Inspired by the ESPN rankings thread:

Tier 1 (All Timers):

Bruce Gradkowski

Logan Woodside

Tier 2 (Good starters when they got the chance):

Brian Jones (Tier 1 stats but Tier 2 sample size. Only started 1 season)

Dequan Finn (This should be his floor. Could be Tier 1 by the time he graduates)

Tavares Bolden (Checked his stats from 2000 and '99 but still feel comfortable putting him in the second tier)

Aaron Opelt

Terrance Owens

Philip Ely

Tier 3 (Might have been something, but didn't/hasn't worked out for one reason or another):

Eli Peters

Mitch Guadagni

Clint Cochran

Finn doesn’t belong in your list of tier 2’s. And, where is Ealey?

(06-01-2022 04:45 PM)rockytop Wrote:  Finn doesn’t belong in your list of tier 2’s. And, where is Ealey?

In small print, "since 2001." Maybe that got added after you posted.

(06-01-2022 04:45 PM)rockytop Wrote:  Finn doesn’t belong in your list of tier 2’s. And, where is Ealey?

Eastisbest is correct, I only listed QBs from the 2001 season to current. The reason I use 2001 as my baseline is because that was my first year as a student and when I started following the Rockets.

Finn shouldn't be listed at Tier 2 since he hasn't completed his career yet, he isn't of that quality, or he is of better quality?