Hello There, Guest! (LoginRegister)

Post Reply 
In the CFP, how does 5-8 have a chance
Author Message
TrojanCampaign Offline
All American
*

Posts: 4,193
Joined: Sep 2011
Reputation: 106
I Root For: USC, UA, AAMU,
Location: Huntsville
Post: #21
RE: In the CFP, how does 5-8 have a chance
I think Alabama and Georgia are the only teams that have a chance. If Ohio State beats Wisconsin then I think Alabama gets in.

If Georgia beats Auburn than Georgia for sure gets in.

If Ohio State beats Wisconsin. And Georgia beats Auburn I think there is also a chance that Georgia and Alabama can get in.
11-29-2017 05:16 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bullet Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 26,750
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 620
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
Post: #22
RE: In the CFP, how does 5-8 have a chance
(11-29-2017 12:13 PM)Frog in the Kitchen Sink Wrote:  
(11-29-2017 11:47 AM)BadgerMJ Wrote:  
(11-29-2017 11:10 AM)NewTimes Wrote:  If 1-4 wins out, the field is set. It's safe to say 1 or 2 teams may lose. How does the 5-8 stack up?

#5 Alabama - idle and likely out, unfamiliar territory, weaker schedule
#6 GA vs, #2 Auburn - May swap places with GA win, Auburn gone with 3 loses
#7 Miami vs. #1 Clemson - Clemson with 2 loses on bubble, Miami to #4 with win
#8 Ohio St vs. #3 Wisconsin - Ohio St replaces Wisconsin with win
#9 Penn St and #10 SoCal out of picture

5-8 in the mix if 1 or 2 1-4's lose.

If any of the top 4 falter, Bama is in, not necessarily because they're better, but because they're Bama.

Like it or not, if it comes down to it, the NAMES are going to get the benefit of the doubt. Why? Because one, they have proven track records, and two the committee knows who butters their bread.... The networks.

They know there's NO WAY all that money keeps rolling in if ratings are down. Networks don't pay hundreds of millions so Southwest Tech can be in the playoffs. Blue Bloods appeal to the casual fan and even to the non-sports fan who might tune in to see the "big game".

All things being equal, if it comes down to a Bama, tOSU or a TCU (for example), you can let it ride that Bama or tOSU will be the ones with their name called.

It's a popular theory (especially among TCU fans!), but don't buy it for a couple of reasons. First, the computer averages and old BCS formula so far have come up with the same 4 participants the first three years as the committee. Second, there are examples of name schools being behind lesser name schools with similar profiles in the weekly and even final rankings. The reality is that name schools typically have had better profiles/arguments to date. We see what we want to see. We see them get in and say "see! Name school!", when it really is their strength of their overall profile.

The old BCS formulas relied on two polls that were heavily biased towards name schools. 2/3 of the amount I believe?
11-29-2017 05:28 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bullet Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 26,750
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 620
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
Post: #23
RE: In the CFP, how does 5-8 have a chance
(11-29-2017 12:30 PM)BadgerMJ Wrote:  
(11-29-2017 12:13 PM)Frog in the Kitchen Sink Wrote:  
(11-29-2017 11:47 AM)BadgerMJ Wrote:  
(11-29-2017 11:10 AM)NewTimes Wrote:  If 1-4 wins out, the field is set. It's safe to say 1 or 2 teams may lose. How does the 5-8 stack up?

#5 Alabama - idle and likely out, unfamiliar territory, weaker schedule
#6 GA vs, #2 Auburn - May swap places with GA win, Auburn gone with 3 loses
#7 Miami vs. #1 Clemson - Clemson with 2 loses on bubble, Miami to #4 with win
#8 Ohio St vs. #3 Wisconsin - Ohio St replaces Wisconsin with win
#9 Penn St and #10 SoCal out of picture

5-8 in the mix if 1 or 2 1-4's lose.

If any of the top 4 falter, Bama is in, not necessarily because they're better, but because they're Bama.

Like it or not, if it comes down to it, the NAMES are going to get the benefit of the doubt. Why? Because one, they have proven track records, and two the committee knows who butters their bread.... The networks.

They know there's NO WAY all that money keeps rolling in if ratings are down. Networks don't pay hundreds of millions so Southwest Tech can be in the playoffs. Blue Bloods appeal to the casual fan and even to the non-sports fan who might tune in to see the "big game".

