DavidSt
Legend

Posts: 27,067
Joined: Dec 2013
Reputation: 1157
I Root For: ATU, P7
Location:
|
RE: Biden* Calls for 'Humanitarian Pause' Between Israel-Hamas
(11-02-2023 08:35 PM)ODUsmitty Wrote: My knowledge weakness in this discussion is whether the Gazan people support Hamas as their government, or if this terrorist group was imposed upon them. My view of how I would hope Israel would respond really hinges on that basic question. Could someone with deeper historical knowledge of this situation chime in?
EDIT: If the Hamas spokesman is to be believed when saying the tunnels are for the fighters, and the Gazan people are the responsibility of Israel/UN, then I would unambiguously support action to the tunnels themselves, hostages or not.
The problem is if you continue killing innocent people trying to go after Hamas in a small area? Imagine the war takes place in NYC and the metro cities around them? You would lose a log of lives in NYC trying to go after the terrorists. What it does in many innocent lives including children would help terrorists to recruit new people who are angered at the butchering of children and all that. When we went to war with ISIS, and Bin Laden? We made sure that innocent lives not to be taken. The problem with the Gaza Strip? It is slam packed with people, it is hard to move people from one spot to another which makes it even more overcrowded. This is why Israel and BIBI gets criticized as they hit neighborhoods, hospitals, ambulances, etc with a lot of innocent people are at or using. Close to 10,000 innocent lives in Gaza Strip have been killed who have nothing to do with Hamas. The political portion of the Hamas from what I understand is upset with the military part of Hamas. There seems to be some striff between the two. It was the same when PLO with Arafat made peace with Israel that some people broke away from him, and created new terror groups.
|
|
| 11-04-2023 05:52 AM |
|
stinkfist
nuts zongo's in the house

Posts: 86,729
Joined: Nov 2011
Reputation: 11982
I Root For: Mustard Buzzards
Location: Hell House
|
RE: Biden* Calls for 'Humanitarian Pause' Between Israel-Hamas
(11-04-2023 05:52 AM)DavidSt Wrote: (11-02-2023 08:35 PM)ODUsmitty Wrote: My knowledge weakness in this discussion is whether the Gazan people support Hamas as their government, or if this terrorist group was imposed upon them. My view of how I would hope Israel would respond really hinges on that basic question. Could someone with deeper historical knowledge of this situation chime in?
EDIT: If the Hamas spokesman is to be believed when saying the tunnels are for the fighters, and the Gazan people are the responsibility of Israel/UN, then I would unambiguously support action to the tunnels themselves, hostages or not.
The problem is if you continue killing innocent people trying to go after Hamas in a small area? Imagine the war takes place in NYC and the metro cities around them? You would lose a log of lives in NYC trying to go after the terrorists. What it does in many innocent lives including children would help terrorists to recruit new people who are angered at the butchering of children and all that. When we went to war with ISIS, and Bin Laden? We made sure that innocent lives not to be taken. The problem with the Gaza Strip? It is slam packed with people, it is hard to move people from one spot to another which makes it even more overcrowded. This is why Israel and BIBI gets criticized as they hit neighborhoods, hospitals, ambulances, etc with a lot of innocent people are at or using. Close to 10,000 innocent lives in Gaza Strip have been killed who have nothing to do with Hamas. The political portion of the Hamas from what I understand is upset with the military part of Hamas. There seems to be some striff between the two. It was the same when PLO with Arafat made peace with Israel that some people broke away from him, and created new terror groups.
like bidet*, you need to go Rip Van Winkle on this ... just dayum, son!
|
|
| 11-04-2023 07:31 AM |
|