Max Power
Not Rod Carey

Posts: 10,865
Joined: Oct 2008
Reputation: 303
I Root For: NIU, Bradley
Location: Peoria
|
RE: 4th Circuit Court of Appeals overturns North Carolina's voter suppression law
And no, NC doesn't have a "right" to do this. Supremacy Clause.
|
|
| 07-29-2016 01:20 PM |
|
200yrs2late
Resident Parrothead

Posts: 15,751
Joined: Jan 2010
Reputation: 846
I Root For: East Carolina
Location: SE of disorder
|
RE: 4th Circuit Court of Appeals overturns North Carolina's voter suppression law
(07-29-2016 12:37 PM)Max Power Wrote: You know I know and everyone and their dog knows AA's vote Democratic and the GOP has an interest in suppressing their turnout which is why these are put in place. There was never an avalanche of voter fraud cases compelling them to do this, it was a solution in search of a problem. Just admit it.
Quote:Opponents of the 2013 bill predicted that these reforms would disenfranchise minority voters and significantly suppress voter turnout. One source referred to the bill as “the worst voter suppression law in the country” and a “monster law.”[9] In September 2013, then-U.S. Attorney General Eric Holder claimed that “the clear and intended effects of these changes would contract the electorate and result in unequal access to participation in the political process on account of race.”[10]
These claims have turned out to be completely wrong. There has been no “suppression” of the turnout of North Carolina voters by any of these reform measures; in fact, turnout increased in the 2014 election—a sharp contrast to the rest of the country, which experienced a significant downturn in election turnout when compared to the previous midterm congressional election.
Quote:The results of the 2014 midterm primary and general election demonstrate that predictions that the North Carolina election law would “suppress” minority turnout were wrong; in North Carolina, turnout of voters in general, and of minority voters in particular, increased.
Quote:Camarota determined that blacks also “increased their share of those who voted from 17.2% of the total in the 2010 election to 19% in the 2014 election.” In contrast, the share of voters who were white declined.[24] Additionally, the percentage of “blacks registered in May 2014 relative to their population size was virtually unchanged from the May 2010 election.”[25] He concluded that the official turnout data from the North Carolina State Board of Elections “for the May 4, 2010 and May 6, 2014 elections show no evidence that H.B. 589 adversely impacted black participation.”
Quote:According to the United States Elections Project, 40.9 percent of the “Voting-Eligible Population” turned out in the 2014 general election in North Carolina.[33] In the United States as a whole, turnout was only 35.9 percent.[34] Four years earlier, in the 2010 general election, turnout in North Carolina was 39.2 percent, while turnout was 40.9 percent in the nation as a whole.[35]
As these numbers indicate, from 2010 to 2014, turnout increased in North Carolina by 1.7 percentage points, while turnout dropped nationwide by 5 percentage points. In fact, North Carolina was one of only 13 states that saw an increase in turnout between 2010 and 2014.
Quote:As a result of North Carolina’s changes in its election laws, including the elimination of same-day registration and the reduction in early voting, not only did turnout not decrease as opponents, including the U.S. Department of Justice, had predicted it would, but turnout actually went up. There was no “voter suppression.” In fact, the increase in turnout of minority voters was higher than the increase in turnout of white voters. It is clear that the claims made against North Carolina’s election reform law are unwarranted and that the pending court challenge to the state’s election reform bill should be rejected.
http://www.heritage.org/research/reports...uppression
But... but... racist!
|
|
| 07-29-2016 01:24 PM |
|
UofMstateU
Legend

Posts: 46,180
Joined: Dec 2009
Reputation: 4536
I Root For: Memphis
Location:
|
RE: 4th Circuit Court of Appeals overturns North Carolina's voter suppression law
(07-29-2016 01:20 PM)Max Power Wrote: And no, NC doesn't have a "right" to do this. Supremacy Clause.
They actually do.
Elections are handled at the state level. The reason the feds are trying to throw discrimination into the mix is because thats the only way they can control a states election.
How long have you been an attorney again? Did maybe you and Obama attend the same constititional law classes?
|
|
| 07-29-2016 01:25 PM |
|
solohawks
Legend

