Hello There, Guest! Registered users see far less ads! Register today and join our virtual tailgate. (Login — Register)

Post Reply 
CFP 23+1
Author Message
JMU2004 Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 8,813
Joined: Sep 2004
Reputation: 185
I Root For: DUKES
Location: the Commonwealth
Post: #21
RE: CFP 23+1
At 24 teams, I would like to see guaranteed bids for conference champs of the top 6 leagues. 18 at large is plenty.

Given the PAC/American being at the table for this expansion, I do wonder if you'll see autobids expanded.
10-16-2026 12:25 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
We Are the Dukes of JMU Offline
1st String
*

Posts: 1,370
Joined: Oct 2021
Reputation: 110
I Root For: JMU
Location:
Post: #22
RE: CFP 23+1
(10-16-2026 12:15 PM)Psicosis Wrote:  Everyone assumes the worst, but they also assumed there would never be two G5s in a 12 team playoff and that happened almost immediately. They're biased against us, but the need to shut out an extra G6 is dramatically lessened by the fact that they're going to have about a dozen playoff games between marquee brands every year going forward.

As an AC or PAC school, this is one of the least catastrophic options they were considering. The MW, SBC, and everyone else were gonna have a rough path either way. Weird to side with the SEC, but this absolutely beats the Big Ten's idea of assigning slots based on conference affiliation and officially limiting the Gs to 1.

I generally agree with this take. It will result in some changes though:

1) G6 conferences will need to go to at least nine conference games. A "qualifying game" is defined as a conference game or a game against a P4 team (including Notre Dame). Considering there are 68 P4 teams and 70 G6 teams, it's not feasible for most G6s to find two P2 games. A nine-game conference schedule will be essential.

2) UConn will need to put its football team in a conference. It's highly unlikely that UConn will be able to consistently find 10 P4 games each year. Under the qualifying games concept, there's really no path to the CFP for an independent that's not ND.

3) Even with nine conference games, G6s will be at the mercy of P4s who can eliminate them from the CFP by cancelling last minute. If for example, Boise State lands the next Ashton Jeanty, you can 100% expect their P4 opponent to cancel in the months leading up to the game. It not only avoids a potential loss, but also eliminates Boise State from the CFP. In those scenarios, there needs to be a concept of a substitute game with a non-P4 that counts as a qualifying game. P4s should not be able to unilaterally eliminate a G6 team from playoff contention without even playing them.

4) G6 vs. P4 games will be played exclusively at P4 stadiums and P4s will no longer pay guarantees. The need for 10 qualifying games will mean that G6s need those games far more than P4s need them. In a really perverse scenario, you could see G6s who are desperate for CFP eligibility buying games at P4 stadiums. If that becomes common, we'll likely see G6 conferences go to 10 conference games.

5) There will be more P4 vs. FCS games. This system essentially treats college football as P4 and "everything else". I don't think FCS wins will be seen as any different than G6 wins, but P4 can get them more cheaply and easily. This is financially good for FCS and bad for the G6. Scheduling more FCS games has the added benefit of decreasing the supply of P4 games for the G6, making the the G6s more likely to pay for games and reducing the number of CFP-eligible G6 teams.
(This post was last modified: 10-16-2026 12:54 PM by We Are the Dukes of JMU.)
10-16-2026 12:53 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
owl at the moon Online
Eastern Screech Owl
*

Posts: 21,716
Joined: Aug 2013
Reputation: 3102
I Root For: rice,smu,uh,unt
Location: 23 mbps from csnbbs
Post: #23
CFP 23+1
(10-16-2026 12:53 PM)We Are the Dukes of JMU Wrote:  
(10-16-2026 12:15 PM)Psicosis Wrote:  Everyone assumes the worst, but they also assumed there would never be two G5s in a 12 team playoff and that happened almost immediately. They're biased against us, but the need to shut out an extra G6 is dramatically lessened by the fact that they're going to have about a dozen playoff games between marquee brands every year going forward.

As an AC or PAC school, this is one of the least catastrophic options they were considering. The MW, SBC, and everyone else were gonna have a rough path either way. Weird to side with the SEC, but this absolutely beats the Big Ten's idea of assigning slots based on conference affiliation and officially limiting the Gs to 1.

I generally agree with this take. It will result in some changes though:

1) G6 conferences will need to go to at least nine conference games. A "qualifying game" is defined as a conference game or a game against a P4 team (including Notre Dame). Considering there are 68 P4 teams and 70 G6 teams, it's not feasible for most G6s to find two P2 games. A nine-game conference schedule will be essential.

