The first month of the season is notoriously bad for most national polls and ranking systems. In September, 99% of them incorporate some input from last season. This makes even less sense today given the high turnover among both players and coaches.
I did find an analytical ranking that reflects very closely with what I’d call the “eye test” Of paying attention to quite a few games in the American Conference (and elsewhere) this season.
It’s called the ESPN “Team Efficiency” and it appears to be one component of the ESPN FPI (but FPI includes historical data to last season and probably some other factors outside of Team Efficiency)
After two weeks:
Rice “held their own” for a half against an elite program (one which proved to be top tier this week), and then beat a power conference rival (who had just beaten one of the favorites in our conference last week).
To my eye test we’ve played so far like a top five AAC team.
According to this ESPN Efficiency Rating:
AAC Top Five:
1 Memphis (23). Unbeaten against weak competition but their defense was smothering in both efforts (for a full game, not just for the first half like ours)
2 SMU (29). One score game against elite competition this week. No problem last week with a team that beat FIU (who beat UNT this week)
3 Tulane (51). Held their own and led in first half against a strong opponent, without their QB1. Tulane will improve once they get healthy.
4 Rice (55). Two strong (but far from perfect) efforts. This team has the talent to beat anyone left on their schedule.
5 UTSA (74). Solid win yesterday against a well regarded (by this ranking) Texas State team. Let the Houston game slip away.
Others:
Texas (5) - beat Ala
Alabama (25)
Other Top non A5 teams
Texas State (27) -beat Bay
Toledo (33) - top MAC
AFA (41) - top MWC
Georgia Southern (44) - beat UAB
Miami-O (48)
Utah State (52)
And:
WKU (68) - top CUSA
Houston (80)
Baylor (103)
UConn (125) - plays Rice next month
Arkansas State (132) - lost to Memphis
Nevada (133) - last in FBS
All of the AAC:
https://www.espn.com/college-football/fpi