Hello There, Guest! (LoginRegister)

Post Reply 
OT: Does App St miss FCS?
Author Message
Bookmark and Share
HerdZoned Offline
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 15,634
Joined: Nov 2003
Reputation: 125
I Root For: The Herd
Location: South Charleston

Folding@NCAAbbsCrappiesCrappiesCrappies
Post: #41
RE: OT: Does App St miss FCS?
(07-12-2017 03:05 PM)H.U.S.T.L.E. Wrote:  Ask them again in 10 years and see if they have the same answer.

From someone who has been in the same situation that Appy is in I can answer that question very easily. The answer is "Hell No, we would never trade our time in IA to go back to IAA."

Marshall will be entering its 21st season in IA moving up after the 1996 season. I nor have I ever heard anyone say they miss going to Cullowhee NC (Western Carolina), Greenville SC (Furman), Charleston SC (The Cit), Lexington VA (VMI), Johnson City TN (ETSU) or Chattanooga TN (UTC). And playing in front of 5-7 thousand people, maybe a little more if they are winning. I mean it took The Cit being #9 in the country and Marshall being #1 in the country to have the largest crowd at Johnson Hagood Stadium in 1992 at 23,025.

The truth is if both Appy and GA Southern would have had the proper personal in place they should have been able to move up in 2001-2005. Unfortunately GA Southern didn't have a president with the forward thinking to be IA and he had a puppet as an AD that went along with everything. And I don't think the Appy admin thought that they could actually do it. After the 2004 season Jerry Moore was skating on thin ice, he was coming off of 2 lack luster seasons of not making the playoffs and from what Ive heard his job was on the line in 2005, when he then rolled off 3 national titles. That is when the ball started to really roll that they needed to be IA.

Everyone at Marshall knew the school would eventually go IA when the new Marshall Stadium, now Joan C Edwards Stadium was approved in 1988. They just didn't know how long it would take.
07-13-2017 02:11 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
BleedingPurple Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 9,132
Joined: Mar 2013
Reputation: 36
I Root For: JMU
Location: Charlotte
Post: #42
RE: OT: Does App St miss FCS?
(07-13-2017 08:44 AM)BDKJMU Wrote:  
(07-12-2017 10:31 PM)BleedingPurple Wrote:  
(07-12-2017 09:38 PM)South Carolina Duke Wrote:  I was picking up SCD Jr from football camp today at Furman Univ.

Interesting conversation took place between myself and the entire coaching staff , except HC and OC ( Cronik) former JMU staff guy.

They all asked me, "when are y'all (JMU) moving to FBS? Even fellow FCS opponents are scratching their heads at our "leadership."

Frankly, I think a lot of FCS folk would like to see us and NDSU gone.

And it would be easier for JMU to move up than NDSU, who moved up from Div 2 in 04'. I don't hunk they can expand their sub 19k capacity Fargodome, so would have to build a new stadium/dome...

That's something I hadn't given any thought to. I took a moment to look up that they began using it in '92 and it's owned by the city rather than the university. Basically the university's part in the deal was the ground it sits on and a team to use it. That certainly presents some major hurdles for them in trying to get another facility before the life expectancy has past. With this obstacle in their path, they may be FCS for a few more years unless they make the move realizing they will have serious demand with little supply for a number of years. Though, they are looking at ways to expand it to roughly 25K seating for football.
07-13-2017 03:09 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
2Buck Offline
1st String
*

Posts: 1,892
Joined: Mar 2014
Reputation: 57
I Root For: James Madison
Location: Big pile of CAA-CAA
Post: #43
RE: OT: Does App St miss FCS?
(07-13-2017 03:09 PM)BleedingPurple Wrote:  
(07-13-2017 08:44 AM)BDKJMU Wrote:  
(07-12-2017 10:31 PM)BleedingPurple Wrote:  
(07-12-2017 09:38 PM)South Carolina Duke Wrote:  I was picking up SCD Jr from football camp today at Furman Univ.

Interesting conversation took place between myself and the entire coaching staff , except HC and OC ( Cronik) former JMU staff guy.

They all asked me, "when are y'all (JMU) moving to FBS? Even fellow FCS opponents are scratching their heads at our "leadership."

Frankly, I think a lot of FCS folk would like to see us and NDSU gone.

And it would be easier for JMU to move up than NDSU, who moved up from Div 2 in 04'. I don't hunk they can expand their sub 19k capacity Fargodome, so would have to build a new stadium/dome...

That's something I hadn't given any thought to. I took a moment to look up that they began using it in '92 and it's owned by the city rather than the university. Basically the university's part in the deal was the ground it sits on and a team to use it. That certainly presents some major hurdles for them in trying to get another facility before the life expectancy has past. With this obstacle in their path, they may be FCS for a few more years unless they make the move realizing they will have serious demand with little supply for a number of years. Though, they are looking at ways to expand it to roughly 25K seating for football.

