(01-18-2022 06:20 AM)Schaefer Beer Wrote: What disappointed me most on Monty was when he first started, I not only thought it was a great hire, but he started out like gangbusters in recruiting. He was getting in on recruits that wouldn't give us a look before
Did some of these recruits have baggage, yes, but I think he thought he could keep on the straight and narrow. I give him credit, once they screwed up, they were gone.
The disappointment came in his last three years of his tenure, he lost his zest to recruit. It seemed that he was content with DIv. 2, Div. 3, NAIA and JUCO players. It was a far cry from Abdel Nader and just missing on Fred Van Fleet.
The last 3 years of his tenure, he was clearly in survival mode. He didn't have any semblance of a replacement for German. Not that German is replaceable but he didn't have a legit scorer to hand the reins to...he had decent complimentary pieces who should have been good enough for that role. But he was forcing guys like Hankerson, Beane and even Mateen into roles where they were expected to carry the team. It was a bad plan and he sealed his own fate with it.
I've said it before about his recruiting and he almost always did this throughout his time at NIU. If he had 4 scholarships, he'd target 4 guys. If he got them, he'd have a nice run for a couple years, but if he didn't, he'd start to scramble and fill in the blanks with whoever was left over.
For whatever reason, players liked him and a number of them were quite loyal. He just didn't have a recruiting plan that went any further than a small focus area.
He was better than his predecessor, that is for damn sure. Granted, the bar was set pretty low and, to his defense, hamstrung him a bit. As bad as the team was that Burno inherited, it wasn't nearly as bad as the team Montgomery inherited. Those last few years under Patton were about as painful to watch as could be imagined. How he got Xavier Silas to transfer is one of the great mysteries of life. But it just goes to show you, some coaches form bonds with guys and it just sticks.
But, even with Silas on the team for 2 years, Patton was only able to win a combined 19 games over that span. With that said, Montgomery went on to follow that up with Nader and won 10 games in 2 years.
Because, Montgomery couldn't fill in the gaps. He'd get a target and focus on it and not see the rest of the field. I'm not sure NIU would have won a game his first two years had it not been for Nader. And he was only barely scoring in double digits. So, maybe.
Man oh man, how do you go 4 consecutive years with future NBA players on your roster (even as bench guys) and win an average of 7.25 games over that span?
Recruiting.
But in regards to your baggage comment. That hurts a program. And it hurt Montgomery. He'd believe he could transform these guys (or maybe he just was wishin' upon a star they'd find the straight and narrow) and when they blew up on him, there was no one there to step in. He'd have to start all over time and time again. Whether it was risky recruits or shooting stars. There was never a plan to sustain momentum.