bullet
Legend

Posts: 83,863
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5067
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
|
RE: First CFP rankings of 2026
(11-04-2026 04:50 PM)YNot Wrote: So, it seems apparent that the committee is placing their thumb on the scale and applying the new Strength of Conference metric for the SEC. Deservedly so, with a combined 10-2 record against OOC P4 teams.
I wish they would reveal how that metric works. It seems like they just bumped most SEC teams 2 or 3 spots higher in the CFP Rankings than in the AP Poll....And, they really bumped Alabama; probably because Alabama and Kentucky were in the same comparison group. That was a head-scratcher for the AP Poll to place Kentucky one spot ahead of Alabama.
Lots of football left. It will be interesting to see how things play out.
Yes. I really think doing it this week creates unnecessary controversy. There are usually a lot of important games that 1st weekend in November. This year there are 4 just in the SEC:
#2 Georgia at #10 Ole Miss
#5 Alabama at #14 LSU
#6 Kentucky at #13 Tennessee
#7 Texas at #18 Missouri
|
|
| 11-04-2026 05:14 PM |
|
Crayton
Heisman

Posts: 5,306
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation: 379
I Root For: Florida
Location:
|
RE: First CFP rankings of 2026
(11-04-2026 04:50 PM)YNot Wrote: So, it seems apparent that the committee is placing their thumb on the scale and applying the new Strength of Conference metric for the SEC. Deservedly so, with a combined 10-2 record against OOC P4 teams.
I wish they would reveal how that metric works. It seems like they just bumped most SEC teams 2 or 3 spots higher in the CFP Rankings than in the AP Poll....And, they really bumped Alabama; probably because Alabama and Kentucky were in the same comparison group. That was a head-scratcher for the AP Poll to place Kentucky one spot ahead of Alabama.
Lots of football left. It will be interesting to see how things play out.
That is actually a real interesting call out. The committee votes on the top 6 teams remaining, locks in 4 one-by-one, and then repeats.
If we look at each block of 4 we see the SEC overwhelming placed in the top half
1-4 Miami, Georgia // Utah, Indiana
5-8 Alabama, Kentucky // Texas, UCLA
9-12 BYU, Ole Miss // Notre Dame, Ohio State
13-16 Tennessee, LSU // Texas Tech, Wake Forest
For all we know UCLA and Notre Dame were in the Top 6 and Top 10 conversations but got bumped because they are not SEC.
|
|
| 11-04-2026 05:16 PM |
|
thrill_house
1st String

Posts: 1,123
Joined: Apr 2021
Reputation: 177
I Root For: Anti-CFP
Location:
|
RE: First CFP rankings of 2026
(11-04-2026 04:03 PM)bullet Wrote: Sports book are not about what is right. They are about what balances the bets.
One of my father's friends in Kentucky said the surest way to make money was to take the points against UK. UK fans were exuberant. So its psychology, not analysis of who is better.
It never has and never will be about balancing bets.
You know absolutely nothing about sportsbooks.
|
|
| 11-04-2026 05:25 PM |
|
bullet
Legend

Posts: 83,863
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5067
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
|
RE: First CFP rankings of 2026
(11-04-2026 05:25 PM)thrill_house Wrote: (11-04-2026 04:03 PM)bullet Wrote: Sports book are not about what is right. They are about what balances the bets.
One of my father's friends in Kentucky said the surest way to make money was to take the points against UK. UK fans were exuberant. So its psychology, not analysis of who is better.
It never has and never will be about balancing bets.
You know absolutely nothing about sportsbooks.
Everything about gambling is balancing the bets. The House ALWAYS wins.
|
|
| 11-04-2026 05:31 PM |
|
WhoseHouse?
Hall of Famer

Posts: 10,210
Joined: Dec 2015
Reputation: 729
I Root For: UH
Location:
|
RE: First CFP rankings of 2026
Not sure how everyone on here felt but from what I’ve seen in the general discourse elsewhere, the four most scrutinized placements were Bama at #5, ND at #11, Ohio St at #12, and Tennessee at #13. Looking at the results today it seems like the committee basically went .500 with these calls. Bamas placement looks pretty justified after stomping LSU in BR. Ohio State certainly no longer looks like a top 10 team without Sayin (and imo should drop out of the top 20 next week). Tennessee looks undervalued. They should be much closer to Bama in the next ranking (frankly they should be ahead based on actual H2H). And ND as I argued with people on Reddit was colossally undervalued at #11. I understand why the committee did it but there were so many metrics that suggested ND was the top team in the country. Imo opinion they deserve the #3 ranking next week. I don’t think the committee will give them such a big jump but I would like them ahead of the 4 2 loss SEC teams. Will be interesting to see where they land.
|
|
| 11-07-2026 09:32 PM |
|
bullet
Legend

