SlyFox
1st String

Posts: 1,994
Joined: Feb 2010
Reputation: 125
I Root For: Liberty
Location: Lake Conroe, Texas
|
RE: FCS "Prospects" COMPARISONS; Budgets, Revenue, Etc..
They are nowhere near as blatant about attendance inflation as the folks in Stephenville. Even still, their fan base is much larger. Tarleton might be a prospect in 8-10 years. But it shouldn't even be on the league's radar at this stage.
|
|
| 09-14-2023 10:22 AM |
|
NDSUguy
2nd String

Posts: 260
Joined: Dec 2012
Reputation: 29
I Root For: NDSU
Location:
|
RE: FCS "Prospects" COMPARISONS; Budgets, Revenue, Etc..
There are so many threads/posts related to this but I'm wondering why CUSA doesn't go hard after NDSU/SDSU/Montana/Montanta State/Missouri St. and possibly other schools from the northern part of the country as football only additions?
I ask this because I'm wondering what the overall "goal" is for the conference from a football perspective? Is the goal to elevate the status of the conference and challenge the Sunbelt, MWC and others? Or is it something else?
Travel? Is putting your football team on a plane and travelling 1-2 times per year up north really make that big of a difference?
Recruiting? Yes, this doesn't add much from a recruitment standpoint but I'd argue that CUSA is already in a pretty good spot from recruiting due to the location of current member schools.
I ask these questions because I keep on seeing conversation about smaller schools that have no facilities, no funding, no tradition, no historical success being mentioned as potential additions when the obvious decision should be to create a northern division and elevate the status of the league.
There is also scuttle about NDSU being approached in the past and saying no.... Would they do that today? What if there were partners with them?
|
|
| 09-14-2023 10:22 AM |
|
whupemall
1st String

Posts: 1,665
Joined: Jan 2021
Reputation: 208
I Root For: Jax State
Location: Newton, AL
|
RE: FCS "Prospects" COMPARISONS; Budgets, Revenue, Etc..
I may have mentioned it before, but thanks once again to the various Texas-based posters for your insights on Tarleton. Most of us outside the Lone Star state have absolutely no clue about that program, other than what we hear about online. And when what we hear about online are things like "located in a part of Texas experiencing skyrocketing growth" and "supported financially by the Texas A&M University System" and "massive facility upgrades" yadda yadda, it makes the Texans seem like a no-brainer.
I'm not saying the negative comments mean Tarleton should be removed permanently from consideration... but it definitely sounds like they should be on the long-term prospects list -- one of the schools who'll need to continue to prove their worth over the next 5-8 years -- rather than a short-term candidate who could conceivably get an invitation by spring 2024.
(Of course, my opinion on the matter doesn't amount to a hill of beans, since I'm not affiliated in any way with the decisionmakers on this, but at least I won't look quite as foolish pushing for their immediate addition to CUSA.)
|
|
| 09-14-2023 10:42 AM |
|
MinerInWisconsin
Hall of Famer

Posts: 11,281
Joined: Apr 2004
Reputation: 524
I Root For: UTEP, of course
Location: The Frozen Tundra
|
RE: FCS "Prospects" COMPARISONS; Budgets, Revenue, Etc..
(09-14-2023 10:22 AM)NDSUguy Wrote: There are so many threads/posts related to this but I'm wondering why CUSA doesn't go hard after NDSU/SDSU/Montana/Montanta State/Missouri St. and possibly other schools from the northern part of the country as football only additions?
I ask this because I'm wondering what the overall "goal" is for the conference from a football perspective? Is the goal to elevate the status of the conference and challenge the Sunbelt, MWC and others? Or is it something else?
Travel? Is putting your football team on a plane and travelling 1-2 times per year up north really make that big of a difference?
Recruiting? Yes, this doesn't add much from a recruitment standpoint but I'd argue that CUSA is already in a pretty good spot from recruiting due to the location of current member schools.
I ask these questions because I keep on seeing conversation about smaller schools that have no facilities, no funding, no tradition, no historical success being mentioned as potential additions when the obvious decision should be to create a northern division and elevate the status of the league.
There is also scuttle about NDSU being approached in the past and saying no.... Would they do that today? What if there were partners with them?
The CUSA commissioner has said that football only additions are possible and imho if NDSU and SDSU are ever added it would most likely be football only as you suggest. Travel in that scenario would not have a big impact. It could be that CUSA is well aware that the 2 Dakota schools are holding out for a MWC invite, which is pretty much common knowledge. Personally I like the idea of adding those 2.
|
|
| 09-14-2023 01:37 PM |
|
TOPSTRAIGHT
Hall of Famer

