Hello There, Guest! Registered users see far less ads! Register today and join our virtual tailgate. (Login — Register)

Post Reply 
Lets Talk Expansion Again
Author Message
Bookmark and Share
3DogNight Offline
1st String
*

Posts: 1,157
Joined: Nov 2021
Reputation: 121
I Root For: Liberty
Location:
Post: #501
RE: Lets Talk Expansion Again
(09-24-2024 09:54 AM)inutech Wrote:  
(09-24-2024 09:31 AM)BlueRaiderDave Wrote:  And now we are seeing the benefit of adding Delaware and MO State.

You think they wouldn't have come if we had only invited them after a potential NMSU/UTEP departure? Was being in a conference with UTEP/NMSU a big selling point to Delaware? Or Missouri State? I don't know the history or interest level between those schools (I'm honestly asking, but I have a guess).

Because if they still would have joined, what's different?

We’ll never really know. If CUSA had waited, they might have looked at it as an act of desperation and might have had reservations unless they just wanted to move up regardless (reactive). Maybe not. Perhaps they were more willing to accept an invitation because they believed that CUSA was a conference who wanted grow and become stronger (proactive). Maybe not. I’m happy that Liberty is a member of this conference, but I know the only reason we’re here is because of a reaction of desperation. Trust me when I say that it would be much better to be asked out of desire rather than desperation.

If we lose NMSU and UTEP, I’m all for staying at 10. Not because I think smaller is better, but because I don’t think there’s FCS teams out there that would benefit CUSA at this point in time. But if the MW is depleted to the point that what’s left of it is looking for a new home, sign me up. I believe that a lot of the uncertainty and confusion that we have witnessed in the last few days is a result of reactive actions, not proactive decisions. I personally would rather be a member of a conference who has a strategic plan and vision. Not one that flies by the seat of their pants and only reacts because they are forced to because of circumstances. But that’s just me. I might be the only one who thinks this way.
09-24-2024 11:16 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
inutech Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,764
Joined: Dec 2014
Reputation: 670
I Root For: Louisiana Tech
Location:
Post: #502
RE: Lets Talk Expansion Again
(09-24-2024 10:44 AM)BlueRaiderDave Wrote:  
(09-24-2024 09:54 AM)inutech Wrote:  
(09-24-2024 09:31 AM)BlueRaiderDave Wrote:  And now we are seeing the benefit of adding Delaware and MO State.

You think they wouldn't have come if we had only invited them after a potential NMSU/UTEP departure? Was being in a conference with UTEP/NMSU a big selling point to Delaware? Or Missouri State? I don't know the history or interest level between those schools (I'm honestly asking, but I have a guess).

Because if they still would have joined, what's different?

The difference is that if NMSU and UTEP leave we still have ten.

If we hadn't added them already, and then UTEP/NMSU left, and then we added them at that time - we still have ten.

So what's the difference? What is the benefit that we are now seeing of having already added them? Just the hassle of inviting them later/now is already over? And the risk that they wouldn't join?
09-24-2024 11:18 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
inutech Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,764
Joined: Dec 2014
Reputation: 670
I Root For: Louisiana Tech
Location:
Post: #503
RE: Lets Talk Expansion Again
(09-24-2024 11:16 AM)3DogNight Wrote:  I personally would rather be a member of a conference who has a strategic plan and vision. Not one that flies by the seat of their pants and only reacts because they are forced to because of circumstances. But that’s just me. I might be the only one who thinks this way.

I agree that a smaller conference with a plan (like, say, if we lose this team or that team or this pair of teams, we'll invite this other team or pair of teams) is much better than any sized conference without a plan.

I don't think you're the only one who thinks a plan is good.
09-24-2024 11:21 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
inutech Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,764
Joined: Dec 2014
Reputation: 670
I Root For: Louisiana Tech
Location:
Post: #504
RE: Lets Talk Expansion Again
(09-24-2024 11:10 AM)freshtop Wrote:  Respect Hawaii as a program, don't see the logic in adding them to CUSA.

I'm very skeptical of that "source."
09-24-2024 11:21 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
SlyFox Offline
1st String
*

Posts: 1,993
Joined: Feb 2010
Reputation: 125
I Root For: Liberty
Location: Lake Conroe, Texas
Post: #505
RE: Lets Talk Expansion Again
I can see Judy working. Schools that travel to Hawaii get that 13th game which as a P4 guarantee game can more than cover the costs of the trip to the Islands. It also opens up another window for the television partners and provides additional inventory. This is not the crazy talk that most assumed when the rumors started surfacing.