Another big difference is fan base potential. I'm not sure how many more fans NDST would get in FBS unless they started pulling off some Top 25 seasons. No doubt they could get another 5k-10k attending games but with the success they've had over the past 6 years and no nearby FBS competitors, I imagine they've pretty much flushed out all the Walmart fans they're going to get. JMU on the other hand has the untapped alumni base within a 2-3 hour drive to get up to the 40k-50k range with some success. Think of how many Va Tech fans pass by Harrisonburg from the DC area having to drive another 2 hours to attend games.

Now think if they had to drive back past JMU after suffering another loss to us ...

[Image: giphy.webp]
07-13-2017 04:02 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
AppManDG Offline
All American
*

Posts: 3,853
Joined: Aug 2010
Reputation: 148
I Root For: App State
Location:
Post: #44
RE: OT: Does App St miss FCS?
I pushed for a move back to 1A/ FBS since we were kicked down in 1982. The folks I know think it was the best thing that has ever happened to App. You never hear the SoCon mentioned any more and most couldn't tell you who won it last year. There was a lot of brainwashing done by the Borkowski/Laney administration. Thei8r main fear factor points were we would have to cut sports, which we haven't. Would have to raise student fees excessively, hasn't happened. Most importantly would have to sacrifice academics in order to attract the talent to play FBS. Just the opposite has been true. 2016 class ave GPA was 3.53 & 2017 was 3.47. Jerry Moore pushed anti-moveup rhetoric out of selfish reasons of wanting to keep his job. When he was shown the door it split fan base. It was a rocky start and a lot of "I told you so's" were being tossed around. However, since half way through the '15 season we're 28-5 with 3 coming to National Runner up Clemson, # 9 Tennessee (in OT) & #25 Miami. These days the naysayers are nowhere to be found. Without question it's the best thing we've ever done.

Sent from my XT1254 using CSNbbs mobile app
(This post was last modified: 07-13-2017 07:56 PM by AppManDG.)
07-13-2017 07:46 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
BleedingPurple Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 9,132
Joined: Mar 2013
Reputation: 36
I Root For: JMU
Location: Charlotte
Post: #45
RE: OT: Does App St miss FCS?
(07-13-2017 07:46 PM)AppManDG Wrote:  I pushed for a move back to 1A/ FBS since we were kicked down in 1982. The folks I know think it was the best thing that has ever happened to App. You never hear the SoCon mentioned any more and most couldn't tell you who won it last year. There was a lot of brainwashing done by the Borkowski/Laney administration. Thei8r main fear factor points were we would have to cut sports, which we haven't. Would have to raise student fees excessively, hasn't happened. Most importantly would have to sacrifice academics in order to attract the talent to play FBS. Just the opposite has been true. 2016 class ave GPA was 3.53 & 2017 was 3.47. Jerry Moore pushed anti-moveup rhetoric out of selfish reasons of wanting to keep his job. When he was shown the door it split fan base. It was a rocky start and a lot of "I told you so's" were being tossed around. However, since half way through the '15 season we're 28-5 with 3 coming to National Runner up Clemson, # 9 Tennessee (in OT) & #25 Miami. These days the naysayers are nowhere to be found. Without question it's the best thing we've ever done.

Sent from my XT1254 using CSNbbs mobile app

But, have you been successful?
07-13-2017 08:17 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
H.U.S.T.L.E. Offline
2nd String
*

Posts: 481
Joined: Mar 2016
Reputation: 58
I Root For: VT / JMU
Location: Northern VA
Post: #46
RE: OT: Does App St miss FCS?
Interesting that my comment got so much attention in this thread. I'll expound a bit on my original point...

While App State has certainly achieved success in its short time in FBS, I just wonder what the measuring stick for success is going to be in 10 years? Maybe in that time the landscape will dramatically shift in G5 football, but with the current trajectory of FBS football I have serious doubts about the viability of G5 football. The elites of college football are outpacing the rest at an alarming clip.

This doesn't just affect G5 schools either. I don't post here a ton, but schools listed that I root for in my profile should give some hint as to my affiliation. I am a VT grad who married a JMU alum, and given that we live in the DMV we made the decision to buy season tickets to JMU. It's more affordable, a closer drive, and fulfills our fix for seeing live football during the fall. But while I openly root for JMU, Tech will always be #1 for me. In this new economy of college football, I think even a school like VT is going to have a hard time breaking through the proverbial glass ceiling. There's a route there, but it's a much narrower one and fraught with many potholes on the way to becoming one of the elites of college football, or more realistically, sniffing a CFP slot.

Now, if it's tough for a school like VT (an ACC member who has been to a national title game, won multiple ACC championships and been to BCS bowls - but never in the CFP era) to get to the mountaintop, it's going to be much harder for G5 schools.