Posts: 13,366
Joined: May 2013
Reputation: 769
I Root For: WKU
Location: Glasgow,KY.
|
RE: FCS "Prospects" COMPARISONS; Budgets, Revenue, Etc..
(09-14-2023 01:37 PM)MinerInWisconsin Wrote: (09-14-2023 10:22 AM)NDSUguy Wrote: There are so many threads/posts related to this but I'm wondering why CUSA doesn't go hard after NDSU/SDSU/Montana/Montanta State/Missouri St. and possibly other schools from the northern part of the country as football only additions?
I ask this because I'm wondering what the overall "goal" is for the conference from a football perspective? Is the goal to elevate the status of the conference and challenge the Sunbelt, MWC and others? Or is it something else?
Travel? Is putting your football team on a plane and travelling 1-2 times per year up north really make that big of a difference?
Recruiting? Yes, this doesn't add much from a recruitment standpoint but I'd argue that CUSA is already in a pretty good spot from recruiting due to the location of current member schools.
I ask these questions because I keep on seeing conversation about smaller schools that have no facilities, no funding, no tradition, no historical success being mentioned as potential additions when the obvious decision should be to create a northern division and elevate the status of the league.
There is also scuttle about NDSU being approached in the past and saying no.... Would they do that today? What if there were partners with them?
The CUSA commissioner has said that football only additions are possible and imho if NDSU and SDSU are ever added it would most likely be football only as you suggest. Travel in that scenario would not have a big impact. It could be that CUSA is well aware that the 2 Dakota schools are holding out for a MWC invite, which is pretty much common knowledge. Personally I like the idea of adding those 2.
I'm Trying to hold off saying anything yet. Till the "Army thing" and the MW/Pac2 stuff gets settled--we are totally guessing. The CFP 2026 contract particulars will also be a big factor and there may be strong indicators on this in less than a year. IMO everyone is waiting to see what happens.
Remember you have to have three things for any conference change:
1.) an opening
2.) a desire by the league (majority) to invite "said" prospect AND probably in consultation with media partner with adjustment to contract to "break even" or increase distributions
3.) a willingness by that prospect to accept invite/terms
(This post was last modified: 09-14-2023 06:29 PM by TOPSTRAIGHT.)
|
|
| 09-14-2023 06:12 PM |
|
EatEmUp11
1st String

Posts: 1,618
Joined: Feb 2022
Reputation: 125
I Root For: Sam Houston State
Location:
|
RE: FCS "Prospects" COMPARISONS; Budgets, Revenue, Etc..
(09-14-2023 10:14 AM)Scout54ever Wrote: (09-14-2023 08:51 AM)EatEmUp11 Wrote: Yep, PASS on Tarleton, and a hard pass at that. Taking what is essentially still a D2 school in everything but name would be bad for CUSA. We need competitive schools with real fans, not ones that are made up for the box score.
If CUSA needs more inventory and has to go to 12, there are quite a few schools I’d take before even considering Tarleton, even assuming Delaware (and probably Missouri State) are not interested.
"We need competitive schools with real fans, not ones that are made up for the box score."
lol That's rich coming from an SHSU supporter with their 12 fans.
Why is it rich? Did I imply that SHSU draws more fans than Tarleton, or that SHSU is a better option for FBS than Tarleton? The reality is, Sam is currently in Conference USA. We’re on the inside. The conference MY team is in (and the one YOUR team badly wants into) needs teams who are good at sports and have fans. As a supporter of a *current member*, I don’t think there’s anything rich at all about making fellow CUSA fans aware of the fact that Tarleton is a fraudulent prospective school that relies on a facade to make it seem like a passable option when the reality is you’re a candidate based on lies.
What’s rich is making fun of the fanbase of a school that just left your’s in the dust. If Sam has 12 fans, what does Tarleton have, 7? SHSU is in the FBS. We got that call for a reason. Sam wins games. Tarleton loses. Winners win. Loser schools lose. That’s why CUSA passed on TSU. No thanks! “Where is Tarleytown in Texas?”
Keep reporting 24k in attendance for your games against North Bama and Dixie State. It looks super-believable when they show that the endzone bleachers are completely empty. #RollTexans
(This post was last modified: 09-14-2023 10:26 PM by EatEmUp11.)
|
|
| 09-14-2023 10:23 PM |
|
TOPSTRAIGHT
Hall of Famer