But it will require a specific set of circumstances for this to go down. I like seeing people covering all of their bases.
09-24-2024 11:41 AM
Visit this user's website Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
3DogNight Offline
1st String
*

Posts: 1,157
Joined: Nov 2021
Reputation: 121
I Root For: Liberty
Location:
Post: #506
RE: Lets Talk Expansion Again
(09-24-2024 11:21 AM)inutech Wrote:  
(09-24-2024 11:16 AM)3DogNight Wrote:  I personally would rather be a member of a conference who has a strategic plan and vision. Not one that flies by the seat of their pants and only reacts because they are forced to because of circumstances. But that’s just me. I might be the only one who thinks this way.

I agree that a smaller conference with a plan (like, say, if we lose this team or that team or this pair of teams, we'll invite this other team or pair of teams) is much better than any sized conference without a plan.

I don't think you're the only one who thinks a plan is good.
If you haven’t already noticed, there’s slim pickings when it comes to serious opinions for schools to choose as backfills. And as time passes, it will only get slimmer. I would love to hear who you think all these qualified members in waiting are. If you know that a flood is coming, you don’t wait until the water is rising to start putting out the sandbags. You put out the sandbags before the water begins to rise. That’s the difference between having a reactive plan and a proactive plan. That’s the difference between the SEC and B1G compared to the ACC and the PAC 12. Proactive versus reactive. I think the Big 12 saw the writing on the wall and became proactive. They didn’t wait around to be forced into adding schools. They got ahead of the game. Being reactive instead of being proactive is the reason the PAC 12 isn’t a “power conference” anymore. The difference between the SBC and the MAC verses CUSA, MW and the AAC. Proactive versus reactive. I don’t think anyone would argue that the conferences that have been proactive are much more stable than the ones who have been reactive.
09-24-2024 12:08 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
inutech Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,764
Joined: Dec 2014
Reputation: 670
I Root For: Louisiana Tech
Location:
Post: #507
RE: Lets Talk Expansion Again
(09-24-2024 12:08 PM)3DogNight Wrote:  
(09-24-2024 11:21 AM)inutech Wrote:  
(09-24-2024 11:16 AM)3DogNight Wrote:  I personally would rather be a member of a conference who has a strategic plan and vision. Not one that flies by the seat of their pants and only reacts because they are forced to because of circumstances. But that’s just me. I might be the only one who thinks this way.

I agree that a smaller conference with a plan (like, say, if we lose this team or that team or this pair of teams, we'll invite this other team or pair of teams) is much better than any sized conference without a plan.

I don't think you're the only one who thinks a plan is good.
If you haven’t already noticed, there’s slim pickings when it comes to serious opinions for schools to choose as backfills. And as time passes, it will only get slimmer. I would love to hear who you think all these qualified members in waiting are.

KSU, Delaware, and Missouri State.

That was my point.


A rational, proactive plan could have been "ok, we're at 9 - that's enough, perfect for football - if weird stuff happens in the future, let's keep working with this group of X schools and if we lose a couple more schools, we'll bring them in."

And it's true that another "proactive" plan might have been "we're pretty sure more change is coming, and we're pretty sure our favorite targets will be less likely to join if we go down a couple of schools, or the risk of a chain reaction might be too high to risk, so let's go ahead and go to 12 now."

And for all we know they have brilliant contingency plans for losing 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, or 7 more schools. It's possible.

Choosing to stay at any particular number of schools may be "reactionary" but it might also be a proactive choice. Choosing not to do the wrong thing is still a choice.
09-24-2024 12:52 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
redfan Offline
2nd String
*

Posts: 383
Joined: Feb 2012
Reputation: 9
I Root For: all
Location:
Post: #508
RE: Lets Talk Expansion Again
It would be proactive to cover the loss of another , a third member, at least temporarily so the conference doesn't drop below ten. It gives time to find a better replacement. Just a possibility.
09-24-2024 12:53 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Baldspot Offline
Special Teams
*

Posts: 793
Joined: Oct 2022
Reputation: 65
I Root For: Liberty
Location:
Post: #509
RE: Lets Talk Expansion Again
Not saying I support the move but I think CUSA teams could legitimately only play at Hawaii in Sept or Nov. Mid-week games in October would be a travel nightmare for classes due to travel issues and jet lag etc.
09-24-2024 01:10 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
3DogNight Offline
1st String
*

Posts: 1,157
Joined: Nov 2021
Reputation: 121
I Root For: Liberty
Location:
Post: #510
RE: Lets Talk Expansion Again
(09-24-2024 12:52 PM)inutech Wrote:  
(09-24-2024 12:08 PM)3DogNight Wrote:  
(09-24-2024 11:21 AM)inutech Wrote:  
(09-24-2024 11:16 AM)3DogNight Wrote:  I personally would rather be a member of a conference who has a strategic plan and vision. Not one that flies by the seat of their pants and only reacts because they are forced to because of circumstances. But that’s just me. I might be the only one who thinks this way.