Posts: 25,727
Joined: May 2008
Reputation: 1187
I Root For: UNCW
Location: Wilmington, NC
|
RE: 4th Circuit Court of Appeals overturns North Carolina's voter suppression law
(07-29-2016 01:25 PM)UofMstateU Wrote: (07-29-2016 01:20 PM)Max Power Wrote: And no, NC doesn't have a "right" to do this. Supremacy Clause.
They actually do.
Elections are handled at the state level. The reason the feds are trying to throw discrimination into the mix is because thats the only way they can control a states election.
How long have you been an attorney again? Did maybe you and Obama attend the same constititional law classes?
This is why electoral reform is so hard to accomplish. Elections throughout our nation's history have always been at the state level. Like UofMstateU said, this is the only way the federal government can legally meddle in an election
|
|
| 07-29-2016 01:29 PM |
|
Max Power
Not Rod Carey

Posts: 10,865
Joined: Oct 2008
Reputation: 303
I Root For: NIU, Bradley
Location: Peoria
|
RE: 4th Circuit Court of Appeals overturns North Carolina's voter suppression law
(07-29-2016 01:25 PM)UofMstateU Wrote: (07-29-2016 01:20 PM)Max Power Wrote: And no, NC doesn't have a "right" to do this. Supremacy Clause.
They actually do.
Elections are handled at the state level. The reason the feds are trying to throw discrimination into the mix is because thats the only way they can control a states election.
How long have you been an attorney again? Did maybe you and Obama attend the same constititional law classes?
You again don't know what you're talking about. The enforcement of federal law trumps any and all conflicting state law. So no, obviously they don't have the right to do this.
|
|
| 07-29-2016 01:33 PM |
|
Max Power
Not Rod Carey

Posts: 10,865
Joined: Oct 2008
Reputation: 303
I Root For: NIU, Bradley
Location: Peoria
|
RE: 4th Circuit Court of Appeals overturns North Carolina's voter suppression law
(07-29-2016 01:29 PM)solohawks Wrote: (07-29-2016 01:25 PM)UofMstateU Wrote: (07-29-2016 01:20 PM)Max Power Wrote: And no, NC doesn't have a "right" to do this. Supremacy Clause.
They actually do.
Elections are handled at the state level. The reason the feds are trying to throw discrimination into the mix is because thats the only way they can control a states election.
How long have you been an attorney again? Did maybe you and Obama attend the same constititional law classes?
This is why electoral reform is so hard to accomplish. Elections throughout our nation's history have always been at the state level. Like UofMstateU said, this is the only way the federal government can legally meddle in an election
The government can "meddle" via enforcement of the US Constitution and the Voting Rights Act, yes.
|
|
| 07-29-2016 01:34 PM |
|
UofMstateU
Legend

Posts: 46,180
Joined: Dec 2009
Reputation: 4536
I Root For: Memphis
Location:
|
RE: 4th Circuit Court of Appeals overturns North Carolina's voter suppression law
(07-29-2016 01:33 PM)Max Power Wrote: (07-29-2016 01:25 PM)UofMstateU Wrote: (07-29-2016 01:20 PM)Max Power Wrote: And no, NC doesn't have a "right" to do this. Supremacy Clause.
They actually do.
Elections are handled at the state level. The reason the feds are trying to throw discrimination into the mix is because thats the only way they can control a states election.
How long have you been an attorney again? Did maybe you and Obama attend the same constititional law classes?
You again don't know what you're talking about. The enforcement of federal law trumps any and all conflicting state law. So no, obviously they don't have the right to do this.
Your malpractice insurance payments must be thru the roof.
|
|
| 07-29-2016 01:36 PM |
|
Max Power
Not Rod Carey