Posts: 13,366
Joined: May 2013
Reputation: 769
I Root For: WKU
Location: Glasgow,KY.
|
RE: FCS "Prospects" COMPARISONS; Budgets, Revenue, Etc..
(09-14-2023 10:23 PM)EatEmUp11 Wrote: (09-14-2023 10:14 AM)Scout54ever Wrote: (09-14-2023 08:51 AM)EatEmUp11 Wrote: Yep, PASS on Tarleton, and a hard pass at that. Taking what is essentially still a D2 school in everything but name would be bad for CUSA. We need competitive schools with real fans, not ones that are made up for the box score.
If CUSA needs more inventory and has to go to 12, there are quite a few schools I’d take before even considering Tarleton, even assuming Delaware (and probably Missouri State) are not interested.
"We need competitive schools with real fans, not ones that are made up for the box score."
lol That's rich coming from an SHSU supporter with their 12 fans.
Why is it rich? Did I imply that SHSU draws more fans than Tarleton, or that SHSU is a better option for FBS than Tarleton? The reality is, Sam is currently in Conference USA. We’re on the inside. The conference MY team is in (and the one YOUR team badly wants into) needs teams who are good at sports and have fans. As a supporter of a *current member*, I don’t think there’s anything rich at all about making fellow CUSA fans aware of the fact that Tarleton is a fraudulent prospective school that relies on a facade to make it seem like a passable option when the reality is you’re a candidate based on lies.
What’s rich is making fun of the fanbase of a school that just left your’s in the dust. If Sam has 12 fans, what does Tarleton have, 7? SHSU is in the FBS. We got that call for a reason. Sam wins games. Tarleton loses. Winners win. Loser schools lose. That’s why CUSA passed on TSU. No thanks! “Where is Tarleytown in Texas?”
Keep reporting 24k in attendance for your games against North Bama and Dixie State. It looks super-believable when they show that the endzone bleachers are completely empty. #RollTexans
Superb response.
|
|
| 09-14-2023 10:37 PM |
|
smith79jordan
Special Teams

Posts: 880
Joined: Dec 2022
Reputation: 163
I Root For: Jax State
Location:
|
RE: FCS "Prospects" COMPARISONS; Budgets, Revenue, Etc..
(09-14-2023 10:23 PM)EatEmUp11 Wrote: (09-14-2023 10:14 AM)Scout54ever Wrote: (09-14-2023 08:51 AM)EatEmUp11 Wrote: Yep, PASS on Tarleton, and a hard pass at that. Taking what is essentially still a D2 school in everything but name would be bad for CUSA. We need competitive schools with real fans, not ones that are made up for the box score.
If CUSA needs more inventory and has to go to 12, there are quite a few schools I’d take before even considering Tarleton, even assuming Delaware (and probably Missouri State) are not interested.
"We need competitive schools with real fans, not ones that are made up for the box score."
lol That's rich coming from an SHSU supporter with their 12 fans.
Why is it rich? Did I imply that SHSU draws more fans than Tarleton, or that SHSU is a better option for FBS than Tarleton? The reality is, Sam is currently in Conference USA. We’re on the inside. The conference MY team is in (and the one YOUR team badly wants into) needs teams who are good at sports and have fans. As a supporter of a *current member*, I don’t think there’s anything rich at all about making fellow CUSA fans aware of the fact that Tarleton is a fraudulent prospective school that relies on a facade to make it seem like a passable option when the reality is you’re a candidate based on lies.
What’s rich is making fun of the fanbase of a school that just left your’s in the dust. If Sam has 12 fans, what does Tarleton have, 7? SHSU is in the FBS. We got that call for a reason. Sam wins games. Tarleton loses. Winners win. Loser schools lose. That’s why CUSA passed on TSU. No thanks! “Where is Tarleytown in Texas?”
Keep reporting 24k in attendance for your games against North Bama and Dixie State. It looks super-believable when they show that the endzone bleachers are completely empty. #RollTexans
Yeah, hard pass on Tarelton, in the strongest possible interpretation of the phrase.
|
|
| 09-15-2023 09:39 AM |
|
smith79jordan
Special Teams