I agree that a smaller conference with a plan (like, say, if we lose this team or that team or this pair of teams, we'll invite this other team or pair of teams) is much better than any sized conference without a plan.

I don't think you're the only one who thinks a plan is good.
If you haven’t already noticed, there’s slim pickings when it comes to serious opinions for schools to choose as backfills. And as time passes, it will only get slimmer. I would love to hear who you think all these qualified members in waiting are.

KSU, Delaware, and Missouri State.

That was my point.



A rational, proactive plan could have been "ok, we're at 9 - that's enough, perfect for football - if weird stuff happens in the future, let's keep working with this group of X schools and if we lose a couple more schools, we'll bring them in."

And it's true that another "proactive" plan might have been "we're pretty sure more change is coming, and we're pretty sure our favorite targets will be less likely to join if we go down a couple of schools, or the risk of a chain reaction might be too high to risk, so let's go ahead and go to 12 now."

And for all we know they have brilliant contingency plans for losing 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, or 7 more schools. It's possible.

Choosing to stay at any particular number of schools may be "reactionary" but it might also be a proactive choice. Choosing not to do the wrong thing is still a choice.
We can’t add those three again. We’re not talking about what we’ve already done. We’re talking about a plan going forward. Those three were great choices in my opinion. They will keep us from going under 8 if we lose NMSU and UTEP. If they weren’t members, that would have put us at 7. But going forward, if we lose other schools besides NMSU and UTEP, who’s on your list besides schools that we’ve already added.
09-24-2024 01:12 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
army56mike Offline
Moderator
*

Posts: 12,787
Joined: Mar 2004
Reputation: 429
I Root For: Liberty & UofL
Location: Shepherdsville, KY
Post: #511
RE: Lets Talk Expansion Again
Which is more likely?

Liberty……………………………..Wyoming
Delaware……………….…………New Mexico
FIU…………………………………..Nevada
Kenny……………………………….San Jose St.
Jax St……………………………….Hawaii
MTSU……………………………….New Mexico St.
WKU……………………….………..UTEP
MoSt……………..OR…………….Sammy
La Tech……………………………..Texas St.
Sammy……………………………..Montana
UTEP………………………………….North Dakota St.
NMSU………………………………..South Dakota St.
New Mexico
Wyoming
Nevada
San Jose St.
(This post was last modified: 09-24-2024 01:17 PM by army56mike.)
09-24-2024 01:17 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
KATatonic Offline
2nd String
*

Posts: 424
Joined: Nov 2021
Reputation: 40
I Root For: Sam Houston Bearkats
Location:
Post: #512
RE: Lets Talk Expansion Again
(09-24-2024 01:10 PM)Baldspot Wrote:  Not saying I support the move but I think CUSA teams could legitimately only play at Hawaii in Sept or Nov. Mid-week games in October would be a travel nightmare for classes due to travel issues and jet lag etc.

Most collegiate athletes take online class at their university/college. They can work on their classes on the plane or in the hotel room. While the travel is time-consuming and expensive, it is not the academic burden that many make it out to be.
09-24-2024 02:47 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
inutech Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,764
Joined: Dec 2014
Reputation: 670
I Root For: Louisiana Tech
Location:
Post: #513
RE: Lets Talk Expansion Again
(09-24-2024 01:12 PM)3DogNight Wrote:  
(09-24-2024 12:52 PM)inutech Wrote:  KSU, Delaware, and Missouri State.

Those three were great choices in my opinion. They will keep us from going under 8 if we lose NMSU and UTEP. If they weren’t members, that would have put us at 7.

Right. And then if you added them when UTEP/NMSU announced they were leaving (if that happened) then how many do you have? You're back to 10. Just like now. Same-same. That's my only point to the post about "now we see the value in adding them." Because that's only true (and it may be!) if you think you couldn't still get them now(if needed).

And of course, if UTEP/NMSU don't leave - it's not really at issue (again - assuming you're not all in on "needing" 12 for 12's sake or 10 or whatever, which is a different discussion I guess). You'd still have the number of teams that you wanted to have (whatever that number is 9, 10, 12, 14, whatever).


But going forward, if we lose other schools besides NMSU and UTEP, who’s on your list besides schools that we’ve already added.

If those two leave you stay at 10. If one more leaves you stay at 9. In either case you better be exploring options for anyone else leaving, but you don't necessarily have to invite them. You just need to be able to as needed (and maybe the only way you can get them is to go ahead and invite them, and that's fine, it's part of the evaluation).

