(08-07-2015 01:21 PM)rosewater Wrote: (08-07-2015 10:58 AM)StillJonesing Wrote: (08-07-2015 10:48 AM)rosewater Wrote: It is hard to say what will happen. Qb is a unique position that success has a lot to do with knowledge of a system and whether the system fits the quarterbacks style. I know we(Cincinnati) brought in a former 5 star starter at Notre Dame and he ended up at linebacker before he quit. He obviously did not fit our system. On the other hand, we have had Gunner(former 5 star Notre Dame transfer) come in and play very well.
Like I said before. Dominque Davis had been a crappy starter at Boston College and couldn't practice until fall camp that first year because of academics. He seemliness transitioned into the system with no problem and had one of the best years in college football that first year. Whoever starts in this system will put up production. That's all I know and really care about. If not this guy someone else and he appears like he can play TE, WR or something as athletic as he is too. Wouldn't worry to much about coming in late though.
Are you trying to say that you can transition anyone into the starting qb role regardless of skills and experience and they will excel. That is just naïve and foolish. Sure you can cherry pick and find some examples, but it is not the norm. Like I said earlier, our system worked out well for 5 star transfer Gunnar Kiel, but not for 5 star transfer Demetrious Jones.
#1 I don't give a crap about high school rankings when they have been in college several years and actually on the field. Maybe Kiel was just that good and a legit big time prospect and that's why it worked for you but I think our system has proven over an over it can take marginal talents and make them some of the most productive QB's in the history of the NCAA. Carden was a nobody recruit for example and we just rolled him into the system and produced. I'd rather have it that way too and not have to have to constantly recruit the next Bortles to have a big time offense.
Texas Tech
Kingsbury: 6th round, 2 NFL passes
Symons: 7th round never played a down
Cumbie: undrafted never played a down
Hodges: undrafted never played a down
Harrell: undrafted 4 NFL passes
Potts: undrafted, never played a down
ECU
Davis undrafted, 7 NFL passes
Carden undrafted
So 13 NFL passes and 2 late draft picks early on in 15 years worth of QB's that all put up monster passing stats with pretty marginal actual talent.
Give me the system that puts up hundreds of yards a game on everyone, including the Texas and Oklahoma's of the world with very marginal talent. It's not even like Texas Tech had a lot of other NFL talent either around them. TT had like 10 total picks on offense in 10 years under Leach and we had about 7 here for perspective, despite putting up top 10 offenses in the Big 12. It's a system that maximizes talent and produces simple as that.