Hello There, Guest! Registered users see far less ads! Register today and join our virtual tailgate. (Login — Register)

Post Reply 
changes this season
Author Message
Hokie Mark Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 26,875
Joined: Sep 2011
Reputation: 2008
I Root For: VT, ACC teams
Location: Greensboro, NC
Post: #21
RE: changes this season
(08-24-2026 06:31 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  
(08-24-2026 04:37 AM)AssKickingChicken Wrote:  I can’t imagine why someone would try it unless it was at the very end of a half.

Right - outside of the situation of receiving a punt with time expiring, you’re giving up 4 offensive downs in exchange for a fair catch field goal attempt, which is essentially the opposite of what all analytics would say to do today. Teams are kicking longer field goals because kickers are having both stronger legs and are more accurate, but simultaneously are going for it on 4th down within the 10-30 yard range because the chance for a TD (the expected value) is so much greater.

I was just rewatching “Moneyball” last night. Remember one of the most important rules of the philosophy: don’t give up outs. Hence why sacrifice bunts dropped precipitously over the last 2 decades - the expected run value of advancing a runner one base with a sacrifice actually goes down because the negative value of that out is greater. It’s similar here for football - you don’t willingly give up an offensive down. The only logical reason why you’d attempt the fair catch kick is when you have no more downs available to you (the last play of a half or game).

Analytics show that, in general, you should NEVER attempt a FG unless it's the last play of the half or game.* This is just a way to do it without any defense.

* If you can't get a first down, punt. If it's too close to punt, why aren't you going for it?
08-24-2026 11:59 AM
Visit this user's website Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bullet Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 83,867
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5067
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
Post: #22
RE: changes this season
(08-23-2026 10:11 PM)jimrtex Wrote:  
(08-21-2026 02:39 PM)bullet Wrote:  https://www.ncnewsonline.com/sports/nati...9a9fa.html

Talks about the playoff changes and a few less publicized changes.

"...In 2026, a player’s first targeting offense will no longer impact their availability for the next game. If a player is disqualified for targeting a second time during the season, they will be held out for the first half of the following game. A third offense calls for a next-game suspension....


Another rule change fans will notice: Offensive pass interference is now a 10-yard penalty instead of 15....


Another rule change this offseason will allow teams to attempt a field goal after a fair catch. The kicker can choose to drop kick from where the returner caught the ball, or they can use a holder with no tee...."
I wondered why they had decided to put it back in the rules. It turns out the NCAA accidentally removed it in 1950, when they completely eliminated fair catches. They reinstated fair catches in 1951, but didn't put the fair catch kick rule back.

There was a successful fair catch kick in the NFL in 2024. The last previously successful fair catch kick was in 1976. There were nine missed attempts between 1976 and 2024.

So somebody was watching the NFL game (December 19, 2024 - Chargers vs. Broncos), and wondered about doing it in NCAA. It took a year to talk the rules committee to reinstate it, and perhaps determine that it was accidentally removed.

It could become more common in NCAA: more games and weaker punters especially when kicking from your own end zone.

Interesting. I thought I had read about it in some old football books, so I did think it was reinstating an old rule. Didn't realize it was that far back.
08-24-2026 12:00 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bullet Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 83,867
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5067
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
Post: #23
RE: changes this season
(08-24-2026 11:56 AM)Hokie Mark Wrote:  
(08-21-2026 03:02 PM)JRsec Wrote:  
(08-21-2026 02:39 PM)bullet Wrote:  https://www.ncnewsonline.com/sports/nati...9a9fa.html

Talks about the playoff changes and a few less publicized changes.

"...In 2026, a player’s first targeting offense will no longer impact their availability for the next game. If a player is disqualified for targeting a second time during the season, they will be held out for the first half of the following game. A third offense calls for a next-game suspension....


Another rule change fans will notice: Offensive pass interference is now a 10-yard penalty instead of 15....


Another rule change this offseason will allow teams to attempt a field goal after a fair catch. The kicker can choose to drop kick from where the returner caught the ball, or they can use a holder with no tee...."

That's the gambling houses trying to get some credibility on targeting back, a needless change in the rules on interference, and a point spread jobbing effort on the spot catch of a punt field goal attempt.

Why can't they just leave the game alone!