All things being equal, if it comes down to a Bama, tOSU or a TCU (for example), you can let it ride that Bama or tOSU will be the ones with their name called.

It's a popular theory (especially among TCU fans!), but don't buy it for a couple of reasons. First, the computer averages and old BCS formula so far have come up with the same 4 participants the first three years as the committee. Second, there are examples of name schools being behind lesser name schools with similar profiles in the weekly and even final rankings. The reality is that name schools typically have had better profiles/arguments to date. We see what we want to see. We see them get in and say "see! Name school!", when it really is their strength of their overall profile.

Which is why I'm NOT a big fan of expanding to 8 teams.

Until there's a system that is completely impartial and takes into account "numbers only", there will be people's opinions and biases involved in the decision.

Perfect example is March Madness. When the NCAA took over, they expanded to 16 teams and the 17th teams griped. On and on till it went to 64 and the 65th team complained. Then they went to 68 and now the 69th team hollers "unfair". Unless the playoffs include every team, someone left out will feel slighted.

The CFP is actually a pretty fair and decent system IMO. It takes into consideration record, SOS, etc, but also gives credit to purely subjective things like the "eye test" and, to be frank, names.

You are right about the "names" though, most times the Blue Bloods got to that position BECAUSE they have better profiles and have won the big games.

The same thing goes for conferences as far as I'm concerned.

Nobody really cares if #65 complains. They have no chance of winning. #3 often had a very good chance of winning. I think TCU was probably the best team in 2014, but they got left out. This year, the gap from #1-#11 isn't very big.
11-29-2017 05:30 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Nerdlinger Offline
1st String
*

Posts: 1,071
Joined: May 2017
Reputation: 35
I Root For: Realignment!
Location: :uoᴉʇɐɔo⌉
Post: #24
RE: In the CFP, how does 5-8 have a chance
(11-29-2017 11:10 AM)NewTimes Wrote:  If 1-4 wins out, the field is set. It's safe to say 1 or 2 teams may lose. How does the 5-8 stack up?

#5 Alabama - idle and likely out, unfamiliar territory, weaker schedule
#6 GA vs, #2 Auburn - May swap places with GA win, Auburn gone with 3 loses
#7 Miami vs. #1 Clemson - Clemson with 2 loses on bubble, Miami to #4 with win
#8 Ohio St vs. #3 Wisconsin - Ohio St replaces Wisconsin with win
#9 Penn St and #10 SoCal out of picture

5-8 in the mix if 1 or 2 1-4's lose.

My assessment:

Top 8 Ranked Teams - Wins Over Current Top 25 Ranked Teams - Losses

#1 Clemson (11-1) - W: #2 Auburn, #22 Virginia Tech, #24 NC State - L: [unranked] Syracuse
#2 Auburn (10-2) - W: #5 Alabama, #6 Georgia, #23 Mississippi State - L: #1 Clemson, #17 LSU
#3 Oklahoma (11-1) - W: #8 Ohio State, #11 TCU, #19 Oklahoma State - L: [unranked] Iowa State
#4 Wisconsin (12-0) - W: #21 Northwestern - L: [none]
#5 Alabama (11-1) - W: #17 LSU, #23 Mississippi State, #25 Fresno State - L: #2 Auburn
#6 Georgia (11-1) - W: #15 Notre Dame, #23 Mississippi State - L: #2 Auburn
#7 Miami (10-1) - W: #15 Notre Dame, #22 Virginia Tech - L: [unranked] Pittsburgh
#8 Ohio State (10-2) - W: #9 Penn State, #16 Michigan State - L: #3 Oklahoma, [unranked] Iowa

Winner of Clemson/Miami will make Top 4
Winner of Auburn/Georgia will make Top 4
Winner of Ohio State/Wisconsin will make Top 4
If Oklahoma wins, will make Top 4 - if not, Alabama will sneak in
(This post was last modified: 11-29-2017 06:22 PM by Nerdlinger.)
11-29-2017 06:15 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
stever20 Online
Legend
*

Posts: 30,249
Joined: Nov 2011
Reputation: 282
I Root For: College Sports
Location:
Post: #25
RE: In the CFP, how does 5-8 have a chance
(11-29-2017 06:15 PM)Nerdlinger Wrote:  
(11-29-2017 11:10 AM)NewTimes Wrote:  If 1-4 wins out, the field is set. It's safe to say 1 or 2 teams may lose. How does the 5-8 stack up?

