RE: FCS "Prospects" Real Data, Opinions, Analytics, Budgets, Revenue, Etc..
(07-16-2026 08:11 AM)Gemofthehills Wrote: Was just giving my thoughts on SDSU I have no inside knowledge nor will my opinion be seeked. But SDSU is closer to us than NMSU. Tarleton is only 400 miles closer so both are plane rides. EKU might be the only bus ride on the somewhat realist list for us.
Speaking only for myself as a UD fan, EKU. That said, as topstraight has clearly explained, they are not an option at this time.
RE: FCS "Prospects" Real Data, Opinions, Analytics, Budgets, Revenue, Etc..
Regarding South Dakota State, I'm only interested in them as a football only, unless they can bring a travel partner with them (i.e. University of North Dakota or University of South Dakota)
Actually, if South Dakota State was willing to join CUSA for all sports, CUSA could invite St. Thomas as olympic sports only to be a travel partner for SDSU's olympic sports.
That actually could be a win/win.
(This post was last modified: 07-16-2026 02:11 PM by sigke.)
RE: FCS "Prospects" Real Data, Opinions, Analytics, Budgets, Revenue, Etc..
Tarleton would have a travel partner. Sam Houston is only 3.5 hours away which is busable and somewhat close by CUSA standards [Would "in theory" replace the 2 games in one trip>> La Tech/SH 4 hour 20m journey which teams have been making recently].
Airports...
Tarleton to DFW----------------------------less than two hours
Sam Houston to G. Bush Intl. (Houston)--one hour
Of course FB (except for SH) would charter fly. So I'm referring to all other sports above.
(This post was last modified: 07-16-2026 06:45 PM by TOPSTRAIGHT.)
RE: FCS "Prospects" Real Data, Opinions, Analytics, Budgets, Revenue, Etc..
(07-16-2026 04:21 PM)TOPSTRAIGHT Wrote: Tarleton would have a travel partner. Sam Houston is only 3.5 hours away which is busable and somewhat close by CUSA standards [Would "in theory" replace the 2 games in one trip>> La Tech/SH 4 hour 20m journey which teams have been making recently].
Airports...
Tarleton to DFW----------------------------less than two hours
Sam Houston to G. Bush Intl. (Houston)--one hour
Of course FB (except for SH) would charter fly. So I'm referring to all other sports above.
Or fly into Waco Regional (ACT), get a nice hotel along the riverfront, and bus 85 miles to Tarleton and 136 miles to Sammy.
RE: FCS "Prospects" Real Data, Opinions, Analytics, Budgets, Revenue, Etc..
Not sure if anyone has seen this post, or dalukes' latest video, but I am interested in everyone's opinion on it. The short of it, CUSA picks up the trash from an imploded MAC. I am not a fan of the idea, and find it irritating that all of these content creators have such a low view of CUSA. We said no to SAC State, and passed on UMass twice, yet, everyone thinks CUSA would jump at the chance to add the lessers from the MAC. Ohio? Yes. Miami of Ohio, Maybe. But there are FCS schools out there that are more attractive than a good many of the others... Rant complete. https://m.youtube.com/post/UgkxNsgXxBocX...8C-O6MqVtA
RE: FCS "Prospects" Real Data, Opinions, Analytics, Budgets, Revenue, Etc..
But are there more attractive FCS schools than attractive MAC schools? Dont think so. Other than veography Toledo, Ohio, Miami, western Mich would be fine additions on paper. Squint hard enough and BGSU, Central Mich, and Buffalo look alright.
RE: FCS "Prospects" Real Data, Opinions, Analytics, Budgets, Revenue, Etc..
(07-26-2026 08:32 AM)Bobcat2013 Wrote: But are there more attractive FCS schools than attractive MAC schools? Dont think so. Other than veography Toledo, Ohio, Miami, western Mich would be fine additions on paper. Squint hard enough and BGSU, Central Mich, and Buffalo look alright.
You are correct, and I agree with you about there being more attractive schools in the MAC than in the FCS. And I would prefer any additions come from there, as long as we are talking about the top of the conference and not the bottom.
RE: FCS "Prospects" Real Data, Opinions, Analytics, Budgets, Revenue, Etc..