Who those schools should be? You got me. I wasn't in the pitch meetings the last time around. I don't get briefings from the consulting firm that deals with the media partners (or did). I don't know which presidents are going to pound the table for their old buddy's school. I kinda think there would be a fairly small difference in impact. It'd largely be "least worst option" to get to whatever number you think you "need" to get to (or actually need to get to). You'd find silver linings and press release bullet points for anyone:

"Their strong academics will be a great fit."

"This will only make CUSA bowling that much more dominant."

"This school's strong history in spring sports. . ."

"The geographic footprint and potential for rivalries to develop (or historic rivalries to renew). . ."

"In such a large and growing demographic area. . ."


But I don't know that there is a (predictable) great answer. Just get whomever. Maybe whoever will pay the highest entry fee?
(This post was last modified: 09-24-2024 04:40 PM by inutech.)
09-24-2024 04:36 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
3DogNight Offline
1st String
*

Posts: 1,157
Joined: Nov 2021
Reputation: 121
I Root For: Liberty
Location:
Post: #514
RE: Lets Talk Expansion Again
(09-24-2024 04:36 PM)inutech Wrote:  
(09-24-2024 01:12 PM)3DogNight Wrote:  
(09-24-2024 12:52 PM)inutech Wrote:  KSU, Delaware, and Missouri State.

Those three were great choices in my opinion. They will keep us from going under 8 if we lose NMSU and UTEP. If they weren’t members, that would have put us at 7.

Right. And then if you added them when UTEP/NMSU announced they were leaving (if that happened) then how many do you have? You're back to 10. Just like now. Same-same. That's my only point to the post about "now we see the value in adding them." Because that's only true (and it may be!) if you think you couldn't still get them now(if needed).

And of course, if UTEP/NMSU don't leave - it's not really at issue (again - assuming you're not all in on "needing" 12 for 12's sake or 10 or whatever, which is a different discussion I guess). You'd still have the number of teams that you wanted to have (whatever that number is 9, 10, 12, 14, whatever).


But going forward, if we lose other schools besides NMSU and UTEP, who’s on your list besides schools that we’ve already added.

If those two leave you stay at 10. If one more leaves you stay at 9. In either case you better be exploring options for anyone else leaving, but you don't necessarily have to invite them. You just need to be able to as needed (and maybe the only way you can get them is to go ahead and invite them, and that's fine, it's part of the evaluation).

Who those schools should be? You got me. I wasn't in the pitch meetings the last time around. I don't get briefings from the consulting firm that deals with the media partners (or did). I don't know which presidents are going to pound the table for their old buddy's school. I kinda think there would be a fairly small difference in impact. It'd largely be "least worst option" to get to whatever number you think you "need" to get to (or actually need to get to). You'd find silver linings and press release bullet points for anyone:

"Their strong academics will be a great fit."

"This will only make CUSA bowling that much more dominant."

"This school's strong history in spring sports. . ."

"The geographic footprint and potential for rivalries to develop (or historic rivalries to renew). . ."

"In such a large and growing demographic area. . ."


But I don't know that there is a (predictable) great answer. Just get whomever. Maybe whoever will pay the highest entry fee?
I’m not asking you who the presidents would pick. I’m asking you who you think is so readily available. In a few posts earlier you seem to suggest that MSU and UD would still be waiting around and available if we lose NMSU and UTEP. Then you seem to believe that if we get so low in membership that it wouldn’t be any problem replacing the departing schools. So if we had to replace someone, who would that replacement be? If it’s as easy replacing someone as you seem to suggest, you have to have some names. I think that there are very few schools who are truly ready to move up. But you say to just get whomever. So apparently you believe that there’s a whole lot more schools to pick from than I do. So again I’m asking you to share your list. Who’s out there and available that we can reach out to at the drop of a hat?
09-24-2024 05:27 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
inutech Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,764
Joined: Dec 2014
Reputation: 670
I Root For: Louisiana Tech
Location:
Post: #515
RE: Lets Talk Expansion Again
(09-24-2024 05:27 PM)3DogNight Wrote:  
(09-24-2024 04:36 PM)inutech Wrote:  
(09-24-2024 01:12 PM)3DogNight Wrote:  
(09-24-2024 12:52 PM)inutech Wrote:  KSU, Delaware, and Missouri State.

Those three were great choices in my opinion. They will keep us from going under 8 if we lose NMSU and UTEP. If they weren’t members, that would have put us at 7.

