(10-29-2026 10:12 AM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote: (10-29-2026 09:55 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote: (10-28-2026 06:07 PM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote: (10-28-2026 05:40 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote: (10-28-2026 09:23 AM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote: Are multi-purpose domes the next cookie cutter stadiums?
Views? Terrible.
Atmosphere? Sucks.
Taxpayer expense? You know it.
Once these monoliths rot, I predict the market pushes for FSS. Know what those are? Football-Specific Stadiums.
The drive to separate baseball from the multi-purpose stadiums from the 1970s was supported by economics: 81 home games made it worth it to have a separate stadium. In the right location, that’s enough critical mass of events to drive development for an entire neighborhood. (See Wrigleyville or the area around Petco Park.)
It’s totally different for an NFL team where there are only 8 or 9 home regular season games plus 1 or 2 preseason games. Considering that there is generally some level of a tax payer subsidy for these venues as you have mentioned, it makes very little sense to build a football-only stadium. Outside of maybe Lambeau Field, there is very little romantic attachment to NFL stadiums compared to how people feel about classic MLB ballparks or top college football stadiums, for that matter.
Buffalo’s new stadium says hello
And I pointed out Buffalo as the one exception.
Look - I’m not saying that it’s a better atmosphere or those other intangibles. I was at the Bears-Rams playoff in January at Soldier Field in -15 degree windchill at night. I don’t need an education on hardcore cold weather NFL fandom. It was as awesome of an atmosphere as you’ll ever get in sports. I was sitting above the end zone where Caleb Williams made that insane throw to Cole Kmet to tie the game and that was the loudest that I have ever heard a crowd at a sporting event.
However, I approach business analysis as if I were the one actually having to make the decision to spend billions of dollars on a new asset. The only reasons why you wouldn’t build a domed stadium in the NFL at this point is that you can’t get the funding for it and/or your market isn’t generally desirable for those other non-NFL events to make that additional expense worth it, which were both factors in Buffalo not building a dome. That’s much different than places like Nashville, Denver, or our market of Chicago - those are no-doubt sites for Final Fours, the biggest concert tours, etc. Those are all markets that are losing big events to markets like Indianapolis and Detroit because they don’t have domes even though they’re bigger overall tourism destinations.
Well, actually you said Lambeau.
But now we have the new Jags stadium as well. Sure, the weather can host concerts, but they are specifically bypassing indoor events like the Big Dance.
I don't need an education on business acumen. I understand why right now, in this market, these multi-purpose domes are being built by NFL owners. I also understand why it makes more economic sense for the Bears to build a dome in Indiana, believe it or not. Go Bears!
I am simply making a hot take prediction based on how I could foresee football as a game evolve, the demand slink, and referencing the trends in baseball and soccer. Simply stated, there could be a future where American football becomes more niche and intimate, football specific stadiums are built to accommodate franchises.
Do you want your kids playing full contact football?
Ok - well that is a much different argument that what your original statement intimated. The changes from multipurpose stadiums back to traditional ballparks in baseball were market-driven, but it wasn’t due to a lower demand at least with respect to ticket sales. Even while MLB has gone down in relative popularity compared to football over the past several decades, the actual attendance is significantly higher than it was in the 1960s/1970s/1980s. Baseball didn’t “right size” due to lower popularity, but rather built ballparks that drove more in-person attendance than before despite that lower popularity. Part of it is simply the nature of baseball - it’s a family day out or a work outing or activity with friends or something that is intended to be accessible to large amounts of people throughout the season compared to a highly concentrated less frequent event like a football game.
You seem to be arguing that football is go down in popularity and, as a result, football stadiums will need to decrease in size.
Here’s the thing with these domes: they are pretty *explicitly* decreased capacities compared to what they would be as outdoor stadiums. The proposed Bears stadium (depending on which one you pick) will likely be no bigger than the capacity of Soldier Field - which already is the smallest capacity stadium in the NFL - even though the Bears could sell out 100,000 seats per week with zero problem. So, even if you were to state that ticket demand is lower, the capacities of indoor stadiums are already lower and, once again, they can be utilized for all different types of events for the entire year in a way that isn’t possible with an outdoor stadium (particularly in a cold weather location).
I don’t want to rehash people’s predictions on the future of football popularity again, but my kids are just finishing high school this year. They did not play contact football, but one kid did compete at a fairly high level in a sport for the past decade. The type of atmosphere where teammates are getting P4 athletic scholarship and athletic recruits at the Ivies and some have a legit shot at the Olympics. For better or worse (and mostly for worse), the one thing that these past 18 years have convinced me of is that there will NEVER be a shortage of upper middle class suburban families that will be 100% convinced that their kid will get to the top level on whatever sport that they play, whether it’s football, basketball, baseball, swimming, track, tennis, etc. Fewer kids might be playing football, but we are not seeing fewer *elite* athletes - the ones that matter for the NFL and P4 - playing football. It’s quite to the contrary.
The best high school football team that we played this season was New Trier. If you haven’t heard of it, look it up. This isn’t merely a rich public high school. It is at the top of the cultural elite in top of being wealthy with its peers being placed like Greenwich, Beverly Hills, and Atherton. It’s where the Home Alone house is located and the inspiration for the high schools in the John Hughes movies (Ferris Bueller, The Breakfast Club, etc.) and Mean Girls for Tina Fey. This is the EXACT type of place people keep saying is going to supposedly stop playing football - the home of multiple billionaires and the top CEOs, tech executives, financiers, lawyers, and doctors of the region. These people are the LAST people on Earth that need their kids to make it to the NFL to become wealthy - most NFL players would be taking a pay cut compared to these parents.
And yet, that New Trier team could probably have hung with most FCS teams with multiple players that are heading to the P4 next year, including their QB and an offensive line that was larger and faster than what we had at Illinois back in the 1990s. The fact that this is one of the wealthiest public high schools in the United States didn’t stop these kids from playing football (and they were all fully aware of concussion issues identified in the 2010s at this age). To the contrary, these guys were trained like an NFL team themselves. The only thing more psycho than the average sports parent is a sports parent that has the money to do whatever they think it takes to get a college scholarship or make it to the pros.
This is not a great picture of society, by the way. I have a ton of conflicting feelings about travel sports culture with the acknowledgment that we as a family willingly participated in it for the last decade. But make no mistake that the true elite athletes will still get driven to football in enough numbers to support the P4 and NFL for a VERY long time. Heck, circling back, baseball is empirical evidence of this where overall participation rates in the sport has gone down and down for decades… yet the players that stay with it have more power hitting and definitely much harder throwers as pitchers today. Your average MLB roster has more guys throwing 100 mph than there were in all of the majors 25 years ago. The casual participation in youth sports has gone down, but the top level elite athlete training has gone way up. Once again, this may not be good for society (as a wide range of kids ought to be able to play sports longer), but it will keep the quality of top level sports competition that we *watch* going higher and higher.