(12-27-2013 12:13 PM)BruceMcF Wrote: (12-26-2013 03:08 PM)omniorange Wrote: That "standing" is already in jeopardy, if not for Nova this year.
So, in other words, assume their strongest school drops down, and don't assume that anyone else rises up, and voila. However, they are presently #3 on conference RPI, even with the rest of the conference several steps below Nova in team RPI, so transferring the hypothetical collapse into the real world would seem to be premature.
I'm talking about "standing with" the P5. Will the BE likely be the "best of the rest" for the foreseeable future. Yes. But my stance has been that they would hang with the P5 for the next 5-10 years before becoming what the A10 has been to the P6 over the past decade - a conference that would occasionally get to the number 4 or 5 level, but not consistently.
No one cares where a conference resides RPI-wise. The smart ones know that RPI is easier to rig than the BCS system is. What folks care about is - who have you beaten and where did you beat them. I'm shocked that the BE has no quality wins outside of Nova beating Kansas and Iowa. And it wouldn't surprise me to see them upset SU tomorrow. But outside of Nova, there just aren't any wins that will make the committee sit up and take notice. None.
I'd have bet my life on this year's BE teams having Georgetown beating Oregon, Marquette beating either Wisconsin or SD State, Butler beating either Okla State or LSU, Creighton beating SD State, etc.
Get even a few of those wins and add them to the scalps Nova has already taken and then the league has an opportunity to grow further with the in conference schedules.
Now, before someone goes on about the ACC, as the Creighton fan did, they should research my posts. If they did they would see where I took the stance that the ACC would not simply become overnight "the greatest basketball conference of all-time" just by stating it.
Rather my stance has been it would take at least three to four years for the synergy of the new arrivals to mix with the old to get it BE circa 2009-2013 levels. And we see that the ACC, has indeed, had a pedestrian start on the road to becoming the best basketball conference.
But even that pedestrian start has multiple teams with high profiles wins and mid-level conference teams with wins as good as everyone else in the Big East outside of Nova.
Cheers,
Neil