(10-11-2024 11:21 AM)army56mike Wrote: I know yall have a lot more expertise and research into expansion than I do. I simply choose by “like” factors.
In today’s environment, I am putting less and less stock in geographic footprints. I know it is easier for the P2M2 conferences to pull off, but now even G conferences are looking to spread.
I choose by, is the athletic department competitive, is there fan support, is the school located in a place I want to go, would I be interested in playing this school regularly, how does it help the conference geographically (to keep footprint small or to add a new state or fanbase).
I know I go against the consensus opinion here when I say I prefer large conferences. Money has never been something I let lead my thinking or determine my life. Even if it meant less shares of money, I’d rather have more teams to create more conference content to see and cheer for.
If we end up at 11 I will be content. If we end up at 12 I’ll be happier. If we go to 14 or 16 I’d still be thrilled.
When I evaluate potential candidates, I have to force myself to separate my own personal preferences from what would be "best" for the conference according to current trends.
That is, I personally don't care one iota about a school's academic prestige, market size, endowment, or any of a dozen other factors which are ACTUALLY used to evaluate candidates.
If I were king of the world these factors would matter most:
1) Schools located within a drivable distance for a sizable percentage of our fans (and opponents' fans). This roughly corresponds to schools within a ~300 mile radius of Jacksonville, but it's not perfectly circular, thanks to large alumni bases in places like Atlanta, Chattanooga, and Birmingham.
2) Schools with engaged, supportive fan bases. This can trump the drivable distance requirement if a given fan base is really, really awesome.
3) Rivalries, rivalries, rivalries. This goes hand in hand with #1 and #2, but I'd be willing to add a school with whom we have zero history, if they had a long, glorious, historical rivalry with one of the other conference schools.
That's pretty much it.
The problem is, when I sketch out variations of conferences that match these guidelines, they look absolutely TERRIBLE for luring lucrative broadcasting deals or giving presidents and trustees something to brag about at their cocktail parties.
When I adhere to realistic market, network, prestige, and financial factors driving actual conference realignment, I inevitably have to leave some great personal favorites on the cutting room floor, while simultaneously holding my nose to include "stronger" candidates which more closely align with reality.
And this is true regardless of how many members we aim for.