That's the existential question here. Is App State going to be content in 10 years if the same obstacles still exist? I don't know. Maybe so, but I would think that Sun Belt championships will move the needle less & less over the course of the next decade, as will the bowl tie-ins the Sun Belt can muster. At least they have some fun bowl locales in their lineup at the moment (New Orleans, Nassau, Orlando top the list I'd say, while Frisco, Montgomery and Mobile seem a little less attractive).

But what is the ultimate goal? At this moment in the landscape, it would seem that the best-case scenario is the type of season we just saw from Western Michigan - undefeated in the regular season, a conference title game win and a spot in a New Year's Six bowl game.

Is that glimmer enough to satisfy G5 fanbases long-term if it may only happen once in a program's history? I don't know the answer to that. Maybe some here can help answer that. People like to bring up, "We could be the next Boise State," but they fail to acknowledge how different things are now than even ten years ago. I think it's infinitely harder to replicate Boise State's success in today's landscape.

Maybe I'm wrong, and I'll end up eating crow with regards to App State. I would happily do so. I just fear that the road to high-end success in FBS is so slim for G5 schools that there's a point where a fanbase wonders if there's a diminishing return to the enterprise.
07-14-2017 08:23 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
JMU2004 Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,901
Joined: Sep 2004
Reputation: 40
I Root For: DUKES
Location: the Commonwealth
Post: #47
RE: OT: Does App St miss FCS?
(07-14-2017 08:23 AM)H.U.S.T.L.E. Wrote:  Interesting that my comment got so much attention in this thread. I'll expound a bit on my original point...

While App State has certainly achieved success in its short time in FBS, I just wonder what the measuring stick for success is going to be in 10 years? Maybe in that time the landscape will dramatically shift in G5 football, but with the current trajectory of FBS football I have serious doubts about the viability of G5 football. The elites of college football are outpacing the rest at an alarming clip.

This doesn't just affect G5 schools either. I don't post here a ton, but schools listed that I root for in my profile should give some hint as to my affiliation. I am a VT grad who married a JMU alum, and given that we live in the DMV we made the decision to buy season tickets to JMU. It's more affordable, a closer drive, and fulfills our fix for seeing live football during the fall. But while I openly root for JMU, Tech will always be #1 for me. In this new economy of college football, I think even a school like VT is going to have a hard time breaking through the proverbial glass ceiling. There's a route there, but it's a much narrower one and fraught with many potholes on the way to becoming one of the elites of college football, or more realistically, sniffing a CFP slot.

Now, if it's tough for a school like VT (an ACC member who has been to a national title game, won multiple ACC championships and been to BCS bowls - but never in the CFP era) to get to the mountaintop, it's going to be much harder for G5 schools.

That's the existential question here. Is App State going to be content in 10 years if the same obstacles still exist? I don't know. Maybe so, but I would think that Sun Belt championships will move the needle less & less over the course of the next decade, as will the bowl tie-ins the Sun Belt can muster. At least they have some fun bowl locales in their lineup at the moment (New Orleans, Nassau, Orlando top the list I'd say, while Frisco, Montgomery and Mobile seem a little less attractive).

But what is the ultimate goal? At this moment in the landscape, it would seem that the best-case scenario is the type of season we just saw from Western Michigan - undefeated in the regular season, a conference title game win and a spot in a New Year's Six bowl game.

Is that glimmer enough to satisfy G5 fanbases long-term if it may only happen once in a program's history? I don't know the answer to that. Maybe some here can help answer that. People like to bring up, "We could be the next Boise State," but they fail to acknowledge how different things are now than even ten years ago. I think it's infinitely harder to replicate Boise State's success in today's landscape.

Maybe I'm wrong, and I'll end up eating crow with regards to App State. I would happily do so. I just fear that the road to high-end success in FBS is so slim for G5 schools that there's a point where a fanbase wonders if there's a diminishing return to the enterprise.

Your concerns are valid. Instead of chasing the unobtainable, perhaps it makes sense to align with schools whose interests and means are on a similar level.

That being said, it will be a hard sell to the FBS schools who hang their hat on being a so called "big boy".
07-14-2017 08:55 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Duke Dawg Offline
All American
*

Posts: 4,310
Joined: Apr 2013
Reputation: 25
I Root For: James Madison
Location:
Post: #48
RE: OT: Does App St miss FCS?
(07-14-2017 08:23 AM)H.U.S.T.L.E. Wrote:  Interesting that my comment got so much attention in this thread. I'll expound a bit on my original point...

While App State has certainly achieved success in its short time in FBS, I just wonder what the measuring stick for success is going to be in 10 years? Maybe in that time the landscape will dramatically shift in G5 football, but with the current trajectory of FBS football I have serious doubts about the viability of G5 football. The elites of college football are outpacing the rest at an alarming clip.