Posts: 880
Joined: Dec 2022
Reputation: 163
I Root For: Jax State
Location:
|
RE: FCS "Prospects" COMPARISONS; Budgets, Revenue, Etc..
(09-14-2023 10:22 AM)NDSUguy Wrote: There are so many threads/posts related to this but I'm wondering why CUSA doesn't go hard after NDSU/SDSU/Montana/Montanta State/Missouri St. and possibly other schools from the northern part of the country as football only additions?
I ask this because I'm wondering what the overall "goal" is for the conference from a football perspective? Is the goal to elevate the status of the conference and challenge the Sunbelt, MWC and others? Or is it something else?
Travel? Is putting your football team on a plane and travelling 1-2 times per year up north really make that big of a difference?
Recruiting? Yes, this doesn't add much from a recruitment standpoint but I'd argue that CUSA is already in a pretty good spot from recruiting due to the location of current member schools.
I ask these questions because I keep on seeing conversation about smaller schools that have no facilities, no funding, no tradition, no historical success being mentioned as potential additions when the obvious decision should be to create a northern division and elevate the status of the league.
There is also scuttle about NDSU being approached in the past and saying no.... Would they do that today? What if there were partners with them?
All the respect in the world for NDSU and SDSU athletes. I believe if invited, both stand a chance at winning our league immediately. IMO, geography and population screw the Dakotas and Montanas. I believe they'd be given much more consideration if they played in markets with more eyeballs on screens. But even if that was the case, they'd still be painfully far away from the rest of the league.
|
|
| 09-15-2023 09:48 AM |
|
EatEmUp11
1st String

Posts: 1,618
Joined: Feb 2022
Reputation: 125
I Root For: Sam Houston State
Location:
|
RE: FCS "Prospects" COMPARISONS; Budgets, Revenue, Etc..
CUSA’s FCS options… just my opinion on how the situation should be approached with the candidates I’ve heard mentioned. Has been talked over before but with things settling down (aside from the potential of independent Army going to the AAC) I thought it’d be good to rehash.
The conference can afford to wait around but I assume ten will not be enough for TV eventually.
Good adds, probably not interested in us: Delaware, UTC
Good adds: SFA, EKU, Missouri State
Maybe down the line, BAD adds right now: Tarleton, UTRGV, UCA
Should NOT be considered: McNeese, Austin Peay
|
|
| 09-15-2023 11:25 AM |
|
smith79jordan
Special Teams

Posts: 880
Joined: Dec 2022
Reputation: 163
I Root For: Jax State
Location:
|
RE: FCS "Prospects" COMPARISONS; Budgets, Revenue, Etc..
(09-15-2023 11:25 AM)EatEmUp11 Wrote: CUSA’s FCS options… just my opinion on how the situation should be approached with the candidates I’ve heard mentioned. Has been talked over before but with things settling down (aside from the potential of independent Army going to the AAC) I thought it’d be good to rehash.
The conference can afford to wait around but I assume ten will not be enough for TV eventually.
Good adds, probably not interested in us: Delaware, UTC
Good adds: SFA, EKU, Missouri State
Maybe down the line, BAD adds right now: Tarleton, UTRGV, UCA
Should NOT be considered: McNeese, Austin Peay
Should our footprint shift further east, I wouldn't mind seeing Chatt and Richmond get a call. We have history with the Mocs. And Richmond would pair someone with Liberty. For the sake of Sam, I hope SFA gets the nod one day.
|
|
| 09-15-2023 11:36 AM |
|
TOPSTRAIGHT
Hall of Famer

