Captain Bearcat
All-American in Everything
Posts: 9,501
Joined: Jun 2010
Reputation: 768
I Root For: UC
Location: IL & Cincinnati, USA
|
RE: Dennis Dodd is a Tool
(07-18-2022 03:14 PM)geef Wrote: (07-18-2022 03:02 PM)Captain Bearcat Wrote: (07-18-2022 01:59 PM)Cataclysmo Wrote: (07-18-2022 12:05 PM)Captain Bearcat Wrote: (07-18-2022 11:48 AM)CliftonAve Wrote: My guess is Dodds consider the city of Cincinnati to be this boring, rust bucket town; not a hip place like Portland, Seattle or LA. The thing is CFB is driven by viewers out of places like Tuscaloosa, AL; State College, PA; Bryan, TX; Norman, OK; not the so-called hip cities listed above.
Yep.
It's funny. He's talking about what was attractive to youth culture 20-40 years ago.
I teach college students, and when they talk about Portland or San Francisco, it's always in a negative light. My students nowadays talk about wanting to move to Nashville, Austin, or Dallas. Followed by Denver, Orlando, or a beach town in Florida. West Coast never makes the list.
The rents in Portland and San Francisco are crazy. Nashville, Austin and Dallas are all young and hip now but are rapidly becoming outpaced too. Asheville, NC will become another hot young place until its too expensive there. And so it goes.
It's not really about rents. It's about how cool it is.
Denver is still cool because of the outdoor activities and the craft beer scene. But that's about the only place that is still cool from 30 years ago.
What would attract the youth to Portland? In 1990, it was eco-hippies who smoked pot. But pot is legal almost everywhere now, and the frontlines of the environmental movement have moved away from save-the-trees (almost exclusively a Pacific Northwest youth movement) to stuffy white-collar climate change conferences (which is nationwide, and is largely people over 35).
What would attract the youth to San Francisco? In 1990, Silicon Valley was exploding and there were great TV shows & movies with a positive image of the city (Full House, Mrs Doubtfire, Star Trek). It offered New York-style urban living without New York problems. Today, the only thing you hear on TV about San Francisco is homelessness, crime, evil tech firms, and tech firms moving jobs to Austin.
I agree that Ashville is a boomtown now. So is Boise.
Interesting perspective. I moved to Denver 28 years ago, then to Portland 11 years ago. The main reason I moved to Colorado was for access to the outdoors, but that became increasingly difficult because of the number of people moving there and poor planning. We moved to Portland for the same reason, and it's been delightful. In just over an hour, I can be on a lift at one of three ski areas, at the beach, in incredible wine country, or on a river for world class rafting. The city has incredible food and beer, but it's ridiculously expensive for young people, thus the attractiveness of other western places like Boise, Salt Lake, etc. I love me some Timbers soccer, but sure to miss pro baseball and hockey.
I travel to San Francisco every other month. It's still an incredible city and region, but the tech bots have caused it to lose some of it's soul. Same with Seattle.
I'm just trying to guess why the coolness factor changed
"why something is cool" is frequently very different from "why something is good."
I lived in San Diego for awhile. It's still cool to a lot of people (especially Europeans), but it's a terrible place to live (even if cost of living was average).
Although San Francisco has gone downhill in both categories. When I visited in the late 90s, I came away thinking it was the best city in the country. When I visited again 7 years ago, I came away thinking that while there's still a lot to like, overall it was one of the worst cities in the country. The homelessness was off-the-charts, and the litter problem has gotten really bad, but those aren't the worst parts. The worst part was the pure snark of the average residents. They've traded peaceful hippies for hipster a-holes who think the epitome of a good time is an ironic joke at someone else's expense. SF's charm wasn't destroyed by suits, it was destroyed by hipsters.
|
|