This doesn't just affect G5 schools either. I don't post here a ton, but schools listed that I root for in my profile should give some hint as to my affiliation. I am a VT grad who married a JMU alum, and given that we live in the DMV we made the decision to buy season tickets to JMU. It's more affordable, a closer drive, and fulfills our fix for seeing live football during the fall. But while I openly root for JMU, Tech will always be #1 for me. In this new economy of college football, I think even a school like VT is going to have a hard time breaking through the proverbial glass ceiling. There's a route there, but it's a much narrower one and fraught with many potholes on the way to becoming one of the elites of college football, or more realistically, sniffing a CFP slot.

Now, if it's tough for a school like VT (an ACC member who has been to a national title game, won multiple ACC championships and been to BCS bowls - but never in the CFP era) to get to the mountaintop, it's going to be much harder for G5 schools.

That's the existential question here. Is App State going to be content in 10 years if the same obstacles still exist? I don't know. Maybe so, but I would think that Sun Belt championships will move the needle less & less over the course of the next decade, as will the bowl tie-ins the Sun Belt can muster. At least they have some fun bowl locales in their lineup at the moment (New Orleans, Nassau, Orlando top the list I'd say, while Frisco, Montgomery and Mobile seem a little less attractive).

But what is the ultimate goal? At this moment in the landscape, it would seem that the best-case scenario is the type of season we just saw from Western Michigan - undefeated in the regular season, a conference title game win and a spot in a New Year's Six bowl game.

Is that glimmer enough to satisfy G5 fanbases long-term if it may only happen once in a program's history? I don't know the answer to that. Maybe some here can help answer that. People like to bring up, "We could be the next Boise State," but they fail to acknowledge how different things are now than even ten years ago. I think it's infinitely harder to replicate Boise State's success in today's landscape.

Maybe I'm wrong, and I'll end up eating crow with regards to App State. I would happily do so. I just fear that the road to high-end success in FBS is so slim for G5 schools that there's a point where a fanbase wonders if there's a diminishing return to the enterprise.

what he said. so many good points in there.

and to add another point re: bowl games. the number of P5 vs G5 matchups in bowls continue to dwindle. I believe you can count on one hand now.

are G5 members going to be happy making a bowl, only to play another G5 member year after year?

used to be, a G5 type school (before the G5 became the G5) could look forward to making a bowl game and matching up against an SEC or Pac10 school that they otherwise might never get a game against, certainly not a home game. A neutral site matchup like that was appealing.

they just don't happen much anymore. the P5 wants a closed society. Keep all the money, all the attention, all the accolades. I can't say I blame them. But where does that leave the G5 in 5-10 years?
07-14-2017 09:15 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
JMUETC Online
1st String
*

Posts: 1,554
Joined: Apr 2013
Reputation: 9
I Root For: JMU
Location:
Post: #49
RE: OT: Does App St miss FCS?
(07-14-2017 09:15 AM)Duke Dawg Wrote:  
(07-14-2017 08:23 AM)H.U.S.T.L.E. Wrote:  Interesting that my comment got so much attention in this thread. I'll expound a bit on my original point...

While App State has certainly achieved success in its short time in FBS, I just wonder what the measuring stick for success is going to be in 10 years? Maybe in that time the landscape will dramatically shift in G5 football, but with the current trajectory of FBS football I have serious doubts about the viability of G5 football. The elites of college football are outpacing the rest at an alarming clip.

This doesn't just affect G5 schools either. I don't post here a ton, but schools listed that I root for in my profile should give some hint as to my affiliation. I am a VT grad who married a JMU alum, and given that we live in the DMV we made the decision to buy season tickets to JMU. It's more affordable, a closer drive, and fulfills our fix for seeing live football during the fall. But while I openly root for JMU, Tech will always be #1 for me. In this new economy of college football, I think even a school like VT is going to have a hard time breaking through the proverbial glass ceiling. There's a route there, but it's a much narrower one and fraught with many potholes on the way to becoming one of the elites of college football, or more realistically, sniffing a CFP slot.

Now, if it's tough for a school like VT (an ACC member who has been to a national title game, won multiple ACC championships and been to BCS bowls - but never in the CFP era) to get to the mountaintop, it's going to be much harder for G5 schools.

That's the existential question here. Is App State going to be content in 10 years if the same obstacles still exist? I don't know. Maybe so, but I would think that Sun Belt championships will move the needle less & less over the course of the next decade, as will the bowl tie-ins the Sun Belt can muster. At least they have some fun bowl locales in their lineup at the moment (New Orleans, Nassau, Orlando top the list I'd say, while Frisco, Montgomery and Mobile seem a little less attractive).

But what is the ultimate goal? At this moment in the landscape, it would seem that the best-case scenario is the type of season we just saw from Western Michigan - undefeated in the regular season, a conference title game win and a spot in a New Year's Six bowl game.

Is that glimmer enough to satisfy G5 fanbases long-term if it may only happen once in a program's history? I don't know the answer to that. Maybe some here can help answer that. People like to bring up, "We could be the next Boise State," but they fail to acknowledge how different things are now than even ten years ago. I think it's infinitely harder to replicate Boise State's success in today's landscape.