#5 Alabama - idle and likely out, unfamiliar territory, weaker schedule
#6 GA vs, #2 Auburn - May swap places with GA win, Auburn gone with 3 loses
#7 Miami vs. #1 Clemson - Clemson with 2 loses on bubble, Miami to #4 with win
#8 Ohio St vs. #3 Wisconsin - Ohio St replaces Wisconsin with win
#9 Penn St and #10 SoCal out of picture

5-8 in the mix if 1 or 2 1-4's lose.

My assessment:

Top 8 Ranked Teams - Wins Over Current Top 25 Ranked Teams - Losses

#1 Clemson (11-1) - W: #2 Auburn, #22 Virginia Tech, #24 NC State - L: [unranked] Syracuse
#2 Auburn (10-2) - W: #5 Alabama, #6 Georgia, #23 Mississippi State - L: #1 Clemson, #17 LSU
#3 Oklahoma (11-1) - W: #8 Ohio State, #11 TCU, #19 Oklahoma State - L: [unranked] Iowa State
#4 Wisconsin (12-0) - W: #21 Northwestern - L: [none]
#5 Alabama (11-1) - W: #19 LSU, #23 Mississippi State - L: #2 Auburn
#6 Georgia (11-1) - W: #15 Notre Dame, #23 Mississippi State - L: #2 Auburn
#7 Miami (10-1) - W: #15 Notre Dame, #22 Virginia Tech - L: [unranked] Pittsburgh
#8 Ohio State (10-2) - W: #9 Penn State, #16 Michigan State - L: #3 Oklahoma, [unranked] Iowa

Winner of Clemson/Miami will make Top 4
Winner of Auburn/Georgia will make Top 4
Winner of Ohio State/Wisconsin will make Top 4
If Oklahoma wins, will make Top 4 - if not, Alabama will sneak in

You forgot the Alabama win over Fresno St, which is a ranked win.

Sorry but it's no lock at all that Ohio St gets in just with a win over Wisconsin. Ohio St won't have just Alabama to deal with, but also could easily have Clemson to deal with as well. Clemson has 3 top 25 wins, including one over what could easily be #1 Auburn.

The problem for Ohio St is that they didn't just lose to Iowa, they got boat raced.
11-29-2017 06:20 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Nerdlinger Offline
1st String
*

Posts: 1,071
Joined: May 2017
Reputation: 35
I Root For: Realignment!
Location: :uoᴉʇɐɔo⌉
Post: #26
RE: In the CFP, how does 5-8 have a chance
(11-29-2017 06:20 PM)stever20 Wrote:  
(11-29-2017 06:15 PM)Nerdlinger Wrote:  
(11-29-2017 11:10 AM)NewTimes Wrote:  If 1-4 wins out, the field is set. It's safe to say 1 or 2 teams may lose. How does the 5-8 stack up?

#5 Alabama - idle and likely out, unfamiliar territory, weaker schedule
#6 GA vs, #2 Auburn - May swap places with GA win, Auburn gone with 3 loses
#7 Miami vs. #1 Clemson - Clemson with 2 loses on bubble, Miami to #4 with win
#8 Ohio St vs. #3 Wisconsin - Ohio St replaces Wisconsin with win
#9 Penn St and #10 SoCal out of picture

5-8 in the mix if 1 or 2 1-4's lose.

My assessment:

Top 8 Ranked Teams - Wins Over Current Top 25 Ranked Teams - Losses

#1 Clemson (11-1) - W: #2 Auburn, #22 Virginia Tech, #24 NC State - L: [unranked] Syracuse
#2 Auburn (10-2) - W: #5 Alabama, #6 Georgia, #23 Mississippi State - L: #1 Clemson, #17 LSU
#3 Oklahoma (11-1) - W: #8 Ohio State, #11 TCU, #19 Oklahoma State - L: [unranked] Iowa State
#4 Wisconsin (12-0) - W: #21 Northwestern - L: [none]
#5 Alabama (11-1) - W: #19 LSU, #23 Mississippi State - L: #2 Auburn
#6 Georgia (11-1) - W: #15 Notre Dame, #23 Mississippi State - L: #2 Auburn
#7 Miami (10-1) - W: #15 Notre Dame, #22 Virginia Tech - L: [unranked] Pittsburgh
#8 Ohio State (10-2) - W: #9 Penn State, #16 Michigan State - L: #3 Oklahoma, [unranked] Iowa

Winner of Clemson/Miami will make Top 4
Winner of Auburn/Georgia will make Top 4
Winner of Ohio State/Wisconsin will make Top 4
If Oklahoma wins, will make Top 4 - if not, Alabama will sneak in

You forgot the Alabama win over Fresno St, which is a ranked win.