Offensive pass interference penalty was always too severe, IMHO. It was an absolute drive killer. This way it's the same as holding (which also used to be 15 yds back in the day...)
And its really subjective. Unless they go out of their way to block the defender on a pick, its grey.
08-24-2026 12:01 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Frank the Tank Online
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 23,549
Joined: Jun 2008
Reputation: 3292
I Root For: Illinois/DePaul
Location: Chicago
Post: #24
RE: changes this season
(08-24-2026 11:48 AM)Scoochpooch1 Wrote:  
(08-24-2026 06:31 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  
(08-24-2026 04:37 AM)AssKickingChicken Wrote:  I can’t imagine why someone would try it unless it was at the very end of a half.

Right - outside of the situation of receiving a punt with time expiring, you’re giving up 4 offensive downs in exchange for a fair catch field goal attempt, which is essentially the opposite of what all analytics would say to do today. Teams are kicking longer field goals because kickers are having both stronger legs and are more accurate, but simultaneously are going for it on 4th down within the 10-30 yard range because the chance for a TD (the expected value) is so much greater.

I was just rewatching “Moneyball” last night. Remember one of the most important rules of the philosophy: don’t give up outs. Hence why sacrifice bunts dropped precipitously over the last 2 decades - the expected run value of advancing a runner one base with a sacrifice actually goes down because the negative value of that out is greater. It’s similar here for football - you don’t willingly give up an offensive down. The only logical reason why you’d attempt the fair catch kick is when you have no more downs available to you (the last play of a half or game).

Great strategy until the games actually.counted. Then A's couldn't do anything right.

I mean - it’s still optimized if you also have money. The A’s deployed the strategy but could only solely use it on bargain basement players due to salary constraints. Those players were extremely efficient relative to their salaries, but the most efficient players overall in MLB are still generally the most expensive. The 2004 Red Sox and 2016 Cubs broke their respective team championship curses (with Theo Epstein being a common thread) largely using Moneyball principles, but they also had large market money to get efficient players at the high end that the A’s could never afford while spending that money efficiently across the roster (even if there were still ultimately mistakes like Jason Heyward’s contract with the Cubs).

Now, since essentially every team transitioned to look at baseball production and efficiency in this manner, the A’s quickly lost their first mover advantage. Money plus efficiency beats efficiency alone.
08-24-2026 12:13 PM
Visit this user's website Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
solohawks Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 25,727
Joined: May 2008
Reputation: 1187
I Root For: UNCW
Location: Wilmington, NC
Post: #25
RE: changes this season
(08-24-2026 11:59 AM)Hokie Mark Wrote:  Analytics show that, in general, you should NEVER attempt a FG unless it's the last play of the half or game.* This is just a way to do it without any defense.

* If you can't get a first down, punt. If it's too close to punt, why aren't you going for it?

Thats seems crazy to me. If its 4th and long from the 30, wouldnt you take the 3 points?
08-24-2026 12:13 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
jimrtex Offline
All American
*

Posts: 4,848
Joined: Aug 2021
Reputation: 653
I Root For: Houston, Tulsa, Colorado
Location:
Post: #26
RE: changes this season
(08-24-2026 12:00 PM)bullet Wrote:  
(08-23-2026 10:11 PM)jimrtex Wrote:  
(08-21-2026 02:39 PM)bullet Wrote:  https://www.ncnewsonline.com/sports/nati...9a9fa.html

Talks about the playoff changes and a few less publicized changes.

"...In 2026, a player’s first targeting offense will no longer impact their availability for the next game. If a player is disqualified for targeting a second time during the season, they will be held out for the first half of the following game. A third offense calls for a next-game suspension....


Another rule change fans will notice: Offensive pass interference is now a 10-yard penalty instead of 15....


Another rule change this offseason will allow teams to attempt a field goal after a fair catch. The kicker can choose to drop kick from where the returner caught the ball, or they can use a holder with no tee...."
I wondered why they had decided to put it back in the rules. It turns out the NCAA accidentally removed it in 1950, when they completely eliminated fair catches. They reinstated fair catches in 1951, but didn't put the fair catch kick rule back.

There was a successful fair catch kick in the NFL in 2024. The last previously successful fair catch kick was in 1976. There were nine missed attempts between 1976 and 2024.

So somebody was watching the NFL game (December 19, 2024 - Chargers vs. Broncos), and wondered about doing it in NCAA. It took a year to talk the rules committee to reinstate it, and perhaps determine that it was accidentally removed.

It could become more common in NCAA: more games and weaker punters especially when kicking from your own end zone.

Interesting. I thought I had read about it in some old football books, so I did think it was reinstating an old rule. Didn't realize it was that far back.
I was wrong that the fair catch kick was incidental to a fair catch. In rugby football and early American football the fair catch was so that you could kick the football and not to protect the punt returner from being obliterated. That is, the fair catch was the precursor to a fair catch kick play.