A few schools in the MAC are more attractive to CUSA but some are not as attractive as FCS schools. Need to weigh each opportunity and go the best route if expansion occurs.
RE: FCS "Prospects" Real Data, Opinions, Analytics, Budgets, Revenue, Etc..
(07-26-2026 08:32 AM)Bobcat2013 Wrote: But are there more attractive FCS schools than attractive MAC schools? Dont think so. Other than veography Toledo, Ohio, Miami, western Mich would be fine additions on paper. Squint hard enough and BGSU, Central Mich, and Buffalo look alright.
I think there are 3 FCS school more attractive than most, not all, of the MAC. South Dakota State and the two Montanas
RE: FCS "Prospects" Real Data, Opinions, Analytics, Budgets, Revenue, Etc..
What makes MAC schools who have shown they cant or dont have the desire to compete attractive? Would rather have several more than the 3 listed from FCS. Some great FCS schools are not interest now but would still make better members.
RE: FCS "Prospects" Real Data, Opinions, Analytics, Budgets, Revenue, Etc..
I agree with the "not all FBS is more attractive" sentiment.
If we're looking at all-sports membership, one could make a case that a crappy football history could be trumped by an outstanding men's basketball program (and to a far lesser degree, other OLY sports), but it's football that drives the bus.
And even then, if it's not at least a moderately large market school with a history of bringing massive numbers of eyeballs to its TV games, it's probably not going to move the needle much with ESPN and/or CBS (or Fox or Amazon or...).
In other words, if we HAVE to expand, we're much better served going after a decent FCS program in our footprint with solid fan support than reaching for a cellar-tier MAC program.
(Let me stop here to emphasize: Not all MAC teams are in that tier!)
If we go football-only, we have any number of options. Geography truthfully doesn't matter. Montana? Montana State? SDSU? Bring it. That'd set us up to eventually poach NDSU, and then we'd be the proverbial cocks of the walk when it comes to football.
But no one wants to be in a conference where 1/3 of the membership are football-only affiliates. So toss that idea out. The MWC can go that route if they want. At least two of those candidates are solid matches for their footprint. (Truthfully, NDSU and SDSU just don't fit anywhere.)
There's just honestly no reason to look at anything more than all-sports members at this time. If the MAC were to dissolve, we could be as picky as we wanted. Ohio? Welcome aboard! Miami? Absolutely! Toledo? Glad to have you! Akron? Your football's kinda meh, but you're saved by your hoops.
Buffalo? We'll have to talk about this one. Football's OK. But their basketball isn't that good. Football may drive the bus, but bad basketball pours water in the engine.
WMU? I'm sorry, but we'll probably have to pass.
Everyone else? Do better. We're not interested at this time.
(This post was last modified: 07-27-2026 10:18 AM by whupemall.)
RE: FCS "Prospects" Real Data, Opinions, Analytics, Budgets, Revenue, Etc..
(07-27-2026 03:57 PM)Gemofthehills Wrote: Isnt Buffalo AAU? Sure the Presidents would be joyful to associate if so.
Buffalo is AAU, however, they are a 50/50 type of pick for any conference.
Because they are a New York State school, they just don't have a financial resources for athletics. From what I understand, the governor can veto large expenditures from the University, including stadiums, practices facilities, etc.; even if they are primarily funded from private donors.
For example, when Stony Brook tried to expand their stadium a few years back, Gov Cuomo vetoed it.
(This post was last modified: 07-28-2026 01:20 PM by sigke.)
RE: FCS "Prospects" Real Data, Opinions, Analytics, Budgets, Revenue, Etc..
Preferred Necessities for FBS in or near FCS candidate locations.
Amenities/ facilities:
1) FBS Road team needs a sizeable hotel including a conference center with multiple meeting rooms and that doesn't include the number of rooms needed for everyone that travels.
2) Local Airport needs to be able to support charter jets of visiting FBS football teams.
Tarleton President has stated need for hotel improvements in Stephenville and stated they were not quite ready in that area. Plans/construction are in the "works" but I'm unsure of details.
Stephenville Clark Regional Airport is inadequate and not large enough to land FB charter jets. Granbury, TX airport (23m away) "might" be large enough (unsure). Of course there is Dallas (almost 100 miles) but that adds to travel time and expense.