Maybe I'm wrong, and I'll end up eating crow with regards to App State. I would happily do so. I just fear that the road to high-end success in FBS is so slim for G5 schools that there's a point where a fanbase wonders if there's a diminishing return to the enterprise.

what he said. so many good points in there.

and to add another point re: bowl games. the number of P5 vs G5 matchups in bowls continue to dwindle. I believe you can count on one hand now.

are G5 members going to be happy making a bowl, only to play another G5 member year after year?

used to be, a G5 type school (before the G5 became the G5) could look forward to making a bowl game and matching up against an SEC or Pac10 school that they otherwise might never get a game against, certainly not a home game. A neutral site matchup like that was appealing.

they just don't happen much anymore. the P5 wants a closed society. Keep all the money, all the attention, all the accolades. I can't say I blame them. But where does that leave the G5 in 5-10 years?

Isn't there value in VT playing an ACC schedule every year over the next 10 years, even if all they do is win an occasional comference championship and play another G5 in a bowl game with little to no chance of playing in the Natuonal Championship?

They are hosting Clemson this year. Seems like a pretty good game, no?

Why has the regular season suddenly lost meaning?
07-14-2017 09:20 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
HyperDuke Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,011
Joined: Jan 2013
Reputation: 40
I Root For: JMU
Location:
Post: #50
RE: OT: Does App St miss FCS?
H.U.S.T.L.E. makes some great points that really crystallize the fears of many of our "leaders". Thanks for making such a good post filled with real concepts based on reality. Seriously, thank you.

But JMUETC brings it right back to the real value of FBS for JMU, the REGULAR SEASON. We're fixated with post-season because that's our measure of success now as an FCS team. Those home games versus natural rivals (Marshall/App/ODU) are what I want more than anything. I can only attend two games this year & it's our two cupcakes in September. That sucks. I'll treasure the playoffs while we're FCS, but post-season success for JMU is not the prize for moving to FBS.
07-14-2017 09:34 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
DirtyDukes Offline
1st String
*

Posts: 2,411
Joined: Mar 2013
Reputation: 50
I Root For: Dukes, bud!
Location: Museum District
Post: #51
RE: OT: Does App St miss FCS?
(07-14-2017 09:34 AM)HyperDuke Wrote:  H.U.S.T.L.E. makes some great points that really crystallize the fears of many of our "leaders". Thanks for making such a good post filled with real concepts based on reality. Seriously, thank you.

But JMUETC brings it right back to the real value of FBS for JMU, the REGULAR SEASON. We're fixated with post-season because that's our measure of success now as an FCS team. Those home games versus natural rivals (Marshall/App/ODU) are what I want more than anything. I can only attend two games this year & it's our two cupcakes in September. That sucks. I'll treasure the playoffs while we're FCS, but post-season success for JMU is not the prize for moving to FBS.

Serious question: would you rather play Marshall/App/ODU than Delaware/Spatters/Nerds/Nova/UNH? I honestly wouldn't.
07-14-2017 09:52 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
H.U.S.T.L.E. Offline
2nd String
*

Posts: 481
Joined: Mar 2016
Reputation: 58
I Root For: VT / JMU
Location: Northern VA
Post: #52
RE: OT: Does App St miss FCS?
(07-14-2017 09:20 AM)JMUETC Wrote:  Isn't there value in VT playing an ACC schedule every year over the next 10 years, even if all they do is win an occasional comference championship and play another G5 in a bowl game with little to no chance of playing in the Natuonal Championship?

They are hosting Clemson this year. Seems like a pretty good game, no?

Why has the regular season suddenly lost meaning?

A few points about the regular season (this might end up in tangents):

1. VT's regular season home schedule has been considered fairly mediocre by many Hokie fans for the past several years. Part of this is due to the expansion of the ACC and how infrequently we play cross-division opponents. We haven't played Clemson during the regular season since 2011, FSU since 2012 or Louisville since their entry in 2014. Yes, we had a home game with Ohio State a couple years ago, but the relative weakness of the Coastal division has contributed to a lackluster home schedule. You can always talk yourself into the Miami game being big, but they've under-performed since their ACC arrival. The UVA game is always a good atmosphere too at least, even if they haven't won a game in this series in over a decade. Hopefully the influx of coaching talent to the Coastal teams will enhance the level of the programs in the coming years. Richt seems to be on the right path with Miami, Narduzzi has Pitt overachieving, and Fedora has UNC as good as they've been in a long time. Throw in stalwarts like Johnson & Cutcliffe, plus a guy with a good track record in Mendenhall (though I'm skeptical UVA is the place for him to succeed), there's traction.