Sorry but it's no lock at all that Ohio St gets in just with a win over Wisconsin. Ohio St won't have just Alabama to deal with, but also could easily have Clemson to deal with as well. Clemson has 3 top 25 wins, including one over what could easily be #1 Auburn.

The problem for Ohio St is that they didn't just lose to Iowa, they got boat raced.

Good catch on Fresno -- fixed. And fair point about Ohio State.
11-29-2017 06:31 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Fighting Muskie Offline
1st String
*

Posts: 1,256
Joined: Sep 2016
Reputation: 37
I Root For: Ohio St, MAC
Location:
Post: #27
RE: In the CFP, how does 5-8 have a chance
(11-29-2017 06:15 PM)Nerdlinger Wrote:  
(11-29-2017 11:10 AM)NewTimes Wrote:  If 1-4 wins out, the field is set. It's safe to say 1 or 2 teams may lose. How does the 5-8 stack up?

#5 Alabama - idle and likely out, unfamiliar territory, weaker schedule
#6 GA vs, #2 Auburn - May swap places with GA win, Auburn gone with 3 loses
#7 Miami vs. #1 Clemson - Clemson with 2 loses on bubble, Miami to #4 with win
#8 Ohio St vs. #3 Wisconsin - Ohio St replaces Wisconsin with win
#9 Penn St and #10 SoCal out of picture

5-8 in the mix if 1 or 2 1-4's lose.

My assessment:

Top 8 Ranked Teams - Wins Over Current Top 25 Ranked Teams - Losses

#1 Clemson (11-1) - W: #2 Auburn, #22 Virginia Tech, #24 NC State - L: [unranked] Syracuse
#2 Auburn (10-2) - W: #5 Alabama, #6 Georgia, #23 Mississippi State - L: #1 Clemson, #17 LSU
#3 Oklahoma (11-1) - W: #8 Ohio State, #11 TCU, #19 Oklahoma State - L: [unranked] Iowa State
#4 Wisconsin (12-0) - W: #21 Northwestern - L: [none]
#5 Alabama (11-1) - W: #17 LSU, #23 Mississippi State, #25 Fresno State - L: #2 Auburn
#6 Georgia (11-1) - W: #15 Notre Dame, #23 Mississippi State - L: #2 Auburn
#7 Miami (10-1) - W: #15 Notre Dame, #22 Virginia Tech - L: [unranked] Pittsburgh
#8 Ohio State (10-2) - W: #9 Penn State, #16 Michigan State - L: #3 Oklahoma, [unranked] Iowa

Winner of Clemson/Miami will make Top 4
Winner of Auburn/Georgia will make Top 4
Winner of Ohio State/Wisconsin will make Top 4
If Oklahoma wins, will make Top 4 - if not, Alabama will sneak in

I am with you. ACC, SEC, and Big Ten conference winners are all locks. A TCU upset of Oklahoma is not enough to elevate the Frogs into the title and Alabama will sneak in as the highest rated non-champion as their lone loss is to a respectable team despite the fact that Miss St is their best win.
11-29-2017 06:39 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Nerdlinger Offline
1st String
*

Posts: 1,071
Joined: May 2017
Reputation: 35
I Root For: Realignment!
Location: :uoᴉʇɐɔo⌉
Post: #28
RE: In the CFP, how does 5-8 have a chance
New assessment:

.png  CFP2017-18.png (Size: 27.67 KB / Downloads: 10)

(How do I get this image to display in the post?)

