(04-15-2015 11:37 AM)Fitbud Wrote: (04-15-2015 11:32 AM)HeartOfDixie Wrote: (04-15-2015 11:27 AM)Fitbud Wrote: (04-15-2015 11:24 AM)HeartOfDixie Wrote: (04-15-2015 11:18 AM)Fitbud Wrote: Because their former status is why we have these sorts of problem in this country today.
That's always the fallback position and when you entrench into it we all end up in a situation of "well whatever" then. It's never constructive.
It also fails to consider the poor whites who are also abused, as if they don't matter at all because they do not have some sort of historical excuse.
The fact remains however that you could take a poor black person and a poor white person and put both of them in an opportunity to succeed and the black person would experience more difficulty by vertue of his race because racism is still prevailant in this country.
Can you honestly say that?
The black kid would have to get 100 points lower on an SAT to get into the same school.
And that is just a single instance of advantage.
You can say, "well racism" all you want but it goes right back to that entrenched mindset that benefits nobody.
You take a very poor white trash kid from the middle of nowhere and an inner city child of street trash welfare queen and they will have the same outcome. There is no racial advantage among those at the bottom, none.
Advantage is all about resources, no colour.
History has proven that people of color are discriminated against even when all other things are equal. That is why affirmative action was necessary. That is why children of color have to be accepted with lower scores. To offset the racism that still exists in this country.
Will Tiger Woods' kids have advantages over mine? What about Magic Johnson's?
It's about money, not race.
You are saying all the the right things if you believe tilting the field helps anything.
However, you do have to apply common sense at a point. There was an article on here recently about how much easier it is for a black kid to get into medical school. Well, common sense says that the average black doctor isn't as capable then. You only have one life, will you think twice?
Now, when you do will you think I am going to trade my one life or the quality of it to give this guy a chance because historical inequality?
I'm not saying there is inherent difference I am saying that the actions you talk about have other results and consequences. Like Clarence Tomas said, and has been proven right, you create a system of 'you are pretty smart, for a black guy.'
That isn't equality. You can't create it. It can only be earned. That always comes across as harsh and unfair but we all know it is the truth. What is given and what is earned is never looked at the same.