2) UConn will need to put its football team in a conference. It's highly unlikely that UConn will be able to consistently find 10 P4 games each year. Under the qualifying games concept, there's really no path to the CFP for an independent that's not ND.

3) Even with nine conference games, G6s will be at the mercy of P4s who can eliminate them from the CFP by cancelling last minute. If for example, Boise State lands the next Ashton Jeanty, you can 100% expect their P4 opponent to cancel in the months leading up to the game. It not only avoids a potential loss, but also eliminates Boise State from the CFP. In those scenarios, there needs to be a concept of a substitute game with a non-P4 that counts as a qualifying game. P4s should not be able to unilaterally eliminate a G6 team from playoff contention without even playing them.

4) G6 vs. P4 games will be played exclusively at P4 stadiums and P4s will no longer pay guarantees. The need for 10 qualifying games will mean that G6s need those games far more than P4s need them. In a really perverse scenario, you could see G6s who are desperate for CFP eligibility buying games at P4 stadiums. If that becomes common, we'll likely see G6 conferences go to 10 conference games.

5) There will be more P4 vs. FCS games. This system essentially treats college football as P4 and "everything else". I don't think FCS wins will be seen as any different than G6 wins, but P4 can get them more cheaply and easily. This is financially good for FCS and bad for the G6. Scheduling more FCS games has the added benefit of decreasing the supply of P4 games for the G6, making the the G6s more likely to pay for games and reducing the number of CFP-eligible G6 teams.


I don’t know if that made the final version. But if it did, what about switching to 10 conference games? Would that meet the qualifying requirement? If nothing else, we can be ready to add a replacement 10th conference game late in the scheduling process if somebody tries to cancel out on one of our teams.
10-16-2026 04:50 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
We Are the Dukes of JMU Offline
1st String
*

Posts: 1,370
Joined: Oct 2021
Reputation: 110
I Root For: JMU
Location:
Post: #24
RE: CFP 23+1
(10-16-2026 04:50 PM)owl at the moon Wrote:  
(10-16-2026 12:53 PM)We Are the Dukes of JMU Wrote:  
(10-16-2026 12:15 PM)Psicosis Wrote:  Everyone assumes the worst, but they also assumed there would never be two G5s in a 12 team playoff and that happened almost immediately. They're biased against us, but the need to shut out an extra G6 is dramatically lessened by the fact that they're going to have about a dozen playoff games between marquee brands every year going forward.

As an AC or PAC school, this is one of the least catastrophic options they were considering. The MW, SBC, and everyone else were gonna have a rough path either way. Weird to side with the SEC, but this absolutely beats the Big Ten's idea of assigning slots based on conference affiliation and officially limiting the Gs to 1.

I generally agree with this take. It will result in some changes though:

1) G6 conferences will need to go to at least nine conference games. A "qualifying game" is defined as a conference game or a game against a P4 team (including Notre Dame). Considering there are 68 P4 teams and 70 G6 teams, it's not feasible for most G6s to find two P2 games. A nine-game conference schedule will be essential.

2) UConn will need to put its football team in a conference. It's highly unlikely that UConn will be able to consistently find 10 P4 games each year. Under the qualifying games concept, there's really no path to the CFP for an independent that's not ND.

3) Even with nine conference games, G6s will be at the mercy of P4s who can eliminate them from the CFP by cancelling last minute. If for example, Boise State lands the next Ashton Jeanty, you can 100% expect their P4 opponent to cancel in the months leading up to the game. It not only avoids a potential loss, but also eliminates Boise State from the CFP. In those scenarios, there needs to be a concept of a substitute game with a non-P4 that counts as a qualifying game. P4s should not be able to unilaterally eliminate a G6 team from playoff contention without even playing them.

4) G6 vs. P4 games will be played exclusively at P4 stadiums and P4s will no longer pay guarantees. The need for 10 qualifying games will mean that G6s need those games far more than P4s need them. In a really perverse scenario, you could see G6s who are desperate for CFP eligibility buying games at P4 stadiums. If that becomes common, we'll likely see G6 conferences go to 10 conference games.

5) There will be more P4 vs. FCS games. This system essentially treats college football as P4 and "everything else". I don't think FCS wins will be seen as any different than G6 wins, but P4 can get them more cheaply and easily. This is financially good for FCS and bad for the G6. Scheduling more FCS games has the added benefit of decreasing the supply of P4 games for the G6, making the the G6s more likely to pay for games and reducing the number of CFP-eligible G6 teams.


