(02-23-2018 04:56 PM)billybobby777 Wrote: (02-23-2018 03:56 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote: (02-23-2018 02:21 PM)YNot Wrote: It depends on how you define "hurt" by realignment.
BYU is a loser if you look at it from the 2009 lens of playing in a football conference that had 2 or 3 top-25 teams annually and was on the verge of qualifying for the BCS exemption, with the Thanksgiving weekend game against its primary rival. Similar analysis when compared to the MWC basketball conference that had perennially ranked teams with SDSU, UNLV, New Mexico, Utah and BYU and multiple NCAA tournament bids.
However, BYU is making more money than ever, has WAY better TV exposure and national fan access than ever possible in the MWC. And, Olympic sports play in a conference with like-minded institutions in states (including Utah) that cover more than 2/3 of the alumni base. And, its conference basketball champion played in the national championship game last year - gym-size notwithstanding.
When compared to the *current* status of the MWC and WAC, it's a no-brainer that BYU hasn't been "hurt." It avoided the situations that could have really hurt them.
I agree with you here. To your point, my pushback is this notion is BYU is on a list of top 10 schools to be hurt by realignment. The fact of the matter is that all of the members of the old MWC and WAC have suffered much more as a result of conference realignment than BYU.
Oh no doubt that the old WAC/MWC have been hurt by realignment more. It’s been catastrophic in fact. But BYU has been hurt too. The grudges that came out of that are visible today as BYU has H&H’s scheduled with far away NIU and ECU (4 games) UMASS (4 Games) instead of Air Force, Wyoming, Colorado St and New Mexico. Their long time historic regional rivals. I remember watching BYU play on tv vs UNLV and UNM. Those were big time games like the original CUSA Louisville/Cincinnati/Memphis Games.
BYU sees this as a massive benefit. The whole point of independence has been exposure and fan access.
BYU doesn't have a lot of alumni or fans in the Front Range. Less than 4% of BYU's alumni come from Colorado, Wyoming, and New Mexico...only about 200K LDS (3% of the US LDS population).
....but half of their MWC conference schedule had games in that footprint.
As an independent, BYU is able to get a truly national schedule. BYU gets better exposure and takes the teams to fans and alumni in each region of the country.
In the last 5 seasons:
-
Midwest: Notre Dame, Michigan, Michigan St., Nebraska, Missouri, Cincinnati,
PLUS upcoming with Wisconsin, Minnesota, Toledo, NIU
-
Southeast: Ole Miss, Mississippi St., Georgia Tech, UCF, ECU, Middle Tennessee, Miami Beach bowl,
PLUS upcoming with Tennessee, USF, NC State, Georgia Southern
-
Mid-Atlantic/NE: Virginia, WVU in Maryland, UConn,
PLUS upcoming with Virginia, Virginia Tech, UMass, Liberty
-
Texas: Texas, Houston, LSU (supposed to be in Houston),
PLUS upcoming with Baylor, Houston
-
Pacific: Cal, UCLA, Arizona, SJSU, Fresno St., Hawaii,
PLUS upcoming with USC, Stanford, Washington, Washington St., Oregon, SDSU, Hawaii
-
Mountain/Regional: Utah, Utah St. and Boise St. are annual games, plus UNLV, Arizona in Las Vegas.