Posts: 13,366
Joined: May 2013
Reputation: 769
I Root For: WKU
Location: Glasgow,KY.
|
RE: FCS "Prospects" COMPARISONS; Budgets, Revenue, Etc..
A couple of Realignment notes:
--Thamel (ESPN) yesterday tweets about Army and the AAC (sources)--- "optimism on both sides", "continuing to progress", "realistic timeline for decision is end of the month".
-- Matt Brown--TODAY on DELAWARE-- "not particularly interested in joining CUSA OR the SBC"--also just trying to get FBS "ready" in case an opportunity [they Like] comes available. Also he is NOT sure if the MAC is looking to actively grow outside of the midwestern footprint.
IMO Delaware should be taken off the list of possibilities for CUSA.
If the MAC does not want the Blue Hens--then it may be a LONG time before they move up.
(This post was last modified: 09-15-2023 05:53 PM by TOPSTRAIGHT.)
|
|
| 09-15-2023 05:47 PM |
|
jones682
1st String

Posts: 2,127
Joined: Nov 2021
Reputation: 89
I Root For: Kennesaw State
Location:
|
RE: FCS "Prospects" COMPARISONS; Budgets, Revenue, Etc..
(09-14-2023 10:14 AM)Scout54ever Wrote: (09-14-2023 08:51 AM)EatEmUp11 Wrote: Yep, PASS on Tarleton, and a hard pass at that. Taking what is essentially still a D2 school in everything but name would be bad for CUSA. We need competitive schools with real fans, not ones that are made up for the box score.
If CUSA needs more inventory and has to go to 12, there are quite a few schools I’d take before even considering Tarleton, even assuming Delaware (and probably Missouri State) are not interested.
"We need competitive schools with real fans, not ones that are made up for the box score."
lol That's rich coming from an SHSU supporter with their 12 fans.
A Tarleton State fan talking? Winn a post season game at the D1 level first. As a KSU fan I would be pisss if Tarleton was picked over EKU, SFA, Mo St.
(This post was last modified: 09-18-2023 08:14 PM by jones682.)
|
|
| 09-15-2023 06:06 PM |
|
TOPSTRAIGHT
Hall of Famer

Posts: 13,366
Joined: May 2013
Reputation: 769
I Root For: WKU
Location: Glasgow,KY.
|
RE: FCS "Prospects" COMPARISONS; Budgets, Revenue, Etc..
TODAY>>>>More ARMY to the AAC a "done deal" evidence.
Dellenger (Yahoo Sports)-Today- "...still hurdles [but]... the school and league are optimistic that the deal will happen in the coming weeks."
The Athletic (Vannini)-- Today- referring to Army coach Monken's new more than Two million a year contract extension---- "The timing of this coming around Army's potential move to the AAC is likely Not a coincidence."
WHY does this matter to CUSA?
If it has to be spelled out--then you have not been paying attention.
|
|
| 09-18-2023 03:19 PM |
|
AssKickingChicken
Heisman

Posts: 6,550
Joined: Jan 2022
Reputation: 585
I Root For: Jax State
Location:
|
RE: FCS "Prospects" COMPARISONS; Budgets, Revenue, Etc..
(09-18-2023 03:19 PM)TOPSTRAIGHT Wrote: TODAY>>>>More ARMY to the AAC a "done deal" evidence.
Dellenger (Yahoo Sports)-Today- "...still hurdles [but]... the school and league are optimistic that the deal will happen in the coming weeks."
The Athletic (Vannini)-- Today- referring to Army coach Monken's new more than Two million a year contract extension---- "The timing of this coming around Army's potential move to the AAC is likely Not a coincidence."
WHY does this matter to CUSA?
If it has to be spelled out--then you have not been paying attention.
I don’t see how Army joining the AAC would matter to us. Is it going to set off a chain of events that causes us to lose a member? At most, they’d add another non-FB member.
|
|
| 09-20-2023 11:06 AM |
|
SlyFox
1st String

