Per the title of this thread, we must ask ourselves these questions:
If UC's talent level was upgraded, would that translate to the "next level" of success (in-season and post-season)? Or would we simply find ourselves watching more talented players operate in a system that frequently appears to generate no coherence or consistency on offense -- and be subject to the same mental errors, defensive lapses, odd play-calls, etc. that sometimes vex us -- just perpetrated by better players? Would this "better talent" also get yanked when their man gets past them once? Would we be even more frustrated? (Certainly, with "better talent," our expectations would be even higher, and we seem to have trouble with managing our expectations now.)
I wonder what would happen if a Dee Brown or a Chris Paul did come here (assuming they're good examples of what we might call "more talented"). Would they be the same players we see today? They have been immersed in Illinois' and Wake's systems since the day they signed their LOIs. If they had come to UC, I feel confident that they would be able to lift more in the weight room than they do now, but I don't know if they'd be the same basketball players. I don't know if they'd lift the games of their teammates. I'm not ripping anyone ... I just don't know the answer. I don't want to hear that they'd be grittier players, better defensive players, more competitive players, per the popular UC profile. UC has no monopoly on hard work, defensive toughness, and overall competitiveness. Everyone in the Top 25 (and beyond) works just as hard as the Bearcats.
Talent, coaching and teaching, recruiting strategy and execution, offensive and defensive systems, scouting and game-planning, in-game adjustments, attention to the fundamentals, instilling teamwork and responsibility in young men, exemplifying a culture of winning and confidence ... Success is a mad mix of all these things -- some you can put your finger on, some you can't.
There is an awful lot that's right about Bearcat basketball these days, and it's too easy to skip over that when we're all gnashing our teeth. Still, we all sense that we're not quite all we could be, and of course, that is usually reinforced each spring, sad to say.
How do you all feel about this? What is fundamentally "right" about things now, what isn't, and what might realistically be done to go forward? After all, the pace is about to quicken.
|