(06-01-2020 08:46 PM)Rice93 Wrote: I just thought it weird that somebody could look at that video and not think that the cops killed George Floyd.
Perhaps I read about the condition he exhibited prior to his final face down position.
Again, when he was removed from his car, he complained about a shortness of breath. When leading him to the cruiser, he collapsed. He was brought back up, then collapsed again. He was brought to his feet a second time, and again he complained of a shortness of breath.
One might surmise he is, at the point of being brought out of his car, already having an attack of some sort. That series is kind of spot on how my grandfather died.
Second, had the initial findings noted asphyxia, I wouldnt have much doubt. They didnt show that.
I look at that video and I see a horrible assault on a man being detained.
And, even before knowing about the symptoms he exhibited before he fell for the last time, I dont automatically assume that the very horrific assault led to his death. Did it seem possible? Of course. Probable? Maybe. But I have seen other actions that I would have sworn to the Bible and back would/should have led to death but didnt. Perhaps I am jaded on the concept of 'actual causation' and have myself fallen for the hook line and sinker of a kneejerk assumption.
There is a concept called 'cause in fact', and requirement of that is --- well -- fact. There were no underlying facts to automatically assume the belief that the knee in the neck would cause that death. There is good cause to think that, but there is also that realm that it did not when underlying facts are missing.
As it stands, the knee on the neck doesnt have such a clear link to the physical reason of his death by heart failure. The prosecutors are going to have a bear of a time proving a murder that way.
The easier mode is this: Chauvin had reason to know Floyd was under physical distress *at the time he was removed from his car*. He exhibited all the classic symptoms of heart failure. When cops detain you, they assume all responsibility for your well being. Chauvin ignored those very visible symptoms. In that short little summary, you have at the very least negligent homicide -- a manslaughter 2 count. Right then and there.
The act of the knee on the neck *even in light* of the classic symptoms of heart failure shows potentially a depraved indifference to Chauvin's well being -- in fact to Chauvin's life. His continued refusal to heed the calls by his other cops is another point; as is the continued refusal to heed the calls of the bystanders. That is enough for a murder 3 count -- depraved or reckless indifference.
The other key is that Chauvin both had an official responsibility for Floyd's well being, but he also had 'physical control' of Floyd at the very same time.
But you all are so gd fixated that the knee was the cause in fact to the death, that the more realistic alternative seems to fly right past you.
Floyd's heart stoppage and symptoms at the point of being detained, and the fact that they were not just ignored, but adamantly ignored is enough. And that fits precisely into the facts given by the witnesses about his collapsing, *and* comforms precisely to the COD meted out by the actual official pathologist.
The analysis to hisn cohorts is more problematic. But blood is in the water, and the acolytes (like you) wont be satisfied with the Chauvin target alone -- the blood lust that you all exhibit guarantee that the others will be charged, even if on that scenario.
And when they are let go at the appellate level for an 'insufficiency of evidence' or a 'just a friggin wrong application of the law to the facts', it will be attitudes like yours that guarantee another city going up in smoke. Got to love that bloodlust.
But that is why I am not a tremendously large fan of progressive causes for the whole part.
So, go ahead and preemptively believe that a knee in the neck causes heart failure. Sounds like fun to me. Also sounds like a belief system that I would prefer not to practice -- that is the belief trumps the factual record.