Right. And then if you added them when UTEP/NMSU announced they were leaving (if that happened) then how many do you have? You're back to 10. Just like now. Same-same. That's my only point to the post about "now we see the value in adding them." Because that's only true (and it may be!) if you think you couldn't still get them now(if needed).

And of course, if UTEP/NMSU don't leave - it's not really at issue (again - assuming you're not all in on "needing" 12 for 12's sake or 10 or whatever, which is a different discussion I guess). You'd still have the number of teams that you wanted to have (whatever that number is 9, 10, 12, 14, whatever).


But going forward, if we lose other schools besides NMSU and UTEP, who’s on your list besides schools that we’ve already added.

If those two leave you stay at 10. If one more leaves you stay at 9. In either case you better be exploring options for anyone else leaving, but you don't necessarily have to invite them. You just need to be able to as needed (and maybe the only way you can get them is to go ahead and invite them, and that's fine, it's part of the evaluation).

Who those schools should be? You got me. I wasn't in the pitch meetings the last time around. I don't get briefings from the consulting firm that deals with the media partners (or did). I don't know which presidents are going to pound the table for their old buddy's school. I kinda think there would be a fairly small difference in impact. It'd largely be "least worst option" to get to whatever number you think you "need" to get to (or actually need to get to). You'd find silver linings and press release bullet points for anyone:

"Their strong academics will be a great fit."

"This will only make CUSA bowling that much more dominant."

"This school's strong history in spring sports. . ."

"The geographic footprint and potential for rivalries to develop (or historic rivalries to renew). . ."

"In such a large and growing demographic area. . ."


But I don't know that there is a (predictable) great answer. Just get whomever. Maybe whoever will pay the highest entry fee?
I’m not asking you who the presidents would pick. I’m asking you who you think is so readily available. In a few posts earlier you seem to suggest that MSU and UD would still be waiting around and available if we lose NMSU and UTEP. Then you seem to believe that if we get so low in membership that it wouldn’t be any problem replacing the departing schools. So if we had to replace someone, who would that replacement be? If it’s as easy replacing someone as you seem to suggest, you have to have some names. I think that there are very few schools who are truly ready to move up. But you say to just get whomever. So apparently you believe that there’s a whole lot more schools to pick from than I do. So again I’m asking you to share your list. Who’s out there and available that we can reach out to at the drop of a hat?

Somehow there is a miscommunication here.

If NMSU and UTEP leave, we're fine with 10.

If one more leaves, that's fine at 9.

If one more leaves, we're still a conference and there are some silver linings, but now we're less than what even I think is ideal and at risk for the next step.

If we then lose another, we have to find someone. I don't know why you think I think that's easy. What I think is just that it's better to do this as needed (having planned proactively to do so) rather than in a reactionary "but what if the worst happens" manner without knowing that you actually needed to do it.

I guess another way of putting it is that I don't think you're better off rushing out to invite someone the day after UTEP/NMSU announce a departure (if they do) than doing that later. I don't think you have great options no matter when you do it. Sorry if that isn't clear.

I'm just saying postpone adding said options for as long as you can. I don't know who they'd be now or later.
09-24-2024 05:41 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
3DogNight Offline
1st String
*

Posts: 1,157
Joined: Nov 2021
Reputation: 121
I Root For: Liberty
Location:
Post: #516
RE: Lets Talk Expansion Again
(09-24-2024 05:41 PM)inutech Wrote:  
(09-24-2024 05:27 PM)3DogNight Wrote:  
(09-24-2024 04:36 PM)inutech Wrote:  
(09-24-2024 01:12 PM)3DogNight Wrote:  
(09-24-2024 12:52 PM)inutech Wrote:  KSU, Delaware, and Missouri State.

Those three were great choices in my opinion. They will keep us from going under 8 if we lose NMSU and UTEP. If they weren’t members, that would have put us at 7.

Right. And then if you added them when UTEP/NMSU announced they were leaving (if that happened) then how many do you have? You're back to 10. Just like now. Same-same. That's my only point to the post about "now we see the value in adding them." Because that's only true (and it may be!) if you think you couldn't still get them now(if needed).

And of course, if UTEP/NMSU don't leave - it's not really at issue (again - assuming you're not all in on "needing" 12 for 12's sake or 10 or whatever, which is a different discussion I guess). You'd still have the number of teams that you wanted to have (whatever that number is 9, 10, 12, 14, whatever).


But going forward, if we lose other schools besides NMSU and UTEP, who’s on your list besides schools that we’ve already added.

If those two leave you stay at 10. If one more leaves you stay at 9. In either case you better be exploring options for anyone else leaving, but you don't necessarily have to invite them. You just need to be able to as needed (and maybe the only way you can get them is to go ahead and invite them, and that's fine, it's part of the evaluation).