Posts: 10,865
Joined: Oct 2008
Reputation: 303
I Root For: NIU, Bradley
Location: Peoria
|
RE: 4th Circuit Court of Appeals overturns North Carolina's voter suppression law
(07-29-2016 01:24 PM)200yrs2late Wrote: (07-29-2016 12:37 PM)Max Power Wrote: You know I know and everyone and their dog knows AA's vote Democratic and the GOP has an interest in suppressing their turnout which is why these are put in place. There was never an avalanche of voter fraud cases compelling them to do this, it was a solution in search of a problem. Just admit it.
Quote:Opponents of the 2013 bill predicted that these reforms would disenfranchise minority voters and significantly suppress voter turnout. One source referred to the bill as “the worst voter suppression law in the country” and a “monster law.”[9] In September 2013, then-U.S. Attorney General Eric Holder claimed that “the clear and intended effects of these changes would contract the electorate and result in unequal access to participation in the political process on account of race.”[10]
These claims have turned out to be completely wrong. There has been no “suppression” of the turnout of North Carolina voters by any of these reform measures; in fact, turnout increased in the 2014 election—a sharp contrast to the rest of the country, which experienced a significant downturn in election turnout when compared to the previous midterm congressional election.
Quote:The results of the 2014 midterm primary and general election demonstrate that predictions that the North Carolina election law would “suppress” minority turnout were wrong; in North Carolina, turnout of voters in general, and of minority voters in particular, increased.
Quote:Camarota determined that blacks also “increased their share of those who voted from 17.2% of the total in the 2010 election to 19% in the 2014 election.” In contrast, the share of voters who were white declined.[24] Additionally, the percentage of “blacks registered in May 2014 relative to their population size was virtually unchanged from the May 2010 election.”[25] He concluded that the official turnout data from the North Carolina State Board of Elections “for the May 4, 2010 and May 6, 2014 elections show no evidence that H.B. 589 adversely impacted black participation.”
Quote:According to the United States Elections Project, 40.9 percent of the “Voting-Eligible Population” turned out in the 2014 general election in North Carolina.[33] In the United States as a whole, turnout was only 35.9 percent.[34] Four years earlier, in the 2010 general election, turnout in North Carolina was 39.2 percent, while turnout was 40.9 percent in the nation as a whole.[35]
As these numbers indicate, from 2010 to 2014, turnout increased in North Carolina by 1.7 percentage points, while turnout dropped nationwide by 5 percentage points. In fact, North Carolina was one of only 13 states that saw an increase in turnout between 2010 and 2014.
Quote:As a result of North Carolina’s changes in its election laws, including the elimination of same-day registration and the reduction in early voting, not only did turnout not decrease as opponents, including the U.S. Department of Justice, had predicted it would, but turnout actually went up. There was no “voter suppression.” In fact, the increase in turnout of minority voters was higher than the increase in turnout of white voters. It is clear that the claims made against North Carolina’s election reform law are unwarranted and that the pending court challenge to the state’s election reform bill should be rejected.
http://www.heritage.org/research/reports...uppression
But... but... racist!
What happened after the fact isn't relevant for the purposes of determining a VRA violation. It's true that it blew up in their faces a bit because of the outrage in the AA community, and the Moral Monday movement sprung up. None of that matters though. The law needs to be overturned, even if ironically doing so would be doing the GOP a favor.
|
|
| 07-29-2016 01:37 PM |
|
Max Power
Not Rod Carey

Posts: 10,865
Joined: Oct 2008
Reputation: 303
I Root For: NIU, Bradley
Location: Peoria
|
RE: 4th Circuit Court of Appeals overturns North Carolina's voter suppression law
(07-29-2016 01:36 PM)UofMstateU Wrote: (07-29-2016 01:33 PM)Max Power Wrote: (07-29-2016 01:25 PM)UofMstateU Wrote: (07-29-2016 01:20 PM)Max Power Wrote: And no, NC doesn't have a "right" to do this. Supremacy Clause.
They actually do.
Elections are handled at the state level. The reason the feds are trying to throw discrimination into the mix is because thats the only way they can control a states election.
How long have you been an attorney again? Did maybe you and Obama attend the same constititional law classes?
You again don't know what you're talking about. The enforcement of federal law trumps any and all conflicting state law. So no, obviously they don't have the right to do this.
Your malpractice insurance payments must be thru the roof.
What part of what I said is incorrect and/or you don't understand?
|
|
| 07-29-2016 01:38 PM |
|
UofMstateU
Legend

