(10-31-2026 03:55 PM)Usajags Wrote: First thing you said is that it wasn’t about the schools and then post the schools you think will or won’t make it. Second, you have ND in the B1G, we all know that will never happen, because for some reason they give ND a pass on everything. Other than that, not terrible, but there needs to be a promotion/relegation method of schools to come and go. Also, this needs to be football only conferences, FBS football needs to leave the NCAA.
It's not about the schools. That's just my version of fill in the list. I went with the best brands and rivalries. Because that's what's TV wants. Some of the bowls have already said they'd rather fold than host games between unknown teams. All due respect to David St, regardless of the amount of students Kennesaw State and West Florida have, that's not the school's that will ever be on this list. It will be the top current G6 brands that make it. Casual fan TV / viewership will be the only thing that matters here.
Someone's gotta be in the middle and bottom. A slim few may make it to the top. But I tried to balance the ACC/Pac-12 for that for travel (for all sports since the media payouts will be less) and rivalries. Plus taking basketball into the mix.
The ACC may be the only league left of those two. And combine the bigger names. That's certainly a possibility. But the goal here is to keep the 5 historical "power" leagues alive. Because there is value for the media in name recognition. Even though they are far from equal.
Big Ten and SEC are already the P2. And the B12 is already the middle man. And more so with this new set up. They are firmly in the middle. The ACC and PAC-12 would remain firmly the bottom 2. In media distribution and perceived status/strength of schedule. And that is reflected in their auto bids. Keeping 100 teams with 5 leagues also gives TV enough "power league" inventory. It's a lot easier to advertise an ACC or PAC-12 matchup than it is a weekday CUSA or Sunbelt one.
Finally, if you read, ND isn't a full member of the BigTen. They will have the same set up they do with the ACC currently. Full member in all sports, except football that remains independent, but plays a partial league flex type schedule. With the new coming 20 team format, there will be no more divisions or round robin play. And there will be no more conference championship games. So this eliminates all the red tape for ND. They are free to remain independent with partial scheduling help from the Big Ten. They also will not be eligible for one of the BigTen's 4 auto spots. They'll have to earn one of the 12 at-large.
With the new format, as long as they earn one of those 12 spots, and thy still finish in the top 8 in the rankings, they get a bye. Same rules for everyone with the seeding. When the ACC and PAC-12 get their bye, they follow the same rules. You play where you are ranked. No more auto bid equaling a bye.
The SEC/BigTen will be the majority of those at-large spots. We all know this in reality. The B12 may nab 1 or 2 after their guaranteed 2 autos, but that will dependent on their rankings. And the ACC and PAC-12 likely will only get their 1 auto bid for each league, unless they've got a big team rising playing out of league games.
It gives everyone the opportunity to make it on their own. You just have to win the games.
----
And if you don't make it and had a good year there are 15 pretty cool bowl games that you can play great, equal footing competition with good location and venue, something fans can want to travel to for the experience. Bowls you've actually heard of before that have value in their branding. And not the overarching 41 games we have now. Just the 15. Like it used to be. And this gives the big venues some revenue in these destination cities. For example, SoFi would never be in the mix for anything other than a CFP National championship game bid. But with this, they get an annual game in addition to that possibility. No more freezing cold/outdated Independence and a Liberty Bowls. Now we have New Orleans Caesars Superdome and the new indoor Nissan Stadium in destination (albeit the coldest place on the entire list). The Hawai'i bowl playing in UH's smaller stadium goes back to the the long tradition of the Aloha Bowl, and will be played in the upcoming brand new Aloha Stadium opening in 2029!
Making the CFP means something. (1-24)
Making the "consolidation" 15 Bowis is still a very great reward. (25-54)
If you don't make it, you're in the bottom 46% of the FBS. So you try again next year.