If you are going to add a school you don't want one with inadequate infrastructure.
This increases costs and time for visiting schools along with other hardships. Sometimes this can be overlooked (for a while). But--Why add a school that is inconvenient and increases your expenses?
Edit--of course these are lesser factors and not crucial impediments--but still important IMHO.
(This post was last modified: 07-28-2026 10:29 PM by TOPSTRAIGHT.)
RE: FCS "Prospects" Real Data, Opinions, Analytics, Budgets, Revenue, Etc..
Say what you want about Judy, she did well this past round of realignment. It is smart holding at 10 for now. If MAC teams are interested we would have to seriously consider them. Ohio, Miami, and Ball State make some sense. I’d take an Ohio and Miami combo if it was on the table immediately. Adds another good rivalry, Cincinnati market and doesn’t move the conference too much.
All that being said, I’m shocked at how bad the MWC messed up their realignment. Reminds me of CUSA when they had a chance at App and others but chose markets. They royally messed up imo. They should have kept Hawaii as a football only, never touched GCU, NIU, or UC Davis. They should have added full members with the Montana and Dakota schools. UTEP and NMSU should have been 11th and 12th full members if they wanted a cushion. I’m so glad we don’t have a part of that conference. It is a ticking time bomb imo.
Air Force
New Mexico
Nevada
UNLV
San Jose State
Wyoming
Montana
Montana State
NDSU
SDSU
UTEP
NMSU
That would have been nice travel partners and a fun conference to watch. Who wants to watch SJSU vs NIU?
RE: FCS "Prospects" Real Data, Opinions, Analytics, Budgets, Revenue, Etc..
CUSA 3.0 went for markets and paid the price when some got too big for their britches and left for the AAC.
The Sun Belt began as a non-football league and then began sponsoring football in a desperate attempt to survive. They were a hybrid for years with members all over the country. Finally they worked there way into a nice regional league. Not a lot of sexy markets with football programs not old enough to run for president, but a lot of places with football programs with deep roots. They kicked out their affiliates and non-football members, which strengthened them.
If we had to expand I would look into one of the MAC Ohio programs. But I doubt any will leave while the Sac State gravy train is running.
I do not want a football-only member. South Dakota State has a fine program but I would rather call up Tarleton as a full member. And definitely no non-football members. We left that hybrid crap in the OVC.
RE: FCS "Prospects" Real Data, Opinions, Analytics, Budgets, Revenue, Etc..
(07-28-2026 07:44 PM)Ewglenn Wrote: Say what you want about Judy, she did well this past round of realignment. It is smart holding at 10 for now. If MAC teams are interested we would have to seriously consider them. Ohio, Miami, and Ball State make some sense. I’d take an Ohio and Miami combo if it was on the table immediately. Adds another good rivalry, Cincinnati market and doesn’t move the conference too much.
All that being said, I’m shocked at how bad the MWC messed up their realignment. Reminds me of CUSA when they had a chance at App and others but chose markets. They royally messed up imo. They should have kept Hawaii as a football only, never touched GCU, NIU, or UC Davis. They should have added full members with the Montana and Dakota schools. UTEP and NMSU should have been 11th and 12th full members if they wanted a cushion. I’m so glad we don’t have a part of that conference. It is a ticking time bomb imo.
Air Force
New Mexico
Nevada
UNLV
San Jose State
Wyoming
Montana
Montana State
NDSU
SDSU
UTEP
NMSU
That would have been nice travel partners and a fun conference to watch. Who wants to watch SJSU vs NIU?
I actually think the Mountain West did a pretty good job.
South Dakota State & the Montanas were simply not ready. I'm sure the Mountain West spoke with them.
Additionally, North Dakota State was NOT interested in full membership at this point in time. They are so remote, the travel for Olympics sports to the Mountain West vs their current league would destroy their budget. South Dakota State wouldn't be able to afford full membership either.
As far as adding New Mexico State, the Mountain West was already adding UTEP & has New Mexico, I don't think adding New Mexico State was very appealing vs adding new markets.
Adding UC Davis was a strategic, long term add. So not bad on their part.
Washington St & Oregon St screwed the Mountain West over, and I think the Mountain West responded as best as they could & as quickly as they could to avoid more schools jumping ship.