened.
Also are you seriously suggesting that the supreme court will just make up a decision on a hearing that's not happening? Do you know how things make it to being presented to the supreme court?
I said nothing of the sort. I said courts can neuter amendments with their rulings. You interpreted that as supreme court, why i do not know.
If you want examples of this see the 10th amendment. It is virtually meaningless as the feds control everything of consequence
It's interpreted as the supreme court because the conversation is about "Hillary picking her judges" and the 2nd amendment being taken away by them. Which other judges would be able to make a decision that has federal consequences (let's take gay marriage as an example: states made it legal or illegal, but it wasn't national policy until the supreme court heard the case)? This is a discussion on federal, not state, policy after all. So please, what else could this have been about now that you've brought that up?
Also your statement on the 10th amendment is not what I said. You need to cite historical precedence when dealing with court rulings. You've made a broad stroke claim with no evidence to support it. Also it's entirely inaccurate anyway - it's about the states being able to make their own laws so long as they don't go against the federal constitution. States do have their own laws and they are very different from one another. Take for instance the state of Virginia and the laws about the percentage of the athletic department budget coming from subsidies as compared to what other states have.
The supreme court is not the only court that can neuter amendments
Also the 10th amendment is about the states having all the power the constitution did not explicitly grant the federal government. Here is the full text if you would like to read it
The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States respectively, or to the people.
So, I stand by my statement that the 10th amendment has been neutered
Sure, State courts could potentially neuter a constitutional amendment at the state level...and then they risk it being brought up against the supreme court and being overturned, because that's how the system is designed to work.
But again: this is about judges that Hillary Clinton could appoint as President. The President appoints federal judges, not state judges. This is 100% about federal judges and has been from the start. Any ruling that goes against the 2nd amendment entirely will be brought up through every court until it reaches the Supreme Court, there is quite literally no way the NRA would allow that to happen otherwise. Without a new law coming into effect, there will be no rulings of the sort. Any judge, regardless of where they are appointed (or elected) can only make a ruling on the cases brought to them. If no new laws come into play, then Clinton hasn't effected anything, and any ruling the court makes has nothing to do with her. If new laws come into play, then the house and senate have both approved them and it had nothing to do with the judges Clinton appointed.
Also you still haven't come up with anything of actual substance to prove your claim. Not a single court ruling, not a single actual source other than your own voice. I'm going to go ahead and assume you have nothing other than your personal beliefs on this until you attempt to prove otherwise.
Start with the Jones & Laughlin Steel Corp. case in the depression and move on to the seminal case of Wickard v. Filburn which started the steady demise of the 10th. The line of laws passed by congress that took advantage of the ruling in Filburn to limit states rights and the cases that followed relating to the interstate commerce clause significantly limit the 10th Amendment's relevance....Reagan passed an executive order in the early 1980's mandating that executive agencies give states leeway in deference to the 10th amendment where ever possible....of course, Clinton revoked it in the mid 1990s by another executive order. The ICC is now so broadly interpreted that the 10th is relegated to a tiny corner and is virtually ignored.
RE: Trump just dog whistled for some one to shoot HRC
(08-09-2016 08:09 PM)rath v2.0 Wrote:
(08-09-2016 07:43 PM)e-parade Wrote:
(08-09-2016 07:25 PM)solohawks Wrote:
(08-09-2016 07:13 PM)e-parade Wrote:
(08-09-2016 07:00 PM)solohawks Wrote: I said nothing of the sort. I said courts can neuter amendments with their rulings. You interpreted that as supreme court, why i do not know.
If you want examples of this see the 10th amendment. It is virtually meaningless as the feds control everything of consequence
It's interpreted as the supreme court because the conversation is about "Hillary picking her judges" and the 2nd amendment being taken away by them. Which other judges would be able to make a decision that has federal consequences (let's take gay marriage as an example: states made it legal or illegal, but it wasn't national policy until the supreme court heard the case)? This is a discussion on federal, not state, policy after all. So please, what else could this have been about now that you've brought that up?
Also your statement on the 10th amendment is not what I said. You need to cite historical precedence when dealing with court rulings. You've made a broad stroke claim with no evidence to support it. Also it's entirely inaccurate anyway - it's about the states being able to make their own laws so long as they don't go against the federal constitution. States do have their own laws and they are very different from one another. Take for instance the state of Virginia and the laws about the percentage of the athletic department budget coming from subsidies as compared to what other states have.