In rugby, kicking the ball was (is) an acceptable way to advance the ball, and the kicking team could recover a ball off the ground just like on an onside kick(off). A fair catch in rugby essentially permitted the kick receiver to make a free kick. Otherwise the receiver might be tackled, and give up the ball which might be lost or turn into a ruck. In American football, the worst that can happen, other than a fumble, is for the receiver to be tackled, and his team go on offense with first down.

The closest analog to a fair catch kick in modern American football is to go three downs and out, and punt on fourth down. If you have two stout defenses or inept offenses, the net movement of the ball depends on who has the better punter.

In early rugby, making a try by touching the ball down past the goal line scored zero points. It gave an opportunity to make a free kick for a goal worth one point, the same as in association football (soccer). The distinction between the two versions, was that in rugby football, the goal is scored by kicking the ball over the cross bar, while in soccer a goal is scored by kicking the ball under the cross bar.

In rugby, the ball is brought out parallel to the touch (side) line from where the ball was touched down, and a free kick made from that point. If the try was scored near the sideline, then the free kick would at a very acute angle to the goal posts. As an alternative, there could be a punt out, where the scoring team could punt from behind the goal line, and player on that team could make a fair catch and have an easier fair catch kick for a goal. This also resulted in melees where everyone was trying to catch the punt out. This was also the rule in early American football.

In American football, scoring has evolved so that points are awarded for merely crossing the goal line, and the extra point is just a bonus. As the placement of the ball has moved toward the center of the field, the extra point has become almost automatic. The punt out was eliminated. The fair catch kick became almost vestigial.

By 1950, hardly anybody remembered a fair catch kick, and the fair catch made for boring football. The NCAA eliminated both. But by 1951 they realized this risked punt receivers being obliterated. Free substitution had made led to swifter offensive "linemen" and spread formations where the linemen could make brush blocks and head down field. So the fair catch was brought back.

In Canadian football there is no fair catch, but there is a five yard halo around the punt receiver. In addition, a punt not touched by the receiving team is a live ball, so there is none of this watching the punt roll as kicking team players wave their hands to make a breeze. Canadian football also permits the ball to be punted back.

High School never eliminated the fair catch kick. And tees are allowed.

Here is a video of a game winning fair catch kick from Utah in 2022. Note on the 3rd down before the punt, the other team took a 10-yard loss from their 15 to the 5 in attempt to run off some time. I don't think the fair catch signal was valid - but maybe the coach had tipped the ref. The FG was from the 37, for 47 yards, which is pretty good for a HS (Cottonwood has around 600 students)





This is a feel good story about the team. The team has won three games over the past five seasons.





The last NCAA fair catch kick was in 1939, Marquette 17, Michigan State 14. Seeing Michigan State, I started wondering whether there was a small Yooper college, until I realized this was the Marquette in Milwaukee (if the Big East only had football?). Northern Michigan is in Marquette, MI. Marquette dropped football in 1960 after losing $50,000 the previous season. They hired Al McGuire in 1964 and won the NCAAT in 1977. If they were still supporting football, would they have done so?

In the 1939 game, Michigan State had the ball on their 6-yard line and the punter only managed a punt to the 30, but a Sparty player interfered with a fair catch, moving the ball to the Michigan State 15, before kicking the fair catch kick. Marquette must not have had much confidence in their offense, because they kicked the winning field goal with six minutes left.
08-25-2026 05:50 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
AssKickingChicken Online
Heisman
*

Posts: 6,540
Joined: Jan 2022
Reputation: 585
I Root For: Jax State
Location:
Post: #27
RE: changes this season
Johns Hopkins converts a fair catch kick to win the game.

https://sports.yahoo.com/college-footbal...01168.html
11-01-2026 06:04 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Post Reply 




User(s) browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)


Copyright © 2002-2026 Collegiate Sports Nation Bulletin Board System (CSNbbs), All Rights Reserved.
CSNbbs is an independent fan site and is in no way affiliated to the NCAA or any of the schools and conferences it represents.
This site monetizes links. FTC Disclosure.
We allow third-party companies to serve ads and/or collect certain anonymous information when you visit our web site. These companies may use non-personally identifiable information (e.g., click stream information, browser type, time and date, subject of advertisements clicked or scrolled over) during your visits to this and other Web sites in order to provide advertisements about goods and services likely to be of greater interest to you. These companies typically use a cookie or third party web beacon to collect this information. To learn more about this behavioral advertising practice or to opt-out of this type of advertising, you can visit http://www.networkadvertising.org.
Powered By MyBB, © 2002-2026 MyBB Group.