umbluegray
Legend
Posts: 42,195
Joined: Nov 2003
Reputation: 2027
I Root For: The Tigers!
Location: Memphis
|
RE: Dysfunctional Black Community Wrapped Up In A Single Video
(06-21-2021 01:20 PM)VA49er Wrote: (06-21-2021 01:11 PM)umbluegray Wrote: (06-20-2021 09:37 AM)swagsurfer11 Wrote: (06-19-2021 10:28 PM)Todor Wrote: (06-19-2021 10:22 PM)swagsurfer11 Wrote: Education and opportunity. That is being defunded. Doesn't matter if a corporation is looking for a black face if one's schools are underfunded and can't afford college. That only leads to opportunities for rich black families and then they are accused of being affirmative action hires.
The good schools already get less funding than the ones with 15% graduation rates. Money doesn't replace parents.
Good Lord, even the Atlantic agrees its not money. Of course, they add in a million other excuses...
https://www.theatlantic.com/education/ar...re/551126/
Schools are funded through property taxes and most of the charter schools aren't that good.
Schools have multiple funding sources.
The highest single source of funding comes from the state. This is not surprising given that the state is the entity responsible for public education. It is NOT a federal responsibility as noted by its absence in the constitution. All things not listed as a federal responsibility fall to the states.
The second highest source of funding comes from the local government. This is where property taxes come into play.
Of the "Big 3" sources of funding, third is the federal government. Note that this amount is surprisingly small ranging anywhere from 1 to 20%. In Memphis, the feds accounted for 12% of the budgeted funding source. In other nearby districts federal funding was as low as 6% of the budget.
Also note that federal funding is NOT typically used for general education purposes. It is almost always earmarked for specific programs.
As far as quality of education in the U.S. goes, homeschool students rank as the top performers followed by private school students and bringing up the rear are public school students.
Interestingly, each of those are funded inversely to their performance.
As homeschool parents we received ZERO dollars from state, local and federal governments.
Private schools fund students at a lower rate than public schools.
Public School Funding Per Student Averages 80% More Than Private Schools
By James D. Agresti
July 29, 2020
Quote:Consistent with that DOE data, new research by Just Facts reveals that average public K–12 school funding per student is about 80% higher than private schools. Specifically, the latest DOE data shows that governments spent an average of $14,439 for every student enrolled in K–12 public schools in the 2016–17 school year. In comparison, Just Facts estimates that private schools spent an average of $8,039 per student in the same year.
The figure for private school spending was determined by Just Facts with data from the DOE and U.S. Bureau of Economic Analysis. All methodological details are provided in the footnotes located here, and all data and calculations are shown in this spreadsheet.
Furthermore, DOE’s figure for public school spending per student doesn’t include the costs of state government administration, unfunded pension liabilities, and public worker post-employment benefits (like health insurance). In contrast, Just Facts’ figure for private schools is comprehensive and includes all spending by private consumers, nonprofit organizations, and governments. This means that the full public school funding advantage is greater than 80%.
The Finances of Homeschooling Your Kids: What It Costs, Tax Breaks, More
By Andrea Browne Taylor
December 8, 2020
Quote:Homeschooling is neither cheap nor easy. The average cost of homeschooling ranges from $700 to $1,800 per child per school year, according to Time4Learning.com, an online resource for homeschool families. This includes the cost of the curriculum, school supplies, field trips and extracurricular activities.
So, if you're keeping track:
Homeshool - Highest Peformance - $1,800 per student
Private School - High Performance - $8,039 per student
Public School - Low Performance - $14,439 per student*
* Public School per student funding is significantly higher when other costs are considered such as state government administration, unfunded pension liabilities, and public worker post-employment benefits.
Why do school funding rates and academic performance have an inverse relationship?
My guess would be all that extra funding goes to administrative nonsense rather than to teachers, etc. Not sure the accounting tricks that are played to make those moneys apply per student.
As far as funding goes... I reviewed the Shelby County Schools budget from last year and for next year.
There is a huge increase in federal funds due to covid stimulus plan.
The largest budget ask ever made by Memphis schools — $2.19 billion — includes teacher raises and building renovations
By Cathryn Stout
May 18, 2021, 10:44pm CDT
Shelby County Schools Reports/Documents link
FY21
Funding: $1,426,924,239
Students: 104,460
Per Student: $13,570
Salaries: $654,005,219
Benefits: $203,120,412
Total: $857,125,631
% of Budget: 60.1%
FY21
Funding: $2,172,643,169
Students: 109,319
Per Student: $20,063
Salaries: $808,960,167
Benefits: $226,619,202
Total: $1,035,579,369
% of Budget: 47.7%
|
|