Based on this assessment, and if we assume that each team (besides Alabama, of course) has a 50/50 chance of winning the CCG, here are the mathematical probabilities of each team reaching the CFP:

Clemson: 67%
Auburn, Georgia, Miami, Oklahoma, Wisconsin: 50% each
Alabama: 48% - not bad
Ohio State: 35%
(This post was last modified: 11-30-2017 09:12 AM by Nerdlinger.)
11-29-2017 07:31 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
BadgerMJ Offline
1st String
*

Posts: 1,189
Joined: Mar 2017
Reputation: 108
I Root For: Wisconsin / ND
Location: Wisconsin
Post: #29
RE: In the CFP, how does 5-8 have a chance
(11-29-2017 05:30 PM)bullet Wrote:  
(11-29-2017 12:30 PM)BadgerMJ Wrote:  
(11-29-2017 12:13 PM)Frog in the Kitchen Sink Wrote:  
(11-29-2017 11:47 AM)BadgerMJ Wrote:  
(11-29-2017 11:10 AM)NewTimes Wrote:  If 1-4 wins out, the field is set. It's safe to say 1 or 2 teams may lose. How does the 5-8 stack up?

#5 Alabama - idle and likely out, unfamiliar territory, weaker schedule
#6 GA vs, #2 Auburn - May swap places with GA win, Auburn gone with 3 loses
#7 Miami vs. #1 Clemson - Clemson with 2 loses on bubble, Miami to #4 with win
#8 Ohio St vs. #3 Wisconsin - Ohio St replaces Wisconsin with win
#9 Penn St and #10 SoCal out of picture

5-8 in the mix if 1 or 2 1-4's lose.

If any of the top 4 falter, Bama is in, not necessarily because they're better, but because they're Bama.

Like it or not, if it comes down to it, the NAMES are going to get the benefit of the doubt. Why? Because one, they have proven track records, and two the committee knows who butters their bread.... The networks.

They know there's NO WAY all that money keeps rolling in if ratings are down. Networks don't pay hundreds of millions so Southwest Tech can be in the playoffs. Blue Bloods appeal to the casual fan and even to the non-sports fan who might tune in to see the "big game".

All things being equal, if it comes down to a Bama, tOSU or a TCU (for example), you can let it ride that Bama or tOSU will be the ones with their name called.

It's a popular theory (especially among TCU fans!), but don't buy it for a couple of reasons. First, the computer averages and old BCS formula so far have come up with the same 4 participants the first three years as the committee. Second, there are examples of name schools being behind lesser name schools with similar profiles in the weekly and even final rankings. The reality is that name schools typically have had better profiles/arguments to date. We see what we want to see. We see them get in and say "see! Name school!", when it really is their strength of their overall profile.

Which is why I'm NOT a big fan of expanding to 8 teams.

Until there's a system that is completely impartial and takes into account "numbers only", there will be people's opinions and biases involved in the decision.

Perfect example is March Madness. When the NCAA took over, they expanded to 16 teams and the 17th teams griped. On and on till it went to 64 and the 65th team complained. Then they went to 68 and now the 69th team hollers "unfair". Unless the playoffs include every team, someone left out will feel slighted.

The CFP is actually a pretty fair and decent system IMO. It takes into consideration record, SOS, etc, but also gives credit to purely subjective things like the "eye test" and, to be frank, names.

You are right about the "names" though, most times the Blue Bloods got to that position BECAUSE they have better profiles and have won the big games.

The same thing goes for conferences as far as I'm concerned.

Nobody really cares if #65 complains. They have no chance of winning. #3 often had a very good chance of winning. I think TCU was probably the best team in 2014, but they got left out. This year, the gap from #1-#11 isn't very big.

While nobody cares about #65, part of the selling points of the "dance" is the whole "Cinderella" storyline. They've bloviated for years about "get in and have a chance". While a 16 has never beat a 1, there have been instances of a 15 beating a 2. Maybe it's not a matter of 65 having no chance, rather 65 knocking off someone who does.

All that being said, there is already a pseudo tournament already in place, the conference championship games. I think ( as has also been stated by others) that the ultimate goal is to get to 4 power conferences, let the championship games act as the 8 team playoff and the final 4 be the conference champions.
11-30-2017 07:47 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
quo vadis Online
Legend
*

Posts: 27,066
Joined: Aug 2008
Reputation: 606
I Root For: USF/Georgetown
Location: Baton Rouge, LA
Post: #30
RE: In the CFP, how does 5-8 have a chance
(11-29-2017 06:31 PM)Nerdlinger Wrote:  Good catch on Fresno -- fixed. And fair point about Ohio State.

The thing about Ohio State vs Alabama, assuming Ohio State wins the CCG today ... If i switch their schedules, i can imagine Alabama having the wins that Ohio State has. For example, Alabama beating Wisconsin? Sure that could happen. Not 100% sure it would, but it's a plausible outcome if they play.

