this point in his career? I contend he's a much better rebounder, as good a slashing type scorer around the basket, not as good from the perimeter, and definitely not as good at the free throw line. Defensively he might be as good, just not as long. If he can somehow learn to shoot free throws, and I've seen him make some nice perimeter shots, he could be just as good by next year as Shane was his senior year.
Of course he won't have Stevie, Fowler, Matt, BP and Mike Smith around to help.