2. The seemingly never-ending series with ECU is not a draw for Hokies fans. Many fans understand the reason for it (it gives us a game in North Carolina during years where we play both UNC & Duke at home, plus they have generally been a solid SOS opponent), but that doesn't mean we enjoy seeing them pop up every year. There was a nice run where it felt like a minor rivalry, but I think it's overstayed its welcome. Personally, I would much rather play an FBS-level JMU annually, even over the upcoming series with ODU (which from a recruiting standpoint, makes more sense unfortunately due to the talent-laden 757).

3. The regular season SHOULD have meaning and conference opponents should be considered rivals, but you have to have the right opponents on a yearly basis. VT vs. GT and VT vs. UNC have evolved into games I think both fanbases have come to consider a minor rivalry, so that's a good step. I think C-USA is finding this out the hard way. The Sun Belt comes closer to it, but does App State playing teams in Louisana or Texas invite that feel? I can't answer that, but I would assume geography is somewhat of an impediment.
07-14-2017 09:57 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
JMU2004 Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,901
Joined: Sep 2004
Reputation: 40
I Root For: DUKES
Location: the Commonwealth
Post: #53
RE: OT: Does App St miss FCS?
(07-14-2017 09:52 AM)DirtyDukes Wrote:  
(07-14-2017 09:34 AM)HyperDuke Wrote:  H.U.S.T.L.E. makes some great points that really crystallize the fears of many of our "leaders". Thanks for making such a good post filled with real concepts based on reality. Seriously, thank you.

But JMUETC brings it right back to the real value of FBS for JMU, the REGULAR SEASON. We're fixated with post-season because that's our measure of success now as an FCS team. Those home games versus natural rivals (Marshall/App/ODU) are what I want more than anything. I can only attend two games this year & it's our two cupcakes in September. That sucks. I'll treasure the playoffs while we're FCS, but post-season success for JMU is not the prize for moving to FBS.

Serious question: would you rather play Marshall/App/ODU than Delaware/Spatters/Nerds/Nova/UNH? I honestly wouldn't.

Yes, I would. The only games that really have ANY palpable excitement anymore are UR/W&M. The rest of those are mausoleums, regardless of the strength of their teams. If UD gets good again, there would be some excitement to that game.

But all things being equal, ODU/APP/Marshall would exceed UR/W&M/UD.
07-14-2017 09:58 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
BDKJMU Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,571
Joined: Apr 2013
Reputation: 16
I Root For: James Madison
Location:
Post: #54
RE: OT: Does App St miss FCS?
(07-14-2017 09:58 AM)JMU2004 Wrote:  
(07-14-2017 09:52 AM)DirtyDukes Wrote:  
(07-14-2017 09:34 AM)HyperDuke Wrote:  H.U.S.T.L.E. makes some great points that really crystallize the fears of many of our "leaders". Thanks for making such a good post filled with real concepts based on reality. Seriously, thank you.

But JMUETC brings it right back to the real value of FBS for JMU, the REGULAR SEASON. We're fixated with post-season because that's our measure of success now as an FCS team. Those home games versus natural rivals (Marshall/App/ODU) are what I want more than anything. I can only attend two games this year & it's our two cupcakes in September. That sucks. I'll treasure the playoffs while we're FCS, but post-season success for JMU is not the prize for moving to FBS.

Serious question: would you rather play Marshall/App/ODU than Delaware/Spatters/Nerds/Nova/UNH? I honestly wouldn't.

Yes, I would. The only games that really have ANY palpable excitement anymore are UR/W&M. The rest of those are mausoleums, regardless of the strength of their teams. If UD gets good again, there would be some excitement to that game.

But all things being equal, ODU/APP/Marshall would exceed UR/W&M/UD.

Absolutely but if your comparing Top 3 desirable in conference can't use ODU/APP/Marshall.

ODU/Marshall/UNCC? >> RU/W&M/back powerhouse UD
APP/GSU/CCU?>> RU/W&M/back powerhouse UD
(This post was last modified: 07-14-2017 10:24 AM by BDKJMU.)
07-14-2017 10:20 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
HyperDuke Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,011
Joined: Jan 2013
Reputation: 40
I Root For: JMU
Location:
Post: #55
RE: OT: Does App St miss FCS?
2004 said what I was gonna say. I'm intrigued by Rocco at UD, but would rather have any of Marshall/App/ODU on the schedule instead. W&M and UR are fun games because of history & Tick Hate, but otherwise those other 3 don't do it for me. Villanova is a good team, but Talley is retiring/retired(?) so that consistency is probably shot. Even with them being a strong team, it wasn't a game I would highly anticipate. Just another team from the North with no fanbase.

If I had to choose, I would choose the FBS 3 over the W&M and UR matchups.
07-14-2017 10:22 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
HyperDuke Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,011
Joined: Jan 2013
Reputation: 40
I Root For: JMU
Location:
Post: #56
RE: OT: Does App St miss FCS?
(07-14-2017 10:20 AM)BDKJMU Wrote:  Absolutely but if your comparing Top 3 desirable in conference can't use ODU/APP/Marshall.