The one thing that doesn't compute is Ohio State losing by 31 to Iowa.

Could anyone here honestly say that they think there's any within-the-bounds-of-reason chance that Alabama would lose by 31 to Iowa? Not me.

So it has to be Alabama if it comes down to that.
(This post was last modified: 12-02-2017 10:13 AM by quo vadis.)
12-02-2017 10:10 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
JRsec Offline
Super Moderator
*

Posts: 16,194
Joined: Mar 2012
Reputation: 882
I Root For: SEC
Location:
Post: #31
RE: In the CFP, how does 5-8 have a chance
(12-02-2017 10:10 AM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(11-29-2017 06:31 PM)Nerdlinger Wrote:  Good catch on Fresno -- fixed. And fair point about Ohio State.

The thing about Ohio State vs Alabama, assuming Ohio State wins the CCG today ... If i switch their schedules, i can imagine Alabama having the wins that Ohio State has. For example, Alabama beating Wisconsin? Sure that could happen. Not 100% sure it would, but it's a plausible outcome if they play.

The one thing that doesn't compute is Ohio State losing by 31 to Iowa.

Could anyone here honestly say that they think there's any within-the-bounds-of-reason chance that Alabama would lose by 31 to Iowa? Not me.

So it has to be Alabama if it comes down to that.

Let's put it another way shall we. Ohio State didn't lose by 31 to Penn State, Michigan, or Michigan State. They lost to an also ran in the worst division in college football by 31 points and they lost at home by 15 to Oklahoma. The only reason they are still in the conversation is that ESPN is desperate for eyeballs from the Big 10.

Personally I think Wisconsin beats them today and ends this worthless talking point.

If Bama is to luck into a slot it would be because T.C.U. beats Oklahoma and Clemson destroys Miami.
12-02-2017 11:25 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
quo vadis Online
Legend
*

Posts: 27,066
Joined: Aug 2008
Reputation: 606
I Root For: USF/Georgetown
Location: Baton Rouge, LA
Post: #32
RE: In the CFP, how does 5-8 have a chance
(12-02-2017 11:25 AM)JRsec Wrote:  
(12-02-2017 10:10 AM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(11-29-2017 06:31 PM)Nerdlinger Wrote:  Good catch on Fresno -- fixed. And fair point about Ohio State.

The thing about Ohio State vs Alabama, assuming Ohio State wins the CCG today ... If i switch their schedules, i can imagine Alabama having the wins that Ohio State has. For example, Alabama beating Wisconsin? Sure that could happen. Not 100% sure it would, but it's a plausible outcome if they play.

The one thing that doesn't compute is Ohio State losing by 31 to Iowa.

Could anyone here honestly say that they think there's any within-the-bounds-of-reason chance that Alabama would lose by 31 to Iowa? Not me.

So it has to be Alabama if it comes down to that.

Let's put it another way shall we. Ohio State didn't lose by 31 to Penn State, Michigan, or Michigan State. They lost to an also ran in the worst division in college football by 31 points and they lost at home by 15 to Oklahoma. The only reason they are still in the conversation is that ESPN is desperate for eyeballs from the Big 10.

Personally I think Wisconsin beats them today and ends this worthless talking point.

If Bama is to luck into a slot it would be because T.C.U. beats Oklahoma and Clemson destroys Miami.

Good point about Oklahoma. Excellent team, but hard to picture Alabama losing by 15 at home to them or anyone else either.
12-02-2017 12:36 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
JRsec Offline
Super Moderator
*

Posts: 16,194
Joined: Mar 2012
Reputation: 882
I Root For: SEC
Location:
Post: #33
RE: In the CFP, how does 5-8 have a chance
(12-02-2017 12:36 PM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(12-02-2017 11:25 AM)JRsec Wrote:  
(12-02-2017 10:10 AM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(11-29-2017 06:31 PM)Nerdlinger Wrote:  Good catch on Fresno -- fixed. And fair point about Ohio State.

The thing about Ohio State vs Alabama, assuming Ohio State wins the CCG today ... If i switch their schedules, i can imagine Alabama having the wins that Ohio State has. For example, Alabama beating Wisconsin? Sure that could happen. Not 100% sure it would, but it's a plausible outcome if they play.

The one thing that doesn't compute is Ohio State losing by 31 to Iowa.