Posts: 46,180
Joined: Dec 2009
Reputation: 4536
I Root For: Memphis
Location:
|
RE: 4th Circuit Court of Appeals overturns North Carolina's voter suppression law
(07-29-2016 01:38 PM)Max Power Wrote: (07-29-2016 01:36 PM)UofMstateU Wrote: (07-29-2016 01:33 PM)Max Power Wrote: (07-29-2016 01:25 PM)UofMstateU Wrote: (07-29-2016 01:20 PM)Max Power Wrote: And no, NC doesn't have a "right" to do this. Supremacy Clause.
They actually do.
Elections are handled at the state level. The reason the feds are trying to throw discrimination into the mix is because thats the only way they can control a states election.
How long have you been an attorney again? Did maybe you and Obama attend the same constititional law classes?
You again don't know what you're talking about. The enforcement of federal law trumps any and all conflicting state law. So no, obviously they don't have the right to do this.
Your malpractice insurance payments must be thru the roof.
What part of what I said is incorrect and/or you don't understand?
You part was a butthurt diversion point that had nothing to do with what I said.
True or False - elections are handled by the states?
|
|
| 07-29-2016 01:40 PM |
|
Max Power
Not Rod Carey

Posts: 10,865
Joined: Oct 2008
Reputation: 303
I Root For: NIU, Bradley
Location: Peoria
|
RE: 4th Circuit Court of Appeals overturns North Carolina's voter suppression law
They're handled at the state level insofar as they don't conflict with federal law. The 4th Cir CoA found that they do on this, ergo, they don't have a right to do it. Capiche?
|
|
| 07-29-2016 01:49 PM |
|
UofMstateU
Legend

Posts: 46,180
Joined: Dec 2009
Reputation: 4536
I Root For: Memphis
Location:
|
RE: 4th Circuit Court of Appeals overturns North Carolina's voter suppression law
(07-29-2016 01:49 PM)Max Power Wrote: They're handled at the state level insofar as they don't conflict with federal law. The 4th Cir CoA found that they do on this, ergo, they don't have a right to do it. Capiche?
So now you are agreeing with me that the feds cant do anything, unless they try to push some sort of constitutional violation? So call anything discrimination and they can butt in.
|
|
| 07-29-2016 01:51 PM |
|
Bull_In_Exile
Eternal Pessimist

Posts: 21,736
Joined: Jun 2009
Reputation: 461
I Root For: The Underdog
Location:
|
RE: 4th Circuit Court of Appeals overturns North Carolina's voter suppression law
(07-29-2016 01:37 PM)Max Power Wrote: What happened after the fact isn't relevant for the purposes of determining a VRA violation.
So a law you say would suppressed the vote did not suppress the vote but that fact is unimportant...
Wow and folks wonder why lawyers are seen by many as slimy soulless hacks. You give the profession a bad name.
|
|
| 07-29-2016 01:52 PM |
|
200yrs2late
Resident Parrothead