ODU/Marshall/??? >> RU/W&M/back powerhouse UD
APP/GSU/??? >> RU/W&M/back powerhouse UD

I started the ODU/APP/MARSHALL thing. It wasn't about conference mates. I just stated nearby "natural rivals" that could likely become annual fixtures on the schedule whether through conference affiliation or OOC schedule.
07-14-2017 10:23 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
JMUETC Online
1st String
*

Posts: 1,554
Joined: Apr 2013
Reputation: 9
I Root For: JMU
Location:
Post: #57
RE: OT: Does App St miss FCS?
(07-14-2017 09:57 AM)H.U.S.T.L.E. Wrote:  
(07-14-2017 09:20 AM)JMUETC Wrote:  Isn't there value in VT playing an ACC schedule every year over the next 10 years, even if all they do is win an occasional comference championship and play another G5 in a bowl game with little to no chance of playing in the Natuonal Championship?

They are hosting Clemson this year. Seems like a pretty good game, no?

Why has the regular season suddenly lost meaning?

A few points about the regular season (this might end up in tangents):

1. VT's regular season home schedule has been considered fairly mediocre by many Hokie fans for the past several years. Part of this is due to the expansion of the ACC and how infrequently we play cross-division opponents. We haven't played Clemson during the regular season since 2011, FSU since 2012 or Louisville since their entry in 2014. Yes, we had a home game with Ohio State a couple years ago, but the relative weakness of the Coastal division has contributed to a lackluster home schedule. You can always talk yourself into the Miami game being big, but they've under-performed since their ACC arrival. The UVA game is always a good atmosphere too at least, even if they haven't won a game in this series in over a decade. Hopefully the influx of coaching talent to the Coastal teams will enhance the level of the programs in the coming years. Richt seems to be on the right path with Miami, Narduzzi has Pitt overachieving, and Fedora has UNC as good as they've been in a long time. Throw in stalwarts like Johnson & Cutcliffe, plus a guy with a good track record in Mendenhall (though I'm skeptical UVA is the place for him to succeed), there's traction.

2. The seemingly never-ending series with ECU is not a draw for Hokies fans. Many fans understand the reason for it (it gives us a game in North Carolina during years where we play both UNC & Duke at home, plus they have generally been a solid SOS opponent), but that doesn't mean we enjoy seeing them pop up every year. There was a nice run where it felt like a minor rivalry, but I think it's overstayed its welcome. Personally, I would much rather play an FBS-level JMU annually, even over the upcoming series with ODU (which from a recruiting standpoint, makes more sense unfortunately due to the talent-laden 757).

3. The regular season SHOULD have meaning and conference opponents should be considered rivals, but you have to have the right opponents on a yearly basis. VT vs. GT and VT vs. UNC have evolved into games I think both fanbases have come to consider a minor rivalry, so that's a good step. I think C-USA is finding this out the hard way. The Sun Belt comes closer to it, but does App State playing teams in Louisana or Texas invite that feel? I can't answer that, but I would assume geography is somewhat of an impediment.

Completely agree, but will add a couple thoughts.

1) JMU joining a conference will raise the profile of the conference. JMU has a ton to offer and will IMMEDIATELY raise the profile of any conference it joins because of the great fans and recent success (Tech win, Game Day, NC. All great immediate talking points).

2) What VT calls a lackluster schedule, JMU would kill for in equivalent teams. A home game a few years ago against OSU is a footnote while at JMU a home game against pick one (Tech, UVA, ECU, Navy, NDSU) would be immediately added to the talking points list above). I guess the WVU game at FedEx comes closest. JMU may spend the next 10 years playing lackluster home schedules while they wait for something to happen. When you add it all up, APP States current home schedules, PLUS wherever they end up in 10 years will be greater than wherever JMU finally finds themselves.
07-14-2017 10:38 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
jmufbs Offline
2nd String
*

Posts: 449
Joined: Apr 2013
Reputation: 2
I Root For: JMU
Location:
Post: #58
RE: OT: Does App St miss FCS?
(07-14-2017 09:52 AM)DirtyDukes Wrote:  
(07-14-2017 09:34 AM)HyperDuke Wrote:  H.U.S.T.L.E. makes some great points that really crystallize the fears of many of our "leaders". Thanks for making such a good post filled with real concepts based on reality. Seriously, thank you.

But JMUETC brings it right back to the real value of FBS for JMU, the REGULAR SEASON. We're fixated with post-season because that's our measure of success now as an FCS team. Those home games versus natural rivals (Marshall/App/ODU) are what I want more than anything. I can only attend two games this year & it's our two cupcakes in September. That sucks. I'll treasure the playoffs while we're FCS, but post-season success for JMU is not the prize for moving to FBS.

Serious question: would you rather play Marshall/App/ODU than Delaware/Spatters/Nerds/Nova/UNH? I honestly wouldn't.