The supreme court is not the only court that can neuter amendments
Also the 10th amendment is about the states having all the power the constitution did not explicitly grant the federal government. Here is the full text if you would like to read it
The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States respectively, or to the people.
So, I stand by my statement that the 10th amendment has been neutered
Sure, State courts could potentially neuter a constitutional amendment at the state level...and then they risk it being brought up against the supreme court and being overturned, because that's how the system is designed to work.
But again: this is about judges that Hillary Clinton could appoint as President. The President appoints federal judges, not state judges. This is 100% about federal judges and has been from the start. Any ruling that goes against the 2nd amendment entirely will be brought up through every court until it reaches the Supreme Court, there is quite literally no way the NRA would allow that to happen otherwise. Without a new law coming into effect, there will be no rulings of the sort. Any judge, regardless of where they are appointed (or elected) can only make a ruling on the cases brought to them. If no new laws come into play, then Clinton hasn't effected anything, and any ruling the court makes has nothing to do with her. If new laws come into play, then the house and senate have both approved them and it had nothing to do with the judges Clinton appointed.
Also you still haven't come up with anything of actual substance to prove your claim. Not a single court ruling, not a single actual source other than your own voice. I'm going to go ahead and assume you have nothing other than your personal beliefs on this until you attempt to prove otherwise.
Start with the Jones & Laughlin Steel Corp. case in the depression and move on to the seminal case of Wickard v. Filburn which started the steady demise of the 10th. The line of laws passed by congress that took advantage of the ruling in Filburn to limit states rights and the cases that followed relating to the interstate commerce clause significantly limit the 10th Amendment's relevance....Reagan passed an executive order in the early 1980's mandating that executive agencies give states leeway in deference to the 10th amendment where ever possible....of course, Clinton revoked it in the mid 1990s by another executive order. The ICC is now so broadly interpreted that the 10th is relegated to a tiny corner and is virtually ignored.
Wow that case was brutal for states rights. Obama care decision makes more sense now. If they can prohibit you from growing something so you have to buy it then its only logical they can prohibit you from not buying something so you have to buy it.
RE: Trump just dog whistled for some one to shoot HRC
They have been applying it every chance ever since. A few attempts over the years have been turned back by the USSC but the vast majority of the laws and agency actions pass commerce clause muster. Its just such a broad standard.
(This post was last modified: 08-09-2016 08:31 PM by rath v2.0.)
RE: Trump just dog whistled for some one to shoot HRC
(08-09-2016 08:08 PM)Owl 69/70/75 Wrote:
(08-09-2016 03:33 PM)Max Power Wrote: The video speaks for itself.
Yep, and it doesn't say what you are insinuating that it says.
But here's my question. How is this somehow inciting people to attack Hillary, but, "What do we want? Dead cops. When do we want them? Now," somehow not inciting people to attack law enforcement officers? Where is the distinction?
(False equivalency masterman)
For starters, what Trump said was a. by a presidential candidate and b. directed at a presidential candidate.
Second, I don't know who said that if anyone but I certainly never defended any such language. They're both pretty bad and if Hillary said either she would be rightly condemned on here.
Here's what Trump said:
“If she gets to pick her judges, nothing you can do, folks. Although the second amendment people, maybe there is, I don’t know."
Let's unpack this shall we? If she's "getting to pick her judges", she has already won the election and is president. And he's right-- at that point there's nothing you can do. Oh, but " maybe there is for the second amendment people.". Hmmmmm, what do the second amendment people have in common? What could they possibly have at their disposal that non second amendment people don't to stop her? That's a real head scratcher.
RE: Trump just dog whistled for some one to shoot HRC
I don't think Trump even meant to say what he said. I think it popped into his stream of consciousness and if Trump has a thought it's gonna fall out of his fat mouth.
RE: Trump just dog whistled for some one to shoot HRC
(08-09-2016 03:33 PM)Max Power Wrote: (False equivalency masterman)
Absolutely not.
Quote:For starters, what Trump said was a. by a presidential candidate
irrelevant
Quote:
and b. directed at a presidential candidate.
Maybe, maybe not. You're interpreting this based upon your own prejudices, see further discussion below.
Quote:Second, I don't know who said that if anyone but I certainly never defended any such language.
I don't remember whether you did or not, but there were plenty of your fellow travelers on the left insisting that BLM's calls to kill police weren't really calls to kill police. And, by the way, you never actually condemned BLM either, did you? Or did you? Should be easy to link where you did if you ever did. But of course you didn't, did you?
Quote:They're both pretty bad and if Hillary said either she would be rightly condemned on here.
Just like you condemned BLM, right?
