(10-18-2026 04:15 PM)ncrdbl1 Wrote: Personally scared to death of heights due to falling out of grandstand at the track.
Each time I repelled I would all but have panic attacks before strapping in.
After I hooked in I had no fear.
Had 100% confidence in my belay man.
US military rarely uses baleymen even in demstrations.
Having a belay is uncommon when descending and is primarily employed to protect a climber from falls -- two very different scenarios. In my extensive experience, a belay is leveraged when descending only if one is training novices or children. Otherwise it's called being lowered and not descending. The soldier who lost their life was highly experienced and there was no belay.
Having a belay in a military context (especially combat) let alone other applications such as mountaineering compounds the overhead and is superfluous. At most one may employ someone at the bottom of the line to pull on it manually to add friction if the individual descending is deemed incapable, mid-descent, as a last ditch measure -- sometimes called a fireman's belay.
Not sure how your fear is relevant to this tragedy and your commentary reflects minimal to no knowledge in this domain. Ultimately, a soldier suffered a horrible and fatal accident. You also directly stated that this was the result of equipment failure, which the evidence currently does not support.
Based on what I have been able to review, I would assume that they may have been somehow incapable of or incorrectly modulating friction with their brake hand. Of course my opinion is based on limited video I was able to find and until a formal review is concluded, this is all speculative.
Prayers for the individual's family, and hopefully this man's untimely death can somehow contribute to the safety of single rope technique.