I don’t know if that made the final version. But if it did, what about switching to 10 conference games? Would that meet the qualifying requirement? If nothing else, we can be ready to add a replacement 10th conference game late in the scheduling process if somebody tries to cancel out on one of our teams.

I thought it made the cut. Agree we'll need flexibility to add a 10th conference game for some teams in the event of a late cancellation. Not sure how that would work for tie breakers though. I don't like the idea of 10 conference games every year.
(This post was last modified: 10-16-2026 06:05 PM by We Are the Dukes of JMU.)
10-16-2026 05:58 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Psicosis Offline
Remain in Light
*

Posts: 16,750
Joined: Nov 2003
Reputation: 539
I Root For: Memphis
Location: Derek Chew Fan Club

Crappies
Post: #25
RE: CFP 23+1
The most reasonable accommodation would be to either make the rule only apply to P4 schools or that anything above FCS games count toward the number for G6 schools.
10-16-2026 06:29 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Side.Show.Joe Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 7,127
Joined: Jan 2021
Reputation: 1344
I Root For: North Texas
Location:
Post: #26
RE: CFP 23+1
(10-16-2026 05:58 PM)We Are the Dukes of JMU Wrote:  
(10-16-2026 04:50 PM)owl at the moon Wrote:  
(10-16-2026 12:53 PM)We Are the Dukes of JMU Wrote:  
(10-16-2026 12:15 PM)Psicosis Wrote:  Everyone assumes the worst, but they also assumed there would never be two G5s in a 12 team playoff and that happened almost immediately. They're biased against us, but the need to shut out an extra G6 is dramatically lessened by the fact that they're going to have about a dozen playoff games between marquee brands every year going forward.

As an AC or PAC school, this is one of the least catastrophic options they were considering. The MW, SBC, and everyone else were gonna have a rough path either way. Weird to side with the SEC, but this absolutely beats the Big Ten's idea of assigning slots based on conference affiliation and officially limiting the Gs to 1.

I generally agree with this take. It will result in some changes though:

1) G6 conferences will need to go to at least nine conference games. A "qualifying game" is defined as a conference game or a game against a P4 team (including Notre Dame). Considering there are 68 P4 teams and 70 G6 teams, it's not feasible for most G6s to find two P2 games. A nine-game conference schedule will be essential.

2) UConn will need to put its football team in a conference. It's highly unlikely that UConn will be able to consistently find 10 P4 games each year. Under the qualifying games concept, there's really no path to the CFP for an independent that's not ND.

3) Even with nine conference games, G6s will be at the mercy of P4s who can eliminate them from the CFP by cancelling last minute. If for example, Boise State lands the next Ashton Jeanty, you can 100% expect their P4 opponent to cancel in the months leading up to the game. It not only avoids a potential loss, but also eliminates Boise State from the CFP. In those scenarios, there needs to be a concept of a substitute game with a non-P4 that counts as a qualifying game. P4s should not be able to unilaterally eliminate a G6 team from playoff contention without even playing them.

4) G6 vs. P4 games will be played exclusively at P4 stadiums and P4s will no longer pay guarantees. The need for 10 qualifying games will mean that G6s need those games far more than P4s need them. In a really perverse scenario, you could see G6s who are desperate for CFP eligibility buying games at P4 stadiums. If that becomes common, we'll likely see G6 conferences go to 10 conference games.

5) There will be more P4 vs. FCS games. This system essentially treats college football as P4 and "everything else". I don't think FCS wins will be seen as any different than G6 wins, but P4 can get them more cheaply and easily. This is financially good for FCS and bad for the G6. Scheduling more FCS games has the added benefit of decreasing the supply of P4 games for the G6, making the the G6s more likely to pay for games and reducing the number of CFP-eligible G6 teams.


I don’t know if that made the final version. But if it did, what about switching to 10 conference games? Would that meet the qualifying requirement? If nothing else, we can be ready to add a replacement 10th conference game late in the scheduling process if somebody tries to cancel out on one of our teams.

I thought it made the cut. Agree we'll need flexibility to add a 10th conference game for some teams in the event of a late cancellation. Not sure how that would work for tie breakers though. I don't like the idea of 10 conference games every year.