Could anyone here honestly say that they think there's any within-the-bounds-of-reason chance that Alabama would lose by 31 to Iowa? Not me.

So it has to be Alabama if it comes down to that.

Let's put it another way shall we. Ohio State didn't lose by 31 to Penn State, Michigan, or Michigan State. They lost to an also ran in the worst division in college football by 31 points and they lost at home by 15 to Oklahoma. The only reason they are still in the conversation is that ESPN is desperate for eyeballs from the Big 10.

Personally I think Wisconsin beats them today and ends this worthless talking point.

If Bama is to luck into a slot it would be because T.C.U. beats Oklahoma and Clemson destroys Miami.

Good point about Oklahoma. Excellent team, but hard to picture Alabama losing by 15 at home to them or anyone else either.

I think Alabama's defense would have beaten Oklahoma. But the reason Alabama has to hope for a break to get into the CFP is because we whipped them.

ESPN can't imagine a world that doesn't have Alabama and Ohio State in it. But as an Auburn guy who spent his younger years in Michigan, I live for a world without both every year! But don't count me a Wolverine fan. Duffy's Spartans were the second team back then. 04-cheers
12-02-2017 12:44 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
chargeradio Online
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,972
Joined: Mar 2007
Reputation: 82
I Root For: ALA, KY, USA
Location: Louisville, KY
Post: #34
RE: In the CFP, how does 5-8 have a chance
Not shaping up well for Alabama so far - #3 Oklahoma won, and Georgia is leading Auburn at the half. In my opinion the Miami/Clemson result is irrelevant to Alabama, because one of them will still be in the Top 4 - I doubt it would be a case where Miami moves up to #5 after beating #1 Clemson, who would fall to #6, even in spite of Miami’s bad loss to Pittsburgh.

The only solution I see for Alabama to make it is to have both Auburn and Ohio State win. Ohio State moves up to #5, and Wisconsin falls below them. Alabama would then move up to #4:

1) Clemson (12-1, ACC champ)
2) Auburn (11-2, SEC champ)
3) Oklahoma (12-1, XII champ)
4) Alabama (11-1)
5) Ohio State (11-2, B1G champ)
6) Wisconsin (12-1)
7) Georgia (10-2)
8) Penn State (10-2)
9) USC (10-2)
10) Miami (10-2)
11) Washington (10-2)

Orange: Ohio State vs. Miami
Fiesta: Wisconsin vs. USC (PAC champ)
Peach: Georgia vs. UCF
Cotton: Penn State vs. Washington

If all of the Top 4 hold, then Penn State is probably headed to the Orange Bowl.
12-02-2017 06:11 PM
Visit this user's website Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
EvilVodka Offline
kwisatz haderach
*

Posts: 2,903
Joined: Jan 2014
Reputation: 107
I Root For: The Mars Volta
Location: Houston, TX
Post: #35
RE: In the CFP, how does 5-8 have a chance
If Wisconsin loses, I'd put USC ahead of Alabama or Ohio State
12-02-2017 06:19 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
quo vadis Online
Legend
*

Posts: 27,066
Joined: Aug 2008
Reputation: 606
I Root For: USF/Georgetown
Location: Baton Rouge, LA
Post: #36
RE: In the CFP, how does 5-8 have a chance
(12-02-2017 06:11 PM)chargeradio Wrote:  Not shaping up well for Alabama so far - #3 Oklahoma won, and Georgia is leading Auburn at the half. In my opinion the Miami/Clemson result is irrelevant to Alabama, because one of them will still be in the Top 4 - I doubt it would be a case where Miami moves up to #5 after beating #1 Clemson, who would fall to #6, even in spite of Miami’s bad loss to Pittsburgh.

The only solution I see for Alabama to make it is to have both Auburn and Ohio State win. Ohio State moves up to #5, and Wisconsin falls below them. Alabama would then move up to #4:

No question, Alabama, like every other team outside the top 4, needs someone in the top 4 to lose to have a chance to get in. As you say, the ACC title game is irrelevant because the winner will get in and the loser will fall out. Also, the SEC title game is similar, in that the winner also will get in and the loser fall out.