Posts: 15,751
Joined: Jan 2010
Reputation: 846
I Root For: East Carolina
Location: SE of disorder
|
RE: 4th Circuit Court of Appeals overturns North Carolina's voter suppression law
(07-29-2016 01:37 PM)Max Power Wrote: (07-29-2016 01:24 PM)200yrs2late Wrote: (07-29-2016 12:37 PM)Max Power Wrote: You know I know and everyone and their dog knows AA's vote Democratic and the GOP has an interest in suppressing their turnout which is why these are put in place. There was never an avalanche of voter fraud cases compelling them to do this, it was a solution in search of a problem. Just admit it.
Quote:Opponents of the 2013 bill predicted that these reforms would disenfranchise minority voters and significantly suppress voter turnout. One source referred to the bill as “the worst voter suppression law in the country” and a “monster law.”[9] In September 2013, then-U.S. Attorney General Eric Holder claimed that “the clear and intended effects of these changes would contract the electorate and result in unequal access to participation in the political process on account of race.”[10]
These claims have turned out to be completely wrong. There has been no “suppression” of the turnout of North Carolina voters by any of these reform measures; in fact, turnout increased in the 2014 election—a sharp contrast to the rest of the country, which experienced a significant downturn in election turnout when compared to the previous midterm congressional election.
Quote:The results of the 2014 midterm primary and general election demonstrate that predictions that the North Carolina election law would “suppress” minority turnout were wrong; in North Carolina, turnout of voters in general, and of minority voters in particular, increased.
Quote:Camarota determined that blacks also “increased their share of those who voted from 17.2% of the total in the 2010 election to 19% in the 2014 election.” In contrast, the share of voters who were white declined.[24] Additionally, the percentage of “blacks registered in May 2014 relative to their population size was virtually unchanged from the May 2010 election.”[25] He concluded that the official turnout data from the North Carolina State Board of Elections “for the May 4, 2010 and May 6, 2014 elections show no evidence that H.B. 589 adversely impacted black participation.”
Quote:According to the United States Elections Project, 40.9 percent of the “Voting-Eligible Population” turned out in the 2014 general election in North Carolina.[33] In the United States as a whole, turnout was only 35.9 percent.[34] Four years earlier, in the 2010 general election, turnout in North Carolina was 39.2 percent, while turnout was 40.9 percent in the nation as a whole.[35]
As these numbers indicate, from 2010 to 2014, turnout increased in North Carolina by 1.7 percentage points, while turnout dropped nationwide by 5 percentage points. In fact, North Carolina was one of only 13 states that saw an increase in turnout between 2010 and 2014.
Quote:As a result of North Carolina’s changes in its election laws, including the elimination of same-day registration and the reduction in early voting, not only did turnout not decrease as opponents, including the U.S. Department of Justice, had predicted it would, but turnout actually went up. There was no “voter suppression.” In fact, the increase in turnout of minority voters was higher than the increase in turnout of white voters. It is clear that the claims made against North Carolina’s election reform law are unwarranted and that the pending court challenge to the state’s election reform bill should be rejected.
http://www.heritage.org/research/reports...uppression
But... but... racist!
What happened after the fact isn't relevant for the purposes of determining a VRA violation. It's true that it blew up in their faces a bit because of the outrage in the AA community, and the Moral Monday movement sprung up. None of that matters though. The law needs to be overturned, even if ironically doing so would be doing the GOP a favor.
It doesn't matter in determining whether or not there was a violation, but it is relevant for evaluating whether the judgement reached by the court is valid after the fact. What we have is a court saying that AA have been disenfranchised and denied equal opportunity to vote based off past assumptions that poorer, mostly rural AA that are less educated won't know how to go about voting or face unfair obstacles by having to obtain an ID (for which they need to do just about every aspect of daily living now and the VAST majority are proven to have) versus the empirical data in the election since the law was enacted that demonstrates those assumptions to be absolutely incorrect. Voter turnout increased in NC after the passage of the law, contrary to the vast majority of states. Not only that, but AA turnout increased at a higher rate than white turnout while AA registration relative to % of population remained unchanged. Two key pieces of evidence that the law did not represent a discriminatory effort to limit access to voting for AA's.
|
|
| 07-29-2016 01:52 PM |
|
200yrs2late
Resident Parrothead

