To win a national championship (even with someone else's players), it's going to require coaching against some of the best coaches in the country. It goes without saying that there will be hundreds if not thousands of in-game decision made in order to steady the ship and allow the players to execute at the necessary level to bring about the desired results. I also think it's fair to say that UConn's 2013 team wasn't Kentucky'esque.
After looking at Ollie's career, it appears he coached the team a year before the national championship. I was thinking had he won the first year he took the team over, he could have just copied everything Calhoun had been doing running straight off a "recipe for success" if you will. But in the second year, his fingerprints would start showing up in different places. I also just noticed that he was the conference tournament champion in 2015-16 which gives him a little more credit still.
There is no question that he'd be lucky if he was 3/4 the coach of a Calhoun, but there's a chance he is better than advertised. Calhoun would certainly not be looking to tank the program after his departure and could have hand picked any available coach in the nation upon retirement. He chose Ollie. There's got to be a reason. Calhoun has made enumerable wise decisions during his tenure at UConn. Yes, Ollie could be a monumental mistake, but the probabilities are low that he was the wrong man for the job at the time Calhoun gave his blessing.
I think I'm ready to offer my diagnosis. *drum roll*
I believe that after UConn separated from the old Big East, Ollie was faced with a more limited pool of high caliber recruits. He still got some 4 star players but they weren't the kind of 4 star players he was used to getting. In other words, he got the 4 star athlete with work ethic or attitude issues that every other major program passed on. These are the players that fill the rosters of the bottom dwellers in every major conference like K-State, Auburn, Northwestern, Rutgers, etc. They still look legit on the outside, but the elevator doesn't go all the way to the top floor. I can assure you that every year there are many 2-3 star recruits that end up way more helpful to a team's overall success than many 4 stars. In fact, there are some highly rated recruits that would actually be cancerous to a team. Chemistry is everything you know.
So instead of reacting to the change in the recruiting landscape, Ollie tried to maintain the appearance of a certain pedigree of athlete; and while the average team rating didn't drop much, the important intangible rating (the one that Marshall is a master at deciphering) plummeted. Now Ollie finds himself with a team of physically talented, incohesive players that exhibit low BBIQ on a nightly basis and completely fold under pressure. This causes Ollie to run up and down the sidelines screaming all night (which further exacerbates the problem).
How did I do?
T
...