Who those schools should be? You got me. I wasn't in the pitch meetings the last time around. I don't get briefings from the consulting firm that deals with the media partners (or did). I don't know which presidents are going to pound the table for their old buddy's school. I kinda think there would be a fairly small difference in impact. It'd largely be "least worst option" to get to whatever number you think you "need" to get to (or actually need to get to). You'd find silver linings and press release bullet points for anyone:

"Their strong academics will be a great fit."

"This will only make CUSA bowling that much more dominant."

"This school's strong history in spring sports. . ."

"The geographic footprint and potential for rivalries to develop (or historic rivalries to renew). . ."

"In such a large and growing demographic area. . ."


But I don't know that there is a (predictable) great answer. Just get whomever. Maybe whoever will pay the highest entry fee?
I’m not asking you who the presidents would pick. I’m asking you who you think is so readily available. In a few posts earlier you seem to suggest that MSU and UD would still be waiting around and available if we lose NMSU and UTEP. Then you seem to believe that if we get so low in membership that it wouldn’t be any problem replacing the departing schools. So if we had to replace someone, who would that replacement be? If it’s as easy replacing someone as you seem to suggest, you have to have some names. I think that there are very few schools who are truly ready to move up. But you say to just get whomever. So apparently you believe that there’s a whole lot more schools to pick from than I do. So again I’m asking you to share your list. Who’s out there and available that we can reach out to at the drop of a hat?

Somehow there is a miscommunication here.

If NMSU and UTEP leave, we're fine with 10.

If one more leaves, that's fine at 9.

If one more leaves, we're still a conference and there are some silver linings, but now we're less than what even I think is ideal and at risk for the next step.

If we then lose another, we have to find someone. I don't know why you think I think that's easy. What I think is just that it's better to do this as needed (having planned proactively to do so) rather than in a reactionary "but what if the worst happens" manner without knowing that you actually needed to do it.

I guess another way of putting it is that I don't think you're better off rushing out to invite someone the day after UTEP/NMSU announce a departure (if they do) than doing that later. I don't think you have great options no matter when you do it. Sorry if that isn't clear.

I'm just saying postpone adding said options for as long as you can. I don't know who they'd be now or later.

I know that you and I have totally different opinions on this subject. But that’s okay. I enjoy debating our opinions and hope you do as well. I think we would both agree that having to backfill to have enough teams to remain a conference isn’t something that either of us would want.
09-24-2024 06:24 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
inutech Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,764
Joined: Dec 2014
Reputation: 670
I Root For: Louisiana Tech
Location:
Post: #517
RE: Lets Talk Expansion Again
(09-24-2024 06:24 PM)3DogNight Wrote:  
(09-24-2024 05:41 PM)inutech Wrote:  
(09-24-2024 05:27 PM)3DogNight Wrote:  
(09-24-2024 04:36 PM)inutech Wrote:  
(09-24-2024 01:12 PM)3DogNight Wrote:  Those three were great choices in my opinion. They will keep us from going under 8 if we lose NMSU and UTEP. If they weren’t members, that would have put us at 7.

Right. And then if you added them when UTEP/NMSU announced they were leaving (if that happened) then how many do you have? You're back to 10. Just like now. Same-same. That's my only point to the post about "now we see the value in adding them." Because that's only true (and it may be!) if you think you couldn't still get them now(if needed).

And of course, if UTEP/NMSU don't leave - it's not really at issue (again - assuming you're not all in on "needing" 12 for 12's sake or 10 or whatever, which is a different discussion I guess). You'd still have the number of teams that you wanted to have (whatever that number is 9, 10, 12, 14, whatever).


But going forward, if we lose other schools besides NMSU and UTEP, who’s on your list besides schools that we’ve already added.

If those two leave you stay at 10. If one more leaves you stay at 9. In either case you better be exploring options for anyone else leaving, but you don't necessarily have to invite them. You just need to be able to as needed (and maybe the only way you can get them is to go ahead and invite them, and that's fine, it's part of the evaluation).

Who those schools should be? You got me. I wasn't in the pitch meetings the last time around. I don't get briefings from the consulting firm that deals with the media partners (or did). I don't know which presidents are going to pound the table for their old buddy's school. I kinda think there would be a fairly small difference in impact. It'd largely be "least worst option" to get to whatever number you think you "need" to get to (or actually need to get to). You'd find silver linings and press release bullet points for anyone:

"Their strong academics will be a great fit."

"This will only make CUSA bowling that much more dominant."

"This school's strong history in spring sports. . ."

"The geographic footprint and potential for rivalries to develop (or historic rivalries to renew). . ."