So that meant either Oklahoma or Wisconsin would have to lose, and since Oklahoma has won, Alabama's last chance is for Ohio State to beat Wisconsin. And that of course doesn't guarantee they get in, but it's a sure thing that if Wisconsin wins, they won't.
12-02-2017 07:10 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
JRsec Offline
Super Moderator
*

Posts: 16,194
Joined: Mar 2012
Reputation: 882
I Root For: SEC
Location:
Post: #37
RE: In the CFP, how does 5-8 have a chance
(12-02-2017 07:10 PM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(12-02-2017 06:11 PM)chargeradio Wrote:  Not shaping up well for Alabama so far - #3 Oklahoma won, and Georgia is leading Auburn at the half. In my opinion the Miami/Clemson result is irrelevant to Alabama, because one of them will still be in the Top 4 - I doubt it would be a case where Miami moves up to #5 after beating #1 Clemson, who would fall to #6, even in spite of Miami’s bad loss to Pittsburgh.

The only solution I see for Alabama to make it is to have both Auburn and Ohio State win. Ohio State moves up to #5, and Wisconsin falls below them. Alabama would then move up to #4:

No question, Alabama, like every other team outside the top 4, needs someone in the top 4 to lose to have a chance to get in. As you say, the ACC title game is irrelevant because the winner will get in and the loser will fall out. Also, the SEC title game is similar, in that the winner also will get in and the loser fall out.

So that meant either Oklahoma or Wisconsin would have to lose, and since Oklahoma has won, Alabama's last chance is for Ohio State to beat Wisconsin. And that of course doesn't guarantee they get in, but it's a sure thing that if Wisconsin wins, they won't.

Well congratulations to Georgia. It was evident tonight that we just weren't healthy enough to represent the conference well going forward. Stove went out at half with the ankle sprain and Carlton Davis (all american quality defensive back) went down for the game if not the season in the first half as well. With Johnson obviously not at full speed I have to wonder how much rehab he's going to need moving forward.

So good luck to the Dawgs, much as I hate to say it!
12-02-2017 07:47 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
chargeradio Online
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,972
Joined: Mar 2007
Reputation: 82
I Root For: ALA, KY, USA
Location: Louisville, KY
Post: #38
RE: In the CFP, how does 5-8 have a chance
Ohio State wins, so here’s the committee’s work for the morning:

1) How far Auburn falls (almost certainly out of the Top 4 with their third loss)
2) Haw far Wisconsin falls
3) How far Georgia, Oklahoma, and Ohio State rise now that #2 and #4 have gone down
4) Should Ohio State be ranked ahead of Wisconsin, Head-to-Head result notwithstanding?
12-03-2017 12:06 AM
Visit this user's website Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
stever20 Online
Legend
*

Posts: 30,249
Joined: Nov 2011
Reputation: 282
I Root For: College Sports
Location:
Post: #39
RE: In the CFP, how does 5-8 have a chance
1 big loser tonight is Notre Dame. They almost certainly won't be in the top 12 now, meaning they're out of the access bowls.
12-03-2017 04:05 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
quo vadis Online
Legend
*

Posts: 27,066
Joined: Aug 2008
Reputation: 606
I Root For: USF/Georgetown
Location: Baton Rouge, LA
Post: #40
RE: In the CFP, how does 5-8 have a chance
(12-03-2017 04:05 AM)stever20 Wrote:  1 big loser tonight is Notre Dame. They almost certainly won't be in the top 12 now, meaning they're out of the access bowls.

... and that's kind of a shame, as they should be in. They played arguably the toughest schedule in the country. One of their losses is to a playoff team, another is to a team that will finish in the top seven, and the third to a team that will finish around #18, and two of those were on the road.
(This post was last modified: 12-03-2017 08:40 AM by quo vadis.)
12-03-2017 08:38 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Post Reply 




User(s) browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)


Copyright © 2002-2018 Collegiate Sports Nation Bulletin Board System (CSNbbs), All Rights Reserved.
CSNbbs is an independent fan site and is in no way affiliated to the NCAA or any of the schools and conferences it represents.
This site monetizes links. FTC Disclosure.
We allow third-party companies to serve ads and/or collect certain anonymous information when you visit our web site. These companies may use non-personally identifiable information (e.g., click stream information, browser type, time and date, subject of advertisements clicked or scrolled over) during your visits to this and other Web sites in order to provide advertisements about goods and services likely to be of greater interest to you. These companies typically use a cookie or third party web beacon to collect this information. To learn more about this behavioral advertising practice or to opt-out of this type of advertising, you can visit http://www.networkadvertising.org.
Powered By MyBB, © 2002-2018 MyBB Group.