RE: FCS "Prospects" Real Data, Opinions, Analytics, Budgets, Revenue, Etc..
Re: Tarleton...
My preference would be to wait. But PAC/MWC dynamics may force our hand. The PAC likely wouldn't come after Tarleton directly, but if they take another MWC team, the MWC would surely come after Tarleton. And as Jordan noted, the MWC may not even wait. They need Central Time Zone teams to give them a more attractive package to sell to networks.
If the CUSA league office plans to add Tarleton *at some point* they should probably just bite the bullet and do it now.
That would bring us to 11 teams, which is not a horrible number to stay at while we evaluate our next move.
I do think we should put the brakes on after that. If football-only Sac State and Illinois State are our next two most attractive adds, I think we can afford to wait.
That said, if ISU is willing to come in all sports, and not just football, I think a strong case could be made for adding them, despite the travel. But chances of that seem very remote.
As for our other "realistic" prospects down in FCS... I just don't see an immediate upside to adding any of them. They'll either get their houses in order and become no-brainer choices for expansion, or they'll prove FCS is their ceiling. We can survive just fine while they work that out.
Re: SFA and "mediocrity"...
SFA's record in football the past three years has been 3-8, 7-5, and 11-3. I mentioned their notable improvement in my post yesterday. An 8-game swing is definitely notable.
Over that same period, McNeese has gone 1-10, 6-6, and 5-7. Improvement from year 1 to year 3, but slight regression from year 2 to year 3.
EKU has gone 5-6, 8-5, and 5-7, which is just underwhelming all around.
Just looking at those raw numbers, it certainly seems like I was unfair to SFA by lumping them in with the mediocre.
But one has to consider that the strength of the lower subdivision is not in the southern half of the U.S. It's in the northern plains. The SLC, SoCon, UAC (ASUN), WAC, and even the CAA are pale shadows of their former selves.
And that's where SFA hits a bit of a wall.
The Southland is not a very strong conference at all. Other than SFA, only 3 SLC teams finished over .500:
UTRGV, which just missed out on a playoff bid in their inaugural season.
SELA, which lost by 18 at home to Illinois State in round 1.
Lamar, which lost by 18 on the road at Abilene in round 1.
SFA played the WAC's Abilene (9-5) twice in 2025, losing in early September 28-20, before getting revenge in the 2nd round of the playoffs, 41-34.
In addition to the early loss against Abilene, SFA's other two losses came against FBS Houston (27-0) and a Quarterfinal loss to the Big Sky's Montana State.
Regardless of how that loss to the Bobcats stacks up against other Bobcat wins, football isn't transitive. The Jacks lost by 16. That's all that matters.
SFA's most impressive win was the playoff victory against Abilene, which had managed to end Tarleton's winning streak earlier in the season, but otherwise had an unremarkable year feasting on WAC and UAC teams.
So SFA had a great season with double-digit wins and a playoff victory. They have much to be proud of. But there were no impressive victories. No wins over top teams from the MVFC or Big Sky.
(Sorry, Jacks. No credit given for beating a 4-8 Cal Poly team.)
The way they're trending, 2026 could be a breakthrough year. It could be the season they finally push through to the semifinals, or even the title game.
But though 2025 was very, very good, in the absence of anything truly impressive, it was ultimately just a solid, but mediocre year.
As for Tarleton, they face the same issue with a weak conference schedule as SFA. The difference is, they won their FBS game against Army and beat North Dakota (a strong MVFC team) in the 2nd round of the playoffs. And though the Texans lost their Quarterfinals game, it was only by 5 points to Villanova.
In fact, Tarleton only lost by a combined 8 points the whole season. That's a little better than mediocre, I think.
|