"In such a large and growing demographic area. . ."


But I don't know that there is a (predictable) great answer. Just get whomever. Maybe whoever will pay the highest entry fee?
I’m not asking you who the presidents would pick. I’m asking you who you think is so readily available. In a few posts earlier you seem to suggest that MSU and UD would still be waiting around and available if we lose NMSU and UTEP. Then you seem to believe that if we get so low in membership that it wouldn’t be any problem replacing the departing schools. So if we had to replace someone, who would that replacement be? If it’s as easy replacing someone as you seem to suggest, you have to have some names. I think that there are very few schools who are truly ready to move up. But you say to just get whomever. So apparently you believe that there’s a whole lot more schools to pick from than I do. So again I’m asking you to share your list. Who’s out there and available that we can reach out to at the drop of a hat?

Somehow there is a miscommunication here.

If NMSU and UTEP leave, we're fine with 10.

If one more leaves, that's fine at 9.

If one more leaves, we're still a conference and there are some silver linings, but now we're less than what even I think is ideal and at risk for the next step.

If we then lose another, we have to find someone. I don't know why you think I think that's easy. What I think is just that it's better to do this as needed (having planned proactively to do so) rather than in a reactionary "but what if the worst happens" manner without knowing that you actually needed to do it.

I guess another way of putting it is that I don't think you're better off rushing out to invite someone the day after UTEP/NMSU announce a departure (if they do) than doing that later. I don't think you have great options no matter when you do it. Sorry if that isn't clear.

I'm just saying postpone adding said options for as long as you can. I don't know who they'd be now or later.

I know that you and I have totally different opinions on this subject. But that’s okay. I enjoy debating our opinions and hope you do as well. I think we would both agree that having to backfill to have enough teams to remain a conference isn’t something that either of us would want.

Yes, I agree that being forced to add any new schools would be bad (and yes, I enjoy a good debate about a trivial topic now and then).

But all along I've suggested that we just play out all the scenarios and pick the best one. A big argument for adding Delaware and Missouri State (not the only one) was "what if we lost NMSU/UTEP to the MWC?" And in this thread a post was made to that effect - isn't it great we already added Delaware and Missouri State? But I don't see what's different than if we waited to issue an invitation.

And I feel the same about "but what if we lost more teams?" Who are you planning to add to protect against that? Ok, now imagine inviting that school only when you really need them. Will they probably say yes? Then why do it any earlier?
09-24-2024 07:03 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
3DogNight Offline
1st String
*

Posts: 1,157
Joined: Nov 2021
Reputation: 121
I Root For: Liberty
Location:
Post: #518
RE: Lets Talk Expansion Again
(09-24-2024 07:03 PM)inutech Wrote:  
(09-24-2024 06:24 PM)3DogNight Wrote:  
(09-24-2024 05:41 PM)inutech Wrote:  
(09-24-2024 05:27 PM)3DogNight Wrote:  
(09-24-2024 04:36 PM)inutech Wrote:  If those two leave you stay at 10. If one more leaves you stay at 9. In either case you better be exploring options for anyone else leaving, but you don't necessarily have to invite them. You just need to be able to as needed (and maybe the only way you can get them is to go ahead and invite them, and that's fine, it's part of the evaluation).

Who those schools should be? You got me. I wasn't in the pitch meetings the last time around. I don't get briefings from the consulting firm that deals with the media partners (or did). I don't know which presidents are going to pound the table for their old buddy's school. I kinda think there would be a fairly small difference in impact. It'd largely be "least worst option" to get to whatever number you think you "need" to get to (or actually need to get to). You'd find silver linings and press release bullet points for anyone:

"Their strong academics will be a great fit."

"This will only make CUSA bowling that much more dominant."

"This school's strong history in spring sports. . ."

"The geographic footprint and potential for rivalries to develop (or historic rivalries to renew). . ."

"In such a large and growing demographic area. . ."


But I don't know that there is a (predictable) great answer. Just get whomever. Maybe whoever will pay the highest entry fee?
I’m not asking you who the presidents would pick. I’m asking you who you think is so readily available. In a few posts earlier you seem to suggest that MSU and UD would still be waiting around and available if we lose NMSU and UTEP. Then you seem to believe that if we get so low in membership that it wouldn’t be any problem replacing the departing schools. So if we had to replace someone, who would that replacement be? If it’s as easy replacing someone as you seem to suggest, you have to have some names. I think that there are very few schools who are truly ready to move up. But you say to just get whomever. So apparently you believe that there’s a whole lot more schools to pick from than I do. So again I’m asking you to share your list. Who’s out there and available that we can reach out to at the drop of a hat?

