I'm not ready to put the 2008 team ahead of the squad from 2002, in large part because of the tourney run. That's a huge separator for me. Though, when breaking the teams down by personnel, I give the edge to the 2002 version.
Huffman/Mitchell vs. Fisher/Mincy/Sherman
Edge to 2002. Huffman and Mitchell, as a duo, brought so much to the table (perimeter shooting, dribble penetration, passing, defense) and complemented each other perfectly.
Singletary vs. Thomas/Shaw
Right now I have this as a push, partly because Singletary still gets into foul trouble, which means his effectiveness is reduced. Also, while Chris has the edge offensively, Shaw was a better defender and rebounder.
Gates vs. Scott
Edge goes to Gates.
Gerwig vs. Q
Q wins this one.
Bench
I'd give the edge to the 2002 team, which I think was more productive and had more specialists. Haut could and did hit the three; Edwards provided defense in the middle; Thomas could score and defend; Bedford did a lot of the little things; Wilkins, who didn't see that much playing time, but did provide a little perimeter scoring.
Where I really see similarities between the two teams is with their regular seasons:
• Each started the season with a bad loss. The 2002 team lost to Hofstra (I don't count the Mercyhurst win as the first game because they're D2) and the 2008 squad lost to Detroit.
• Both teams played Xavier and Illinois State in back-to-back games, and both teams lost to the Musketeers but beat the Redbirds. Interestly, in 2002, Xavier finished 22-5 overall and 14-2 in its conference. This year's team currently is 23-4 overall and 11-1 in conference.
• Both teams lost to a storied program (2002 - Kentucky, 2008 - UNC).
• Both teams nearly ran the table in the MAC (2002 - 16-1, 2008 - 11-2 so far).
• Both teams lost a road MAC game in the final seconds that they should've won (2002 - Buffalo, 2008 - Toledo).
• Possible Defensive POY for both teams (2002 - Shaw, 2008 - Q).
• As of today, both teams have three players who score in double digits (2002 - Huffman, Mitchell, Gates; 2008 - Fisher, Scott, Q). Though Singletary is a whisker under 10 ppg, there's a good chance the 2008 team will finish with four double-digit scorers.
• Both have dominating defenses (2002 - held opponents to 63.5 points per game, 2008 - is holding opponents to 62.5 points per game).
• Both teams possibly undefeated at home.
• Jim Christian was a coach on both teams, albeit in different positions.
• And hopefully we can add later that both teams won the MAC regular season, were the No. 1 seed, won the MAC Tournament, and made it to the Elite 8.