Posts: 83,863
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5067
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
|
RE: First CFP rankings of 2026
(11-07-2026 09:32 PM)WhoseHouse? Wrote: Not sure how everyone on here felt but from what I’ve seen in the general discourse elsewhere, the four most scrutinized placements were Bama at #5, ND at #11, Ohio St at #12, and Tennessee at #13. Looking at the results today it seems like the committee basically went .500 with these calls. Bamas placement looks pretty justified after stomping LSU in BR. Ohio State certainly no longer looks like a top 10 team without Sayin (and imo should drop out of the top 20 next week). Tennessee looks undervalued. They should be much closer to Bama in the next ranking (frankly they should be ahead based on actual H2H). And ND as I argued with people on Reddit was colossally undervalued at #11. I understand why the committee did it but there were so many metrics that suggested ND was the top team in the country. Imo opinion they deserve the #3 ranking next week. I don’t think the committee will give them such a big jump but I would like them ahead of the 4 2 loss SEC teams. Will be interesting to see where they land.
What metrics? Opinion polls of people in South Bend?
|
|
| 11-07-2026 09:34 PM |
|
WhoseHouse?
Hall of Famer

Posts: 10,210
Joined: Dec 2015
Reputation: 729
I Root For: UH
Location:
|
RE: First CFP rankings of 2026
(11-07-2026 09:34 PM)bullet Wrote: (11-07-2026 09:32 PM)WhoseHouse? Wrote: Not sure how everyone on here felt but from what I’ve seen in the general discourse elsewhere, the four most scrutinized placements were Bama at #5, ND at #11, Ohio St at #12, and Tennessee at #13. Looking at the results today it seems like the committee basically went .500 with these calls. Bamas placement looks pretty justified after stomping LSU in BR. Ohio State certainly no longer looks like a top 10 team without Sayin (and imo should drop out of the top 20 next week). Tennessee looks undervalued. They should be much closer to Bama in the next ranking (frankly they should be ahead based on actual H2H). And ND as I argued with people on Reddit was colossally undervalued at #11. I understand why the committee did it but there were so many metrics that suggested ND was the top team in the country. Imo opinion they deserve the #3 ranking next week. I don’t think the committee will give them such a big jump but I would like them ahead of the 4 2 loss SEC teams. Will be interesting to see where they land.
What metrics? Opinion polls of people in South Bend?
Sagarin, FPI, etc. People jumped off them way too hard. There was still plenty of reason to think they were a very good team. It was probably the first time I’ve found myself defending the Irish but I’m feeling very vindicated at the moment.
|
|
| 11-07-2026 09:37 PM |
|
bullet
Legend

Posts: 83,863
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5067
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
|
RE: First CFP rankings of 2026
(11-07-2026 09:37 PM)WhoseHouse? Wrote: (11-07-2026 09:34 PM)bullet Wrote: (11-07-2026 09:32 PM)WhoseHouse? Wrote: Not sure how everyone on here felt but from what I’ve seen in the general discourse elsewhere, the four most scrutinized placements were Bama at #5, ND at #11, Ohio St at #12, and Tennessee at #13. Looking at the results today it seems like the committee basically went .500 with these calls. Bamas placement looks pretty justified after stomping LSU in BR. Ohio State certainly no longer looks like a top 10 team without Sayin (and imo should drop out of the top 20 next week). Tennessee looks undervalued. They should be much closer to Bama in the next ranking (frankly they should be ahead based on actual H2H). And ND as I argued with people on Reddit was colossally undervalued at #11. I understand why the committee did it but there were so many metrics that suggested ND was the top team in the country. Imo opinion they deserve the #3 ranking next week. I don’t think the committee will give them such a big jump but I would like them ahead of the 4 2 loss SEC teams. Will be interesting to see where they land.
What metrics? Opinion polls of people in South Bend?
Sagarin, FPI, etc. People jumped off them way too hard. There was still plenty of reason to think they were a very good team. It was probably the first time I’ve found myself defending the Irish but I’m feeling very vindicated at the moment.
Hard to understand how Sagarin had them #1. None of Sagarin's metrics look like a #1 for Notre Dame. Sagarin had BYU #24. Odd.
|
|
| 11-07-2026 11:28 PM |
|
WhoseHouse?
Hall of Famer