Somehow there is a miscommunication here.

If NMSU and UTEP leave, we're fine with 10.

If one more leaves, that's fine at 9.

If one more leaves, we're still a conference and there are some silver linings, but now we're less than what even I think is ideal and at risk for the next step.

If we then lose another, we have to find someone. I don't know why you think I think that's easy. What I think is just that it's better to do this as needed (having planned proactively to do so) rather than in a reactionary "but what if the worst happens" manner without knowing that you actually needed to do it.

I guess another way of putting it is that I don't think you're better off rushing out to invite someone the day after UTEP/NMSU announce a departure (if they do) than doing that later. I don't think you have great options no matter when you do it. Sorry if that isn't clear.

I'm just saying postpone adding said options for as long as you can. I don't know who they'd be now or later.

I know that you and I have totally different opinions on this subject. But that’s okay. I enjoy debating our opinions and hope you do as well. I think we would both agree that having to backfill to have enough teams to remain a conference isn’t something that either of us would want.

Yes, I agree that being forced to add any new schools would be bad (and yes, I enjoy a good debate about a trivial topic now and then).

But all along I've suggested that we just play out all the scenarios and pick the best one. A big argument for adding Delaware and Missouri State (not the only one) was "what if we lost NMSU/UTEP to the MWC?" And in this thread a post was made to that effect - isn't it great we already added Delaware and Missouri State? But I don't see what's different than if we waited to issue an invitation.

And I feel the same about "but what if we lost more teams?" Who are you planning to add to protect against that? Ok, now imagine inviting that school only when you really need them. Will they probably say yes? Then why do it any earlier?

And this is why you and I will forever disagree. lol
09-24-2024 07:10 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
inutech Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,764
Joined: Dec 2014
Reputation: 670
I Root For: Louisiana Tech
Location:
Post: #519
RE: Lets Talk Expansion Again
I guess so.

Because I don't see a difference in adding Delaware and Missouri State in 2025 and adding them in 2026 (if needed, and always assuming you still think they'd say yes).

Let me know if there is one (there isn't, unless you're being preemptively reactive instead of proactivity making a plan).

But if we lose 3 schools now, and we're urgently needing to build a big safety buffer - who do you want to add?









And don't you think we could still add that same school later? Where else would they go? And how much better than your second choice could they possibly be if you did "miss out" on them?
09-24-2024 08:45 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
3DogNight Offline
1st String
*

Posts: 1,157
Joined: Nov 2021
Reputation: 121
I Root For: Liberty
Location:
Post: #520
RE: Lets Talk Expansion Again
(09-24-2024 08:45 PM)inutech Wrote:  I guess so.

Because I don't see a difference in adding Delaware and Missouri State in 2025 and adding them in 2026 (if needed, and always assuming you still think they'd say yes). You’re assuming that Delaware and Missouri State would always be available. If we hadn’t been able to get them, they would have ended up somewhere. They weren’t going to wait indefinitely on CUSA.

Let me know if there is one (there isn't, unless you're being preemptively reactive instead of proactivity making a plan). Have absolutely no idea what you’re talking about.

But if we lose 3 schools now, and we're urgently needing to build a big safety buffer - who do you want to add? If you had read what I wrote earlier, you would know that I don’t see anyone in FCS that would benefit CUSA at this point in time. That’s why it was important to get Delaware and Missouri State when we did and not assume that they would be waiting on a call from CUSA. That’s being proactive and not reactive by the way.






And don't you think we could still add that same school later? No, I don’t think you can assume that they will always be there. Where else would they go? I don’t think CUSA has the corner on the market when it comes to call ups. And how much better than your second choice could they possibly be if you did "miss out" on them? I think there’s a world of difference between Delaware and Missouri State compared to what’s currently left out there.
09-24-2024 10:31 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Post Reply 




User(s) browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)


Copyright © 2002-2026 Collegiate Sports Nation Bulletin Board System (CSNbbs), All Rights Reserved.
CSNbbs is an independent fan site and is in no way affiliated to the NCAA or any of the schools and conferences it represents.
This site monetizes links. FTC Disclosure.
We allow third-party companies to serve ads and/or collect certain anonymous information when you visit our web site. These companies may use non-personally identifiable information (e.g., click stream information, browser type, time and date, subject of advertisements clicked or scrolled over) during your visits to this and other Web sites in order to provide advertisements about goods and services likely to be of greater interest to you. These companies typically use a cookie or third party web beacon to collect this information. To learn more about this behavioral advertising practice or to opt-out of this type of advertising, you can visit http://www.networkadvertising.org.
Powered By MyBB, © 2002-2026 MyBB Group.