Seriously ?

who would rather sit in a "rivalry" away game in "stadiums" with UD / UR/ UNH / NOVA with anywhere between 3,000 - 6,000 fans in the seats ( with the exception of UD ocassionally drawing in the teens if the game is before the earlybird dinner rush ) or go to an electrically charged away game with Marshall / App/ ODU which will at a minimum draw stadium capacity at ODU (20k and growing) up to 40,000 with Marshall and App on their heels.

don't think small time, or that's where you'll end up - forever.
07-14-2017 10:41 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Dukeman2 Offline
2nd String
*

Posts: 263
Joined: Sep 2013
Reputation: 0
I Root For: James Madison
Location:
Post: #59
RE: OT: Does App St miss FCS?
Spring 2015 - CAA Commissioner Yeager - “I have also spent a considerable amount of time answering rumors surrounding whether several current CAA members are also exploring other conference options (these questions are also being raised by the prospective institutions),” Yeager wrote. “I have been in direct and open communication with the institution(JMU) and based on their assurances, I am confident that there is no substance to the rumors which are being created and repeated by speculation outside the institution.”


Tom Yeager June 2015 - said he will be retiring with the CAA’s membership having been “stabilized.”

Sun Belt Commissioner (May 2014); “JMU made a decision that they do not want to play FBS football”

Did JMU initiate the vote to raise exit fees for the CAA just two years ago?

Has anyone at JMU ever make the statement "the objective at JMU is to compete at the highest level of intercollegiate football"?

Did JMU reject the offer from CUSA to meet as part of a package deal with ODU?

The AD reporting to King is overwhelming evidence that JMU sees athletics as an expense and not a marketing opportunity to elevate the national brand, attract better quality students, engage alumni, attract substantial contributions, etc..

Until this small time paradigm shifts, we will continue to fall behind our once peers like ODU, App State, Charlotte; even Richmond and George Mason.

The opportunity cost keeps moving higher
07-14-2017 10:59 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
JMUPurple Offline
Bench Warmer
*

Posts: 130
Joined: Jan 2013
Reputation: 2
I Root For: James Madison
Location: Richmond, VA
Post: #60
RE: OT: Does App St miss FCS?
(07-14-2017 10:41 AM)jmufbs Wrote:  
(07-14-2017 09:52 AM)DirtyDukes Wrote:  
(07-14-2017 09:34 AM)HyperDuke Wrote:  H.U.S.T.L.E. makes some great points that really crystallize the fears of many of our "leaders". Thanks for making such a good post filled with real concepts based on reality. Seriously, thank you.

But JMUETC brings it right back to the real value of FBS for JMU, the REGULAR SEASON. We're fixated with post-season because that's our measure of success now as an FCS team. Those home games versus natural rivals (Marshall/App/ODU) are what I want more than anything. I can only attend two games this year & it's our two cupcakes in September. That sucks. I'll treasure the playoffs while we're FCS, but post-season success for JMU is not the prize for moving to FBS.

Serious question: would you rather play Marshall/App/ODU than Delaware/Spatters/Nerds/Nova/UNH? I honestly wouldn't.

Seriously ?

who would rather sit in a "rivalry" away game in "stadiums" with UD / UR/ UNH / NOVA with anywhere between 3,000 - 6,000 fans in the seats ( with the exception of UD ocassionally drawing in the teens if the game is before the earlybird dinner rush ) or go to an electrically charged away game with Marshall / App/ ODU which will at a minimum draw stadium capacity at ODU (20k and growing) up to 40,000 with Marshall and App on their heels.

don't think small time, or that's where you'll end up - forever.

I would definitely prefer regular season games against Marshall/APP/ODU over the CAA. However, watching last season's playoff run and National Championship was so enjoyable! We got to watch our Dukes play 4 additional meaningful games after the regular season! The fun I had watching the playoff and NC has made me re-think my previous support for FBS. I have no interest in watching any meaningless bowl games outside of the 3 that are part of the FBS playoffs. I really wish the G5 would adopt their own playoff and that JMU would be a part of it. Until then..........I'm now torn.
07-14-2017 11:15 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Post Reply 




User(s) browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)


Copyright © 2002-2018 Collegiate Sports Nation Bulletin Board System (CSNbbs), All Rights Reserved.
CSNbbs is an independent fan site and is in no way affiliated to the NCAA or any of the schools and conferences it represents.
This site monetizes links. FTC Disclosure.
We allow third-party companies to serve ads and/or collect certain anonymous information when you visit our web site. These companies may use non-personally identifiable information (e.g., click stream information, browser type, time and date, subject of advertisements clicked or scrolled over) during your visits to this and other Web sites in order to provide advertisements about goods and services likely to be of greater interest to you. These companies typically use a cookie or third party web beacon to collect this information. To learn more about this behavioral advertising practice or to opt-out of this type of advertising, you can visit http://www.networkadvertising.org.
Powered By MyBB, © 2002-2018 MyBB Group.