Quote:Here's what Trump said:
“If she gets to pick her judges, nothing you can do, folks. Although the second amendment people, maybe there is, I don’t know."
Let's unpack this shall we? If she's "getting to pick her judges", she has already won the election and is president. And he's right-- at that point there's nothing you can do. Oh, but " maybe there is for the second amendment people.". Hmmmmm, what do the second amendment people have in common? What could they possibly have at their disposal that non second amendment people don't to stop her? That's a real head scratcher.
Stop playing dumb.
You are "unpacking" based upon your prejudices about how "second amendment people" think. I know lots of "second amendment people." I don't know as many as one who would ever think that shooting a president--or a supreme court justice--would be an appropriate response to any situation. Trump isn't calling for what you think he is calling for, because that's not what his audience is going to hear.
You're the one playing dumb.
(This post was last modified: 08-09-2016 09:40 PM by Owl 69/70/75.)
RE: Trump just dog whistled for some one to shoot HRC
Irony is the libtards who have been jumping up and down screaming about this have now probably put the idea in some knucklehead's noggin that didn't hear that in the original message to begin with.
RE: Trump just dog whistled for some one to shoot HRC
(08-09-2016 04:13 PM)TerryD Wrote:
(08-09-2016 04:03 PM)ODU BLUE Wrote:
(08-09-2016 03:59 PM)ark30inf Wrote:
(08-09-2016 03:47 PM)dbackjon Wrote:
(08-09-2016 03:34 PM)SuperFlyBCat Wrote: MSM is hell bent on grabbing and twisting anything Trump says into anything under the sun.
No, it is the blind Trump supporters that are doing the mental gymnastics to try to justify voting for a mentally unstable, treasonous, bad businessman, racist fool
I'm not voting for Trump. But what he meant was obvious. If 2nd Amendment rights are withheld...revolt.
Whether thats a good thing or bad thing to say is up for debate. But he wasn't referring to assassinating Hillary.
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-G870A using Tapatalk
People see right through the liberal media BS. Trump in a landslide!
You are setting yourself up for a meltdown like Karl Rove had on election night 2012.
Even the Fox News poll has her up 10 points. This one is over.
Now it looks like you're the one setting yourself up for a 2012 Karl Rove-like meltdown. It ain't over and you know it.
RE: Trump just dog whistled for some one to shoot HRC
(08-09-2016 04:55 PM)QuestionSocratic Wrote:
(08-09-2016 04:33 PM)Redwingtom Wrote:
(08-09-2016 04:13 PM)QuestionSocratic Wrote: I took it to mean that if you want to keep your second amendment rights as they now are, you need to make sure you get out and vote. But that's only me.
Interesting. That's pretty much exactly the Trump campaign damage control talking point on this. I'm sure it's just a coincidence.
But why would he only need the second amendment folks to make this happen? Aren't they pretty much all voting for him to begin with? So what else could they do outside of their votes.
It was a coincidence as I had not heard the campaign's response. But if you choose to believe I was just parroting their talking points, fine have at it. Not like I'm going to loose any respect for you over it, I have none.
And yes, they probably would all vote for Trump but they still have to show up. Turn out is a key.
...but are you going to tighten any respect for him? That is the question.
RE: Trump just dog whistled for some one to shoot HRC
This is so damn funny. Anyone with half a brain can listen to what Trump said and know that he means the political strength that the second amendment believers hold and how they will fight any attempt to take away the second amendment. The media is so blatantly twisting anything Trump says, they could eventually be the difference in Trump winning.
RE: Trump just dog whistled for some one to shoot HRC
(08-09-2016 11:21 PM)usmbacker Wrote: This is so damn funny. Anyone with half a brain can listen to what Trump said and know that he means the political strength that the second amendment believers hold and how they will fight any attempt to take away the second amendment. The media is so blatantly twisting anything Trump says, they could eventually be the difference in Trump winning.
What political strength would they have after the fact? He said if Hillary is president. They have no political strength to stop her after the fact.
RE: Trump just dog whistled for some one to shoot HRC
(08-09-2016 03:51 PM)wmubroncopilot Wrote: He's a buffoon. Whatever thought comes into his head just falls out of his stupid mouth. Someone needs to get him on a permanent teleprompter.
I seriously wonder at this point what it would take for people to stop supporting him (not the whacked out creepy alt-right that actually likes the **** he spews, but the ostensibly thinking people that are voting for him).
There are many Dylon Roof's out there that would take the word from Trump saying it is okay to kill Clinton.