Posts: 10,210
Joined: Dec 2015
Reputation: 729
I Root For: UH
Location:
|
RE: First CFP rankings of 2026
(11-07-2026 11:28 PM)bullet Wrote: (11-07-2026 09:37 PM)WhoseHouse? Wrote: (11-07-2026 09:34 PM)bullet Wrote: (11-07-2026 09:32 PM)WhoseHouse? Wrote: Not sure how everyone on here felt but from what I’ve seen in the general discourse elsewhere, the four most scrutinized placements were Bama at #5, ND at #11, Ohio St at #12, and Tennessee at #13. Looking at the results today it seems like the committee basically went .500 with these calls. Bamas placement looks pretty justified after stomping LSU in BR. Ohio State certainly no longer looks like a top 10 team without Sayin (and imo should drop out of the top 20 next week). Tennessee looks undervalued. They should be much closer to Bama in the next ranking (frankly they should be ahead based on actual H2H). And ND as I argued with people on Reddit was colossally undervalued at #11. I understand why the committee did it but there were so many metrics that suggested ND was the top team in the country. Imo opinion they deserve the #3 ranking next week. I don’t think the committee will give them such a big jump but I would like them ahead of the 4 2 loss SEC teams. Will be interesting to see where they land.
What metrics? Opinion polls of people in South Bend?
Sagarin, FPI, etc. People jumped off them way too hard. There was still plenty of reason to think they were a very good team. It was probably the first time I’ve found myself defending the Irish but I’m feeling very vindicated at the moment.
Hard to understand how Sagarin had them #1. None of Sagarin's metrics look like a #1 for Notre Dame. Sagarin had BYU #24. Odd.
Because they have a talented roster which is the same thing that traditionally informs preseason rankings and they have the 2nd largest margin of victory in the country. The only weak part about their schedule was the lack of signature wins but their actual SOS wasn’t that weak. When you’re blowing decent teams out week to week, have zero bad losses, and have elite talent, chances are you are really good.
Tbc clear I was fine with the committee dropping them some but there was no reason to move them behind any of the SEC 2 loss teams.
|
|
| 11-07-2026 11:38 PM |
|
stever20
Legend

Posts: 50,362
Joined: Nov 2011
Reputation: 1019
I Root For: Hoyas
Location:
|
RE: First CFP rankings of 2026
new updated BCS ratings-
|
|
| 11-09-2026 10:01 AM |
|
bullet
Legend

Posts: 83,863
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5067
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
|
RE: First CFP rankings of 2026
(11-07-2026 11:38 PM)WhoseHouse? Wrote: (11-07-2026 11:28 PM)bullet Wrote: (11-07-2026 09:37 PM)WhoseHouse? Wrote: (11-07-2026 09:34 PM)bullet Wrote: (11-07-2026 09:32 PM)WhoseHouse? Wrote: Not sure how everyone on here felt but from what I’ve seen in the general discourse elsewhere, the four most scrutinized placements were Bama at #5, ND at #11, Ohio St at #12, and Tennessee at #13. Looking at the results today it seems like the committee basically went .500 with these calls. Bamas placement looks pretty justified after stomping LSU in BR. Ohio State certainly no longer looks like a top 10 team without Sayin (and imo should drop out of the top 20 next week). Tennessee looks undervalued. They should be much closer to Bama in the next ranking (frankly they should be ahead based on actual H2H). And ND as I argued with people on Reddit was colossally undervalued at #11. I understand why the committee did it but there were so many metrics that suggested ND was the top team in the country. Imo opinion they deserve the #3 ranking next week. I don’t think the committee will give them such a big jump but I would like them ahead of the 4 2 loss SEC teams. Will be interesting to see where they land.
What metrics? Opinion polls of people in South Bend?
Sagarin, FPI, etc. People jumped off them way too hard. There was still plenty of reason to think they were a very good team. It was probably the first time I’ve found myself defending the Irish but I’m feeling very vindicated at the moment.
Hard to understand how Sagarin had them #1. None of Sagarin's metrics look like a #1 for Notre Dame. Sagarin had BYU #24. Odd.
Because they have a talented roster which is the same thing that traditionally informs preseason rankings and they have the 2nd largest margin of victory in the country. The only weak part about their schedule was the lack of signature wins but their actual SOS wasn’t that weak. When you’re blowing decent teams out week to week, have zero bad losses, and have elite talent, chances are you are really good.
Tbc clear I was fine with the committee dropping them some but there was no reason to move them behind any of the SEC 2 loss teams.
Talented roster doesn't have anything to do with Sagarin's calculations. MOV could be it.
|
|
| 11-09-2026 10:44 AM |
|