(08-05-2019 09:34 PM)DavidSt Wrote: The only way to breakup this CARTEL that is called Power 5? All other schools and universities from G5, FCS and D2 should join forces to file an anti-trust lawsuit against P5 and NCAA. If the schools win? All tv contracts for the P5 would be void and the P5 conferences would be broken up like Ma Bell was in the 1980s. All you have to say is anti-trust and watched them add MWC and AAC as power conferences. I would love to see all the states represented into Power conferences.
you do not have a clue how anti-trust works it has nothing at all to do with the conference TV contracts
those conferences are in no way shape or form preventing any other conference from getting a TV contract
the fact that they do not add more members is not anti trust at all because the USA has the right of association and because the fact that some teams cannot get in a conference they wish they were in does not mean that anyone is preventing them from forming a conference and trying to get the best TV contract they can
there are multiple bidders for TV contracts so the fact that some conferences get little to nothing is not anti trust it just means no one wants to pay them and that has nothing to do with other conferences
and you analogy with Ma Bell is extremely poor because what you are saying has in fact already happened......OU and UGA went to court and accused the CFA of being anti trust and it was found to be so and thus the CFA was broken up and individual conferences formed and signed their own TV deals
those conferences are not "Ma Bell" they are Bell South, Southwestern Bell, Verizon, US West, Qwest and others
the fact that SWB is now called AT&T and gets a lot of business and Verizon (Formerly Bell Atlantic) gets a lot of business does not mean that Frontier and Century Link have any anti trust case against them they are all ILEC carriers in some area
nor does it mean that CLEC carriers have any claim against them
there is nothing anti trust about the conferences and their TV deals
and even if anyone wants to say that the football playoffs are anti trust the result of pushing a court case with that is the conferences that own the individual bowls like Big 10/PAC 12 and SEC Sugar would just go back to the way things were before where they have a set match up between two conferences which is 100% legal and other conferences are free to start a bowl game and try and lure the best team to play in that bowl and then the media can award a national champion
the fact that those bowl games and conferences got together and made agreements is not anti trust in and of itself even if the G5 conferences are not happy with their part of the deal......because the conferences that had an ownership stake in the major bowls that brought the value did not have to include any other conference nor did they force other conferences to participate nor did they stop other conferences from trying to start their own bowl game and matching teams and then claiming a national championship
the P5 conferences could have simply signed agreements among themselves they did not have to offer anything to he G5 conferences nor are they stopping those conferences from trying to do the same.....the market is