No need for a 10th conference game if we sign an OOC scheduling agreement with the PAC. Both conferences would benefit.
10-16-2026 06:37 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
We Are the Dukes of JMU Offline
1st String
*

Posts: 1,370
Joined: Oct 2021
Reputation: 110
I Root For: JMU
Location:
Post: #27
RE: CFP 23+1
(10-16-2026 06:37 PM)Side.Show.Joe Wrote:  
(10-16-2026 05:58 PM)We Are the Dukes of JMU Wrote:  
(10-16-2026 04:50 PM)owl at the moon Wrote:  
(10-16-2026 12:53 PM)We Are the Dukes of JMU Wrote:  
(10-16-2026 12:15 PM)Psicosis Wrote:  Everyone assumes the worst, but they also assumed there would never be two G5s in a 12 team playoff and that happened almost immediately. They're biased against us, but the need to shut out an extra G6 is dramatically lessened by the fact that they're going to have about a dozen playoff games between marquee brands every year going forward.

As an AC or PAC school, this is one of the least catastrophic options they were considering. The MW, SBC, and everyone else were gonna have a rough path either way. Weird to side with the SEC, but this absolutely beats the Big Ten's idea of assigning slots based on conference affiliation and officially limiting the Gs to 1.

I generally agree with this take. It will result in some changes though:

1) G6 conferences will need to go to at least nine conference games. A "qualifying game" is defined as a conference game or a game against a P4 team (including Notre Dame). Considering there are 68 P4 teams and 70 G6 teams, it's not feasible for most G6s to find two P2 games. A nine-game conference schedule will be essential.

2) UConn will need to put its football team in a conference. It's highly unlikely that UConn will be able to consistently find 10 P4 games each year. Under the qualifying games concept, there's really no path to the CFP for an independent that's not ND.

3) Even with nine conference games, G6s will be at the mercy of P4s who can eliminate them from the CFP by cancelling last minute. If for example, Boise State lands the next Ashton Jeanty, you can 100% expect their P4 opponent to cancel in the months leading up to the game. It not only avoids a potential loss, but also eliminates Boise State from the CFP. In those scenarios, there needs to be a concept of a substitute game with a non-P4 that counts as a qualifying game. P4s should not be able to unilaterally eliminate a G6 team from playoff contention without even playing them.

4) G6 vs. P4 games will be played exclusively at P4 stadiums and P4s will no longer pay guarantees. The need for 10 qualifying games will mean that G6s need those games far more than P4s need them. In a really perverse scenario, you could see G6s who are desperate for CFP eligibility buying games at P4 stadiums. If that becomes common, we'll likely see G6 conferences go to 10 conference games.

5) There will be more P4 vs. FCS games. This system essentially treats college football as P4 and "everything else". I don't think FCS wins will be seen as any different than G6 wins, but P4 can get them more cheaply and easily. This is financially good for FCS and bad for the G6. Scheduling more FCS games has the added benefit of decreasing the supply of P4 games for the G6, making the the G6s more likely to pay for games and reducing the number of CFP-eligible G6 teams.


I don’t know if that made the final version. But if it did, what about switching to 10 conference games? Would that meet the qualifying requirement? If nothing else, we can be ready to add a replacement 10th conference game late in the scheduling process if somebody tries to cancel out on one of our teams.

I thought it made the cut. Agree we'll need flexibility to add a 10th conference game for some teams in the event of a late cancellation. Not sure how that would work for tie breakers though. I don't like the idea of 10 conference games every year.

No need for a 10th conference game if we sign an OOC scheduling agreement with the PAC. Both conferences would benefit.

I don't think an OOC game against a G6 opponent counts as a qualifying game. I think the definition of qualifying is a conference game or a game against a P4 opponent.
10-17-2026 09:26 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Post Reply 




User(s) browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)


Copyright © 2002-2026 Collegiate Sports Nation Bulletin Board System (CSNbbs), All Rights Reserved.
CSNbbs is an independent fan site and is in no way affiliated to the NCAA or any of the schools and conferences it represents.
This site monetizes links. FTC Disclosure.
We allow third-party companies to serve ads and/or collect certain anonymous information when you visit our web site. These companies may use non-personally identifiable information (e.g., click stream information, browser type, time and date, subject of advertisements clicked or scrolled over) during your visits to this and other Web sites in order to provide advertisements about goods and services likely to be of greater interest to you. These companies typically use a cookie or third party web beacon to collect this information. To learn more about this behavioral advertising practice or to opt-out of this type of advertising, you can visit http://www.networkadvertising.org.
Powered By MyBB, © 2002-2026 MyBB Group.