Posts: 1,994
Joined: Feb 2010
Reputation: 125
I Root For: Liberty
Location: Lake Conroe, Texas
|
RE: FCS "Prospects" COMPARISONS; Budgets, Revenue, Etc..
Army joining the AAC would indeed be a stabilizing influence on realignment from CUSA's perspective. If things don't work out, it could get complicated for a spell.
|
|
| 09-20-2023 11:51 AM |
|
AssKickingChicken
Heisman

Posts: 6,550
Joined: Jan 2022
Reputation: 585
I Root For: Jax State
Location:
|
RE: FCS "Prospects" COMPARISONS; Budgets, Revenue, Etc..
(09-20-2023 11:51 AM)SlyFox Wrote: Army joining the AAC would indeed be a stabilizing influence on realignment from CUSA's perspective. If things don't work out, it could get complicated for a spell.
My biggest concern is what happens with the PAC-2. If they just merge with the MWC, we’re fine. If they start cherry-picking, then we could be in trouble when the MWC has to backfill.
|
|
| 09-20-2023 12:29 PM |
|
EatEmUp11
1st String

Posts: 1,618
Joined: Feb 2022
Reputation: 125
I Root For: Sam Houston State
Location:
|
RE: FCS "Prospects" COMPARISONS; Budgets, Revenue, Etc..
If Army were to surprisingly remain independent, the question for the American would become, what is worth more… remaining at 13 (14) members? Or raiding CUSA/SBC of a school that was EIGHTH at best of their expansion options just two years ago? And I’m not sure how many schools in the Belt are willing to leave for the American at this point.
|
|
| 09-20-2023 12:31 PM |
|
TOPSTRAIGHT
Hall of Famer

Posts: 13,366
Joined: May 2013
Reputation: 769
I Root For: WKU
Location: Glasgow,KY.
|
RE: FCS "Prospects" COMPARISONS; Budgets, Revenue, Etc..
(09-20-2023 11:06 AM)AssKickingChicken Wrote: (09-18-2023 03:19 PM)TOPSTRAIGHT Wrote: TODAY>>>>More ARMY to the AAC a "done deal" evidence.
Dellenger (Yahoo Sports)-Today- "...still hurdles [but]... the school and league are optimistic that the deal will happen in the coming weeks."
The Athletic (Vannini)-- Today- referring to Army coach Monken's new more than Two million a year contract extension---- "The timing of this coming around Army's potential move to the AAC is likely Not a coincidence."
WHY does this matter to CUSA?
If it has to be spelled out--then you have not been paying attention.
I don’t see how Army joining the AAC would matter to us. Is it going to set off a chain of events that causes us to lose a member? At most, they’d add another non-FB member.
As I said--not paying attention. But that's OK--not everybody has time to follow all this realignment stuff.
|
|
| 09-20-2023 12:37 PM |
|
AssKickingChicken
Heisman

Posts: 6,550
Joined: Jan 2022
Reputation: 585
I Root For: Jax State
Location:
|
RE: FCS "Prospects" COMPARISONS; Budgets, Revenue, Etc..
(09-20-2023 12:37 PM)TOPSTRAIGHT Wrote: (09-20-2023 11:06 AM)AssKickingChicken Wrote: (09-18-2023 03:19 PM)TOPSTRAIGHT Wrote: TODAY>>>>More ARMY to the AAC a "done deal" evidence.
Dellenger (Yahoo Sports)-Today- "...still hurdles [but]... the school and league are optimistic that the deal will happen in the coming weeks."
The Athletic (Vannini)-- Today- referring to Army coach Monken's new more than Two million a year contract extension---- "The timing of this coming around Army's potential move to the AAC is likely Not a coincidence."
WHY does this matter to CUSA?
If it has to be spelled out--then you have not been paying attention.
I don’t see how Army joining the AAC would matter to us. Is it going to set off a chain of events that causes us to lose a member? At most, they’d add another non-FB member.
As I said--not paying attention. But that's OK--not everybody has time to follow all this realignment stuff.
I have been following it. Could you kindly explain your theory?
|
|
| 09-20-2023 12:45 PM |
|