Posts: 15,751
Joined: Jan 2010
Reputation: 846
I Root For: East Carolina
Location: SE of disorder
|
RE: 4th Circuit Court of Appeals overturns North Carolina's voter suppression law
(07-29-2016 01:51 PM)UofMstateU Wrote: (07-29-2016 01:49 PM)Max Power Wrote: They're handled at the state level insofar as they don't conflict with federal law. The 4th Cir CoA found that they do on this, ergo, they don't have a right to do it. Capiche?
So now you are agreeing with me that the feds cant do anything, unless they try to push some sort of constitutional violation? So call anything discrimination and they can butt in.
That's the way it works. Not only that, but in many cases changes aren't even allowed due to perceived or potential discrimination, despite what the facts show.
|
|
| 07-29-2016 01:54 PM |
|
john01992
Former ESPNer still in recovery mode
Posts: 16,233
Joined: Jul 2013
I Root For: John0 out!!!!
Location: The Worst P5 Program
|
RE: 4th Circuit Court of Appeals overturns North Carolina's voter suppression law
so much crying by the cons in this thread.
|
|
| 07-29-2016 01:54 PM |
|
UofMstateU
Legend

Posts: 46,180
Joined: Dec 2009
Reputation: 4536
I Root For: Memphis
Location:
|
RE: 4th Circuit Court of Appeals overturns North Carolina's voter suppression law
(07-29-2016 01:54 PM)john01992 Wrote: so much crying by the cons in this thread.
crying foul on judicial activism. as any true american patriot should. oh ,wait, sorry. I forgot, you are with the party that just booed a cop that gave a speech, and booed our military. I may have to define the term american patriot to you.
|
|
| 07-29-2016 01:57 PM |
|
Max Power
Not Rod Carey

Posts: 10,865
Joined: Oct 2008
Reputation: 303
I Root For: NIU, Bradley
Location: Peoria
|
RE: 4th Circuit Court of Appeals overturns North Carolina's voter suppression law
(07-29-2016 01:51 PM)UofMstateU Wrote: (07-29-2016 01:49 PM)Max Power Wrote: They're handled at the state level insofar as they don't conflict with federal law. The 4th Cir CoA found that they do on this, ergo, they don't have a right to do it. Capiche?
So now you are agreeing with me that the feds cant do anything, unless they try to push some sort of constitutional violation? So call anything discrimination and they can butt in.
The Constitution -- and VRA -- were there long, long before the 2013 NC voter suppression law was enacted. You've got it backwards. It's the NC law that's "butting in." And everyone can always "push some sort of constitutional violation" because it's the highest law of the land. You conservatives used to have some reverence for it if I recall.
|
|
| 07-29-2016 01:58 PM |
|
Max Power
Not Rod Carey

Posts: 10,865
Joined: Oct 2008
Reputation: 303
I Root For: NIU, Bradley
Location: Peoria
|
RE: 4th Circuit Court of Appeals overturns North Carolina's voter suppression law
(07-29-2016 01:52 PM)Bull_In_Exile Wrote: (07-29-2016 01:37 PM)Max Power Wrote: What happened after the fact isn't relevant for the purposes of determining a VRA violation.
So a law you say would suppressed the vote did not suppress the vote but that fact is unimportant...
Wow and folks wonder why lawyers are seen by many as slimy soulless hacks. You give the profession a bad name.
First of all, it's only been one cycle. It caused outrage, which drove up turnout a bit, but that outrage will likely subside and work its suppression magic in the long run.
Second, I didn't write the law.
(This post was last modified: 07-29-2016 02:00 PM by Max Power.)
|
|
| 07-29-2016 02:00 PM |
|
solohawks
Legend

Posts: 25,727
Joined: May 2008
Reputation: 1187
I Root For: UNCW
Location: Wilmington, NC
|
RE: 4th Circuit Court of Appeals overturns North Carolina's voter suppression law
Max, do you support the election of judges?
The reason I ask is most liberals I know feel that politicizes the court. What do you say?
|
|
| 07-29-2016 02:06 PM |
|